Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Mass of a weakly measured photon

Yakov Bloch, Joshua Foo

Published Nov 1, 2023• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Bohmian mechanics has garnered significant attention as an interpretation of quantum theory since the paradigmatic experiments by [Kocsis et al., Science 332, 1170 (2011)] and [Mahler et al., Sci. Adv. 2, e1501466 (2016)], which inferred the average trajectories of photons in the nonrelativistic regime. These experiments were largely motivated by Wiseman's formulation of Bohmian mechanics, which grounded these trajectories in weak measurements. Recently, Wiseman's framework was extended to the relativistic regime by expressing the velocity field of single photons in terms of weak values of the photon energy and momentum. Here, we propose an operational, weak value-based definition for the Bohmian ``local mass'' of relativistic single particles. For relativistic wave functions satisfying the scalar Klein-Gordon equation, this mass coincides with the effective mass defined by de Broglie in his relativistic pilot-wave theory, a quantity closely connected with the quantum potential that is responsible for Bohmian trajectory self-bending and the anomalous photoelectric effect. We demonstrate the relationship between the photon trajectories and the mass in an interferometric setup.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.108.052201

Related papers

How the result of a measurement of a photon's mass can turn out to be 100

Yakov Bloch, Joshua Foo

Bohmian mechanics has garnered significant attention as an interpretation of quantum theory since the paradigmatic experiments by Kocsis et. al. [Science 332, 6034 (2011)] and Mahler et. al. [Sci. Adv. 2, 2 (2016)], which inferred the average trajectories of photons in the nonrelativistic regime. These experiments were largely motivated by Wiseman's formulation of Bohmian mechanics, which grounded these trajectories in weak measurements. Recently, Wiseman's framework was extended to the relativistic regime by expressing the velocity field of single photons in terms of weak values of the photon energy and momentum. Here, we propose an operational, weak value-based definition for the Bohmian "local mass" of relativistic single particles. For relativistic wavefunctions satisfying the scalar Klein-Gordon equation, this mass coincides with the effective mass defined by de Broglie in his relativistic pilot-wave theory, a quantity closely connected with the quantum potential that is responsible for Bohmian trajectory self-bending and the anomalous photoelectric effect. We demonstrate the relationship between the photon trajectories and the mass in an interferometric setup.

arXiv:2305.00891•May 1, 2023•19 citations

Observation of relativistic Bohmian dynamics

Yunfei Wang, Hui Wang, Tong Zhang +5 more

Bohmian mechanics, also referred to as the de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory, represents a deterministic and nonlocal interpretation of quantum mechanics. Central to this framework is a description of quantum motion in terms of particle trajectories, whose reconciliation with relativity remains a fundamental challenge. Although relativistic guidance laws have been proposed, their predicted dynamics has remained experimentally untested. Here we use weak measurements in a single-photon interferometer to jointly reconstruct the photon energy and momentum weak values and the associated relativistic velocity field. The reconstructed average trajectories agree with theoretical predictions. Near destructive interference, the flow exhibits local reconstructed velocities exceeding the speed of light and negative values of the effective squared-mass parameter. Our results establish an experimental basis for investigating the physical meaning of quantum trajectories and their role in describing motion in relativistic spacetime.

arXiv:2509.11609•Sep 15, 2025•0 citations

Relativistic Bohmian trajectories of photons via weak measurements

Joshua Foo, Estelle Asmodelle, Austin P. Lund +1 more

Bohmian mechanics is a nonlocal hidden-variable interpretation of quantum theory which predicts that particles follow deterministic trajectories in spacetime. Historically, the study of Bohmian trajectories has mainly been restricted to nonrelativistic regimes due to the widely held belief that the theory is incompatible with special relativity. Here, we present an approach for constructing the relativistic Bohmian-type velocity field of single particles. The advantage of our proposal is that it is operational in nature, grounded in weak measurements of the particle's momentum and energy. We apply our weak measurement formalism to obtain the relativistic spacetime trajectories of photons in a Michelson-Sagnac interferometer. The trajectories satisfy quantum-mechanical continuity and the relativistic velocity addition rule. We propose a modified Alcubierre metric which could give rise to these trajectories within the paradigm of general relativity.

arXiv:2108.05169•Nature Communications•Jul 11, 2022•26 citations

Weak Values of Momentum of the Electromagnetic Field: Average Momentum Flow Lines, Not Photon Trajectories

R. Flack, Basil J. Hiley

In a recent paper Mahler {\em et al.} have argued that the experiments of Kocsis {\em et al.} provide experimental evidence for Bohmian mechanics. Unfortunately these experiments used relativistic, zero rest mass photons whereas Bohmian mechanics is based on non-relativistic Schrödinger particles having non-zero rest mass. The experimental results can be accounted for in terms of a different approach based on the electromagnetic field that was already outlined by Bohm in an appendix of the second of his 1952 papers. A subsequent development of this approach by Bohm, Hiley, Holland, Kaloyerou, Lam and Dewdney, shows in detail how this theory accounts for experimental quantum phenomena in general. Using this theory, we are led to the conclusion that the experiments have constructed mean momentum flow lines by measuring the real part of what we term the weak Poynting vector. These results support and clarify the analysis of Bliokh {\em et al}. The experimental flow lines can be constructed independently of the number of photons in the beam leading to the conclusion that flow lines cannot be interpreted as `photon trajectories'. We discuss exactly how the notion of a photon arises in the field approach in the light of weak values.

arXiv:1611.06510•Nov 20, 2016•5 citations

Actual and weak actual values in Bohmian mechanics

Weixiang Ye

We systematically analyze Holland's local expectation values within Bohmian mechanics, referring to them as weak actual values to emphasize their connection with weak measurement theory. We derive the exact time evolution equation for these quantities along a Bohmian trajectory and formally establish their correspondence with the real part of the weak value under position postselection. The explanatory power of this framework is demonstrated by revisiting a recent waveguide experiment: we show that the measured quantity corresponds to the imaginary part of the momentum weak value, which reflects the spatial decay of the wave field, not the particle velocity. This cleanly clarifies the distinct physical roles of the real and imaginary parts of weak values.

quant-pharXiv:2512.12951•Annalen der Physik•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations

Measurement-based Lorentz-covariant Bohmian trajectories of interacting photons

Joshua Foo, Austin P. Lund, Timothy C. Ralph

In a recent article [Nat. Commun. 13, 2 (2022)], we devised a method of constructing the Lorentz-covariant Bohmian trajectories of single photons via weak measurements of the photon's momentum and energy. However, whether such a framework can consistently describe multiparticle interactions remains to be seen. Here we present a nontrivial generalization of our framework to describe the relativistic Bohmian trajectories of two interacting photons (this interaction arising from the symmetrization of the two-particle wave function) exhibiting nonclassical interference due to their indistinguishability. We begin by deriving the average velocity fields of the indistinguishable photons using a conditional weak measurement protocol, with detectors that are agnostic to the identity of the respective photons. We demonstrate a direct correspondence between the operationally derived trajectories and those obtained using a position- and time-symmetrized multiparticle Klein-Gordon wave function, whose dynamics are manifestly Lorentz covariant. We propose a space-time metric that depends nonlocally on the positions of both particles as a curvature-based interpretation of the resulting trajectories. Contrary to prior expectations, our results demonstrate a consistent trajectory-based interpretation of relativistic multiparticle dynamics in quantum theory.

arXiv:2309.16011•Physical Review A•Feb 21, 2024•10 citations
Bohmian mechanics has garnered significant attention as an interpretation of quantum theory since the paradigmatic experiments by [Kocsis et al., Science 332, 1170 (2011)] and [Mahler et al., Sci. Adv. 2, e1501466 (2016)], which inferred the average trajectories of photons in the nonrelativistic regime. These experiments were largely motivated by Wiseman's formulation of Bohmian mechanics, which grounded these trajectories in weak measurements. Recently, Wiseman's framework was extended to the relativistic regime by expressing the velocity field of single photons in terms of weak values of the photon energy and momentum. Here, we propose an operational, weak value-based definition for the Bohmian ``local mass'' of relativistic single particles. For relativistic wave functions satisfying the scalar Klein-Gordon equation, this mass coincides with the effective mass defined by de Broglie in his relativistic pilot-wave theory, a quantity closely connected with the quantum potential that is responsible for Bohmian trajectory self-bending and the anomalous photoelectric effect. We demonstrate the relationship between the photon trajectories and the mass in an interferometric setup.
Bohmian mechanics has garnered significant attention as an interpretation of quantum theory since the paradigmatic experiments by Kocsis et. al. [Science 332, 6034 (2011)] and Mahler et. al. [Sci. Adv. 2, 2 (2016)], which inferred the average trajectories of photons in the nonrelativistic regime. These experiments were largely motivated by Wiseman's formulation of Bohmian mechanics, which grounded these trajectories in weak measurements. Recently, Wiseman's framework was extended to the relativistic regime by expressing the velocity field of single photons in terms of weak values of the photon energy and momentum. Here, we propose an operational, weak value-based definition for the Bohmian "local mass" of relativistic single particles. For relativistic wavefunctions satisfying the scalar Klein-Gordon equation, this mass coincides with the effective mass defined by de Broglie in his relativistic pilot-wave theory, a quantity closely connected with the quantum potential that is responsible for Bohmian trajectory self-bending and the anomalous photoelectric effect. We demonstrate the relationship between the photon trajectories and the mass in an interferometric setup.
Bohmian mechanics, also referred to as the de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory, represents a deterministic and nonlocal interpretation of quantum mechanics. Central to this framework is a description of quantum motion in terms of particle trajectories, whose reconciliation with relativity remains a fundamental challenge. Although relativistic guidance laws have been proposed, their predicted dynamics has remained experimentally untested. Here we use weak measurements in a single-photon interferometer to jointly reconstruct the photon energy and momentum weak values and the associated relativistic velocity field. The reconstructed average trajectories agree with theoretical predictions. Near destructive interference, the flow exhibits local reconstructed velocities exceeding the speed of light and negative values of the effective squared-mass parameter. Our results establish an experimental basis for investigating the physical meaning of quantum trajectories and their role in describing motion in relativistic spacetime.
Bohmian mechanics is a nonlocal hidden-variable interpretation of quantum theory which predicts that particles follow deterministic trajectories in spacetime. Historically, the study of Bohmian trajectories has mainly been restricted to nonrelativistic regimes due to the widely held belief that the theory is incompatible with special relativity. Here, we present an approach for constructing the relativistic Bohmian-type velocity field of single particles. The advantage of our proposal is that it is operational in nature, grounded in weak measurements of the particle's momentum and energy. We apply our weak measurement formalism to obtain the relativistic spacetime trajectories of photons in a Michelson-Sagnac interferometer. The trajectories satisfy quantum-mechanical continuity and the relativistic velocity addition rule. We propose a modified Alcubierre metric which could give rise to these trajectories within the paradigm of general relativity.
In a recent paper Mahler {\em et al.} have argued that the experiments of Kocsis {\em et al.} provide experimental evidence for Bohmian mechanics. Unfortunately these experiments used relativistic, zero rest mass photons whereas Bohmian mechanics is based on non-relativistic Schrödinger particles having non-zero rest mass. The experimental results can be accounted for in terms of a different approach based on the electromagnetic field that was already outlined by Bohm in an appendix of the second of his 1952 papers. A subsequent development of this approach by Bohm, Hiley, Holland, Kaloyerou, Lam and Dewdney, shows in detail how this theory accounts for experimental quantum phenomena in general. Using this theory, we are led to the conclusion that the experiments have constructed mean momentum flow lines by measuring the real part of what we term the weak Poynting vector. These results support and clarify the analysis of Bliokh {\em et al}. The experimental flow lines can be constructed independently of the number of photons in the beam leading to the conclusion that flow lines cannot be interpreted as `photon trajectories'. We discuss exactly how the notion of a photon arises in the field approach in the light of weak values.
We systematically analyze Holland's local expectation values within Bohmian mechanics, referring to them as weak actual values to emphasize their connection with weak measurement theory. We derive the exact time evolution equation for these quantities along a Bohmian trajectory and formally establish their correspondence with the real part of the weak value under position postselection. The explanatory power of this framework is demonstrated by revisiting a recent waveguide experiment: we show that the measured quantity corresponds to the imaginary part of the momentum weak value, which reflects the spatial decay of the wave field, not the particle velocity. This cleanly clarifies the distinct physical roles of the real and imaginary parts of weak values.
In a recent article [Nat. Commun. 13, 2 (2022)], we devised a method of constructing the Lorentz-covariant Bohmian trajectories of single photons via weak measurements of the photon's momentum and energy. However, whether such a framework can consistently describe multiparticle interactions remains to be seen. Here we present a nontrivial generalization of our framework to describe the relativistic Bohmian trajectories of two interacting photons (this interaction arising from the symmetrization of the two-particle wave function) exhibiting nonclassical interference due to their indistinguishability. We begin by deriving the average velocity fields of the indistinguishable photons using a conditional weak measurement protocol, with detectors that are agnostic to the identity of the respective photons. We demonstrate a direct correspondence between the operationally derived trajectories and those obtained using a position- and time-symmetrized multiparticle Klein-Gordon wave function, whose dynamics are manifestly Lorentz covariant. We propose a space-time metric that depends nonlocally on the positions of both particles as a curvature-based interpretation of the resulting trajectories. Contrary to prior expectations, our results demonstrate a consistent trajectory-based interpretation of relativistic multiparticle dynamics in quantum theory.