Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Generalized photon-number-splitting attack on a coherent one-way quantum-key-distribution protocol

Ashot S. Avanesov, Dmitry Anatolevich Kronberg

Published Apr 2, 2025• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum key distribution (QKD) offers an unprecedented level of security, which, unlike its classical analog, is not based on computational assumptions. But tight lower and upper security bounds are still not provided for some QKD protocols. Here, we propose an effective attack strategy for coherent one-way (COW) QKD protocol. It is a generalized photon-number splitting (PNS) attack combined with sequential unambiguous state discrimination (USD) attack. We discuss the possibility of a generalized PNS attack because this attack demonstrates efficiency and does not introduce error, while previously the COW protocol was considered secure against PNS attack. To our knowledge, it is the most efficient attack on the COW protocol to date, hence we sharpen the upper security bound for this protocol.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.111.042601

Related papers

Upper Security Bounds for Coherent-One-Way Quantum Key Distribution

J. González-Payo, Róbert Trényi, Weilong Wang +1 more

The performance of quantum key distribution (QKD) is severely limited by multiphoton pulses emitted by laser sources due to the photon-number splitting attack. Coherent-one-way (COW) QKD has been introduced as a promising solution to overcome this limitation, and thus extend the achievable distance of practical QKD. Indeed, thanks to its experimental simplicity, the COW protocol is already used in commercial applications. Here, we derive simple upper security bounds on its secret key rate, which demonstrate that it scales at most quadratically with the system's transmittance, thus solving a long-standing problem. That is, in contrast to what has been claimed, this approach is inappropriate for long-distance QKD transmission. Remarkably, our findings imply that all implementations of the COW protocol performed so far are insecure.

arXiv:2006.16891•Physical Review Letters•Dec 31, 2020•31 citations

Foiling zero-error attacks against coherent-one-way quantum key distribution

Marcos Curty

To protect practical quantum key distribution (QKD) against photon-number-splitting attacks, one could measure the coherence of the received signals. One prominent example that follows this approach is coherent-one-way (COW) QKD, which is commercially available. Surprisingly, however, it has been shown very recently that its secret key rate scales quadratically with the channel transmittance and thus this scheme is unsuitable for long-distance transmission. This result was derived by using a zero-error attack, which prevents the distribution of a secure key without introducing any error. Here we study various countermeasures to foil zero-error attacks against COW QKD. They require either monitoring some additional available detection statistics or increasing the number of quantum states emitted. We obtain asymptotic upper security bounds on the secret key rate that scale close to linearly with the channel transmittance, thus suggesting the effectiveness of the countermeasures to boost the performance of this protocol.

arXiv:2108.12393•Physical Review A•Dec 10, 2021•7 citations

Hacking coherent-one-way quantum key distribution with present-day technology

Javier Rey-Domínguez, Álvaro Navarrete, Peter van Loock +1 more

Abstract Recent results have shown that the secret-key rate of coherent-one-way (COW) quantum key distribution (QKD) scales quadratically with the system’s transmittance, thus rendering this protocol unsuitable for long-distance transmission. This was proven by using a so-called zero-error attack, which relies on an unambiguous state discrimination (USD) measurement. This type of attack allows the eavesdropper to learn the whole secret key without introducing any error. Here, we investigate the feasibility and effectiveness of zero-error attacks against COW QKD with present-day technology. For this, we introduce two practical USD receivers that can be realized with linear passive optical elements, phase-space displacement operations and threshold single-photon detectors. The first receiver is optimal with respect to its success probability, while the second one can impose stronger restrictions on the protocol’s performance with faulty eavesdropping equipment. Our findings suggest that zero-error attacks could break the security of COW QKD even assuming realistic experimental conditions.

arXiv:2406.13760•Quantum Science and Technology•May 22, 2024•5 citations

Quantum soft filtering for the improved security analysis of the coherent one-way quantum-key-distribution protocol

Dmitry Anatolevich Kronberg, Anastasiia S. Nikolaeva, Yury Kurochkin +1 more

A precise security analysis of practical quantum key distribution (QKD) systems is an important step for improving their performance. Here we consider a class of quantum soft filtering operations, which generalizes the unambiguous state discrimination (USD) technique. These operations can be applied as a basis for a security analysis of the original coherent one-way (COW) QKD protocol since their application interpolates between beam-splitting (BS) and USD attacks. We demonstrate that a zero-error attack based on quantum soft filtering operations gives a larger amount of the information for Eve at a given level of losses. We calculate the Eve information as a function of the channel length. The efficiency of the proposed attack highly depends on the level of the monitoring under the maintenance of the statistics of control (decoy) states, and best-case results are achieved in the case of the absence of maintenance of control state statistics. Our results form additional requirements for the analysis of practical QKD systems based on the COW QKD protocol and its variants by providing an upper bound on the security.

arXiv:1910.06167•Physical Review A•Mar 20, 2020•26 citations

Quantum soft filtering for the improved security analysis of the coherent one-way QKD protocol

Dmitry Anatolevich Kronberg, Anastasiia S. Nikolaeva, Yury Kurochkin +1 more

A precise security analysis of practical quantum key distribution (QKD) systems is an important step for improving their performance. Here we consider a class of quantum soft filtering operations, which generalizes the unambiguous state discrimination (USD) technique. These operations can be applied as a basis for a security analysis of the original coherent one-way (COW) QKD protocol since their application interpolates between beam-splitting (BS) and USD attacks. We demonstrate that a zero-error attack based on quantum soft filtering operations gives a larger amount of the information for Eve at a given level of losses. We calculate the Eve information as a function of the channel length. The efficiency of the proposed attack highly depends on the level of the monitoring under the maintenance of the statistics of control (decoy) states, and best-case results are achieved in the case of the absence of maintenance of control state statistics. Our results form additional requirements for the analysis of practical QKD systems based on the COW QKD protocol and its variants by providing an upper bound on the security.

•Oct 14, 2019•0 citations

Analysis of PNS Attacks on Quantum Key Distribution Protocols

Madhu Venkat Dasari, S. Kirubakaran, A. Paventhan

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is one of the most promising technologies that enable theoretically unbreakable secure communications in this highly advanced information security era. This work provides a comparative analysis of QKD protocols such as BB84, Coherent One-Way (COW), and Differential Phase-Shift (DPS) against eavesdropping attacks e.g., Photon Number Splitting (PNS) attack. It employs a realistic approach to simulations such as using weak coherent pulse (WCP) sources. This work also explores qubit generation and the whole key distribution process in non-ideal conditions. Detailed algorithms have been discussed that simulate the encoding, transmission, and decoding process for every protocol, as well as simulating PNS attacks where an eavesdropper removes photons to gain key information without any detectable errors. Statistical metrics, such as Visibility and the information gain, are used to quantify the impact of these attacks. Future work aspects may include the extension of the simulation to incorporate additional parameters such as channel noise, fiber attenuation, detector dark counts, etc. to provide a realistic analysis to compare various QKD protocols.

IEEE Wireless Antenna and Microwave Symposium (WAMS)•Jun 5, 2025•1 citation
Quantum key distribution (QKD) offers an unprecedented level of security, which, unlike its classical analog, is not based on computational assumptions. But tight lower and upper security bounds are still not provided for some QKD protocols. Here, we propose an effective attack strategy for coherent one-way (COW) QKD protocol. It is a generalized photon-number splitting (PNS) attack combined with sequential unambiguous state discrimination (USD) attack. We discuss the possibility of a generalized PNS attack because this attack demonstrates efficiency and does not introduce error, while previously the COW protocol was considered secure against PNS attack. To our knowledge, it is the most efficient attack on the COW protocol to date, hence we sharpen the upper security bound for this protocol.
The performance of quantum key distribution (QKD) is severely limited by multiphoton pulses emitted by laser sources due to the photon-number splitting attack. Coherent-one-way (COW) QKD has been introduced as a promising solution to overcome this limitation, and thus extend the achievable distance of practical QKD. Indeed, thanks to its experimental simplicity, the COW protocol is already used in commercial applications. Here, we derive simple upper security bounds on its secret key rate, which demonstrate that it scales at most quadratically with the system's transmittance, thus solving a long-standing problem. That is, in contrast to what has been claimed, this approach is inappropriate for long-distance QKD transmission. Remarkably, our findings imply that all implementations of the COW protocol performed so far are insecure.
To protect practical quantum key distribution (QKD) against photon-number-splitting attacks, one could measure the coherence of the received signals. One prominent example that follows this approach is coherent-one-way (COW) QKD, which is commercially available. Surprisingly, however, it has been shown very recently that its secret key rate scales quadratically with the channel transmittance and thus this scheme is unsuitable for long-distance transmission. This result was derived by using a zero-error attack, which prevents the distribution of a secure key without introducing any error. Here we study various countermeasures to foil zero-error attacks against COW QKD. They require either monitoring some additional available detection statistics or increasing the number of quantum states emitted. We obtain asymptotic upper security bounds on the secret key rate that scale close to linearly with the channel transmittance, thus suggesting the effectiveness of the countermeasures to boost the performance of this protocol.
Abstract Recent results have shown that the secret-key rate of coherent-one-way (COW) quantum key distribution (QKD) scales quadratically with the system’s transmittance, thus rendering this protocol unsuitable for long-distance transmission. This was proven by using a so-called zero-error attack, which relies on an unambiguous state discrimination (USD) measurement. This type of attack allows the eavesdropper to learn the whole secret key without introducing any error. Here, we investigate the feasibility and effectiveness of zero-error attacks against COW QKD with present-day technology. For this, we introduce two practical USD receivers that can be realized with linear passive optical elements, phase-space displacement operations and threshold single-photon detectors. The first receiver is optimal with respect to its success probability, while the second one can impose stronger restrictions on the protocol’s performance with faulty eavesdropping equipment. Our findings suggest that zero-error attacks could break the security of COW QKD even assuming realistic experimental conditions.
A precise security analysis of practical quantum key distribution (QKD) systems is an important step for improving their performance. Here we consider a class of quantum soft filtering operations, which generalizes the unambiguous state discrimination (USD) technique. These operations can be applied as a basis for a security analysis of the original coherent one-way (COW) QKD protocol since their application interpolates between beam-splitting (BS) and USD attacks. We demonstrate that a zero-error attack based on quantum soft filtering operations gives a larger amount of the information for Eve at a given level of losses. We calculate the Eve information as a function of the channel length. The efficiency of the proposed attack highly depends on the level of the monitoring under the maintenance of the statistics of control (decoy) states, and best-case results are achieved in the case of the absence of maintenance of control state statistics. Our results form additional requirements for the analysis of practical QKD systems based on the COW QKD protocol and its variants by providing an upper bound on the security.
A precise security analysis of practical quantum key distribution (QKD) systems is an important step for improving their performance. Here we consider a class of quantum soft filtering operations, which generalizes the unambiguous state discrimination (USD) technique. These operations can be applied as a basis for a security analysis of the original coherent one-way (COW) QKD protocol since their application interpolates between beam-splitting (BS) and USD attacks. We demonstrate that a zero-error attack based on quantum soft filtering operations gives a larger amount of the information for Eve at a given level of losses. We calculate the Eve information as a function of the channel length. The efficiency of the proposed attack highly depends on the level of the monitoring under the maintenance of the statistics of control (decoy) states, and best-case results are achieved in the case of the absence of maintenance of control state statistics. Our results form additional requirements for the analysis of practical QKD systems based on the COW QKD protocol and its variants by providing an upper bound on the security.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) is one of the most promising technologies that enable theoretically unbreakable secure communications in this highly advanced information security era. This work provides a comparative analysis of QKD protocols such as BB84, Coherent One-Way (COW), and Differential Phase-Shift (DPS) against eavesdropping attacks e.g., Photon Number Splitting (PNS) attack. It employs a realistic approach to simulations such as using weak coherent pulse (WCP) sources. This work also explores qubit generation and the whole key distribution process in non-ideal conditions. Detailed algorithms have been discussed that simulate the encoding, transmission, and decoding process for every protocol, as well as simulating PNS attacks where an eavesdropper removes photons to gain key information without any detectable errors. Statistical metrics, such as Visibility and the information gain, are used to quantify the impact of these attacks. Future work aspects may include the extension of the simulation to incorporate additional parameters such as channel noise, fiber attenuation, detector dark counts, etc. to provide a realistic analysis to compare various QKD protocols.