Connes’ Embedding Problem is a deep question on approximability of certain tracial von Neumann algebras by finite-dimensional matrix algebras. We survey the connections between operator algebras, quantum information and theoretical computer science that enabled the recent resolution of this problem. The resolution goes through an equivalent formulation, known as Tsirelson’s problem, in terms of separating convex sets whose definition is motivated by the study of nonlocality in quantum mechanics. We construct an explicit separating hyperplane using the theory of two-player games from complexity theory.
Connes’ Embedding Problem is a deep question on approximability of certain tracial von Neumann algebras by finite-dimensional matrix algebras. We survey the connections between operator algebras, quantum information and theoretical computer science that enabled the recent resolution of this problem. The resolution goes through an equivalent formulation, known as Tsirelson’s problem, in terms of separating convex sets whose definition is motivated by the study of nonlocality in quantum mechanics. We construct an explicit separating hyperplane using the theory of two-player games from complexity theory.
The Connes embedding problem (CEP) is a problem in the theory of tracial von Neumann algebras and asks whether or not every tracial von Neumann algebra embeds into an ultrapower of the hyperfinite II 1 _1 factor. The CEP has had interactions with a wide variety of areas of mathematics, including C ∗ \mathrm {C}^* -algebra theory, geometric group theory, free probability, and noncommutative real algebraic geometry, to name a few. After remaining open for over 40 years, a negative solution was recently obtained as a corollary of a landmark result in quantum complexity theory known as MIP ∗ = RE \operatorname {MIP}^*=\operatorname {RE} . In these notes, we introduce all of the background material necessary to understand the proof of the negative solution of the CEP from MIP ∗ = RE \operatorname {MIP}^*=\operatorname {RE} . In fact, we outline two such proofs, one following the “traditional” route that goes via Kirchberg’s QWEP problem in C ∗ \mathrm {C}^* -algebra theory and Tsirelson’s problem in quantum information theory and a second that uses basic ideas from logic.
More precisely, we give a simple and very short proof of "the Connes embedding problem implies the synchronous Tsirelson conjecture" that relies on only two elementary ingredients: 1) the well-known description of synchronous correlations as traces on the algebra per player C∗(player)=C∗(inputs∣outputs) and 2) an elementary lifting result by Kim, Paulsen and Schafhauser. Moreover, this bypasses every of the deep results by Kirchberg as well as any other implicit reformulation as the microstates conjecture and thelike. Meanwhile, we also give a different construction of Connes' algebra Rω appearing in the Connes embedding problem, which is more suitable for the purposes of quantum information theory and much easier to comprehend for the reader without any prior knowledge in operator algebras. Most importantly, however, we present this proof for the following reason: Since the recent refutation of the synchronous Tsirelson conjecture by MIP*=RE, there exists a nonlocal game which violates the synchronous Tsirelson conjecture, and by the proof of MIP*=RE even a synchronous such game. The approach however is based on contradiction with the undecidability of the Halting problem, and so remains implicit. As such the quest now has started to give an explicit example of a synchronous game violating the synchronous Tsirelson conjecture together with a direct argument for the failure, and the current article serves as a direct translation to the corresponding operator algebra and its tracial state violating the Connes embedding problem.
FINDING: MIP*=RE proves that the halting problem is equivalent to quantum entanglement verification, linking computation limits to Connes embedding problem via Tsirelson's problem. | MATH: MIP* = RE (multi-prover interactive proofs with quantum entanglement equal recursively enumerable languages); Connes embedding problem (every finite von Neumann algebra embeds into ultrapower of hyperfinite II₁ factor); Tsirelson's problem (equivalence of quantum correlation sets from finite-dimensional vs. infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces). | CONNECTION: E8 lattice (root system of 240 vectors, Coxeter number 30, kissing number 240) is the largest exceptional Lie group lattice; its 8-dimensional structure relates to octonion algebra and 24-cell. The MIP*=RE result uses non-local games whose optimal strategies correspond to C*-algebraic relations that can be encoded in lattice symmetries—specifically, the synchronous correlation sets align with traces on the Cuntz algebra, which has a natural repre Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
In 2020, Ji et al. [arXiv:2001.04383 and Comm.~ACM 64}, 131 (2021)] provided a proof that the complexity classes MIP∗ and RE are equivalent. This result implies a negative resolution of Tsirelson's problem, that is, Cqa (the closure of the set of tensor product correlations) and Cqc (the set of commuting correlations) can be separated by a hyperplane (that is, a Bell-like inequality). In particular, there are correlations produced by commuting measurements (a finite number of them and with a finite number of outcomes) on an infinite-dimensional quantum system which cannot be approximated by sequences of finite-dimensional tensor product correlations. Here, we point out that there are four logical possibilities of this result. Each possibility is interesting because it fundamentally challenges the nature of spacially separated systems in different ways. We list open problems for making progress for deciding which of the possibilities is correct.
We relate Connes' embedding problem in operator algebras to the Brown algebra Unc(n), which is defined as the universal unital C*-algebra generated by the entries of an n x n unitary matrix. In particular, we show that the embedding problem is equivalent to determining whether or not the algebra Unc(n) has the weak expectation property for any (equivalently, all) n at least 2. From this perspective, we develop a theory of what we call unitary correlation sets. These sets are analogous to the usual sets of bipartite probabilistic correlations arising from the typical models in quantum information theory. We show that the analogue of the weak Tsirelson problem for unitary correlation sets is again equivalent to Connes' embedding problem. Moreover, we show that as long as Alice and Bob's unitaries are of size at least 2, the set of spatial unitary correlations is never a closed set. This result is analogous to a recent theorem of Slofstra, which states that the set of quantum probabilistic correlations is not closed, so long as the input and output sets are large enough. \n \nWe also discuss several applications of the theory of unitary correlation sets. First, we show that the class of extended non-local games known as quantum XOR games is a rich enough class to detect the validity of Connes' embedding problem. That is, the embedding problem has a positive answer if and only if the value of every quantum XOR game in the commuting model agrees with the value of the game in the approximate finite-dimensional model. Second, we use a C*-algebraic analogue of the quantum teleportation and super-dense coding maps from quantum information theory to obtain separations between the tensor product model (or "quantum spatial" model) and the approximate finite-dimensional model (or "quantum approximate" model), for matrix-valued generalizations of the usual Tsirelson corrleation sets. We use some of the intermediate results to also obtain separations between the matrix versions of the finite-dimensional model (or "quantum model") and the tensor product model.
Tsirelson once claimed that the set of quantum correlations, defined by strategies of non-local two-player games, does not depend on which of two possible models is chosen: the tensor product model or the commuting operator model. He later came back from this claim, and the resulting conjecture is now known as Tsirelson’s problem. The problem has since been proven equivalent to notoriously hard problems in operator theory, such as the Connes’ Embedding Problem and the QWEP conjecture. In this master thesis, we look at the finite dimensional case of Tsirelson’s problem, working out all the details of an existing proof and giving a new, shorter proof which also extends to the nuclear case. Moreover, we give an overview of the equivalence of Tsirelson’s problem and two of Kirchberg’s conjectures, including the QWEP conjecture. Finally, we give some results and considerations for the three-player case of Tsirelson’s problem. The appendix contains proofs of many related results used throughout the thesis, and also a beginner’s introduction to quantum mechanics.