Classical mechanics seems to deal with limitless precision. For example, a particle may be precisely at x at t. The widths associated with these values are dx and dt, but are taken to approach 0. We argue that this view is carried over into probabilistic scenarios such as a photon moving in the x direction reflecting or refracting. Classically there is limitless precision so the photon is an incident one at one precise x and then instantaneously is either a reflected one, presumably at the same x, or a refracted one. This leads to the equation: 1=probability to reflect + probability to refract ((1)), which holds for a single photon which may be written in terms of fluxes (which are average values). For this equation to make sense, one requires limitless precision so that the states (incident, reflected, refracted) are precise and exist at precise times. We argue (as we have before) that this is the inherent reason why ((1)) is not sufficient to solve for the relative probabilities of reflection/refraction. We suggest that the interaction at an n1-n2 interface (indices of refraction) is complicated and there is not sharp x,t precision or even a clear picture of what is instantaneously occurring. As a result, we suggest one uses averages to try to describe the situation, with p and E being average values during the interaction. Nonrelativistically p=mov and given the quantum exp(-iEt+ipx), one cannot have a precise velocity, we suggest v is an average and hence p an average. Thus impulses may be described in terms of averages as well as speeds. This is why Snell’s law may be obtained using only these average values, which are taken to be precise deterministic values in classical mechanics. The blurriness of the interaction suggests there is not an instantaneous division between the incident and refracted/reflected or even the refracted/reflected photon. As a result, it is a blurry or probabilistic scenario which describes the situation probabilistically. One may note that during the interaction, p and E could be changing so these are treated as average values. Thus the idea seems to be to use average values of p and E when describing complicated interactions, but x and t probabilities governed by these average values. The question then becomes: How does one find these probabilities? We argue (as before) that a general approach is to use maximization of Shannon’s entropy (subject to periodic constraints) to obtain exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx). E and p are Lagrange multipliers and so like in classical statistical theory are averages. This equilibrium approach with its blurriness in x and t , but average p and E values, allows one to describe a complicated interaction by changes in the average value e.g. the magnitude or direction of the p vector together by adding exp(ipx) for what would be normally deterministic paths.
Classical mechanics seems to deal with limitless precision. For example, a particle may be precisely at x at t. The widths associated with these values are dx and dt, but are taken to approach 0. We argue that this view is carried over into probabilistic scenarios such as a photon moving in the x direction reflecting or refracting. Classically there is limitless precision so the photon is an incident one at one precise x and then instantaneously is either a reflected one, presumably at the same x, or a refracted one. This leads to the equation: 1=probability to reflect + probability to refract ((1)), which holds for a single photon which may be written in terms of fluxes (which are average values). For this equation to make sense, one requires limitless precision so that the states (incident, reflected, refracted) are precise and exist at precise times. We argue (as we have before) that this is the inherent reason why ((1)) is not sufficient to solve for the relative probabilities of reflection/refraction. We suggest that the interaction at an n1-n2 interface (indices of refraction) is complicated and there is not sharp x,t precision or even a clear picture of what is instantaneously occurring. As a result, we suggest one uses averages to try to describe the situation, with p and E being average values during the interaction. Nonrelativistically p=mov and given the quantum exp(-iEt+ipx), one cannot have a precise velocity, we suggest v is an average and hence p an average. Thus impulses may be described in terms of averages as well as speeds. This is why Snell’s law may be obtained using only these average values, which are taken to be precise deterministic values in classical mechanics. The blurriness of the interaction suggests there is not an instantaneous division between the incident and refracted/reflected or even the refracted/reflected photon. As a result, it is a blurry or probabilistic scenario which describes the situation probabilistically. One may note that during the interaction, p and E could be changing so these are treated as average values. Thus the idea seems to be to use average values of p and E when describing complicated interactions, but x and t probabilities governed by these average values. The question then becomes: How does one find these probabilities? We argue (as before) that a general approach is to use maximization of Shannon’s entropy (subject to periodic constraints) to obtain exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx). E and p are Lagrange multipliers and so like in classical statistical theory are averages. This equilibrium approach with its blurriness in x and t , but average p and E values, allows one to describe a complicated interaction by changes in the average value e.g. the magnitude or direction of the p vector together by adding exp(ipx) for what would be normally deterministic paths.
Some problems only require a certain amount of information for their solution. For example, a photon refracting from a medium interface along the x axis problem may be solved by noting that momentum and speed in medium 1 are pn1 and c/n1 (where p,c are momentum and speed in a vacuum and n1 is the index of refraction). In medium n2, one replaces n1 with n2. From these classical smooth values (deterministic values) one may obtain Snell’s law which may be verified experimentally. What happens if one takes this same information and tries to solve for the relative probabilities of reflection/refraction for a photon moving along the x axis in a medium with n1 and hitting an interface along the y axis at x=0. The medium for x>0 has n2>n1. Can this problem be solved simply using E=pc, and pni , c/ni? It seems it cannot. Furthermore, the smooth pni and c/ni appear to be approximations because the speed of light in a medium changes due to interactions with atoms. One might expect some type of stochastic behaviour, as a result, with pni and c/ni being averages. As shown in (1), one may maximize Shannon’s entropy subject to periodic constraints to find an unusual two-dimensional probability exp(-iEt+ipx). This probability allows one to find relative probabilities for reflection/refraction and also predicts/solves a n-slit interference-diffraction problem. Thus the smoothed over pni and c/ni information is not wrong, but only solves certain problems. More information is given by exp(-iEt+ipx) which may be used to solve further problems. Given that we suggest exp(-iEt+ipx) follows from two maximizations of Shannon’s entropy, one for P(x) and one for P(t), one might expect there is no further information. We suggest, however, that for t-> t+ constant/E and x-> x+constant/p, -Et+px does not change and this result should hold as seen in any frame moving at constant average v (velocity). By mentioning average v, one already takes a deterministic view and approximates the stochasticity of exp(-iEt+ipx). In (1), we argued that one may find the specific transformation involved in viewing E,p,x,t from a moving frame and that not only is -Et+px invariant, but also -tt+xx and -EE+pp. In fact, -EE+pp=momo (c=1) is a relation between E and p as well as being an inner product. We argue here that an inner product, in general, loses information as it is a relative relationship between two vectors. A point we wish to make is that exp(-iEt+ipx) is a solution of -EE+pp=momo (c=1) if one replaces E with id/dt partial and p with -id/dx partial. Thus, we suggest some information is lost. There is no reason to require a second order differential equation when a first order one yields p and E, although the second order equation is not wrong, it just removes some information as does an average. We thus suggest that Dirac’s approach to finding a linear equation in id/dt partial and -id/dx partial is an attempt to retrieve this extra information. This approach applies to finding extra information called spin, which again, is only useful in certain problems (for example, when a magnetic field is present). In (2) we examined a continuity equation with the Poynting vector and energy density .5(C1 Electric field Electric field + C1 Magnetic field Magnetic field) and showed it may also be broken into two linear equations which yield spin 1 information. Thus we argue that certain equations (quadratic in nature) may represent a loss of information, especially those that represent a kind of coarse grained average as in the case of energy density or even classical probability to reflect or refract. In such a case, one may try to linearize in order to find this lost information.
In Newtonian mechanics a particle with constant momentum moves deterministically according to x=p/m t. Even a quantum object such as a photon or electron should satisfy this equation on average to give meaning to the notion of the speed of light in a vacuum, for example. Thus it seems surprising that a quantum free particle is also associated with exp(ipx) which only contains momentum and is periodic and complex. Furthermore the physical consequences of exp(ipx) are real as shown in a two-slit interference experiment etc. In this note, we attempt to discover why exp(ipx) exists in the first place by examining the example of the reflection/refraction of light which occurs in the macroscopic classical world. Basically our argument is based on analyzing two important pieces of information in the system, namely the scalar energy (or particle count) and the vector momentum. A main point we make is that energy or particle number considerations are linked to determinism i.e. a specific time of interaction. One may note that the interaction x is fixed by the two medium barrier. This means a single incident photon exists in one time range and the reflected OR refracted photon in another. It is possible to compare the incident photon to either the reflected or refracted or to a sum of probabilities. In particular, a single photon has an energy E and a count of 1. If it reflects, it has an energy E and count of 1 so there is a balance, likewise for refraction. Thinking in terms of probabilities “a” and 1-a to reflect/refract: 1= a + 1-a. Can one perform such a matching for momentum, which is a physical piece of information? We argue one cannot. For example, a single incident photon has a momentum p which is linked to the impulse it may deliver. If it refracts, “all of a sudden” it is linked with momentum of p2 = n2 p where n2 is the index of refraction in the second medium and n1=1. This seems problematic because a physical impulse of 2p is all of a sudden an impulse of 2p2. Thus there exists a big problem which seems to require the notion of probability and all three momentum values p, -p and p2 considered together, unlike the situation of energy/particle number for which a comparison of the incident photon and one possible result yields a balance. Combining all three momenta, however, is also problematic in a deterministic picture because the incident photon exists in one time range and the reflected or refracted in another. How can one possibly compare them together? The solution seems to be to argue that the incident photon is only deterministic on average. In particular, if it has an x probability distribution over a certain length (called a wavelength), one does not know the precise time at which it hits “x” the medium interface. In such a situation, there is time uncertainty which allows all three momenta to be compared at the same x. This, however, leads to a major consequence, namely that so-called deterministic motion associated with constant p is deterministic on average, but contains repeated pockets of x probability distributions such that time is not deterministic within. We try to examine these ideas in this note.
A quantum particle (or photon) is described by the two dimensional probabilistic exp(-iEt+ipx), with t and x being treated as independent. exp(-iEt) suggests a stochasticity in time associated with energy E, but none in space. Similarly, there is a stochasticity in x associated with p but none in time. For -Et+px to be invariant as seen in different frames moving with constant average velocities, -EE+pp must also be an invariant i.e. equal momo (c=1). This leads to a contradiction. exp(ipx) suggests a stochasticity in x for a given p, but -EE+pp=momom converts a given p into an E, so there exists stochasticity in x for E as well (which contracts the notion that exp(-iEt) is only stochastic in time). The link between E and p, however, which breaks x-t independence is the notion of average velocity v=x/t, which is physical (as is exp(ipx)). How does one deal with this contradiction? We suggest that p and E are associated with different physical interaction processes. P is related to impulse hits, while E may be associated with loss of energy over a distance if a potential V(x) exists. Even though exp(ipx) suggests stochasticity in x, at the same time one considers fixed objects (targets, slits) and even potentials V(x) at well-defined deterministic x points. This seems to mean that if one wishes to make energy deterministic at each x, one must create an average of exp(ipx)s. We argue that there seem to be two important ideas associated with exp(ipx). First, it is a two-dimensional probability linked to a flux because it is due to p which is due to a v. Probability flux does not get created or destroyed (unless there are sinks or sources). This leads to issues when dealing with a bound state which should be localized. A flux probability is not localized, nor is an average in general (except in the case of an infinite potential). A bound state problem is really a flux problem consisting of a particle trapped in a potential together with it tunneling out or in i.e. one has a dynamic equilibrium picture somewhat like evaporation in equilibrium. (To see the clear difference between a state based probability and a flux-based one, consider the problem of a photon moving in the x direction and reflecting/refracting from an n1-n2 (index of refraction) y-plane at x=0. State probabilities (P(reflect), P(refract)) are not sufficient to solve the problem, but a flux-based one exp(ipx) which allows a single particle to appear as if in a steady stream scenario is.) Secondly, unlike evaporation, the guiding statistical condition for exp(ipx) is that its average makes E deterministic in x space. Thus E is like T (temperature) in that it is a statistical parameter, but it is not based on maximization of entropy (equilibration), but rather in creating E as an average which is then treated as deterministic (ignoring in a sense exp(-iEt) value characterizing an equilibrium system (not based on equilibration). This deterministic E system is linked with discrete values (due to the exp(ipx) equilibrium), but given that E is treated as deterministic, a stochastic process based on maximization of entropy is introduced to describe the absorption and emission of photons (which allow for jumps from one average-deterministic En to another). We argue that the flux-like probability exp(ipx) exists in order to deal with sharp interfaces (e.g. n1-n2 index of refraction) at a deterministic x=0 which probabilistically leads to different p values. It uses the reverse approach i.e. a deterministic p and a stochastic x. In such a way, one may use continuity (and first derivative continuity) at the sharp x with flux-probabilities containing the various allowed p values (due to the impulses). The continuity follows from no sinks or sources existing for the flux-like probability.
Newtonian mechanics deals with smoothness in time and space through x(t) where the “details” occur within dx and dt which tend to zero. Thus there are no discontinuities in x and t. We have argued that the quantum free particle wavefunction pieces exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx) deal with discontinuities and that smoothness is due to a “modulus” of two dimensional probability e.g. exp(ipx)exp(-ipx) which yields 1 or determinism. Both exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx) contain finite measures in time and space, namely hbar/E and hbar/p and so there may be discontinuities. For example, exp(ipx) contains probability cos(px) and sin(px) within a wavelength so x=vt is only an average type of motion. Thus using exp(ipx) in a problem may result in time discontinuities because the particle is not moving as x=vt within a wavelength. In Part I we examined one-dimensional reflection/refraction of light from an interface of two media with n1=1 and n2>n1. We concluded that the quantum solution of this problem involves two equations, one linked to probabilities and the other to impulse. Multiplying the two equations together (with a special grouping, namely a spatial grouping) yields a single equation which may either be interpreted as a pressure balance equation. Thus one starts with two equations which are both grouped in time, but with the second demonstrating vector directions and obtain a single equation which is only grouped in space (which is linked with spatial grouping). By rearranging this equation, one may obtain a time grouping i.e. energy conservation equation, but the two groupings cannot exist together. This is the problem with the classical pressure picture linked to a steady state scenario and not a single photon process which displays a discontinuity in time i.e. a single photon may either reflect or refract. In this note we try to consider why classical energy conservation/ pressure balance only leads to one equation, while the quantum mechanical approach leads to the two required equations at the price of introducing a square root flux type of probability. We argue that there seem to be two factors. First there is the notion of scalars and vectors and a space versus time picture. The single conservation of energy equation AA/c1 = BB/c1 + CC/c2 where AA,BB,CCC represent the incident, reflected and refracted beams is expressed in terms of time and so vector information (i.e. -p for the reflected beam is not conveyed). If one rewrites this as AA/c1 -BB/c1 = CC/c2 then one obtains a pressure balance type of equation, but time is removed and one is grouping by space. The second and more important feature we argue is time discontinuity. If one considers a single photon, it may reflect or refract, but not both. Thus there is a time period in which to observe both reflection and refraction and more than one incident photon is needed. Newtonian mechanics in the form of steady state treats time as smooth and so everything must happen instantaneously. This is the idea behind pressure. One considers an impulse 2p multiplied by flux i.e. velocity. The flux is used to find the number of particles which strike a surface per second as if this were a continuous smooth process in time. For the case of reflection/refraction it is not. It is discontinuous because either a reflected ro a refracted photon is created each time. Thus the notion of pressure averages this over and loses some of the information in the problem. This, we argue, is why a pressure balance/ energy conservation equation is not sufficient to solve the reflection/refraction problem even though pressure is a physical concept and may be measured (on average) just as x=vt may be measured on average.
In previous notes (1), we argued that stochasticity (in x and t for a fixed E energy and p momentum) may occur at a single particle level based on the Lorentz invariant A = -Et+px ((1)). This invariant is also the relativistic/nonrelativistic classical action for v=x/t. The argument made in (1) was that a fluctuation in t of constant/E could cancel one in x of constant/p. We further argued one could create eigenvalue equations using id/dt and -id/dx and obtain the two dimensional probabilities exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx), i.e obtain a description of free particle quantum mechanics. Experimentally, both exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx) have been verified through interference patterns. Theoretically, however, ((1)) was known about 1905 and no single particle stochasticity was associated with it. In this note, we try to argue why there should be an associated stochasticity associated with ((1)) based on motion through a constant potential for a particle with rest mass and motion through a medium with an index of refraction for a photon. We in fact argue that one cannot solve certain photon problems such as one dimensional reflection/refraction without explicitly considering the stochasticity which is usually left out when describing p2=pn2 and c2=c/n2 where n2 is the index of refraction in the second medium and p and c are values in the first medium with n1=1. We further consider exp(ipx) and exp(-iEt) as arising from the maximization of Shannon’s entropy subject to certain constraints. The product of these two two-dimensional periodic probabilities is exp(-iEt+ipx) which we argue must hold as seen from observers moving with constant velocity. Thus we argue that the Lorentz invariant -Et+px follows from statistical considerations alone. Given this expression (a subset of the whole picture), one may try to create a deterministic viewpoint by setting x/t=v=constant. This allows one to consider transformations which define E and p in terms of mo and v and yields the invariant EE = pp+momo (c=1). Thus we argue that the conservation of energy equation ultimately follows from a deterministic view of the argument of a statistical probability. In other words, it is only a subset of the full picture i.e the quantum mechanical statistical one.
We have suggested in previous notes that there is a tendency to consider quantum mechanics as a kind of hybrid probabilistic-deterministic theory because it is supposed to ultimately “merge’ with classical mechanics for high energy levels (tiny wavelengths). Newtonian mechanics is deterministic and so somehow it seems quantum mechanics should also be seen as deterministic, hence the sense of surprise at tunneling when KEave(x)=0, even though vrms(x)=0 does not mean that actual values creating the probability are 0. Here, we wish to argue that exp(-iEt+ipx) (or the exp(ipx) part for spatial interactions) is really a momentum probability scheme which may possibly bypass many aspects of the actual physics to describe a problem in a simpler form in terms of a momentum conserving probability. A key idea is that exp(ipx) is actually the form to use when one has randomness as we will argue for reflection-refraction from an n1-n2 index of refraction junction. We argue that this idea is already known for a particle in an infinite well for which one has sin(pave x), i.e. 1/2i (exp(i pave x) - exp(- i pave x)). In other words, one has the form exp(i pave x), even though it is linked with an average p. Given that one is not considering deterministic physics, there is nothing wrong with exp(i pave x) being composed of Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx), where exp(ipx) holds in all space, not just within the infinite well potential. exp(ipx) is a momentum conserving probability, but on average momentum must also be conserved by a free statistical entity within the well. Similarly, W(x) for a single particle bound state consists of many exp(ipx)s, but represents a fixed E ave and on average this Eave must be conserved in time, hence the time dependent exp(-i Eave t). As a result, one may see that the quantum mechanical exp(-iEt+ipx) is an attempt to describe a system in a simple manner in terms of momentum conserving probability. To see this in more detail, we consider (1) which describes reflection and refraction of a photon at an n1-n2 junction in depth. In a previous note, we have already pointed out that in n2, c/n2 simply means that the photon is interacting on average with atoms/molecules in n2, but has c in between such interactions. It is only on average that one has c/n2 and even E and p2 = p n2. Nevertheless, one may use exp(ip2 x) as a probability which describes average properties of the system, just as it does in the examples in the above paragraph. The question then becomes: Do the microscopic details of the photon physics (the actual interactions) dictate the probabilities to reflect/refract or does the simplified exp(ipx) set linked to momentum conservation do so? Based on (1), it seems that reflection is completely independent physically from “refraction”, the latter requiring re-radiation and affecting all glass molecules. As a result, it appears that it is difficult to suggest that it is the microscopic interactions which dictate probability because reflection and refraction are microscopically so different. On the other hand, reflection-refraction is not a .5-.5 probability random process as experimental results show. The question then becomes: If some kind of systematic probability driver is not supplied by the microscopic interaction, what provides it? We argued in previous notes that one may introduce the probability exp(ipx) into Newtonian scattering to account for an initial p1,p2 (momentum vector set) having equal probability to produce any pi, pj (outcome set) as long as momentum is conserved. We suggest here that it is exp(ipx) that one must use for random interaction if one insists on conserving momentum. Thus, exp(ipx) bypasses microscopic details of interaction and provides an “ any outcome pair of momenta” is equally likely if momentum is conserved. This is a major simplification of the problem, but the question is: What constraints does it impose on physical results? For a free particle, it suggests that it may interact probabilistically with both slits of 2-slit apparatus if the slits are about hbar/p apart. For randomness, one would expect equal probability for each slit and this is the case as long as one also considers exp(ipx) for each slit to a the same point on a screen. In the case of reflection-refraction at an n1-n2 index of refraction junction, we try to see how the simplification exp(ipx) can be consistent with the microscopic details of the interactions and at the same time dictate the probabilities to reflect and refract. We try to consider why an exp(ipx) scheme predicts how nature behaves while a random one with no momentum conservation considerations does not. In particular, we argue that exp(ipx) represent randomness in a two body scattering problem in which momentum is conserved and so this same exp(ipx) must be carried over into problems which involve interactions instead of simply suggesting that one has .5 probability to reflect and .5 to refract because the two processes are independent and hence random. They are random, but with conserved momentum and hence an exp(ipx) scheme is required, we argue.