Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The European Physical Journal C

Effects of a thermal bath and the accelerated motion on collective transitions of two atoms in an entangled state

Chenyuan Zhou, Wenting Zhou

Published Feb 23, 2024• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Transition rates of a uniformly accelerated atom coupled to a vacuum scalar field are identical with those of one being static in a thermal bath at a temperature proportional to the proper acceleration a, i.e., $$T_U=\frac{a}{2\pi }$$ T U = a 2 π . We discuss in this paper whether there exists such an equivalence in the electromagnetic field case if more atoms are involved. To be specific, we explore the similarities and distinctions between effects of a thermal bath and those of the uniformly accelerated motion by comparing the transition rates of a two-atom system initially in the symmetric or antisymmetric entangled state [ $$|\psi _{\pm }\rangle $$ | ψ ± ⟩ ] in two cases, i.e., two static atoms in a thermal bath [the thermal case] and two atoms uniformly accelerated in vacuum [the acceleration case]. We discover that, for some particular orientations of atomic dipole moments, coherent radiation which happens in the acceleration case never occurs in the thermal case. The rates in the acceleration case with a low acceleration which means a low $$T_U$$ T U can be smaller or larger and even equal to their counterparts in the thermal case; while the rates in the acceleration case with a high acceleration which means a high $$T_U$$ T U are always much larger than their counterparts in the thermal case. Our results suggest that effects of a thermal bath and those of the uniformly accelerated motion on transition properties of a two-atom system in $$|\psi _{\pm }\rangle $$ | ψ ± ⟩ are not necessarily distinctive, but can be equivalent if the acceleration is relatively low, depending on the value of the interatomic separation.

DOI
10.1140/epjc/s10052-024-12539-6

Related papers

Transitions of a two-atom system in an entangled state and the Fulling–Davies–Unruh effect: The electromagnetic field case

Chenyuan Zhou, Wenting Zhou

We explore, respectively, from the viewpoints of a locally inertial observer and a coaccelerated observer, the transition rates of a two-atom system in the symmetric or antisymmetric entangled state, [Formula: see text] or [Formula: see text], and coupled to the electromagnetic fields. The interatomic separation is assumed to be constant and perpendicular to the acceleration; the fields to which the atoms are coupled are assumed to be in the vacuum state in the locally inertial frame and in a thermal state in the coaccelerated frame. We find that, in the viewpoints of the two observers, both the downward transition [Formula: see text] and the upward transition [Formula: see text] can take place, where [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] denote two eigenstates of the two-atom system with both atoms in their ground states and excited states, respectively. With an appropriate choice of the orientations of the atomic dipole moments, coherent radiation can happen for a system in acceleration but not for one in inertial motion. By comparing the transition rates viewed by the two observers, we show that the transition rates of the accelerated two-atom system viewed by a locally inertial observer can only be recovered in the coaccelerated frame by assuming a thermal bath at the Fulling–Davies–Unruh temperature. The effects of these collective transitions on the evolution of energy of the two-atom system are also analyzed.

Modern Physics Letters A•Jan 20, 2022•2 citations

Radiative Processes of Two Accelerated Entangled Atoms Near Boundaries

Chi Zhang, Wenting Zhou

By considering the interaction between a two-atom system and the vacuum massless scalar field in the viewpoint of an instantaneously inertial observer, we study the rates of transition of a uniformly accelerated two-atom system in the symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state near a reflecting boundary and in a cavity, respectively. We find that both the downward transition | ψ ± ⟩ → | g A g B ⟩ and the upward transition | ψ ± ⟩ → | e A e B ⟩ occur for the accelerated two-atom system, as in sharp contrast with the case of a static two-atom system, in which the upward transition can never happen. Similar to the rates of transition of atoms immersed in a thermal bath with the FDU temperature, both the downward transition rate and the upward transition rate are characterized by the Plank factor ( e 2 π ω 0 / a − 1 ) − 1 . This character of the transition rates is very different from the other radiative properties of the accelerated two-atom system, such as the resonance interatomic energy, for which the revisions of the effects of uniform acceleration are never characterized by such a factor. We show with analytical and numerical results that both the downward transition and the upward transition processes can be effectively manipulated by the atomic non-inertial motion and by the presence of boundaries. By comparing the upward transition rate with the downward transition rate, we discover that, when ω 0 ≫ a , with ω 0 and a being the energy space and the proper acceleration of the two-atom system, the disentanglement caused by the upward transition is negligible, while, if ω 0 ≪ a , the disentanglement caused by the upward transition becomes as important as that caused by the downward transition.

Symmetry•Dec 13, 2019•7 citations

Collective transitions of two entangled atoms and the Fulling-Davies-Unruh effect

Wenting Zhou, Hongwei Yu

We calculate respectively, from the viewpoints of an instantaneously/locally inertial observer and a coaccelerated observer, the transition rates of the two-atom system in the symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state [$|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}⟩$]. The scalar fields to which the atoms are coupled are respectively assumed to be in the vacuum state and a thermal state in the instantaneously inertial frame and in the coaccelerated frame. We show that both the upward transition $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}⟩\ensuremath{\rightarrow}|{e}_{A}{e}_{B}⟩$ and the downward transition $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}⟩\ensuremath{\rightarrow}|{g}_{A}{g}_{B}⟩$ take place, where $|{g}_{A}{g}_{B}⟩$ and $|{e}_{A}{e}_{B}⟩$ represent two collective eigenstates of the two-atom system with both atoms in their ground state and excited state respectively, and the transition rates observed in the two frames are identical only if there exists a thermal bath at the Fulling-Davies-Unruh temperature in the coaccelerated frame. Though both the downward and upward transition rates are characterized by the Plankian factor, this factor does not show up in the average variation rate of energy of the two-atom system, as a result of the perfect cancellation of the terms in the transition rates in the instantaneously inertial frame multiplied by the Plankian factor which corresponds to the Unruh thermal bath, and the cancellation of the temperature-dependent terms in the transition rates observed in the coaccelerated frame. A comparison of the transition rates of a static two-atom system in interaction with the massless scalar field in a thermal state at an arbitrary temperature with those of a uniformly accelerated two-atom system in interaction with the vacuum massless scalar field shows that the equivalence between the thermal bath and the uniform acceleration, which is well known to be valid for the single atom case, no longer holds for the two-atom system in the symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state. The effect of atomic uniform acceleration in the transition rates of the two-atom system, and the roles of both the downward and the upward transitions in the disentanglement of the two-atom system are also discussed.

Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Apr 20, 2020•11 citations

Radiation-reaction-induced transitions of two maximally entangled atoms in noninertial motion

Wenting Zhou, Hongwei Yu

We apply the DDC formalism [proposed by Dalibard, Dupont-Roc and Cohen-Tannoudji] to study the average rate of change of energy of two identical two-level atoms interacting with the vacuum massless scalar field in synchronized motion along stationary trajectories. By separating the contributions of vacuum fluctuations and atomic radiation reaction, we first show that for the two-atom system initially prepared in the factorizable eigenstates $|{g}_{A}{g}_{B}⟩$ and $|{e}_{A}{e}_{B}⟩$, where $g$ and $e$ represent the ground state and the excited state of a single atom, respectively, both vacuum fluctuations and atomic radiation reaction contribute to the average rate of change of energy of the two-atom system, and the contribution of vacuum fluctuations is independent of the interatomic separation while that of atomic radiation reaction is dependent on it. This is contrary to the existing results in the literature where vacuum fluctuations are interatomic-separation dependent. However, if the two-atom system is initially prepared in the unfactorizable symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state, the average rate of change of energy of the two-atom system is never perturbed by the vacuum fluctuations, but is totally a result of the atomic radiation reaction. We then consider two special cases of motion of the two-atom system, which is initially prepared in the symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state, i.e., synchronized inertial motion and synchronized uniform acceleration. In contrast to the average rate of change of energy of a single uniformly accelerated atom, the average rate of change of energy of the uniformly accelerated two-atom system is nonthermal-like. The effects of noninertial motion on the transitions of states of the two correlated atoms are also discussed.

arXiv:2001.00750•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jan 16, 2020•19 citations

Entanglement dynamics for uniformly accelerated two-level atoms

Jiawei Hu, Hongwei Yu

We study, in the paradigm of open quantum systems, the entanglement dynamics of two uniformly accelerated atoms with the same acceleration perpendicular to the separation. The two-atom system is treated as an open system coupled with a bath of fluctuating massless scalar fields in the Minkowski vacuum, and the master equation that governs its evolution is derived. It has been found that, for accelerated atoms with a nonvanishing separation, entanglement sudden death is a general feature when the initial state is entangled, while for those in a separable initial state, entanglement sudden birth only happens for atoms with an appropriate interatomic separation and sufficiently small acceleration. Remarkably, accelerated atoms can get entangled in certain circumstances while the inertial ones in the Minkowski vacuum cannot. A comparison between the results of accelerated atoms and those of static ones in a thermal bath shows that uniformly accelerated atoms exhibit features distinct from those immersed in a thermal bath at the Unruh temperature in terms of entanglement dynamics.

arXiv:1501.03321•Physical Review A•Jan 21, 2015•91 citations

Collective transitions of two accelerated entangled atoms coupled to electromagnetic fields in the presence of a boundary

Shijing Cheng, Xuerong Cheng

Abstract We study the average rate of change of energy of two accelerated entangled atoms coupled to electromagnetic fields in the presence of a reflecting boundary, which according to the Dalibard, Dupont–Roc and Cohen-Tannoudji formalism is only attributed to the contribution of the radiative reaction of atoms. When the boundary is present, this result can be expressed as the sum of the free-space result and the boundary-induced modifications, and it generally depends on the two-atom initial state, the orientations of atomic dipole moments, as well as the relative scales among atom-boundary distance, interatomic separation and the inverse of atomic acceleration. When the two atoms are vertically aligned and one atom is very close to the boundary, we find that the terms only related to the closer atom are zero for the symmetric state but double the free-space counterpart for the antisymmetric state, if the atom is polarizable parallel to the boundary. However, for the atom polarizable vertically to the boundary, these terms vanish for the antisymmetric state but are twice the free-space counterpart for the symmetric state. Moreover, the terms related to the farther atom exhibit obviously oscillatory behavior, and the terms related to both atoms are vanishing unless the dipole moments of two atoms both have their components vertical to the boundary. When the two atoms are aligned parallel to and very close to the boundary, the terms related to one atom are interatomic-separation-independent and only influenced by the atomic dipole moments. The terms related to both atoms are actually consistent with the counterpart in the vertical-alignment case. In addition, when the two atoms are polarizable along the direction parallel to the boundary, the average rate of change of energy of two parallel-aligned and symmetric entangled atoms vanishes as if the two atoms were a closed system.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Jan 2, 2025•0 citations
Abstract Transition rates of a uniformly accelerated atom coupled to a vacuum scalar field are identical with those of one being static in a thermal bath at a temperature proportional to the proper acceleration a, i.e., TU=a2πT_U=\frac{a}{2\pi }TU​=2πa​ T U = a 2 π . We discuss in this paper whether there exists such an equivalence in the electromagnetic field case if more atoms are involved. To be specific, we explore the similarities and distinctions between effects of a thermal bath and those of the uniformly accelerated motion by comparing the transition rates of a two-atom system initially in the symmetric or antisymmetric entangled state [ ∣ψ±⟩|\psi _{\pm }\rangle ∣ψ±​⟩ | ψ ± ⟩ ] in two cases, i.e., two static atoms in a thermal bath [the thermal case] and two atoms uniformly accelerated in vacuum [the acceleration case]. We discover that, for some particular orientations of atomic dipole moments, coherent radiation which happens in the acceleration case never occurs in the thermal case. The rates in the acceleration case with a low acceleration which means a low TUT_UTU​ T U can be smaller or larger and even equal to their counterparts in the thermal case; while the rates in the acceleration case with a high acceleration which means a high TUT_UTU​ T U are always much larger than their counterparts in the thermal case. Our results suggest that effects of a thermal bath and those of the uniformly accelerated motion on transition properties of a two-atom system in ∣ψ±⟩|\psi _{\pm }\rangle ∣ψ±​⟩ | ψ ± ⟩ are not necessarily distinctive, but can be equivalent if the acceleration is relatively low, depending on the value of the interatomic separation.
We explore, respectively, from the viewpoints of a locally inertial observer and a coaccelerated observer, the transition rates of a two-atom system in the symmetric or antisymmetric entangled state, [Formula: see text] or [Formula: see text], and coupled to the electromagnetic fields. The interatomic separation is assumed to be constant and perpendicular to the acceleration; the fields to which the atoms are coupled are assumed to be in the vacuum state in the locally inertial frame and in a thermal state in the coaccelerated frame. We find that, in the viewpoints of the two observers, both the downward transition [Formula: see text] and the upward transition [Formula: see text] can take place, where [Formula: see text] and [Formula: see text] denote two eigenstates of the two-atom system with both atoms in their ground states and excited states, respectively. With an appropriate choice of the orientations of the atomic dipole moments, coherent radiation can happen for a system in acceleration but not for one in inertial motion. By comparing the transition rates viewed by the two observers, we show that the transition rates of the accelerated two-atom system viewed by a locally inertial observer can only be recovered in the coaccelerated frame by assuming a thermal bath at the Fulling–Davies–Unruh temperature. The effects of these collective transitions on the evolution of energy of the two-atom system are also analyzed.
By considering the interaction between a two-atom system and the vacuum massless scalar field in the viewpoint of an instantaneously inertial observer, we study the rates of transition of a uniformly accelerated two-atom system in the symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state near a reflecting boundary and in a cavity, respectively. We find that both the downward transition | ψ ± ⟩ → | g A g B ⟩ and the upward transition | ψ ± ⟩ → | e A e B ⟩ occur for the accelerated two-atom system, as in sharp contrast with the case of a static two-atom system, in which the upward transition can never happen. Similar to the rates of transition of atoms immersed in a thermal bath with the FDU temperature, both the downward transition rate and the upward transition rate are characterized by the Plank factor ( e 2 π ω 0 / a − 1 ) − 1 . This character of the transition rates is very different from the other radiative properties of the accelerated two-atom system, such as the resonance interatomic energy, for which the revisions of the effects of uniform acceleration are never characterized by such a factor. We show with analytical and numerical results that both the downward transition and the upward transition processes can be effectively manipulated by the atomic non-inertial motion and by the presence of boundaries. By comparing the upward transition rate with the downward transition rate, we discover that, when ω 0 ≫ a , with ω 0 and a being the energy space and the proper acceleration of the two-atom system, the disentanglement caused by the upward transition is negligible, while, if ω 0 ≪ a , the disentanglement caused by the upward transition becomes as important as that caused by the downward transition.
We calculate respectively, from the viewpoints of an instantaneously/locally inertial observer and a coaccelerated observer, the transition rates of the two-atom system in the symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state [$|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}⟩$]. The scalar fields to which the atoms are coupled are respectively assumed to be in the vacuum state and a thermal state in the instantaneously inertial frame and in the coaccelerated frame. We show that both the upward transition $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}⟩\ensuremath{\rightarrow}|{e}_{A}{e}_{B}⟩$ and the downward transition $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}}⟩\ensuremath{\rightarrow}|{g}_{A}{g}_{B}⟩$ take place, where ∣gAgB⟩|{g}_{A}{g}_{B}⟩∣gA​gB​⟩ and ∣eAeB⟩|{e}_{A}{e}_{B}⟩∣eA​eB​⟩ represent two collective eigenstates of the two-atom system with both atoms in their ground state and excited state respectively, and the transition rates observed in the two frames are identical only if there exists a thermal bath at the Fulling-Davies-Unruh temperature in the coaccelerated frame. Though both the downward and upward transition rates are characterized by the Plankian factor, this factor does not show up in the average variation rate of energy of the two-atom system, as a result of the perfect cancellation of the terms in the transition rates in the instantaneously inertial frame multiplied by the Plankian factor which corresponds to the Unruh thermal bath, and the cancellation of the temperature-dependent terms in the transition rates observed in the coaccelerated frame. A comparison of the transition rates of a static two-atom system in interaction with the massless scalar field in a thermal state at an arbitrary temperature with those of a uniformly accelerated two-atom system in interaction with the vacuum massless scalar field shows that the equivalence between the thermal bath and the uniform acceleration, which is well known to be valid for the single atom case, no longer holds for the two-atom system in the symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state. The effect of atomic uniform acceleration in the transition rates of the two-atom system, and the roles of both the downward and the upward transitions in the disentanglement of the two-atom system are also discussed.
We apply the DDC formalism [proposed by Dalibard, Dupont-Roc and Cohen-Tannoudji] to study the average rate of change of energy of two identical two-level atoms interacting with the vacuum massless scalar field in synchronized motion along stationary trajectories. By separating the contributions of vacuum fluctuations and atomic radiation reaction, we first show that for the two-atom system initially prepared in the factorizable eigenstates ∣gAgB⟩|{g}_{A}{g}_{B}⟩∣gA​gB​⟩ and ∣eAeB⟩|{e}_{A}{e}_{B}⟩∣eA​eB​⟩, where ggg and eee represent the ground state and the excited state of a single atom, respectively, both vacuum fluctuations and atomic radiation reaction contribute to the average rate of change of energy of the two-atom system, and the contribution of vacuum fluctuations is independent of the interatomic separation while that of atomic radiation reaction is dependent on it. This is contrary to the existing results in the literature where vacuum fluctuations are interatomic-separation dependent. However, if the two-atom system is initially prepared in the unfactorizable symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state, the average rate of change of energy of the two-atom system is never perturbed by the vacuum fluctuations, but is totally a result of the atomic radiation reaction. We then consider two special cases of motion of the two-atom system, which is initially prepared in the symmetric/antisymmetric entangled state, i.e., synchronized inertial motion and synchronized uniform acceleration. In contrast to the average rate of change of energy of a single uniformly accelerated atom, the average rate of change of energy of the uniformly accelerated two-atom system is nonthermal-like. The effects of noninertial motion on the transitions of states of the two correlated atoms are also discussed.
We study, in the paradigm of open quantum systems, the entanglement dynamics of two uniformly accelerated atoms with the same acceleration perpendicular to the separation. The two-atom system is treated as an open system coupled with a bath of fluctuating massless scalar fields in the Minkowski vacuum, and the master equation that governs its evolution is derived. It has been found that, for accelerated atoms with a nonvanishing separation, entanglement sudden death is a general feature when the initial state is entangled, while for those in a separable initial state, entanglement sudden birth only happens for atoms with an appropriate interatomic separation and sufficiently small acceleration. Remarkably, accelerated atoms can get entangled in certain circumstances while the inertial ones in the Minkowski vacuum cannot. A comparison between the results of accelerated atoms and those of static ones in a thermal bath shows that uniformly accelerated atoms exhibit features distinct from those immersed in a thermal bath at the Unruh temperature in terms of entanglement dynamics.
Abstract We study the average rate of change of energy of two accelerated entangled atoms coupled to electromagnetic fields in the presence of a reflecting boundary, which according to the Dalibard, Dupont–Roc and Cohen-Tannoudji formalism is only attributed to the contribution of the radiative reaction of atoms. When the boundary is present, this result can be expressed as the sum of the free-space result and the boundary-induced modifications, and it generally depends on the two-atom initial state, the orientations of atomic dipole moments, as well as the relative scales among atom-boundary distance, interatomic separation and the inverse of atomic acceleration. When the two atoms are vertically aligned and one atom is very close to the boundary, we find that the terms only related to the closer atom are zero for the symmetric state but double the free-space counterpart for the antisymmetric state, if the atom is polarizable parallel to the boundary. However, for the atom polarizable vertically to the boundary, these terms vanish for the antisymmetric state but are twice the free-space counterpart for the symmetric state. Moreover, the terms related to the farther atom exhibit obviously oscillatory behavior, and the terms related to both atoms are vanishing unless the dipole moments of two atoms both have their components vertical to the boundary. When the two atoms are aligned parallel to and very close to the boundary, the terms related to one atom are interatomic-separation-independent and only influenced by the atomic dipole moments. The terms related to both atoms are actually consistent with the counterpart in the vertical-alignment case. In addition, when the two atoms are polarizable along the direction parallel to the boundary, the average rate of change of energy of two parallel-aligned and symmetric entangled atoms vanishes as if the two atoms were a closed system.