Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Civil War Book Review

Entanglement in the Hawking Effect: from Astrophysical to Optical Black Holes

Dimitrios Kranas

Published Apr 26, 2023• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Hawking effect is an exciting physical prediction lying at the intersection of the two most successful theories of the past century, namely, Einstein’s theory of relativity and quantum mechanics. In this dissertation, we put special emphasis on the quantum aspects of the Hawking process encoded in the entanglement shared by the emitted fluxes of created quanta. In particular, we employ sharp tools from quantum information theory to quantify the entanglement produced by the Hawking effect throughout the black hole evaporation process. Our framework allows us to extend previous calculations of entanglement to a larger set of cases, for instance, the situation where a black hole is immersed in a thermal bath, such as the cosmic microwave background (CMB), and the quantum state of infalling radiation is, therefore, mixed. Motivated by recent intense experimental efforts, we extend our framework to the case of an optical white-black hole pair analog gravity system created by a strong electromagnetic pulse propagating in a non-linear dielectric medium. One of the main results presented in this dissertation is the development of a numerical code that recreates the Hawking process in such an optical analog. Utilizing this code together with our quantum information tools, we study how different input quantum states of light alter the amount of the entanglement produced in the Hawking pairs. We find that although ambient thermal noise and detector inefficiencies, unsurprisingly, tend to reduce quantum correlations in the Hawking process, when horizons are illuminated with single-mode squeezed states of light, the entanglement generated increases in a tunable manner. As a last application in optical analogs, we investigate the laser configuration in which two strong electromagnetic pulses propagate in a non-linear dielectric medium exchanging Hawking quanta, thus, stimulating each other. In such a setup, we observe that not only the number of Hawking quanta created is exponentially increased but also the entanglement shared between the mode of the electromagnetic field inside the laser cavity with the modes of the field outside the cavity grows with time. We conclude that these novel results open a promising window for the observability of the quantum origin of the Hawking effect in the lab.

DOI
10.31390/gradschool_dissertations.6215

Related papers

Quantum Aspects of Stimulated Hawking Radiation in an Optical Analog White-Black Hole Pair

Iván Agulló, Anthony J. Brady, Dimitrios Kranas

This Letter introduces a synergistic combination of analytical and numerical methods to study the Hawking effect in optical systems containing the analog of a white-black hole pair. Our analytical treatment, based on techniques from Gaussian quantum information, provides a simple and efficient model to describe all aspects of the out-state, including the entanglement between any bipartition. We complement the study with a numerical analysis and apply our tools to investigate the influence that ambient thermal noise and detector inefficiencies have on the out-state. We find that aspects of the Hawking effect that are of quantum origin, i.e., quantum entanglement, are extremely fragile to the influence of inefficiencies and noise. We propose a protocol to amplify and observe these quantum aspects, based on seeding the process with a single-mode squeezed input, opening the door to new possibilities for experimental verification of the Hawking effect.

Physical Review Letters•Feb 28, 2022•28 citations

Entanglement from rotating black holes in thermal baths

Iván Agulló, Anthony J. Brady, Adrià Delhom +1 more

We extend previous efforts to quantify the entanglement generated in Hawking's evaporation process by including rotation and thermal environments (e.g. the cosmic microwave background). Both extensions are needed to describe real black holes in our Universe. Leveraging techniques from Gaussian quantum information, we find that the black hole's ergoregion is an active source of quantum entanglement and that thermal environments drastically degrade entanglement generation. Our predictions are suitable to be tested in the lab using analog platforms and also provide tools to assess the fate of quantum information for black holes in more generic settings.

arXiv:2307.06215•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 23, 2024•9 citations

Applications of Quantum Optics: From the Quantum Internet to Analogue Gravity

Anthony J. Brady

The aim of this thesis is to highlight applications of quantum optics in two very distinct fields: space-based quantum communication and the Hawking effect in analogue gravity. Regarding the former: We simulate and analyze a constellation of satellites, equipped with entangled photon-pair sources, which provide on-demand entanglement distribution ser- vices to terrestrial receiver stations. Satellite services are especially relevant for long-distance quantum-communication scenarios, as the loss in satellite-based schemes scales more favor- ably with distance than in optical fibers or in atmospheric links, though establishing quantum resources in the space-domain is expensive. We thus develop an optimization technique which balances both the number of satellites in the constellation and the entanglement-distribution rates that they provide. Comparisons to ground-based quantum-repeater rates are also made. Overall, our results suggest that satellite-based quantum networks are a viable option for establishing the backbone of future quantum internet. Regarding the latter: The Hawking effect was discussed in the astrophysical context of the spontaneous decay of black holes into blackbody radiation, i.e. Hawking radiation. However, this effect seems to be universal, appearing anywhere that an event horizon (a region which restricts the flow of information to one direction) forms. Here, we analyze the Hawking effect in an optical-analogue gravity system, building on prior theoretical results regarding this effect in dielectric media. We provide a simplification of the process via the Bloch- Messiah decomposition, which allows us to decompose the Hawking effect into a discrete set of elementary processes. With this simplification and utilizing a popular entanglement measure (the logarithmic negativity), we examine the quantum correlations of the stimulated Hawking effect, explicitly showing that an environmental background temperature, along with backscattering, can lead to entanglement “sudden-death", even when the number of entangled Hawking-pairs is comparatively large. We also discuss the prospect of enhancing and “reviving" entanglement using single-mode, non-classical resources at the input. Though much of the discussion is phrased in terms of an optical-analogue model, the methods used and results obtained apply just as well to a variety of other systems supporting this effect. Finally, we provide decompositions of more exotic scenarios consisting of e.g. a white-hole– black-hole pair which share an interior region.

Civil War Book Review•Mar 15, 2021•0 citations

Analogue Hawking radiation in nonlinear quantum optics

Isaac Bernal, Miguel A. Cortés-Ortiz, David Bermudez

The Hawking effect can be understood as a broad kinematic phenomenon associated with mode behavior near a horizon. While astrophysical black holes produce one specific realization of this radiation, this perspective inspires extensive theoretical and experimental efforts to create event horizons in diverse physical systems to observe the resulting analogue Hawking emission. One of the most successful realizations is the fiber-optical analogue, based on nonlinear quantum optics. In these notes, we introduce and motivate this system while outlining the theoretical concepts underlying the gravitational analogy. Finally, we review key experiments and discuss their impact on the field.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2603.03525•Mar 5, 2026

Stimulating the Quantum Aspects of an Optical Analog White-Black Hole

Iván Agulló, Anthony J. Brady, Dimitrios Kranas

This work introduces a synergistic combination of analytical methods and numerical simulations to study the propagation of weak wave-packet modes in an optical medium containing the analog of a pair white-black hole. We apply our tools to analyze several aspects of the evolution, such as (i) the region of the parameter space where the analogy with the Hawking effect is on firm ground and (ii) the influence that ambient thermal noise and detector inefficiencies have on the observability of the Hawking effect. We find that aspects of the Hawking effect that are of quantum origin, such as quantum entanglement, are extremely fragile to the influence of inefficiencies and noise. We propose a protocol to amplify and observe these quantum aspects, based on seeding the process with a single-mode squeezed input.

arXiv:2107.10217•Jul 21, 2021•0 citations

Quantum Optical Inspired Models for Unitary Black Hole Evaporation

Paul M. Alsing

In this work, we describe optically inspired models for unitary black hole (BH) evaporation. The goal of these models are (i) to be operationally simple, (ii) approximately preserve the thermal nature of the emitted Hawking Radiation (HR), and (iii) attempt to reproduce the Page Curve that purports that information flows forth from the BH when it has evaporated to approximately half its initial mass. We concentrate on modeling the BH as a single mode squeezed state successively interacting, by means of beam splitters and squeezers, with vacuum modes near the horizon, giving rise to entangled pairs representing the external Hawking radiation and its partner particle inside the horizon. Since all states and operations are Gaussian throughout, we use a symplectic formalism to track the evolution of the composite system through the evolving means and variances of their quadrature operators. This allows us to easily compute correlations and entanglement between the BH and the HR, as well as calculate correlations between the BH at early and late times.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2601.09820•Jan 16, 2026
The Hawking effect is an exciting physical prediction lying at the intersection of the two most successful theories of the past century, namely, Einstein’s theory of relativity and quantum mechanics. In this dissertation, we put special emphasis on the quantum aspects of the Hawking process encoded in the entanglement shared by the emitted fluxes of created quanta. In particular, we employ sharp tools from quantum information theory to quantify the entanglement produced by the Hawking effect throughout the black hole evaporation process. Our framework allows us to extend previous calculations of entanglement to a larger set of cases, for instance, the situation where a black hole is immersed in a thermal bath, such as the cosmic microwave background (CMB), and the quantum state of infalling radiation is, therefore, mixed. Motivated by recent intense experimental efforts, we extend our framework to the case of an optical white-black hole pair analog gravity system created by a strong electromagnetic pulse propagating in a non-linear dielectric medium. One of the main results presented in this dissertation is the development of a numerical code that recreates the Hawking process in such an optical analog. Utilizing this code together with our quantum information tools, we study how different input quantum states of light alter the amount of the entanglement produced in the Hawking pairs. We find that although ambient thermal noise and detector inefficiencies, unsurprisingly, tend to reduce quantum correlations in the Hawking process, when horizons are illuminated with single-mode squeezed states of light, the entanglement generated increases in a tunable manner. As a last application in optical analogs, we investigate the laser configuration in which two strong electromagnetic pulses propagate in a non-linear dielectric medium exchanging Hawking quanta, thus, stimulating each other. In such a setup, we observe that not only the number of Hawking quanta created is exponentially increased but also the entanglement shared between the mode of the electromagnetic field inside the laser cavity with the modes of the field outside the cavity grows with time. We conclude that these novel results open a promising window for the observability of the quantum origin of the Hawking effect in the lab.
This Letter introduces a synergistic combination of analytical and numerical methods to study the Hawking effect in optical systems containing the analog of a white-black hole pair. Our analytical treatment, based on techniques from Gaussian quantum information, provides a simple and efficient model to describe all aspects of the out-state, including the entanglement between any bipartition. We complement the study with a numerical analysis and apply our tools to investigate the influence that ambient thermal noise and detector inefficiencies have on the out-state. We find that aspects of the Hawking effect that are of quantum origin, i.e., quantum entanglement, are extremely fragile to the influence of inefficiencies and noise. We propose a protocol to amplify and observe these quantum aspects, based on seeding the process with a single-mode squeezed input, opening the door to new possibilities for experimental verification of the Hawking effect.
We extend previous efforts to quantify the entanglement generated in Hawking's evaporation process by including rotation and thermal environments (e.g. the cosmic microwave background). Both extensions are needed to describe real black holes in our Universe. Leveraging techniques from Gaussian quantum information, we find that the black hole's ergoregion is an active source of quantum entanglement and that thermal environments drastically degrade entanglement generation. Our predictions are suitable to be tested in the lab using analog platforms and also provide tools to assess the fate of quantum information for black holes in more generic settings.
The aim of this thesis is to highlight applications of quantum optics in two very distinct fields: space-based quantum communication and the Hawking effect in analogue gravity. Regarding the former: We simulate and analyze a constellation of satellites, equipped with entangled photon-pair sources, which provide on-demand entanglement distribution ser- vices to terrestrial receiver stations. Satellite services are especially relevant for long-distance quantum-communication scenarios, as the loss in satellite-based schemes scales more favor- ably with distance than in optical fibers or in atmospheric links, though establishing quantum resources in the space-domain is expensive. We thus develop an optimization technique which balances both the number of satellites in the constellation and the entanglement-distribution rates that they provide. Comparisons to ground-based quantum-repeater rates are also made. Overall, our results suggest that satellite-based quantum networks are a viable option for establishing the backbone of future quantum internet. Regarding the latter: The Hawking effect was discussed in the astrophysical context of the spontaneous decay of black holes into blackbody radiation, i.e. Hawking radiation. However, this effect seems to be universal, appearing anywhere that an event horizon (a region which restricts the flow of information to one direction) forms. Here, we analyze the Hawking effect in an optical-analogue gravity system, building on prior theoretical results regarding this effect in dielectric media. We provide a simplification of the process via the Bloch- Messiah decomposition, which allows us to decompose the Hawking effect into a discrete set of elementary processes. With this simplification and utilizing a popular entanglement measure (the logarithmic negativity), we examine the quantum correlations of the stimulated Hawking effect, explicitly showing that an environmental background temperature, along with backscattering, can lead to entanglement “sudden-death", even when the number of entangled Hawking-pairs is comparatively large. We also discuss the prospect of enhancing and “reviving" entanglement using single-mode, non-classical resources at the input. Though much of the discussion is phrased in terms of an optical-analogue model, the methods used and results obtained apply just as well to a variety of other systems supporting this effect. Finally, we provide decompositions of more exotic scenarios consisting of e.g. a white-hole– black-hole pair which share an interior region.
The Hawking effect can be understood as a broad kinematic phenomenon associated with mode behavior near a horizon. While astrophysical black holes produce one specific realization of this radiation, this perspective inspires extensive theoretical and experimental efforts to create event horizons in diverse physical systems to observe the resulting analogue Hawking emission. One of the most successful realizations is the fiber-optical analogue, based on nonlinear quantum optics. In these notes, we introduce and motivate this system while outlining the theoretical concepts underlying the gravitational analogy. Finally, we review key experiments and discuss their impact on the field.
This work introduces a synergistic combination of analytical methods and numerical simulations to study the propagation of weak wave-packet modes in an optical medium containing the analog of a pair white-black hole. We apply our tools to analyze several aspects of the evolution, such as (i) the region of the parameter space where the analogy with the Hawking effect is on firm ground and (ii) the influence that ambient thermal noise and detector inefficiencies have on the observability of the Hawking effect. We find that aspects of the Hawking effect that are of quantum origin, such as quantum entanglement, are extremely fragile to the influence of inefficiencies and noise. We propose a protocol to amplify and observe these quantum aspects, based on seeding the process with a single-mode squeezed input.
In this work, we describe optically inspired models for unitary black hole (BH) evaporation. The goal of these models are (i) to be operationally simple, (ii) approximately preserve the thermal nature of the emitted Hawking Radiation (HR), and (iii) attempt to reproduce the Page Curve that purports that information flows forth from the BH when it has evaporated to approximately half its initial mass. We concentrate on modeling the BH as a single mode squeezed state successively interacting, by means of beam splitters and squeezers, with vacuum modes near the horizon, giving rise to entangled pairs representing the external Hawking radiation and its partner particle inside the horizon. Since all states and operations are Gaussian throughout, we use a symplectic formalism to track the evolution of the composite system through the evolving means and variances of their quadrature operators. This allows us to easily compute correlations and entanglement between the BH and the HR, as well as calculate correlations between the BH at early and late times.