Consider the problem of a photon moving in the x direction in a medium with index of refraction n1 and striking an interface along the y axis at x=0 with n2=n1 for x>0. It is evident that 1= Probability(reflect) + Probability(refract), but this equation does not yield the relative probability ratio. One might try to apply maximization of Shannon’s entropy subject to the constraint Sum over i P(i) = 1 ((1)). This, however, like for a coin, yields probabilities of .5 which do not match experiment. What is wrong? First, it seems like there are more constraints in the problem which have been overlooked in the constraint ((1)). For instance, E=pc and E is constant for all x. There is a discontinuity in p (momentum) and speed at x=0. The speed of light in a medium with index of refraction is c/ni where c is the speed in a vacuum. Thus we suggest a kind of motion related equilibrium throughout the medium. This same idea applies to p, momentum. How does one characterize such an equilibrium. In (1), we suggested a probability P(x) obtained by maximizing Shannon’s entropy subject to the periodic constrain i p x P(x) with p being the Lagrange multiplier. Here we point out that this maximization of entropy is equivalent to the statement that P(p,x)P(-p,x) = 1. Thus a very different kind of equilibrium i.e. maximization of Shannon’s entropy exists. One does not maximize a Shannon’s entropy based on allowable state results as in the toss of a coin or die, or a Maxwell-Boltzmann gas. The equation P(reflect)+P(refract)=1, however, is based on state probabilities and we ask: Why is it guaranteed to exist if one uses an equilibrium based on exp(ipx) flux-like probabilities? Given the constraint that E is the same for all x, a particle reflecting at x=0 back into x<0 has no choice but to have a momentum of -p. This has important consequences on the link between the exp(ipx) flux-like probability and the state probabilities P(reflect), P(refract). In fact, we argue that it guarantees that a probability calculation using exp(ipx) yields P(reflect)+P(refract) =1 . In (2), for example, such a relationship is shown to exist, but it is not explained why it must exist.
Consider the problem of a photon moving in the x direction in a medium with index of refraction n1 and striking an interface along the y axis at x=0 with n2=n1 for x>0. It is evident that 1= Probability(reflect) + Probability(refract), but this equation does not yield the relative probability ratio. One might try to apply maximization of Shannon’s entropy subject to the constraint Sum over i P(i) = 1 ((1)). This, however, like for a coin, yields probabilities of .5 which do not match experiment. What is wrong? First, it seems like there are more constraints in the problem which have been overlooked in the constraint ((1)). For instance, E=pc and E is constant for all x. There is a discontinuity in p (momentum) and speed at x=0. The speed of light in a medium with index of refraction is c/ni where c is the speed in a vacuum. Thus we suggest a kind of motion related equilibrium throughout the medium. This same idea applies to p, momentum. How does one characterize such an equilibrium. In (1), we suggested a probability P(x) obtained by maximizing Shannon’s entropy subject to the periodic constrain i p x P(x) with p being the Lagrange multiplier. Here we point out that this maximization of entropy is equivalent to the statement that P(p,x)P(-p,x) = 1. Thus a very different kind of equilibrium i.e. maximization of Shannon’s entropy exists. One does not maximize a Shannon’s entropy based on allowable state results as in the toss of a coin or die, or a Maxwell-Boltzmann gas. The equation P(reflect)+P(refract)=1, however, is based on state probabilities and we ask: Why is it guaranteed to exist if one uses an equilibrium based on exp(ipx) flux-like probabilities? Given the constraint that E is the same for all x, a particle reflecting at x=0 back into x<0 has no choice but to have a momentum of -p. This has important consequences on the link between the exp(ipx) flux-like probability and the state probabilities P(reflect), P(refract). In fact, we argue that it guarantees that a probability calculation using exp(ipx) yields P(reflect)+P(refract) =1 . In (2), for example, such a relationship is shown to exist, but it is not explained why it must exist.
It is known that a single photon moving in the x direction and encountering an n1-n2 index of refraction discontinuity at xo will either reflect or refract, with the probabilities for each summing to 1. This problem, however, is solved using a balance of Aexp(ipx)+Bexp(-ipx) = Cexp(ip2 x) at xo and the derivative d/dx, of this equation. The complex conjugate of one equation multiplied by the second yields: AA/c = BB/c + CC/c2 where E=pc and E is constant for the incident, reflected and refracted photon. The two continuity equations apply even in the case of a single photon, but in such a case one has either an incident photon changing to a reflected one or an incident to a refracted one. One never has all three together as in thte two continuity equations. We ask: How is it possible to include both a refracted and reflected photon together with the incident in the same equation? We suggest here that the form exp(ipx) applies to momentum, whether it is part of a particle or part of a potential field. exp(ipx) may be obtained from maximization of entropy -P(x)ln(P(x)) subject to the periodic constraint ipxP(x). We suggest that in a single photon interaction, one has momentum in media n1 and n2 and these allow for the continuity equation with the system interactions taking the place of a photon to create the balance. There is stochasticity in that a single photon either becomes a reflected or refracted one, but exp(ipx) does not simply apply to the photon. it may be applied to the n1-n2 interface momentum which is created during the interaction. This interaction is consistent with the a steady stream picture only involving photons . Thus for a single photon, it appears as if one has an entangled probability exp(ipx)’s for the incident, reflected and refracted photons, but actually the physical photon only plays a role as first an incident one and then either a reflected or refracted one with the n1-n2 interface momentum creating the missing exp(ipx) piece needed for the continuity balance. Ultimately, A,B and C become probabilities AA/c,= 1, BB/c = P(reflected) and CC/c2= P(refracted), but these are not obtained by maximizing entropy subject to a constraint.as one does not have independence of probabilities.We note that the two continuity equations combine to create a pressure balance which one wishes to have physically in the problem. The photon reflection-refraction problem may be reformulated for a particle with rest mass using a particle with E, p in a constant potential V1 reaching a V1-V2 (both constant) interface at xo with E remaining constant.
Some problems only require a certain amount of information for their solution. For example, a photon refracting from a medium interface along the x axis problem may be solved by noting that momentum and speed in medium 1 are pn1 and c/n1 (where p,c are momentum and speed in a vacuum and n1 is the index of refraction). In medium n2, one replaces n1 with n2. From these classical smooth values (deterministic values) one may obtain Snell’s law which may be verified experimentally. What happens if one takes this same information and tries to solve for the relative probabilities of reflection/refraction for a photon moving along the x axis in a medium with n1 and hitting an interface along the y axis at x=0. The medium for x>0 has n2>n1. Can this problem be solved simply using E=pc, and pni , c/ni? It seems it cannot. Furthermore, the smooth pni and c/ni appear to be approximations because the speed of light in a medium changes due to interactions with atoms. One might expect some type of stochastic behaviour, as a result, with pni and c/ni being averages. As shown in (1), one may maximize Shannon’s entropy subject to periodic constraints to find an unusual two-dimensional probability exp(-iEt+ipx). This probability allows one to find relative probabilities for reflection/refraction and also predicts/solves a n-slit interference-diffraction problem. Thus the smoothed over pni and c/ni information is not wrong, but only solves certain problems. More information is given by exp(-iEt+ipx) which may be used to solve further problems. Given that we suggest exp(-iEt+ipx) follows from two maximizations of Shannon’s entropy, one for P(x) and one for P(t), one might expect there is no further information. We suggest, however, that for t-> t+ constant/E and x-> x+constant/p, -Et+px does not change and this result should hold as seen in any frame moving at constant average v (velocity). By mentioning average v, one already takes a deterministic view and approximates the stochasticity of exp(-iEt+ipx). In (1), we argued that one may find the specific transformation involved in viewing E,p,x,t from a moving frame and that not only is -Et+px invariant, but also -tt+xx and -EE+pp. In fact, -EE+pp=momo (c=1) is a relation between E and p as well as being an inner product. We argue here that an inner product, in general, loses information as it is a relative relationship between two vectors. A point we wish to make is that exp(-iEt+ipx) is a solution of -EE+pp=momo (c=1) if one replaces E with id/dt partial and p with -id/dx partial. Thus, we suggest some information is lost. There is no reason to require a second order differential equation when a first order one yields p and E, although the second order equation is not wrong, it just removes some information as does an average. We thus suggest that Dirac’s approach to finding a linear equation in id/dt partial and -id/dx partial is an attempt to retrieve this extra information. This approach applies to finding extra information called spin, which again, is only useful in certain problems (for example, when a magnetic field is present). In (2) we examined a continuity equation with the Poynting vector and energy density .5(C1 Electric field Electric field + C1 Magnetic field Magnetic field) and showed it may also be broken into two linear equations which yield spin 1 information. Thus we argue that certain equations (quadratic in nature) may represent a loss of information, especially those that represent a kind of coarse grained average as in the case of energy density or even classical probability to reflect or refract. In such a case, one may try to linearize in order to find this lost information.
In Newtonian mechanics a particle with constant momentum moves deterministically according to x=p/m t. Even a quantum object such as a photon or electron should satisfy this equation on average to give meaning to the notion of the speed of light in a vacuum, for example. Thus it seems surprising that a quantum free particle is also associated with exp(ipx) which only contains momentum and is periodic and complex. Furthermore the physical consequences of exp(ipx) are real as shown in a two-slit interference experiment etc. In this note, we attempt to discover why exp(ipx) exists in the first place by examining the example of the reflection/refraction of light which occurs in the macroscopic classical world. Basically our argument is based on analyzing two important pieces of information in the system, namely the scalar energy (or particle count) and the vector momentum. A main point we make is that energy or particle number considerations are linked to determinism i.e. a specific time of interaction. One may note that the interaction x is fixed by the two medium barrier. This means a single incident photon exists in one time range and the reflected OR refracted photon in another. It is possible to compare the incident photon to either the reflected or refracted or to a sum of probabilities. In particular, a single photon has an energy E and a count of 1. If it reflects, it has an energy E and count of 1 so there is a balance, likewise for refraction. Thinking in terms of probabilities “a” and 1-a to reflect/refract: 1= a + 1-a. Can one perform such a matching for momentum, which is a physical piece of information? We argue one cannot. For example, a single incident photon has a momentum p which is linked to the impulse it may deliver. If it refracts, “all of a sudden” it is linked with momentum of p2 = n2 p where n2 is the index of refraction in the second medium and n1=1. This seems problematic because a physical impulse of 2p is all of a sudden an impulse of 2p2. Thus there exists a big problem which seems to require the notion of probability and all three momentum values p, -p and p2 considered together, unlike the situation of energy/particle number for which a comparison of the incident photon and one possible result yields a balance. Combining all three momenta, however, is also problematic in a deterministic picture because the incident photon exists in one time range and the reflected or refracted in another. How can one possibly compare them together? The solution seems to be to argue that the incident photon is only deterministic on average. In particular, if it has an x probability distribution over a certain length (called a wavelength), one does not know the precise time at which it hits “x” the medium interface. In such a situation, there is time uncertainty which allows all three momenta to be compared at the same x. This, however, leads to a major consequence, namely that so-called deterministic motion associated with constant p is deterministic on average, but contains repeated pockets of x probability distributions such that time is not deterministic within. We try to examine these ideas in this note.
Note: Dec. 28, 2022 The form exp(-iEt)exp(ipx) for both the photon and a particle with rest mass may be obtained from the Lorentz in variant -Et+px=A by noting that -id/dx A = p and that exp(ipx) is an eigenfunction of exp(ipx). In a series of notes we have considered the problem of light moving in the positive x direction hitting a medium along the y axis at x=0 and reflecting and refracting. We assumed that light is of the form of a photon which has an energy E which is the same in the incident, reflected and refracted beams. We also considered the notion of a steady state stream. Given a single photon in the incident beam, it has a probability a to reflect and 1-a to refract. As discussed in previous notes, one may consider an intensity AA, BB, CC for the incident, reflected and refracted rays (AA>0 etc) and write energy conservation as: AA/c1 = BB/c1 + CC/c2 where c1 is the speed of light in medium 1 and c2 in medium 2. We noted that the energy conservation equation has two unknowns B,C if A is known, but may be broken into two equations if one considers time removed from the problem (i.e steady state) and one groups by space i.e. (AA/c1 -BB/c1) = CC/c2 i.e. A+B=C and A/c1 -B/c1=C/c2. One may note that one does not have a conservation of flux/intensity equation, but that flux/intenisty which physically exists is directly linked to energy conservation. One may also note that one does not have an equation of energy flux conservation. In this note, we consider the dispersion relationship of light E=pc and the notion of a continuity equation which applies to the “square root” probabilities. We consider exp(-iEt+ipx) as the simplest solution, other than a constant and speculate whether exp(ipx) for a steady state picture represents a kind of square root flux. The idea of a square root flux suggests two sets of equations with square root fluxes which may be multiplied to create a flux equation. exp(ipx) has a kind of wavelike structure with two dimensions and may interfere. It also maps to a constant flux through exp(-ipx)exp(ipx). We consider these ideas and conclude that the wavefunction is like a square root flux which helps to associate a picture with the idea of it being a dynamical probability. This is helpful when considering a W(r vector) not equal to W(r) i.e. not spherically symmetric. This suggests unbalanced flux and rotation. In quantum mechanics, one does not have a container and so the fluxes create a static-appearing density in the bound case.
In previous notes (1), we argued that stochasticity (in x and t for a fixed E energy and p momentum) may occur at a single particle level based on the Lorentz invariant A = -Et+px ((1)). This invariant is also the relativistic/nonrelativistic classical action for v=x/t. The argument made in (1) was that a fluctuation in t of constant/E could cancel one in x of constant/p. We further argued one could create eigenvalue equations using id/dt and -id/dx and obtain the two dimensional probabilities exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx), i.e obtain a description of free particle quantum mechanics. Experimentally, both exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx) have been verified through interference patterns. Theoretically, however, ((1)) was known about 1905 and no single particle stochasticity was associated with it. In this note, we try to argue why there should be an associated stochasticity associated with ((1)) based on motion through a constant potential for a particle with rest mass and motion through a medium with an index of refraction for a photon. We in fact argue that one cannot solve certain photon problems such as one dimensional reflection/refraction without explicitly considering the stochasticity which is usually left out when describing p2=pn2 and c2=c/n2 where n2 is the index of refraction in the second medium and p and c are values in the first medium with n1=1. We further consider exp(ipx) and exp(-iEt) as arising from the maximization of Shannon’s entropy subject to certain constraints. The product of these two two-dimensional periodic probabilities is exp(-iEt+ipx) which we argue must hold as seen from observers moving with constant velocity. Thus we argue that the Lorentz invariant -Et+px follows from statistical considerations alone. Given this expression (a subset of the whole picture), one may try to create a deterministic viewpoint by setting x/t=v=constant. This allows one to consider transformations which define E and p in terms of mo and v and yields the invariant EE = pp+momo (c=1). Thus we argue that the conservation of energy equation ultimately follows from a deterministic view of the argument of a statistical probability. In other words, it is only a subset of the full picture i.e the quantum mechanical statistical one.
In a previous note, we asked the question: How does a single photon approaching an n1-n2 index of refraction junction in a one-dimensional problem know what its probability to reflect or refract is? We argued that this probability does not follow from some stochastic feature of the junction, but rather from a directional probability exp(ipx). We argued that exp(ipx) is a probability linked with conservation of momentum in Newtonian scattering and implies that there is a spatial uncertainty region of hbar/p. We argued that within a delta x region of the n1-n2 junction, the photon is able to establish a “balance” or equilibrium of the incident, reflected and refracted photon, because one does not know which it is during the time spent in dx. We argued that one must describe this by a balance of Aexp(ipx)+Bexp(-ipx) = Cexp(ip2x) at x=0 and a similar equation obtained taking d/dx. It is this balance or equilibrium which determines the weights of B and C relative to A, i.e. essentially solves the problem. If this is in fact the process which occurs, then we argue here that it should also apply to the scattering of a particle from a spherical infinite well potential at ro, for example. In other words, we consider all of the possible directional probability solutions outside of ro together as these participate in the balance or equilibrium at ro, the interaction region. In such a case, one has a general solution of the Schrodinger equation of: Al jl(pr) + Bl nl(pr) ((1)), where jl is a Bessel function, and nl, a Neumann. In order to have equilibrium between all possible exp(ipx) type directional probabilities, one must establish a constraint condition just as in the n1-n2 problem. The constraint condition for the infinite spherical potential at ro is that there is no probability for ro inside. Thus, we argue that the relevant weights in the problem (i.e. the solution of the problem) are established by the constraint condition at the interaction surface. This leads to 0 = Al jl(pro) + Bl nl(pro) ((2)). This yields a relative weight between Al and Bl. The question is then: How does this relate to anything physical? The fact is that even though ((1)) is a general math solution, with Bl now given in terms of Al through ((2)), one may now rewrite ((1)) in terms of a math sum of physical directional probabilities, namely exp(ipz) (incident particle) and f(theta) exp(ipr)/r (scattered particle). Thus, it is the use of directional probabilities (linked to momentum conservation) and constraint conditions which govern the weights of the allowable directional probabilities at an interaction point/region, i.e. ro in the spherical infinite potential case and x=0 in the n1-n2 junction reflection-refraction case. In particular, if one has an incident particle linked with exp(ipz) one wishes to know the weight f(theta) of exp(ipr)/r in order to find out what per cent of particles scatter into angle theta. This means finding a relative weight between the two directional probabilities and this occurs by a probabilistic sampling of all solutions at the interaction point (here ro). Then, only one choice of outcome occurs, but in keeping with the probabilistic balance, just as in the n1-n2 index of refraction junction reflection-refraction situation. We then try to generalize to the one-dimensional quantum bound state situation.