IEEE International Conference Nanomaterials: Applications & Properties (NAP)
Spectroscopic Theories and First-principles Calculations for Using Rare-Earth Ions Doped in Nanofabricated Materials to Build Quantum Computers: Showcases of RE3+ Doped Y2SiO5
Without using any trapping lasers, rare-earth (RE) ions can be doped into some nanofabricated materials in form of nanocrystals in a solid state matrix, thus rendering a natural trap for potential application as a quantum computing device. In particular, passive nuclear spin states of RE ions can be utilized as (i) optical quantum memory (with huge density as yielded from nanocrystals), (ii) qubits by encoding in ground hyperfine states and operated as (iii) two-qubit gate when transferring them to active magnetized electronic states. A feasible implementation of qubits is realised by using those doped RE ions whose open-shell (for inner highly shielded $4 f$ shell electrons) energy levels and statevectors are well described by the crystal field (CF) interaction and hyperfine coupling in which the Hamiltonian is composed of various freeion interactions, the CF potential, electronic and nuclear Zeeman effects as well as the hyperfine interaction. For those qubit encoded in the two ground hyperfine states of RE ions, they can have fairly long lifetimes of days and coherence times (from 1.3s for $\mathrm{Er}^{3+}$ to 6 hours for $\mathrm{Eu}^{3+}$) due to the unique spectroscopic properties of RE ions. Because of the recent progress in optical single-ion detection for addressing individual qubits with a specific frequency channel, RE ions could be packed in a solid state 3D matrix at nanometer spacing, hence rendering very high qubit densities for quantum memories. Meanwhile, this configure also leads to strong dipole-dipole interactions (or high connectivity) between qubits which are not nearest neighbors. In this study, Kramers ions like ${ }^{167} \mathbf{E r}$ and ${ }^{171} \mathbf{Y b}$ doped in yttrium orthosilicate ${Y}_{2} {SiO}_{5}$ (YSO) nanocrystals will be investigated as a promising system for quantum computing because of their weak spin bath and possibility for being directly milled in single nanocrystals as nano-resonators. By using the famous Wien2k package to carry out the first-principles calculations, we can obtain the CF parameters and hyperfine constants as well as various electronic properties like energy gap and band structure for those Kramers RE ions doped in YSO. We shall present some essential findings from first-principles calculations to obtain various properties of the ground and excited CF and hyperfine states for those RE ions with an aim to optimize RE ions doping in YSO nanocrystals for quantum memories and qubits, contributing to scalable quantum computing architectures.
Without using any trapping lasers, rare-earth (RE) ions can be doped into some nanofabricated materials in form of nanocrystals in a solid state matrix, thus rendering a natural trap for potential application as a quantum computing device. In particular, passive nuclear spin states of RE ions can be utilized as (i) optical quantum memory (with huge density as yielded from nanocrystals), (ii) qubits by encoding in ground hyperfine states and operated as (iii) two-qubit gate when transferring them to active magnetized electronic states. A feasible implementation of qubits is realised by using those doped RE ions whose open-shell (for inner highly shielded 4f shell electrons) energy levels and statevectors are well described by the crystal field (CF) interaction and hyperfine coupling in which the Hamiltonian is composed of various freeion interactions, the CF potential, electronic and nuclear Zeeman effects as well as the hyperfine interaction. For those qubit encoded in the two ground hyperfine states of RE ions, they can have fairly long lifetimes of days and coherence times (from 1.3s for Er3+ to 6 hours for Eu3+) due to the unique spectroscopic properties of RE ions. Because of the recent progress in optical single-ion detection for addressing individual qubits with a specific frequency channel, RE ions could be packed in a solid state 3D matrix at nanometer spacing, hence rendering very high qubit densities for quantum memories. Meanwhile, this configure also leads to strong dipole-dipole interactions (or high connectivity) between qubits which are not nearest neighbors. In this study, Kramers ions like 167Er and 171Yb doped in yttrium orthosilicate Y2SiO5 (YSO) nanocrystals will be investigated as a promising system for quantum computing because of their weak spin bath and possibility for being directly milled in single nanocrystals as nano-resonators. By using the famous Wien2k package to carry out the first-principles calculations, we can obtain the CF parameters and hyperfine constants as well as various electronic properties like energy gap and band structure for those Kramers RE ions doped in YSO. We shall present some essential findings from first-principles calculations to obtain various properties of the ground and excited CF and hyperfine states for those RE ions with an aim to optimize RE ions doping in YSO nanocrystals for quantum memories and qubits, contributing to scalable quantum computing architectures.
The main aim of this work, was to lay the foundations for the experimental realisation of a quantum mechanical controlled NOT gate in rare-earth-metal-ion-doped crystals. Small amounts of rare-earth elements, added during the growth of some inorganic crystals, will become substituted into the crystal lattice as trivalent ions. The trivalent rare-earth-metal ions between cerium, with atomic number 58, and ytterbium, with atomic number 70, have a partly filled 4f shell, which does not extend spatially outside the full 5s and 5p shells. The 4f vacancies make electronic inner shell transitions possible between spectroscopic 4f terms. Some of these optical transitions have coherence times of the order of milliseconds, when the crystals are cooled down to ~ 4 K. There are several reasons for these extraordinary coherence times, which are approximately 8 orders of magnitude greater than those typical for electronic transitions in solids. The most important one is the cage-like shield which the outer 5s and 5p shells provide for the 4f electrons. Furthermore, since these ions are naturally trapped inside the crystal lattice there is no Doppler broadening of the line-width. The coherence properties of these optical transitions is one of the features that makes these materials attractive for use as a solid-state platform for quantum computing, using these ions as qubits. Another appealing characteristic is the fact that different ions have different optical resonance frequencies, which means that ions belonging to different qubits, which only have nm separation, can still be addressed separately by using different laser frequencies. Since the inter-ion spacing is so small, it is possible to make two ions interact strongly, although they are well shielded, through a permanent dipole-dipole interaction. This interaction can be turned on and off by switching between two different ways of encoding the qubit, a most useful feature. When the qubit is represented as a superposition between two ground state hyperfine levels, the interaction is turned off. The interaction is turned on selectively by transferring this superposition to the optical transition with a pi-pulse, for the specific ions that are to interact. This thesis describes how peaks of ions, absorbing on a single transition, residing in spectral pits with no other ions, have been isolated. It is shown how these ions can be coherently transferred between hyperfine levels via the optically excited state, how the interaction between such peaks of ions representing qubits can be turned on and off, and how subgroups of ions with strong interaction can be distilled out. All the work described here has been performed using the ensemble approach. The ensemble approach will, however, be difficult to scale up to large numbers of qubits. A method employing a single ion in each qubit, using a specialised ion for readout, has therefore also been proposed. The rare-earth-metal-ion-based quantum computing experiments require a laser with coherence properties which at least match those of the material. To this end a frequency stabilisation system was developed for a dye laser. This system uses a transient spectral hole in a rare-earth-metal-ion-doped crystal, of the same kind that is used in the experiments, as frequency reference, and is to the authors knowledge the first demonstration of locking a dye laser to a spectral hole. This system provides a line-width of 1 kHz on a 10 microseconds timescale and a frequency drift below 1 kHz/s.
Quantum light-matter interfaces that reversibly map the quantum state of photons onto the quantum states of atoms, are essential components in the quantum engineering toolbox with applications in quantum communication, computing, and quantum-enabled sensing. In this talk I present our progress towards developing on-chip quantum light-matter interfaces based on nanophotonic resonators fabricated in rare-earth-doped crystals known to exhibit the longest optical and spin coherence times in the solid state. We recently demonstrated coherent control of neodymium (Nd3+) ions coupled to yttrium orthosilicate Y2SiO5 (YSO) photonic crystal nano-beam resonator. The coupling of the Nd3+ 883 nm 4I9/2-4F3/2 transition to the nano-resonator results in a 40 fold enhancement of the transition rate (Purcell effect), and increased optical absorption (~80%) - adequate for realizing efficient optical quantum memories via cavity impedance matching. Optical coherence times T2 up to 100 μs with low spectral diffusion were measured for ions embedded in photonic crystals, which are comparable to those observed in unprocessed bulk samples. This indicates that the remarkable coherence properties of REIs are preserved during nanofabrication process. Multi-temporal mode photon storage using stimulated photon echo and atomic frequency comb (AFC) protocols were implemented in these nano-resonators. Our current technology can be readily transferred to Erbium (Er) doped YSO devices, therefore opening the possibility of efficient on-chip optical quantum memory at 1.5 μm telecom wavelength. Integration with superconducting qubits can lead to devices for reversible quantum conversion of optical photons to microwave photons.
Rare-earth-ion doped crystals are an interesting system for quantum computing investigations due to their long optical and hyperfine coherence times. In particular, the ground-state coherence times can be longer than one second, which makes them perfect for long-term storage of quantum states. They also have the advantage of being a solid-state system. At present, many of the fundamental requirements for quantum computing have been demonstrated using rare-earth-ions; however, quantum state readout has yet to be achieved. The strong-coupling regime is of great importance in cavity quantum electrodynamics, as in this regime interactions between single atoms and single photons can be realized. Strong coupling thereby provides a method of enabling qubit-qubit interactions. It is desirable to achieve this regime with rare-earth-ion doped resonators, as it would enable on-demand readout of quantum states, a necessity for quantum computing, and provide the scalability required for implementation of quantum networks. This thesis describes the work that has gone into investigating the suitability of rare-earth-ion doped whispering-gallery mode resonators for quantum computing applications. A theoretical analysis of the strong-coupling regime is performed, followed by experiments investigating the properties of ions in resonators, and of new rare-earth-ion materials. A final set of experiments studies a new quantum memory protocol for use with rare-earth-ions. A theoretical investigation is undertaken to determine whether the strong-coupling regime will be attainable with rare-earth-ion doped whispering-gallery mode resonators. Emphasis is given to determining which rare-earth-ion materials will have the best properties when used as resonators. Specific applications of the strong-coupling regime are examined for this system; in particular, whether it will be possible to demonstrate the reversible transfer of quantum states, and detection of single dopants. Experiments are performed, measuring the properties of millimetre-sized Pr3+:Y2SiO5 resonators. Direct measurements of cavity quantum electrodynamics parameters are made using photon echoes, giving good agreement with theoretical predictions. Interactions between the atom and cavity are observed and a theoretical model is presented to describe these effects. Thus, a more realistic picture is obtained of the experimental requirements for achieving the strong-coupling regime. The properties of different rare-earth-ion doped materials are measured and analysed to determine their suitability for quantum computing applications. The spin Hamiltonian parameters of Pr3+:YAG are measured using Raman heterodyne spectroscopy, and then used to find the optical transitions with zero first-order Zeeman shift, as this should allow the coherence time to be extended to a point where this system is useful for resonator applications. Hyperfine transitions with zero first-order Zeeman shift are also calculated for Er3+:Y2SiO5, with the aim of enabling long-term storage in a telecommunication-wavelength memory. The thesis concludes with an experimental investigation into a new quantum memory technique that does not require spectral hole burning. The hybrid photon echo rephasing protocol uses strong optical pulses to perform rephasing, thus utilizing the advantageous properties of the two-pulse photon echo. Furthermore, the use of external broadening fields removes the usual problem of noise from amplified spontaneous emission. The properties of this memory are examined using a Pr3+:Y2SiO5 crystal.
This thesis work contributes to the effort of detecting single rare earth ions doped into crystals, an operation crucial for the development of rare earth quantum computer hardware. Doping crystals with rare earth elements, their trivalent ions substitute some of the crystal’s original bonds. These ions have a partially filled 4f shell, protected by the full 5s and 5p shell from the environment which makes them good candidates for qubits. Because not every ion experiences the same electric field from the imperfect crystal, their total linewidth is inhomogeneously broadened. If the doping is sufficiently low and the crystal sufficiently small, each ion undergoes a different optical shift and can thus be addressed separately. Communication between ions happens due to their permanent dipole moments which change according to their energy level. So far no single ions could be detected in Lund because highly doped bulk crystals were used. It was nevertheless tried to construct quantum logic gates using qubits that consisted of an ensemble of ions. Constructing logic gates with these means that every single ion of one qubit needs to be able to communicate with every single ion of another qubit, a method that becomes increasingly difficult when more and more qubits are to be entangled. Connecting as many qubits as possible is a crucial step in building a quantum computer that could outperform classical computers and this could be facilitated if every qubit consisted of only one ion which is the reason for the recent explorations towards nano crystals. This development also makes it possible to address another problem of rare earth ions, their low probability of spontaneous emission. Placing nano crystals into an optical cavity promises the enhancement of spontaneous emission by the Purcell effect. Ideal cavities are Fiber Fabry-Pérot resonators of which one side consists of a mirror coated fiber tip and the other of a plane mirror functioning as the substrate for the nano crystals. It was the aim of this thesis to build a cryostat holder that would bring these two mirrors together with high stability and would allow for vertical and horizontal scanning.
In this thesis, crystals of yttrium orthosilicate (Y2SiO5) that are randomly doped with another rare-earth element, such as praseodymium (Pr), europium (Eu), or cerium (Ce), are investigated with lasers locked to ultra-stable cavities using the Pound-Drever-Hall locking technique. Many of these rare-earth elements have long-lived 4f-4f transitions, hundreds of microseconds to a few milliseconds, with even longer ground hyperfine lifetimes of up to several days. The coherence properties are, to the best of the author's knowledge, the longest achieved for any material, currently with a record of six hours for the nuclear spin states of Eu3+:Y2SiO5 measured at cryogenic temperatures. Furthermore, due to natural trapping and differences in the local environments, each dopant ion experiences a slightly different crystal field, and thus an inhomogeneity in the 4f-4f transition exists between all ions in a crystal. Since the homogeneous linewidth is in the order of kHz or below, whereas the inhomogeneous profile can be several GHz wide, these materials have dense storing capabilities.This thesis explores how light interacts with such rare-earth-ion-doped crystals; how the absorption and light polarization varies during propagation; how spectral features in the inhomogeneous absorption profile can be tailored to create narrowband spectral filters; how the speed of light is slowed down significantly in such narrow transmission windows; and how that can be used to either frequency shift incoming light, control its group velocity, or temporally compress pulses. It also uses rare-earth-ions to research quantum computing, the field of using quantum mechanical effects such as superpositions and entanglements to outperform classical computers on certain specific problems. This is done by examining how two-color pulses can be used to rapidly induce coherence from an initially mixed state; how qubit-qubit interactions can be performed experimentally using ensemble qubits, which opens the door to two-qubit experiments such as the CNOT-gate and entanglements; how a scalable quantum computer might be constructed using a single ion qubit approach with a dedicated readout ion and buffer ion(s) to improve readout fidelity; and how cerium is investigated as a candidate for such a dedicated readout ion.
Light-matter interaction at single quantum object level is a long-lived challenge and dream of physicists. From the 1970s, the development of single ion spectroscopy and the observation of single photon states pave a way to a new era of detecting, and coherently manipulating quantum objects with electromagnetic field at single-ion levels. Later on, the invention of single molecular spectroscopy offers a new approach to investigate single quantum objects in condensed matter, where the sophisticated trapping systems like in ions and cold atoms are not needed, resulting in the discovery of various of single photon emitters embedded in solids. Among all, single quantum dots and single negatively charged nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond attract most attentions, since their single spins can be coherently manipulated and entangled by the light field giving rise to numerous applications from nanoscale sensing to quantum computing. They are intensively studied as the most promising candidates for the realization of solid-state quantum bits. However, these systems coupled to a complex environment which can result in rapid loss of spin coherence or optical instability. Finding an alternative solid-state single system with remarkable optical and spin properties is the motivation of this dissertation. Rare earth ions doped in inorganic crystal hosts provide promises not only by the high quality factor 4f-4f optical transitions but also by the well preserved and long-lived spin states, with the applications from solid-state laser spectroscopy to quantum information processing. However, for almost three decades, not being able to identify single rare earth elements in solids is the obstacle to achieve their full potential functionality. We demonstrated the first direct optical detection of single rare earth ions (praseodymium) in solids in 2012. This research was covered in my Master Degree Thesis. This dissertation presents experimental progress in optically detecting other single rare earth species in crystals, understanding their fundamental spectroscopy properties and coherently controlling them, which is mainly focused on single trivalent cerium ions in different host materials. Following the optical detection of single cerium ions in yttrium aluminum garnet (YAG), the optical and spin properties of single Ce ions are investigated. Single Ce ions show good photostability under the pulsed laser excitation. Still, like in other solid emitters, photo-induced dynamics of single Ce ions is observed, however, in a counterintuitive way under the continuous laser irradiation. To understand this behavior, we proposed a charge dynamics model, and developed a novel method to suppress this undesired charge dynamics. With this approach, we obtain the photoluminescence excitation spectrum of single Ce ions in YAG under a CW laser excitation. Narrow (~80 MHz) and spectrally stable optical transitions between the lowest Kramers doublets of the ground and the excited states are observed. In comparison with the large inhomogeneous broadening (500 GHz), narrow resonant transitions provide the good selectivity in the spectral domain. Moreover, the single Ce ground spin state presents a spin 1/2 system with anisotropy g factor. It results in the optical selection rules dependent on the directions of the external magnetic field. Under parallel external magnetic field with respect to the quantization axis, only the spin-flip transitions are allowed with high transition contrast. It gives the opportunity to optically initialize the ground spin state of single Ce ions with 97.5% fidelity. The coherent spin properties of single Ce ions can be investigated, after the successful optical initialization. By scanning the microwave frequency, we obtain the electron spin resonance of single Ce spin transitions. We show the spin state has a coherence time of 290 ns, which is dominated by the surrounding aluminum nuclear spin bath and impurities induced electron spin bath. The coherence time can be extended to 2 ms through dynamical decoupling method, which approaches closely to the upper limit 4.5 ms due to spin-lattice relaxation. This result indicates single Ce electron spin can be a good solid-state qubit. With the combination of optical and spin manipulations of single Ce ions, a quantum interface between a single spin and a single photon is observed by monitoring the temporal behavior of circularly polarized emission photons from the ion. We obtain the Larmor precession of the excited spin state, indicating the direct mapping of the excited spin states of single Ce ions onto the polarization states of the fluorescence photons. Furthermore, with both optical and spin access, we all-optically demonstrate coherent population trapping of a single Ce spin qubit. To scale up the system for further applications, we present the nano-scale engineering of rare earth species in YAG crystal, with the acquirement of the production yield of Ce and Pr implantation (53 and 91% respectively). The optical and spin properties of single implanted Ce ions show fairly good performance, which paves the way towards coherent coupling of single rare earth qubits in a small volume. Besides the study of single Ce ions, the spectroscopy properties of single praseodymium ions in YAG crystal are investigated. We obtain the photoluminescence excitation spectrum and the hyperfine splitting of a single praseodymium ion. All-optical control of a single praseodymium ion is achieved. In this dissertation, we solve the key problem of optically detecting, spectrally studying and coherently manipulating single rare earth ions in solids. The developed methods including optical detection, initialization, readout, coherent control and nanoscale production of single rare earth elements in crystals offer novel and powerful tools for understanding and exploring the fundamental spectroscopy properties of single rare earth elements in solids. It paves a way towards constructing scalable quantum network based on single rare earth solid-state qubits.