Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Test of universality at first order phase transitions: The Lebwohl–Lasher model

Aojie Xue, Jiahao Xu, David Paul Landau, Kurt Binder

Published Oct 2, 2024• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Finite size scaling for a first order phase transition, where a continuous symmetry is broken, is tested using an approximation of Gaussian probability distributions with a phenomenological "degeneracy" factor. Predictions are compared to the data from Monte Carlo simulations of the Lebwohl-Lasher model on L × L × L simple cubic lattices. The data show that the intersection of the fourth-order cumulant of the order parameter for different lattice sizes can be expressed in terms of the relative degeneracy q = 4π of the ordered and disordered phases. This result further supports the concept of universality at first order transitions developed recently.

DOI
10.1063/5.0221215

Related papers

Finite-size scaling for a first-order transition where a continuous symmetry is broken: The spin-flop transition in the three-dimensional XXZ Heisenberg antiferromagnet

Jiahao Xu, Shan-Ho Tsai, D. P. Landau +1 more

Finite-size scaling for a first-order phase transition where a continuous symmetry is broken is developed using an approximation of Gaussian probability distributions with a phenomenological "degeneracy" factor included. Predictions are compared with data from Monte Carlo simulations of the three-dimensional, XXZ Heisenberg antiferromagnet in a field in order to study the finite-size behavior on a L×L×L simple cubic lattice for the first-order "spin-flop" transition between the Ising-like antiferromagnetic state and the canted, XY-like state. Our theory predicts that for large linear dimension L the field dependence of all moments of the order parameters as well as the fourth-order cumulants exhibit universal intersections. Corrections to leading order should scale as the inverse volume. The values of these intersections at the spin-flop transition point can be expressed in terms of a factor q that characterizes the relative degeneracy of the ordered phases. Our theory yields q=π, and we present numerical evidence that is compatible with this prediction. The agreement between the theory and simulation implies a heretofore unknown universality can be invoked for first-order phase transitions.

arXiv:1901.10643•Physical review. E•Feb 13, 2019•13 citations

A New Universality at a First-Order Phase Transition: The Spin-flop Transition in an Anisotropic Heisenberg Antiferromagnet

Jiahao Xu, Shan-Ho Tsai, David Paul Landau +1 more

Abstract A great triumph of statistical physics in the latter part of the 20th century was the understanding of critical behavior and universality at second-order phase transitions. In contrast, first-order transitions were believed to have no common features. However, we argue that the classic, first-order “spin-flop” transition (between the antiferromagnetic and the rotationally degenerate, canted state) in an anisotropic antiferromagnet in a magnetic field exhibits a new kind of universality. We present a finite-size scaling theory for a first-order phase transition where a continuous symmetry is broken using an approximation of Gaussian probability distributions with a phenomenological degeneracy factor “q” included, where “q” characterizes the relative degeneracy of the ordered phases. Predictions are compared with high resolution Monte Carlo simulations of the three-dimensional, XXZ Heisenberg antiferromagnet in a field to study the finite-size behavior for L×L×L simple cubic lattices. The field dependence of all moments of the order parameters exhibit universal intersections at the spin-flop transition. Our Monte Carlo data agree with theoretical predictions for asymptotic large L behavior. Our theory yields q = π, and we present numerical evidence that is compatible with this prediction. The agreement between the theory and simulation implies a heretofore unknown universality.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Feb 1, 2020•0 citations

Finite-size scaling and Monte Carlo simulations of first-order phase transitions

Jooyoung Lee, J. Michael Kosterlitz

We develop a detailed finite-size-scaling theory at a general, asymmetric, temperature-driven, strongly first-order phase transition in a system with periodic boundary conditions. We compute scaling functions for various cumulants of energy in the form U(L,t)=${\mathit{U}}_{0}$(${\mathit{tL}}^{\mathit{d}}$)+${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$${\mathit{U}}_{1}$(${\mathit{tL}}^{\mathit{d}}$) with t=1-${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$/T. In particular, we consider the specific heat and Binder's fourth cumulant and show this has a minimum value of 2/3-(${\mathit{e}}_{1}$/${\mathit{e}}_{2}$-${\mathit{e}}_{2}$/${\mathit{e}}_{1}$${)}^{2}$/12+O(${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$) at a temperature ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}^{(2)}$(L)-${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$=O(${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$). Various other pseudocritical temperatures corresponding to extrema of other cumulants are evaluated. We compare these theoretical predictions with extensive Monte Carlo simulations of the nominally strong first-order transitions in the eight- and ten-state Potts models in two dimensions for system sizes L\ensuremath{\le}50. The ten-state simulations agree with theory in all details in contrast to the eight-state data, and we give estimates for the bulk specific heats at ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$ using all exactly known analytic results. A criterion is developed to estimate numerically whether or not system sizes used in a simulation of a first-order transition are in the finite-size-scaling regime.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Feb 1, 1991•316 citations

Monte Carlo studies of finite-size effects at first-order transitions

Murty S. S. Challa, D. P. Landau, Kurt Binder

First-order phase transitions are ubiquitous in nature but their presence is often uncertain because of the effects which finite size has on all transitions. In this article we consider a general treatment of size effects on lattice systems with discrete degrees of freedom and which undergo a first-order transition in the thermodynamic limit. We review recent work involving studies of the distribution functions of the magnetization and energy at a first-order transition in a finite sample of size N connected to a bath of size N′. Two cases: N′ = ∞ and N′ = finite are considered. In the former (canonical ensemble) case, the distributions are approximated by a superposition of Gaussians corresponding to the different phases; all finite-size effects then vary as N or 1/N. The latter case involves the Gaussian ensemble where the entropy of the bath has a convenient form; for small N′, first-order transitions are characterized by van der Waals' loops in (for example) the energy vs. temperature curves. Results from extensive Monte Carlo simulations of Ising and Potts models in d = 2 are presented to confirm the predictions. Comparison is made with data from second-order transitions to show that the order of a transition can be distinguished through such studies, although problems still occur for first-order transitions very close to critical points.

Phase Transitions•Aug 1, 1990•14 citations

Finite-size scaling and universality for the totally asymmetric simple-exclusion process

J.G. Brankov, Nadezhda Bunzarova

The applicability of the concepts of finite-size scaling and universality to nonequilibrium phase transitions is considered in the framework of the one-dimensional totally asymmetric simple-exclusion process with open boundaries. In the thermodynamic limit there are boundary-induced transitions both of the first and second order between steady-state phases of the model. We derive finite-size scaling expressions for the current near the continuous phase transition and for the local density near the first-order transition under different stochastic dynamics and compare them to establish the existence of universal functions. Next we study numerically the finite-size behavior of the Lee-Yang zeros of the normalization factor for the different steady-state probabilities.

Physical Review E•Mar 22, 2005•12 citations

Finite-size scaling of Monte Carlo simulations for the fcc Ising antiferromagnet: Effects of the low-temperature phase degeneracy

Ronja Stübel, Wolfhard Janke E

The Ising antiferromagnet on a face-centered cubic (fcc) lattice with nearest-neighbor interaction only is well known to exhibit a macroscopic (exponential in the system size $L$) ground-state degeneracy. With increasing temperature, this degeneracy is expected to be lifted and the model undergoes a first-order phase transition. For a model with an exponential degeneracy in the whole low-temperature phase, it was recently found that the finite-size scaling behavior is governed by leading correction terms $\ensuremath{\sim}{L}^{\ensuremath{-}2}$ instead of $\ensuremath{\sim}{L}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$ as usual. To test the conjecture that such a transmuted behavior may effectively persist also for the fcc antiferromagnet up to some crossover system size, we have performed parallel multicanonical Monte Carlo simulations for lattices of linear size $L\ensuremath{\le}18$ with periodic boundary conditions and determined various inverse pseudo phase transition temperatures, as well as the extremal values of the specific heat and the energetic Binder parameter. We indeed find that, for the simulated lattice sizes, the conjectured transmuted finite-size scaling ansatz fits the data better than the standard ansatz. On this basis, we extrapolate for the transition temperature an estimate of ${T}_{0}=1.735047(46)$.

arXiv:1810.05006•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 9, 2018•7 citations
Finite size scaling for a first order phase transition, where a continuous symmetry is broken, is tested using an approximation of Gaussian probability distributions with a phenomenological "degeneracy" factor. Predictions are compared to the data from Monte Carlo simulations of the Lebwohl-Lasher model on L × L × L simple cubic lattices. The data show that the intersection of the fourth-order cumulant of the order parameter for different lattice sizes can be expressed in terms of the relative degeneracy q = 4π of the ordered and disordered phases. This result further supports the concept of universality at first order transitions developed recently.
Finite-size scaling for a first-order phase transition where a continuous symmetry is broken is developed using an approximation of Gaussian probability distributions with a phenomenological "degeneracy" factor included. Predictions are compared with data from Monte Carlo simulations of the three-dimensional, XXZ Heisenberg antiferromagnet in a field in order to study the finite-size behavior on a L×L×L simple cubic lattice for the first-order "spin-flop" transition between the Ising-like antiferromagnetic state and the canted, XY-like state. Our theory predicts that for large linear dimension L the field dependence of all moments of the order parameters as well as the fourth-order cumulants exhibit universal intersections. Corrections to leading order should scale as the inverse volume. The values of these intersections at the spin-flop transition point can be expressed in terms of a factor q that characterizes the relative degeneracy of the ordered phases. Our theory yields q=π, and we present numerical evidence that is compatible with this prediction. The agreement between the theory and simulation implies a heretofore unknown universality can be invoked for first-order phase transitions.
Abstract A great triumph of statistical physics in the latter part of the 20th century was the understanding of critical behavior and universality at second-order phase transitions. In contrast, first-order transitions were believed to have no common features. However, we argue that the classic, first-order “spin-flop” transition (between the antiferromagnetic and the rotationally degenerate, canted state) in an anisotropic antiferromagnet in a magnetic field exhibits a new kind of universality. We present a finite-size scaling theory for a first-order phase transition where a continuous symmetry is broken using an approximation of Gaussian probability distributions with a phenomenological degeneracy factor “q” included, where “q” characterizes the relative degeneracy of the ordered phases. Predictions are compared with high resolution Monte Carlo simulations of the three-dimensional, XXZ Heisenberg antiferromagnet in a field to study the finite-size behavior for L×L×L simple cubic lattices. The field dependence of all moments of the order parameters exhibit universal intersections at the spin-flop transition. Our Monte Carlo data agree with theoretical predictions for asymptotic large L behavior. Our theory yields q = π, and we present numerical evidence that is compatible with this prediction. The agreement between the theory and simulation implies a heretofore unknown universality.
We develop a detailed finite-size-scaling theory at a general, asymmetric, temperature-driven, strongly first-order phase transition in a system with periodic boundary conditions. We compute scaling functions for various cumulants of energy in the form U(L,t)=U0{\mathit{U}}_{0}U0​(tLd{\mathit{tL}}^{\mathit{d}}tLd)+${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$U1{\mathit{U}}_{1}U1​(tLd{\mathit{tL}}^{\mathit{d}}tLd) with t=1-Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​/T. In particular, we consider the specific heat and Binder's fourth cumulant and show this has a minimum value of 2/3-(e1{\mathit{e}}_{1}e1​/e2{\mathit{e}}_{2}e2​-e2{\mathit{e}}_{2}e2​/e1{\mathit{e}}_{1}e1​)2{)}^{2})2/12+O(${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$) at a temperature Tc(2){\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}^{(2)}Tc(2)​(L)-Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​=O(${\mathit{L}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{d}}$). Various other pseudocritical temperatures corresponding to extrema of other cumulants are evaluated. We compare these theoretical predictions with extensive Monte Carlo simulations of the nominally strong first-order transitions in the eight- and ten-state Potts models in two dimensions for system sizes L\ensuremath{\le}50. The ten-state simulations agree with theory in all details in contrast to the eight-state data, and we give estimates for the bulk specific heats at Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​ using all exactly known analytic results. A criterion is developed to estimate numerically whether or not system sizes used in a simulation of a first-order transition are in the finite-size-scaling regime.
First-order phase transitions are ubiquitous in nature but their presence is often uncertain because of the effects which finite size has on all transitions. In this article we consider a general treatment of size effects on lattice systems with discrete degrees of freedom and which undergo a first-order transition in the thermodynamic limit. We review recent work involving studies of the distribution functions of the magnetization and energy at a first-order transition in a finite sample of size N connected to a bath of size N′. Two cases: N′ = ∞ and N′ = finite are considered. In the former (canonical ensemble) case, the distributions are approximated by a superposition of Gaussians corresponding to the different phases; all finite-size effects then vary as N or 1/N. The latter case involves the Gaussian ensemble where the entropy of the bath has a convenient form; for small N′, first-order transitions are characterized by van der Waals' loops in (for example) the energy vs. temperature curves. Results from extensive Monte Carlo simulations of Ising and Potts models in d = 2 are presented to confirm the predictions. Comparison is made with data from second-order transitions to show that the order of a transition can be distinguished through such studies, although problems still occur for first-order transitions very close to critical points.
The applicability of the concepts of finite-size scaling and universality to nonequilibrium phase transitions is considered in the framework of the one-dimensional totally asymmetric simple-exclusion process with open boundaries. In the thermodynamic limit there are boundary-induced transitions both of the first and second order between steady-state phases of the model. We derive finite-size scaling expressions for the current near the continuous phase transition and for the local density near the first-order transition under different stochastic dynamics and compare them to establish the existence of universal functions. Next we study numerically the finite-size behavior of the Lee-Yang zeros of the normalization factor for the different steady-state probabilities.
The Ising antiferromagnet on a face-centered cubic (fcc) lattice with nearest-neighbor interaction only is well known to exhibit a macroscopic (exponential in the system size LLL) ground-state degeneracy. With increasing temperature, this degeneracy is expected to be lifted and the model undergoes a first-order phase transition. For a model with an exponential degeneracy in the whole low-temperature phase, it was recently found that the finite-size scaling behavior is governed by leading correction terms $\ensuremath{\sim}{L}^{\ensuremath{-}2}$ instead of $\ensuremath{\sim}{L}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$ as usual. To test the conjecture that such a transmuted behavior may effectively persist also for the fcc antiferromagnet up to some crossover system size, we have performed parallel multicanonical Monte Carlo simulations for lattices of linear size $L\ensuremath{\le}18$ with periodic boundary conditions and determined various inverse pseudo phase transition temperatures, as well as the extremal values of the specific heat and the energetic Binder parameter. We indeed find that, for the simulated lattice sizes, the conjectured transmuted finite-size scaling ansatz fits the data better than the standard ansatz. On this basis, we extrapolate for the transition temperature an estimate of T0=1.735047(46){T}_{0}=1.735047(46)T0​=1.735047(46).