We compare critical quantum sensing to passive quantum strategies to perform frequency estimation. Critical strategies achieve quadratic scaling in the number of photons even in dissipative scenarios, thus outperforming passive quantum strategies.
Quantum phenomena offer the possibility of measuring physical quantities with precision beyond classical limits. However, current progress is constrained by scalability, environmental noise, and challenges in practical integration. This highlights the necessity for novel approaches. An emerging paradigm in this direction is , which harnesses the enhanced susceptibility and nonclassical correlations that naturally occur near quantum phase transitions as resources for quantum-enhanced precision. This tutorial provides a pedagogical introduction to key concepts and a detailed overview of prominent quantum sensing strategies that exploit critical phenomena in metrology. Through examples of increasing complexity, the reader is guided through various critical quantum sensing protocols applied to different critical systems. Special emphasis is placed on the optimal scaling of estimation precision with respect to fundamental resources. Finally, we discuss how critical quantum metrology extends from idealized models to realistic open-system, dissipative regimes, and strongly correlated fermionic systems, outlining both the challenges and opportunities for future quantum technologies.
Critical quantum metrology exploits the hypersensitivity of quantum systems near phase transitions to achieve enhanced precision in parameter estimation. While single-parameter estimation near critical points is well established, the simultaneous estimation of multiple parameters, which is essential for practical sensing applications, remains challenging. This difficulty arises from sloppiness, a phenomenon that typically renders the quantum Fisher information matrix (QFIM) singular or nearly singular. In this work, we demonstrate that multiparameter critical metrology is not only feasible but can also retain divergent precision scaling, provided one accepts a trade-off in the scaling exponent. Using the ground state of the single-cavity Dicke model (DM), we show that two Hamiltonian parameters can be simultaneously estimated with a scalar variance bound scaling as the square root of the critical parameter. This overcomes the inherent sloppiness by leveraging higher-order contributions to the QFIM. To recover the optimal quadratic scaling, we introduce the Dicke dimer (DD) with photon hopping. In this extended model, a triple point in the phase diagram enables the simultaneous closure of two excitation gaps, which effectively increases the rank of the QFIM and restores the ideal single-parameter scaling for specific parameter pairs. Furthermore, we extend our analysis to dissipative settings subject to photon loss. Finally, we establish a connection between the derived critical scalings and the fundamental state preparation time, providing a unified framework to operationally compare different sensing strategies. Our results demonstrate that critical quantum metrology can be made robust against dissipation and scalable to multiparameter scenarios, paving the way for practical quantum sensors operating near phase transitions.
We compare critical quantum sensing to passive quantum strategies to perform frequency estimation, in the case of single-mode quadratic Hamiltonians. We show that, while in the unitary case both strategies achieve precision scaling quadratic with the number of photons, in the presence of dissipation this is true only for critical strategies. We also establish that working at the exceptional point or beyond threshold provides suboptimal performance. This critical enhancement is due to the emergence of a transient regime in the open critical dynamics, and is invariant to temperature changes. When considering both time and system size as resources, for both strategies the precision scales linearly with the product of the total time and the number of photons, in accordance with fundamental bounds. However, we show that critical protocols outperform optimal passive strategies if preparation and measurement times are not negligible. Our results are applicable to a broad variety of critical sensors whose phenomenology can be reduced to that of a single-mode quadratic Hamiltonian, including systems described by finite-component and fully connected models.
In recent years, several estimation strategies have been formulated to determine the value of an unknown parameter in the most precise way, taking into account the presence of noise. These strategies typically rely on the use of quantum entanglement between the sensing probes and they have been shown to be optimal in the asymptotic limit in the number of probes, as long as one performs measurements on shorter and shorter time scales. Here, we present a different approach to frequency estimation, which exploits quantum coherence in the state of each sensing particle in the long time limit and is obtained by properly engineering the environment. By means of a commonly used master equation, we show that our strategy can overcome the precision achievable with entanglement-based strategies for a finite number of probes. We discuss a possible implementation of the scheme in a realistic setup that uses trapped ions as quantum sensors.