Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Zhongguo kexue. Wulixue Lixue Tianwenxue

Limitations of free operations in quantum resource theory

Liu Feng

Published Feb 27, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum resource theories provide a unified theoretical framework for understanding inherent quantum-mechanical properties that serve as resources in quantum information processing. State conversion can be implemented by free operations. The partial trace and the incoherent operation, similarly to the local operation and classical communication, are all free operations in the corresponding quantum resource theory. This work mainly studies the limitations of these two types of free operations: (1) Masking information is a protocol that encodes quantum information into a bipartite correlated state while the information is completely unknown to local systems. While the no-masking theorem turns out that it is not possible to determinately mask arbitrary quantum states, quantum information in certain restricted sets of states can be masked. We consider the new regime of probabilistic and approximate masking quantum information. Here, the goal is to mask a set of quantum states with maximal probability, allowing for a small error in the masking. And we provide limits on both the fidelity and the probability of masking, and derive limitations on the masking of quantum information by providing bounds on the maximal masking fidelity. (2) From quantum sensors to quantum computers, many technologies require quantum resources. The properties of such states are coherent or correlated in a way that would not be possible in classical physics. Ideally, for technology applications, these states should be in the so-called maximally resource state, one in which all possible measures of quantum resource are maximized. In a quantum system with noise, an important question is whether there exists maximal resource states. This work answered this important quantum question with a negative answer, i.e., there are no maximal resource states in general. In order to do so, this work considers the case of rank-2 states and shows that for particular values of the eigenvalues, there exists no state that can be transformed to all other states under free operations. This in particular implies that in these cases the state that maximizes a given resource measure among all states depends on the choice of resource measure, i.e., it cannot be that the aforementioned family of states maximizes all resource measures.

DOI
10.1360/sspma-2024-0570

Related papers

Stochastic approximate state conversion for entanglement and general quantum resource theories

Tulja Varun Kondra, Chandan Datta, Alexander Streltsov

Quantum resource theories provide a mathematically rigorous way of understanding the nature of various quantum resources. An important problem in any quantum resource theory is to determine how quantum states can be converted into each other within the physical constraints of the theory. The standard approach to this problem is to study approximate or probabilistic transformations. Here, we investigate the intermediate regime, providing limits on both, the fidelity and the probability of state transformations. We derive limitations on the transformations, which are valid in all quantum resource theories, by providing bounds on the maximal transformation fidelity for a given transformation probability. As an application, we show that these bounds imply an upper bound on the asymptotic rates for various classes of states under probabilistic transformations. We also show that the deterministic version of the single copy bounds can be applied for drawing limitations on the manipulation of quantum channels, which goes beyond the previously known bounds of channel manipulations. Furthermore, we completely solve the question of stochastic-approximate state conversion via local operations and classical communication in the following two cases: (i) Both initial and target states are pure bipartite entangled states of arbitrary dimensions. (ii) The target state is a two-qubit entangled state and the initial state is a pure bipartite state.

arXiv:2111.12646•Quantum•Dec 5, 2025•5 citations

Free encoding capacity: A universal unit for quantum resources

Shampa Mondal, Soumajit Das, Preeti Parashar +1 more

A perfect d-dimensional quantum channel can convey log d-bits of classical information by encoding messages in d-orthogonal quantum states. Alternatively, for every quantum state at the senders end, there exist d-encoding operations which produce d-orthogonal quantum states. Transmitting which via a d-level perfect quantum channel it is possible to communicate log d-bits of classical information. But what if the set of encoding operations is restricted only within a physically constrained class? Here, we consider such a class of encoding operations to be the set of free operations for any quantum resource theory and show that the constrained capacity - namely, the free encoding capacity (FEC) emerged as a unit of the corresponding quantum resource. Moreover, we show that for the pointed resource theories - a resource theory admitting only a single free state - FEC becomes a faithful resource measure also. We also discuss the implications of FEC in the question of resource-theoretic state transformations and the possibility of extending its faithfulness for general quantum resource theories.

quant-pharXiv:2601.23116•Feb 2, 2026•0 citations

The Structure of Higher-Order Quantum Resources with an Application to Coherence

Felix Ahnefeld, Thomas Theurer, Martin B. Plenio

We develop a general framework for higher-order quantum resources that treats the resourcefulness of quantum states, channels, and supermaps (also called processes) in a unified manner. By generalizing well-established concepts from resource theories of states and channels, we introduce and study supermap resource monotones and supermap distillation and dilution. As free supermaps, we consider free networks (supermaps that can be implemented with free channels), compatible supermaps (sets of supermaps closed under arbitrary composition), and maximally free superchannels. Specializing to approximate channel-to-channel conversions, we show that under mild assumptions, the conversion error with respect to the diamond distance and the worst-case infidelity coincide. We then apply the general framework to resource theories of dynamical coherence, where we establish the existence of largest sets of compatible supermaps. By characterizing these sets with semidefinite constraints, we show that they are strictly larger than the corresponding free networks but do not contain all maximally free superchannels. We finish by investigating the operational differences of these sets in one-shot channel distillation and dilution, providing solutions for both tasks in the parallel setting and for dilution in the adaptive setting.

quant-pharXiv:2609.40186•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

Resource theory of Absolute Negativity

Roberto Salazar, Jakub Czartowski, Junior, A. de Oliveira

A crucial goal of quantum information is to find new ways to exploit the properties of quantum devices as resources. One of the prominent properties of quantum devices of particular interest is their negativity in quasi-probability representations, intensively studied in foundational and practical investigations. In this article, we introduce the concept of Absolute Negativity to characterise the negativity of sets of quantum devices in a basis-independent way. Moreover, we provide a resource theory for our relational notion of Absolute Negativity, which applies to sets of quantum state-measurement pairs. Additionally, we determine a complete hierarchy of upper bounds for resource measures, which allows for estimating the resources of a set of devices. We demonstrate operational interpretations of our resource theory for communication and output-estimation advantages over state-measurement pairs with a classical probability representation. Furthermore, we illustrate the newly introduced concepts with an exhaustive analysis of a simple case of four qubit state-measurement pairs. Finally, we outline possible generalisations, applications and open questions.

arXiv:2205.13480•May 26, 2022•1 citation

Transformacje stanów w teoriach zasobów kwantowych

Tulja Varun Kondra

Quantum theory provides us with a mathematical framework to understand nature at the microscopic level.It explains phenomena that classical physics could not account for.A deeper understanding of these non-classical phenomena (e.g., entanglement and quantum coherence) is not only of a foundational interest, but also paves the way towards potential technological advancements.Developments in the field of quantum information showed that such quantum features help us to perform operational tasks which would be impossible in the framework of classical physics.Therefore, these quantum phenomena can be viewed as resources which help us to go beyond the restrictions imposed by classical physics.Inspired by this, the mathematical framework of quantum resource theories was developed.Each resource theory singles out a particular quantum resource by setting the states which contain no resource as free states.Furthermore, the set of free operations are defined such that they do not generate resource states out of free states.An important problem in any resource theory is to understand how different resources transform into each other under the action of free operations.This problem of state transformation will be the main focus of this thesis.We will start by studying the notion of deterministic transformations, where one aims to achieve a target state without a chance of failure.We will explore the connection between deterministic transformations and the problem of quantification of resources.We will then go further and concentrate on transformations which allow for a probability of failure, and study the fundamental restrictions imposed on the achievable error and the probability of success.Finally we will explore the idea of catalytic transformations, where we allow for an ancillary quantum system which increases the transformation power while remaining invariant in the process.For the resource theory of entanglement, we will give a full solution for this problem when the target state is pure and the initial state is distillable.Finally, we discuss potential applications of catalysis to the problem of sending quantum information through noisy channels.

•Feb 1, 2024•0 citations

No-masking theorem for observables

Swapnil Bhowmick, Abhay Srivastav, Arun Kumar Pati

The no-masking theorem for quantum information proves that it is impossible to encode an arbitrary input state into a larger bipartite entangled state such that the full information is stored in the correlation but the individual subsystems have no information about the input state. Here, we ask the question: Is it possible to mask an observable such that the information about the observable is available in the joint system, but individual subsystems reveal nothing about the imprints of the observable? This generalizes the notion of masking to observables. We show that a universal unitary that can mask an arbitrary observable in any dimension does not exist. For a qubit system, we show that the masking operation for a given observable is locally unitarily connected to the swap operation. This suggests a conservation law for information content of observables that goes beyond the conservation laws under symmetry operations. Furthermore, we prove that the unconditional no-bit commitment result follows from the no-masking theorem for observables. Our results can have important applications in quantum information and quantum communication where we encode information not in states but in observables.

arXiv:2209.12261•Physical Review A•Aug 15, 2024•2 citations
Quantum resource theories provide a unified theoretical framework for understanding inherent quantum-mechanical properties that serve as resources in quantum information processing. State conversion can be implemented by free operations. The partial trace and the incoherent operation, similarly to the local operation and classical communication, are all free operations in the corresponding quantum resource theory. This work mainly studies the limitations of these two types of free operations: (1) Masking information is a protocol that encodes quantum information into a bipartite correlated state while the information is completely unknown to local systems. While the no-masking theorem turns out that it is not possible to determinately mask arbitrary quantum states, quantum information in certain restricted sets of states can be masked. We consider the new regime of probabilistic and approximate masking quantum information. Here, the goal is to mask a set of quantum states with maximal probability, allowing for a small error in the masking. And we provide limits on both the fidelity and the probability of masking, and derive limitations on the masking of quantum information by providing bounds on the maximal masking fidelity. (2) From quantum sensors to quantum computers, many technologies require quantum resources. The properties of such states are coherent or correlated in a way that would not be possible in classical physics. Ideally, for technology applications, these states should be in the so-called maximally resource state, one in which all possible measures of quantum resource are maximized. In a quantum system with noise, an important question is whether there exists maximal resource states. This work answered this important quantum question with a negative answer, i.e., there are no maximal resource states in general. In order to do so, this work considers the case of rank-2 states and shows that for particular values of the eigenvalues, there exists no state that can be transformed to all other states under free operations. This in particular implies that in these cases the state that maximizes a given resource measure among all states depends on the choice of resource measure, i.e., it cannot be that the aforementioned family of states maximizes all resource measures.
Quantum resource theories provide a mathematically rigorous way of understanding the nature of various quantum resources. An important problem in any quantum resource theory is to determine how quantum states can be converted into each other within the physical constraints of the theory. The standard approach to this problem is to study approximate or probabilistic transformations. Here, we investigate the intermediate regime, providing limits on both, the fidelity and the probability of state transformations. We derive limitations on the transformations, which are valid in all quantum resource theories, by providing bounds on the maximal transformation fidelity for a given transformation probability. As an application, we show that these bounds imply an upper bound on the asymptotic rates for various classes of states under probabilistic transformations. We also show that the deterministic version of the single copy bounds can be applied for drawing limitations on the manipulation of quantum channels, which goes beyond the previously known bounds of channel manipulations. Furthermore, we completely solve the question of stochastic-approximate state conversion via local operations and classical communication in the following two cases: (i) Both initial and target states are pure bipartite entangled states of arbitrary dimensions. (ii) The target state is a two-qubit entangled state and the initial state is a pure bipartite state.
A perfect d-dimensional quantum channel can convey log d-bits of classical information by encoding messages in d-orthogonal quantum states. Alternatively, for every quantum state at the senders end, there exist d-encoding operations which produce d-orthogonal quantum states. Transmitting which via a d-level perfect quantum channel it is possible to communicate log d-bits of classical information. But what if the set of encoding operations is restricted only within a physically constrained class? Here, we consider such a class of encoding operations to be the set of free operations for any quantum resource theory and show that the constrained capacity - namely, the free encoding capacity (FEC) emerged as a unit of the corresponding quantum resource. Moreover, we show that for the pointed resource theories - a resource theory admitting only a single free state - FEC becomes a faithful resource measure also. We also discuss the implications of FEC in the question of resource-theoretic state transformations and the possibility of extending its faithfulness for general quantum resource theories.
We develop a general framework for higher-order quantum resources that treats the resourcefulness of quantum states, channels, and supermaps (also called processes) in a unified manner. By generalizing well-established concepts from resource theories of states and channels, we introduce and study supermap resource monotones and supermap distillation and dilution. As free supermaps, we consider free networks (supermaps that can be implemented with free channels), compatible supermaps (sets of supermaps closed under arbitrary composition), and maximally free superchannels. Specializing to approximate channel-to-channel conversions, we show that under mild assumptions, the conversion error with respect to the diamond distance and the worst-case infidelity coincide. We then apply the general framework to resource theories of dynamical coherence, where we establish the existence of largest sets of compatible supermaps. By characterizing these sets with semidefinite constraints, we show that they are strictly larger than the corresponding free networks but do not contain all maximally free superchannels. We finish by investigating the operational differences of these sets in one-shot channel distillation and dilution, providing solutions for both tasks in the parallel setting and for dilution in the adaptive setting.
A crucial goal of quantum information is to find new ways to exploit the properties of quantum devices as resources. One of the prominent properties of quantum devices of particular interest is their negativity in quasi-probability representations, intensively studied in foundational and practical investigations. In this article, we introduce the concept of Absolute Negativity to characterise the negativity of sets of quantum devices in a basis-independent way. Moreover, we provide a resource theory for our relational notion of Absolute Negativity, which applies to sets of quantum state-measurement pairs. Additionally, we determine a complete hierarchy of upper bounds for resource measures, which allows for estimating the resources of a set of devices. We demonstrate operational interpretations of our resource theory for communication and output-estimation advantages over state-measurement pairs with a classical probability representation. Furthermore, we illustrate the newly introduced concepts with an exhaustive analysis of a simple case of four qubit state-measurement pairs. Finally, we outline possible generalisations, applications and open questions.
Quantum theory provides us with a mathematical framework to understand nature at the microscopic level.It explains phenomena that classical physics could not account for.A deeper understanding of these non-classical phenomena (e.g., entanglement and quantum coherence) is not only of a foundational interest, but also paves the way towards potential technological advancements.Developments in the field of quantum information showed that such quantum features help us to perform operational tasks which would be impossible in the framework of classical physics.Therefore, these quantum phenomena can be viewed as resources which help us to go beyond the restrictions imposed by classical physics.Inspired by this, the mathematical framework of quantum resource theories was developed.Each resource theory singles out a particular quantum resource by setting the states which contain no resource as free states.Furthermore, the set of free operations are defined such that they do not generate resource states out of free states.An important problem in any resource theory is to understand how different resources transform into each other under the action of free operations.This problem of state transformation will be the main focus of this thesis.We will start by studying the notion of deterministic transformations, where one aims to achieve a target state without a chance of failure.We will explore the connection between deterministic transformations and the problem of quantification of resources.We will then go further and concentrate on transformations which allow for a probability of failure, and study the fundamental restrictions imposed on the achievable error and the probability of success.Finally we will explore the idea of catalytic transformations, where we allow for an ancillary quantum system which increases the transformation power while remaining invariant in the process.For the resource theory of entanglement, we will give a full solution for this problem when the target state is pure and the initial state is distillable.Finally, we discuss potential applications of catalysis to the problem of sending quantum information through noisy channels.
The no-masking theorem for quantum information proves that it is impossible to encode an arbitrary input state into a larger bipartite entangled state such that the full information is stored in the correlation but the individual subsystems have no information about the input state. Here, we ask the question: Is it possible to mask an observable such that the information about the observable is available in the joint system, but individual subsystems reveal nothing about the imprints of the observable? This generalizes the notion of masking to observables. We show that a universal unitary that can mask an arbitrary observable in any dimension does not exist. For a qubit system, we show that the masking operation for a given observable is locally unitarily connected to the swap operation. This suggests a conservation law for information content of observables that goes beyond the conservation laws under symmetry operations. Furthermore, we prove that the unconditional no-bit commitment result follows from the no-masking theorem for observables. Our results can have important applications in quantum information and quantum communication where we encode information not in states but in observables.