According to the axioms of classical probability theory, a person is in a certain state with respect to certain judgement and cognition at each given instant, and it is possible to assign a probability to a cognitive response with a specific value at each moment. It is established and quantifiable, and its existence may be disclosed. However, there has been evidence of so-called constructive influences in decision-making, whereby a decision appears to alter the underlying mental state. Quantum accounting, unlike classical theory, permits a person to exist in an indeterminate condition, known as a superposition state, at all times. This implies that one cannot assume that psychological states are characterized by specific values that can be recorded by a psychological measurement at every moment. The act of choosing one choice over another, for instance, produces a preference for the selected option. In this chapter, we will discuss the findings of a study conducted on a group of 60 lawyers (judges, prosecutors and attorneys at law) and 30 non-lawyers. We will investigate the positive effect of expressing an intermediate judgement on the suspect’s guilt on the total rating of guilt. With the application of the quantum probability theory, we present a cognitive model that formalizes such a constructive process.
According to the axioms of classical probability theory, a person is in a certain state with respect to certain judgement and cognition at each given instant, and it is possible to assign a probability to a cognitive response with a specific value at each moment. It is established and quantifiable, and its existence may be disclosed. However, there has been evidence of so-called constructive influences in decision-making, whereby a decision appears to alter the underlying mental state. Quantum accounting, unlike classical theory, permits a person to exist in an indeterminate condition, known as a superposition state, at all times. This implies that one cannot assume that psychological states are characterized by specific values that can be recorded by a psychological measurement at every moment. The act of choosing one choice over another, for instance, produces a preference for the selected option. In this chapter, we will discuss the findings of a study conducted on a group of 60 lawyers (judges, prosecutors and attorneys at law) and 30 non-lawyers. We will investigate the positive effect of expressing an intermediate judgement on the suspect’s guilt on the total rating of guilt. With the application of the quantum probability theory, we present a cognitive model that formalizes such a constructive process.
Making a choice between alternatives can influence our subsequent evaluation of the selected option (e.g.Sharot, Velasquez & Dolan, 2010).Thus, in resolving psychological uncertainty, the act of making a judgment itself appears to have a constructive role in subsequent related decisions.This study focuses on emotional ambivalence and the development of affective evaluations over two stages, such that (just) making an intermediate evaluation in the first stage is shown to influence the overall affective evaluation in the second stage.Models based on classical probability theory, which assume that an intermediate evaluation simply reads off an existing internal state, cannot accommodate this result in a natural way.An explanation is offered with a quantum probability model, which, under specific circumstances, requires the measurement of an internal state to have a constructive role.The predictions of the quantum probability model were supported by the empirical results.
Classical models of decision-making under uncertainty, grounded in expected utility theory and Bayesian probability, often fail to account for systematic cognitive anomalies such as preference reversals, order effects, ambiguity aversion, and context-dependent choices. Quantum cognition models offer a novel theoretical framework that applies the mathematical principles of quantum probability—such as superposition, interference, and non-commutativity—to cognitive processes without assuming physical quantum mechanisms in the brain. By representing cognitive states as probabilistic superpositions that collapse through decision “measurements,” these models provide parsimonious explanations for violations of classical rationality. This paper examines how quantum cognition frameworks capture contextual influence, belief updating, and interference effects in uncertain decision environments. Drawing on findings from cognitive psychology and behavioral economics, the study highlights the relevance of quantum cognition for applications in economic choice modeling, legal decision analysis, and artificial intelligence. The analysis suggests that quantum probability offers a robust alternative to classical approaches when modeling human decision-making in complex, ambiguous, and context-sensitive situations.
There are two basic theories of probability and two scientific perspectives – classical and quantum. In this chapter, assumptions of both the classical and the quantum probability theories will be presented and confronted. The rules for quantum probabilities differ from those of classical probabilities. In this chapter, we will describe what is the difference between the quantum cognitive modelling different from traditional cognitive modelling. In quantum probability theory (QPT) states of individual quantum, systems are called pure states, which are represented as vectors in a vector space (the Hilbert space). Properties of the Hilbert space and vectors’ operations will be explained. Two aspects of quantum theory open the door to addressing problems facing cognition and decision in a totally new light. The first is known as “contextuality” of judgements and decisions: the context generated by making a first judgement or decision interferes with subsequent judgements or decisions to produce order effects, so that judgements and decisions are non-commutative. The second aspect relates to quantum entanglement – a phenomenon whereby making an observation on one part of the system instantaneously affects the state in another part of the system, even if the respective systems are separated by space-like distances. This opens the door to developing quantum-like models of cognitive phenomena which are not decompositional in nature. Examples of cognitive processes modelled using the quantum account and results on the previous studies will be presented. We will also discuss the quantum–classical boundary.
Traditional approaches to cognitive psychology correspond with a classical view of logic and probability theory. More specifically, one typically assumes that cognitive processes of human thought are founded on the Boolean structures of classical logic, while the probabilistic aspects of these processes are based on the Kolmogorovian structures of classical probability theory. However, growing experimental evidence indicates that the models founded on classical structures systematically fail when human decisions are at stake. These experimental deviations from classical behavior have been called `paradoxes’, `fallacies’, `effects’ or `contradictions’, depending on the specific situation where they appear. But, they involve a broad spectrum of cognitive and social science domains, ranging from conceptual combination to decision making under uncertainty, behavioral economics, and linguistics. This situation has constituted a serious drawback to the development of various disciplines, like cognitive science, linguistics, artificial intelligence, economic modeling and behavioral finance. A different approach to cognitive psychology, initiated two decades ago, has meanwhile matured into a new domain of research, called ‘quantum cognition’. Its main feature is the use of the mathematical formalism of quantum theory as modeling tool for these cognitive situations where traditional classically based approaches fail. Quantum cognition has recently attracted the interest of important journals and editing houses, academic and funding institutions, popular science and media. Specifically, within a quantum cognition approach, one assumes that human decisions do not necessarily obey the rules of Boolean logic and Kolmogorovian probability, and can on the contrary be modeled by the quantum-mechanical formalism. Different concrete quantum-theoretic models have meanwhile been developed that successfully represent the cognitive situations that are classically problematical, by explaining observed deviations from classicality in terms of genuine quantum effects, such as `contextuality’, `emergence’, `interference’, `superposition’, `entanglement’ and `indistinguishability’. In addition, the validity of these quantum models is convincingly confirmed by new experimental tests. We also stress that, since the use of a quantum-theoretic framework is mainly for modeling purposes, the identification of quantum structures in cognitive processes does not presuppose (without being incompatible with it) the existence of microscopic quantum processes in the human brain. In this Research Topic, we review the major achievements that have been obtained in quantum cognition, by providing an accurate picture of the state-of-the-art of this emerging discipline. Our overview does not pretend to be either complete or exhaustive. But, we aim to introduce psychologists and social scientists to this challenging new research area, encouraging them, at the same time, to consider its promising results. It is our opinion that, if continuous progress in this domain can be realized, quantum cognition can constitute an important breakthrough in cognitive psychology, and potentially open the way towards a new scientific paradigm in social science.
The present thesis (mostly) concerns the application of alternative mathematical methods to understand patterns in human cognition and to model them. The different chapters presented in this thesis show research that concerns the application of quantum probability (QP) theory in the modeling of human decision-making. Quantum probability (QP) theory is a theory for how to assign probabilities to events. QP theory can be thought of as the probability rules from quantum mechanics, without any of the physics. This work is not about the application of quantum physics to brain physiology. Rather, we are interested in QP theory as a mathematical framework for cognitive modelling. This theory is potentially relevant in any behavioural situation that involves uncertainty. QP theory is analogous to classical probability theory, though QP theory and classical probability (CP) theory are founded from different sets of axioms (the Kolmogorov and Dirac/von Neumann axioms respectively) and so are subject to alternative constraints. In this thesis we show that especially over the last decade, there has been a growing interest in decision-making and cognitive models using a quantum probabilistic (QP) framework. We see how this development encompasses publications in major journals (see Pothos and Busemeyer, 2013; Wang et al., 2014; and Yearsley and Pothos, 2014; among others), special issues, and dedicated workshops, as well as several comprehensive books (Busemeyer and Bruza, 2012; Khrennikov, 2010; and Haven and Khrennikov, 2010). However, uncertainty itself is neither ethical nor unethical – yet it is inherent to most situations in which, for instance, moral judgments and decisions have to be made. For a descriptive understanding of judgment and decisions in moral situations, it is an important lesson to acknowledge both the cognitive side (bounded rationality) and the environment (ecological rationality) – and thus the uncertainty of the world and how the mind deals with it. This thesis also shows significant interest in moral and social psychology. Specifically, we consider present technologies that suggest a need for evaluating alternative contexts for ethical decision-making. How the research on human-machine interaction feeds back into humans’ understanding of themselves as moral agents? This key question ultimately relates to the nature of ethical theory itself. Overall, this dissertation presents and addresses not only standard aspects of decision- making processes, such as similarity judgments (Chapters 1 to 4) or the constructive role of articulating impressions (Chapter 5), but also standard aspects of social psychology, such as moral judgments (Chapters 6 and 7) and game theory (Chapter 8). As stated in the Declarations section, the present thesis is a combination of a standard and a publication- based dissertation.
The decision-making process of the individual is analogous to the collapse of a quantum system at the moment of measurement, whereby quantum system we mean the decision-maker, his mental processes and the environmental context that influences him in his choices. Classical probability depends on the lack of information, quantum probability is instead intrinsic to the system to be studied, meaning that the system, consisting of the decision-maker and the context, is in a superposition of states, each with its own amplitude of probability. Only the measurement process (the decision) selects in the decision maker a specific state among those in which he was overlapping. We demonstrated on a Noisy Intermediate –Scale Quantum Processor the model of the “order effect”, one of the most important cognitive bias.