Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Acta Physica Sinica

Robustness anylysis of periodic oscillations in continuous-time crystals

Hongxia Li, LI Tingmei, WANG Zengpu, Yuhui Chen, Xiangdong ZHANG

Published Jan 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Continuous time crystals represent a novel state in many-body systems that can self-organize into timeperiodic oscillations without external periodic driving. Recent experiments have achieved such systems in dissipative solid-state materials, where persistent temporal order is autonomously sustained. A decisive characteristic of time crystals is their robustness, meaning that despite various disturbances, including fluctuations in internal parameters and external noise, they can still maintain rhythmic behavior, which has scientific value and echnological application potential. Although previous studies have shown that specific experimental parameters have robustness, thare is a lack of a systematic framework for quantifying and predicting their resilience to disturbances, and the underlying physics of this robustnessis still not fully understood. The key unresolved problems include how nonlinear interactions and feedback mechanisms contribute to stability, and what the critical thresholds are for parameter variations beyond which temporal order collapses. This work addresses these gaps by systematically analyzing how internal parameters and external influences affect the oscillation period and overall stability. Internally, the dynamics are determined by dipole-dipole interactions and atomic transition strengths, which define the temporal symmetry breaking that occurs in the system. Externally, the response of the system is controlled by the strength of the optical driving field and the energy dissipation rate. A key finding is the determination of an intrinsic feedback mechanism for a dynamically stabile time crystal. This mechanism plays a role in restoring force, correcting deviations caused by minor disturbances, and maintaining the coherence of oscillatory phase. Moreover, the system displays nonlinear dynamical behavior, characterized by two different states: one is stable oscillation continuing under moderate disturbance, and the other is stronger disturbance causing dynamical phase transition, resulting in switching between disordered or dynamically unstable state and stable state. These results provide a comprehensive understanding of the various behaviors observed in continuous time crystals and lay an important theoretical foundation for utilizing their unique properties in advanced applications such as quantum information processing and precision metrology.

DOI
10.7498/aps.74.20250036

Related papers

Self-organized time crystal in driven-dissipative quantum system

Ya-Xin Xiang, Qun‐Li Lei, Zhengyang Bai +1 more

Continuous time crystals (CTCs) are characterized by sustained oscillations that break the time-translation symmetry. Since the ruling out of equilibrium CTCs by no-go theorems, the emergence of such dynamical phases has been observed in various driven-dissipative quantum platforms. The current understanding of CTCs is mainly based on mean-field theories, which fail to address the problem of whether the continuous time-translation symmetry can be broken in noisy, spatially extended systems absent in all-to-all couplings. Here, we propose a CTC realized in a quantum contact model through self-organized bistability. The CTCs stem from the interplay between collective dissipation induced by the first-order absorbing phase transitions and slow constant driving provided by an incoherent pump. The stability of such oscillatory phases in finite dimensions under the action of intrinsic quantum fluctuations is scrutinized by the functional renormalization group method and numerical simulations. Occurring at the edge of many-body synchronization, the CTC phase exhibits an inherent period and amplitude with a coherence time linearly diverging with system size, thus also constituting a boundary time crystal. Our results serve as a solid route towards self-protected CTCs in strongly interacting open systems. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2311.08899•Physical Review Research•Aug 19, 2024•4 citations

Realization of an inherent time crystal in a dissipative many-body system

Yu‐Hui Chen, Xiangdong Zhang

Time crystals are many-body states that spontaneously break translation symmetry in time the way that ordinary crystals do in space. While experimental observations have confirmed the existence of discrete or continuous time crystals, these realizations have relied on the utilization of periodic forces or effective modulation through cavity feedback. The original proposal for time crystals is that they would represent self-sustained motions without any external periodicity, but realizing such purely self-generated behavior has not yet been achieved. Here, we provide theoretical and experimental evidence that many-body interactions can give rise to an inherent time crystalline phase. Following a calculation that shows an ensemble of pumped four-level atoms can spontaneously break continuous time translation symmetry, we observe periodic motions in an erbium-doped solid. The inherent time crystal produced by our experiment is self-protected by many-body interactions and has a measured coherence time beyond that of individual erbium ions.

arXiv:2310.04847•Nature Communications•Oct 3, 2023•19 citations

Observation of a phase transition from a continuous to a discrete time crystal

Phatthamon Kongkhambut, Jayson G. Cosme, Jim Skulte +4 more

Discrete (DTCs) and continuous time crystals (CTCs) are novel dynamical many-body states, that are characterized by robust self-sustained oscillations, emerging via spontaneous breaking of discrete or continuous time translation symmetry. DTCs are periodically driven systems that oscillate with a subharmonic of the external drive, while CTCs are continuously driven and oscillate with a frequency intrinsic to the system. Here, we explore a phase transition from a continuous time crystal to a discrete time crystal. A CTC with a characteristic oscillation frequencyωCTCis prepared in a continuously pumped atom-cavity system. Modulating the pump intensity of the CTC with a frequencyωdrclose to2ωCTCleads to robust locking ofωCTCtoωdr/2, and hence a DTC arises. This phase transition in a quantum many-body system is related to subharmonic injection locking of non-linear mechanical and electronic oscillators or lasers.

arXiv:2402.12378•Reports on Progress in Physics•Jul 19, 2024•14 citations

Emergent continuous time crystal in dissipative quantum spin system without driving

Shu Yang, Zeqing Wang, Libin Fu +1 more

Time crystals are a nonequilibrium phase of matter that extend fundamental spontaneous symmetry breaking into the temporal dimension, typically requiring external driving for their realization. Here, we explore the nonequilibrium phase diagram of a two-dimensional dissipative Heisenberg spin system without external coherent or incoherent driving. Through numerical analysis of spin dynamics, we identify nonstationary steady states, some of which are limit cycles with persistent periodic oscillations, while others exhibit chaotic, aperiodic behavior. The emergence of limit cycle steady states breaks the continuous time-translation symmetry of this time-independent many-body system, classifying them as continuous time crystals. We further validate these oscillatory behaviors by testing their stability against local perturbations and assess the robustness of the emergent continuous time crystals by introducing isotropic Gaussian white noise. This work provides insights into the intricate interplay between the dissipation and spin interaction, and opens possibilities for realizing dissipation-induced, heating-immune time crystals. Time crystals represent a nonequilibrium phase of matter without an equilibrium counterpart. The authors investigate the nonequilibrium steadystate phase diagram of a two-dimensional dissipative Heisenberg model in the absence of driving, and identify a continuous time crystalline phase exhibiting persistent oscillations in time.

arXiv:2403.08476•Communications Physics•Mar 24, 2025•12 citations

Time Crystals on Quantum Devices

Gonzalo Camacho, Benedikt Fauseweh

Time crystals are nonequilibrium phases of matter characterized by the emergence of temporal ordering, in which an interacting many-body system develops robust structure in its time evolution that is not trivially dictated by the external driving or environment. While related phenomena have long been studied in classical nonlinear systems, their realization in entangled quantum matter represents a distinct frontier. The theoretical understanding of discrete time crystals has substantially advanced, yet recent experiments using modern quantum devices and quantum processors reveal regimes beyond established paradigms. These developments call for an extended classification of time-crystalline phases according to both their stabilization mechanisms and their physical character, including discrete and continuous, closed and open, critical, topological, quasiperiodic, and controlled realizations. We review recent implementations of time crystals on quantum platforms and propose such a classification framework, identifying promising directions for the discovery of novel time-crystalline phases of matter.

quant-pharXiv:2605.27211•Quantum Science and Technology•May 27, 2026•0 citations

Continuous time quasi-crystal and its transition to continuous time crystal in coupled Rydberg atomic chains

Weilun Jiang

Abstract We investigate the nonlinear dynamics of two coupled driven–dissipative Rydberg atomic chains, each of which formed a previously reported continuous time crystal phase. By tuning the inter-chain interaction, the two time-crystalline subsystems with distinct intrinsic oscillation frequencies will naturally mix, and support luxuriant stable and collective oscillatory behavior. We identify a dynamical phase characterized by quasi-periodic oscillations with multiple incommensurate frequencies, corresponding to a continuous-time quasi-crystalline order. In addition, we identify a phase transition from a time quasi-crystalline phase to a time-crystalline phase at sufficiently strong inter-chain coupling. This transition can be understood as the evolution from partially synchronized oscillations between the two chains to fully synchronized dynamics. From a mathematical perspective, we confirm that the transition is governed by either a saddle-node or a torus bifurcation, depending on the separation between the two original oscillation frequencies. These theoretical results provide guidance for exploring complex periodic dynamics in Rydberg atomic platforms.

Chinese Physics B•Sep 10, 2026•0 citations
Continuous time crystals represent a novel state in many-body systems that can self-organize into timeperiodic oscillations without external periodic driving. Recent experiments have achieved such systems in dissipative solid-state materials, where persistent temporal order is autonomously sustained. A decisive characteristic of time crystals is their robustness, meaning that despite various disturbances, including fluctuations in internal parameters and external noise, they can still maintain rhythmic behavior, which has scientific value and echnological application potential. Although previous studies have shown that specific experimental parameters have robustness, thare is a lack of a systematic framework for quantifying and predicting their resilience to disturbances, and the underlying physics of this robustnessis still not fully understood. The key unresolved problems include how nonlinear interactions and feedback mechanisms contribute to stability, and what the critical thresholds are for parameter variations beyond which temporal order collapses. This work addresses these gaps by systematically analyzing how internal parameters and external influences affect the oscillation period and overall stability. Internally, the dynamics are determined by dipole-dipole interactions and atomic transition strengths, which define the temporal symmetry breaking that occurs in the system. Externally, the response of the system is controlled by the strength of the optical driving field and the energy dissipation rate. A key finding is the determination of an intrinsic feedback mechanism for a dynamically stabile time crystal. This mechanism plays a role in restoring force, correcting deviations caused by minor disturbances, and maintaining the coherence of oscillatory phase. Moreover, the system displays nonlinear dynamical behavior, characterized by two different states: one is stable oscillation continuing under moderate disturbance, and the other is stronger disturbance causing dynamical phase transition, resulting in switching between disordered or dynamically unstable state and stable state. These results provide a comprehensive understanding of the various behaviors observed in continuous time crystals and lay an important theoretical foundation for utilizing their unique properties in advanced applications such as quantum information processing and precision metrology.
Continuous time crystals (CTCs) are characterized by sustained oscillations that break the time-translation symmetry. Since the ruling out of equilibrium CTCs by no-go theorems, the emergence of such dynamical phases has been observed in various driven-dissipative quantum platforms. The current understanding of CTCs is mainly based on mean-field theories, which fail to address the problem of whether the continuous time-translation symmetry can be broken in noisy, spatially extended systems absent in all-to-all couplings. Here, we propose a CTC realized in a quantum contact model through self-organized bistability. The CTCs stem from the interplay between collective dissipation induced by the first-order absorbing phase transitions and slow constant driving provided by an incoherent pump. The stability of such oscillatory phases in finite dimensions under the action of intrinsic quantum fluctuations is scrutinized by the functional renormalization group method and numerical simulations. Occurring at the edge of many-body synchronization, the CTC phase exhibits an inherent period and amplitude with a coherence time linearly diverging with system size, thus also constituting a boundary time crystal. Our results serve as a solid route towards self-protected CTCs in strongly interacting open systems. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Time crystals are many-body states that spontaneously break translation symmetry in time the way that ordinary crystals do in space. While experimental observations have confirmed the existence of discrete or continuous time crystals, these realizations have relied on the utilization of periodic forces or effective modulation through cavity feedback. The original proposal for time crystals is that they would represent self-sustained motions without any external periodicity, but realizing such purely self-generated behavior has not yet been achieved. Here, we provide theoretical and experimental evidence that many-body interactions can give rise to an inherent time crystalline phase. Following a calculation that shows an ensemble of pumped four-level atoms can spontaneously break continuous time translation symmetry, we observe periodic motions in an erbium-doped solid. The inherent time crystal produced by our experiment is self-protected by many-body interactions and has a measured coherence time beyond that of individual erbium ions.
Discrete (DTCs) and continuous time crystals (CTCs) are novel dynamical many-body states, that are characterized by robust self-sustained oscillations, emerging via spontaneous breaking of discrete or continuous time translation symmetry. DTCs are periodically driven systems that oscillate with a subharmonic of the external drive, while CTCs are continuously driven and oscillate with a frequency intrinsic to the system. Here, we explore a phase transition from a continuous time crystal to a discrete time crystal. A CTC with a characteristic oscillation frequencyωCTCis prepared in a continuously pumped atom-cavity system. Modulating the pump intensity of the CTC with a frequencyωdrclose to2ωCTCleads to robust locking ofωCTCtoωdr/2, and hence a DTC arises. This phase transition in a quantum many-body system is related to subharmonic injection locking of non-linear mechanical and electronic oscillators or lasers.
Time crystals are a nonequilibrium phase of matter that extend fundamental spontaneous symmetry breaking into the temporal dimension, typically requiring external driving for their realization. Here, we explore the nonequilibrium phase diagram of a two-dimensional dissipative Heisenberg spin system without external coherent or incoherent driving. Through numerical analysis of spin dynamics, we identify nonstationary steady states, some of which are limit cycles with persistent periodic oscillations, while others exhibit chaotic, aperiodic behavior. The emergence of limit cycle steady states breaks the continuous time-translation symmetry of this time-independent many-body system, classifying them as continuous time crystals. We further validate these oscillatory behaviors by testing their stability against local perturbations and assess the robustness of the emergent continuous time crystals by introducing isotropic Gaussian white noise. This work provides insights into the intricate interplay between the dissipation and spin interaction, and opens possibilities for realizing dissipation-induced, heating-immune time crystals. Time crystals represent a nonequilibrium phase of matter without an equilibrium counterpart. The authors investigate the nonequilibrium steadystate phase diagram of a two-dimensional dissipative Heisenberg model in the absence of driving, and identify a continuous time crystalline phase exhibiting persistent oscillations in time.
Time crystals are nonequilibrium phases of matter characterized by the emergence of temporal ordering, in which an interacting many-body system develops robust structure in its time evolution that is not trivially dictated by the external driving or environment. While related phenomena have long been studied in classical nonlinear systems, their realization in entangled quantum matter represents a distinct frontier. The theoretical understanding of discrete time crystals has substantially advanced, yet recent experiments using modern quantum devices and quantum processors reveal regimes beyond established paradigms. These developments call for an extended classification of time-crystalline phases according to both their stabilization mechanisms and their physical character, including discrete and continuous, closed and open, critical, topological, quasiperiodic, and controlled realizations. We review recent implementations of time crystals on quantum platforms and propose such a classification framework, identifying promising directions for the discovery of novel time-crystalline phases of matter.
Abstract We investigate the nonlinear dynamics of two coupled driven–dissipative Rydberg atomic chains, each of which formed a previously reported continuous time crystal phase. By tuning the inter-chain interaction, the two time-crystalline subsystems with distinct intrinsic oscillation frequencies will naturally mix, and support luxuriant stable and collective oscillatory behavior. We identify a dynamical phase characterized by quasi-periodic oscillations with multiple incommensurate frequencies, corresponding to a continuous-time quasi-crystalline order. In addition, we identify a phase transition from a time quasi-crystalline phase to a time-crystalline phase at sufficiently strong inter-chain coupling. This transition can be understood as the evolution from partially synchronized oscillations between the two chains to fully synchronized dynamics. From a mathematical perspective, we confirm that the transition is governed by either a saddle-node or a torus bifurcation, depending on the separation between the two original oscillation frequencies. These theoretical results provide guidance for exploring complex periodic dynamics in Rydberg atomic platforms.