Quantum computers offer the potential to process data using significantly fewer qubits compared to conventional bits, as per theoretical foundations. However, recent experiments [1] have indicated that the practical feasibility of retrieving an image from its quantum encoded version is currently limited to very small image sizes. Despite this constraint, variational quantum machine learning algorithms can still be employed in the current noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) era. An example is a hybrid quantum machine learning approach for edge detection [2]. In our study, we showcase an application of quantum transfer learning for detecting cracks in gray value images. We evaluate the performance and training time of PennyLane’s standard qubits with IBM’s qasm_simulator and real backends, offering insights into their execution efficiency.
Quantum computers offer the potential to process data using significantly fewer qubits compared to conventional bits, as per theoretical foundations. However, recent experiments [1] have indicated that the practical feasibility of retrieving an image from its quantum encoded version is currently limited to very small image sizes. Despite this constraint, variational quantum machine learning algorithms can still be employed in the current noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) era. An example is a hybrid quantum machine learning approach for edge detection [2]. In our study, we showcase an application of quantum transfer learning for detecting cracks in gray value images. We evaluate the performance and training time of PennyLane’s standard qubits with IBM’s qasm_simulator and real backends, offering insights into their execution efficiency.
Quantum computers possess the potential to process data using a remarkably reduced number of qubits compared to conventional bits, as per theoretical foundations. However, recent experiments have indicated that the practical feasibility of retrieving an image from its quantum encoded version is currently limited to very small image sizes. Despite this constraint, variational quantum machine learning algorithms can still be employed in the current noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) era. An example is a hybrid quantum machine learning approach for edge detection. In our study, we present an application of quantum transfer learning for detecting cracks in gray value images. We compare the performance and training time of PennyLane's standard qubits with IBM's qasm\_simulator and real backends, offering insights into their execution efficiency.
Quantum transfer learning combines pretrained classical deep learning models with quantum circuits to reuse expressive feature representations while limiting the number of trainable parameters. In this work, we introduce a family of compact quantum transfer learning architectures that attach variational quantum classifiers to frozen convolutional backbones for image classification. We instantiate and evaluate several classical-quantum hybrid models implemented in PennyLane and Qiskit, and systematically compare them with a classical transfer-learning baseline across heterogeneous image datasets. To ensure a realistic assessment, we evaluate all approaches under both ideal simulation and noisy emulation using noise models calibrated from IBM quantum hardware specifications, as well as on real IBM quantum hardware. Experimental results show that the proposed quantum transfer learning architectures achieve competitive and, in several cases, superior accuracy while consistently reducing training time and energy consumption relative to the classical baseline. Among the evaluated approaches, PennyLane-based implementations provide the most favorable trade-off between accuracy and computational efficiency, suggesting that hybrid quantum transfer learning can offer practical benefits in realistic NISQ era settings when feature extraction remains classical.
We implement a post-variational quantum neural network on a real HPC-QC system and show the feasibility of fully training this class of algorithms on current Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices, which are limited by noise, low number of qubits, and scarcity. Post-variational methods are hybrid classical-quantum Machine Learning algorithms that remove the need for quantum circuits evaluations during training, thus making them more suited to the availability constraints of physical quantum devices. We investigate the scalability of the algorithm to a higher number of qubits, larger datasets, and more elaborate models, giving insight for more efficient implementation. Experiments for an image classification task on a cutting-edge HPC-QC system show that post-variational quantum neural networks are fully trainable in reasonable times on a superconducting device. The models trained also show performance at least comparable to a variational approach, with one configuration showing a significant improvement in classification accuracy.
Abstract Edges are image locations where the gray value intensity changes suddenly. They are among the most important features to understand and segment an image. Edge detection is a standard task in digital image processing, solved, for example, using filtering techniques. However, the amount of data to be processed grows rapidly and pushes even supercomputers to their limits. Quantum computing promises exponentially lower memory usage in terms of the number of qubits compared to the number of classical bits. In this paper, we propose a hybrid method for quantum edge detection based on the idea of a quantum artificial neuron. Our method can be practically implemented on quantum computers, especially on those of the current noisy intermediate-scale quantum era. We compare six variants of the method to reduce the number of circuits and thus the time required for the quantum edge detection. Taking advantage of the scalability of our method, we can practically detect edges in images considerably larger than reached before.
We extend the concept of transfer learning, widely applied in modern machine learning algorithms, to the emerging context of hybrid neural networks composed of classical and quantum elements. We propose different implementations of hybrid transfer learning, but we focus mainly on the paradigm in which a pre-trained classical network is modified and augmented by a final variational quantum circuit. This approach is particularly attractive in the current era of intermediate-scale quantum technology since it allows to optimally pre-process high dimensional data (e.g., images) with any state-of-the-art classical network and to embed a select set of highly informative features into a quantum processor. We present several proof-of-concept examples of the convenient application of quantum transfer learning for image recognition and quantum state classification. We use the cross-platform software library PennyLane to experimentally test a high-resolution image classifier with two different quantum computers, respectively provided by IBM and Rigetti.
This thesis presents a systematic empirical evaluation of quantum machine learning performance under noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era constraints. Through 670 controlled experiments, it evaluated quantum kernel support vector machines and variational quantum classifiers against classical baselines on MNIST binary and multiclass classification tasks with systematic variation of problem difficulty, feature dimensionality (4, 8 qubits), and training set size (n ∈{100, 250, 400, 500, 2000, 4000}). Statistical rigor was ensured through five random seeds per condition and comprehensive significance testing. During the testing with binary datasets, classical methods (SVM, logistic regression, k-NN, neural networks) achieved 85.9% to 99.6% accuracy with training times under one second across all sample sizes. Quantum kernel methods utilizing ZZ feature maps yielded 70.5% to 96.0% accuracy, requiring 129 to 2,140 seconds training with quadratic sample size scaling. Larger scale quantum experiments (n = 4000 for both architectures, 8-qubit encoding with n = 2000 for quantum kernels) proved computationally impossible on available hardware leading to out of memory errors, highlighting practical NISQ-era scalability constraints. Variational quantum classifiers exhibited persistent performance stagnation, failing to exceed 66.5% accuracy despite increases in training data and feature dimensionality. Performance gaps ranged from 3.3 to 35.2 percentage points. All quantum classical differences achieved statistical significance (p< 0.05, with 13 of 14 comparisons meeting p< 0.01) and exhibited large to very large efect sizes (d> 1.0, with 13 of 14 comparisons exceeding d> 2.0). To further evaluate performance and scalability, a 4 class classification experiment was conducted following an identical experimental protocol, with training set sizes of n ∈{100, 250, 400}. Across 180 runs, classical baselines achieved mean accuracies between 87.2% and 95% across both 4 and 8 dimensional data. Quantum Kernel SVM struggled during runs with 4 dimensions, accuracy varying between 64.6% and 74%. Quantum Kernel SVM accuracy declined 16%-25% when the dimension and qubit count were increased to 8, showing findings of exponential kernel concentration. The Variational Quantum Classifier also performed poorly, with accuracy ranging from 43.4% to 44.6% across all runs, providing further evidence that it failed to leverage additional features or training data. Experiments employed noiseless statevector simulation, establishing that quantum underperformance stems from fundamental algorithmic limitations independent of hardware noise. A further extension to 8 class classification (digits 0–7) confirmed and amplified these findings: classical methods maintained 65–83% accuracy while Quantum Kernel SVM degraded to 34–47% and VQC collapsed to 21–23%, approaching the 12.5% random baseline. Supplementary appendix experiments further examined amplitude encoding on raw 784 dimensional pixel features and an alternative angle encoding scheme on the 8-class task; the latter demonstrated that replacing the ZZ Feature Map with simple per qubit rotations substantially recovered quantum kernel performance, suggesting feature map design as a more consequential variable than circuit depth or qubit count in near-term quantum classification.