In classical statistical mechanics, one often has an ideal gas of identical particles subject to the global constraints of total energy E and total number of particles N. The energy constraint prevents each particle from being completely independent because if two particles each have E/2 of the energy, the rest must have 0 energy. This not only places interdependence on the particles, but also on regions of space because one cannot consider them as independent. In the case of particle number, this also places restrictions locally because if a certain proportion of particles are in states with ej > ei, one cannot locally place as many particles as one wants into state ei. We suggest that relaxing these constraints i.e. using new constraints Sum over i ei n(ei) = Eave and Sum over i n(ei) = Nave are really approaches of enhancing local probability for e and n in e although the exact manner in which this enhancement appears must be determined. (Note: In the Fermi-Dirac case which is restrictive in n values, probability is inhibited. The enhancement is for bosons.)
In classical statistical mechanics, one often has an ideal gas of identical particles subject to the global constraints of total energy E and total number of particles N. The energy constraint prevents each particle from being completely independent because if two particles each have E/2 of the energy, the rest must have 0 energy. This not only places interdependence on the particles, but also on regions of space because one cannot consider them as independent. In the case of particle number, this also places restrictions locally because if a certain proportion of particles are in states with ej > ei, one cannot locally place as many particles as one wants into state ei. We suggest that relaxing these constraints i.e. using new constraints Sum over i ei n(ei) = Eave and Sum over i n(ei) = Nave are really approaches of enhancing local probability for e and n in e although the exact manner in which this enhancement appears must be determined. (Note: In the Fermi-Dirac case which is restrictive in n values, probability is inhibited. The enhancement is for bosons.)
Classical mechanics in the ideal gas scenario and quantum mechanics make use of a set of energy levels which a single particle may occupy. Thus the problem becomes to determine the probability associated with ei i.e. P(ei). In this note we take the approach that relative probabilities depend on the energy gap in question. For example, consider a quantum two level system where ei values are provided by the time-independent Schrodinger equation. From the point of view of statistics, these are simply a set of ei values. Their associated physics is contained in the Schrodinger equation. For the quantum two level system one must find the relative probabilities PR(e1) and PR(e2). Next, imagine a quantum system with many levels and assume for the sake of argument there are levels e1,e2 and ei,e(i+1) such that e2-e1=e(i+1)-ei. If the mechanism is the same for jumping from e1 to e2 and from ei to e(i+1) (i.e. absorbing a photon of the same energy), one might argue that the relative probabilities PR(e2)/PR(e1) = PR(e(i+1))/PR(ei). From this one may obtain the Maxwell-Boltzman result exp(-ei/T)). Note that levels do not need to be adjacent. For example in a large level system one might consider e1 and e3 and any ei and ej such that e3-e1 = ej - ei. In some situations this may need to be modified (e.g. fermions and bosons have enhancements and there may be level related issues), but as a first step we argue that insisting on relative probabilities being dependent on ei-ej has important consequences. Furthermore, in such a case the normalization constant for these relative probabilities i.e. C(T)= Sum over i exp(-ei/T) is important. Taking ln(C(T) and then taking the derivative d/dT yields an expression proportional to the average energy. An expression for dE/dT dT, however, would lead to a second order differential equation in ln(C(T)). If one introduces a new function S such that E-TS = -Tln(C), then one may show that dE/dT = T dS/dT i.e. entropy S emerges.
Classical statistical equilibrium, for a Maxwell-Boltzmann gas for example, is based on localizing the gas to a certain volume and having no average changes in time. In other words, maximization of entropy subject to the average energy constraint sum over i ei P(ei) is linked with these two ideas. Ei (kinetic energy for no V(x)) is a conserved quantity in reactions and overall energy represents a quantity which does not change in time consistent with a center-of-mass which does not change and average values which do not change in time. This approach is associated with a specific kind of statistics, namely that of the constituents of the system. As a result, one obtains the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution exp(-ei/T) where ei is an extensive property of a particle (or subset of the system) and T an intensive property linked with the whole system. Entire systems, however, may interact. For example, a N particle system with T1 may achieve equilibrium with a N system with T2 yielding a new average (T1+T2)/2. The probabilities exp(-ei/T), however, are for subcomponents of a system. One could argue that momentum is an additive (vector) quantity which is conserved in collisions, but the average momentum of the system is 0 which does not allow one to describe increases in average p and -p which may be described using energy, i.e. through T temperature. This begs the question whether momentum may be associated with maximization of entropy subject to a constraint. In (1), we argued that there were flow probabilities in quantum mechanics linked with exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx), which may be obtained formally through maximization of entropy. Here we argue that while an MB gas describes a localized volume with average values not changing in time, x and t state values change, even if p and pp/2m remain constant for a free particle and it may be possible to have a maximum entropy situation to describe the combination of px and -Et. In other words, we suggest localized versus nonlocalized equilibria. The latter represents a quantum free particle, but one may then try to localize such a particle in a potential. What happens in such a case? One does not switch to a localized maximization of entropy as in the MB gas case, because it is possible to have the potential leave the flow unbroken as argued in (1). In other words, the nonlocalized free particle equilibrium is akin to a particle bouncing back and forth in a box, which in classical mechanics is not considered a statistical process. Here we suggest that the underlying picture is statistical meaning that the classical mechanics approach seems to be an approximation. We consider both a quantum particle trapped in an infinite potential well and the ground state of an oscillator to examine ideas of maximizing entropy beyond exp(ipx). A key common feature of both types of equilibrium is the product rule P(ei)P(ej) = P(ei+ej) or exp(ip1x)exp(ip2x) = exp(i (p1+p2)x). We consider this feature as well.
In (1), we noted that a Gaussian wavefunction may be a solution to the time-independent Schrodinger equation (e.g. the ground state solution of the quantum oscillator) and simultaneously a solution of maximizing spatial Shannon’s entropy - density(x) ln(density(x)) subject to the constraint V(x) xx constant, where density(x) =W*(x)W(x) with W(x) being the wavefunction. In (2), which deals strictly with classical probabilities and the Maxwell-Boltzmann factor n(ei) = exp(-ei/T), we argued that this function is equivalent to: ln(n(ei)) = -ei/T. This in turn is equivalent to the maximization of ln(n(ei)!) with the constraint ei n(ei) which is part of: ln( N!/ Product over i n(ei)!) with the full constraint Sum over i ei n(ei)=Eave. Here n(ei)=N p(ei) where p(ei) is a probability and N a very large number. Thus a function of exp( something) may indicate that “something” * density(x) is a constraint with -density ln(density) being Shannon’s entropy. Quantum mechanics for a bound system yields a real wavefunction W(x) such that density(x)=W(x)W(x)=probability(x). Thus maximization of Shannon’s entropy - density(x) ln (density) subject to a constraint: density(x)B(x) should correspond to a solution for density of exp( B(x)). B(x) as part of the constraint, however, should represent a physical constraint. Thus if there is a solution to the Schrodinger equation of the form exp(.5B(x)) and B(x)density(x) represents the physical constraint in the system, classical maximization of probability solves the quantum problem in such a case. The above ideas may be applied to the quantum oscillator ground state and essentially repeat what is done in (1). We, however, try to generalize them to see if they may apply to a free quantum particle. In this case the probability used is exp(ipx) which is complex. It corresponds to P(x)=exp(ipx)exp(-ipx)=1 which is a uniform distribution which has maximum lack of information.
Extremization of entropy, usually subject to an average energy constraint,(Maxwell-Boltzmann gas) is often associated with maximization of the number of microstates N gas particles may represent. The math procedure of extremization (variational calculus) is then associated with the ln of a factorial expression which reduces to n(ei)ln(n(ei)) using Stirling’s approximation. The central limit theorem, on the other hand, states that the distribution of sample means of a random variable approaches a Gaussian, i.e exp(-pp/(2sig sig)). Here sig sig is the standard deviation. For a random variable, the important or characteristic information is the standard deviation associated with the average of the square pp. We suggest here that an alternative way of looking at maximization of entropy (which is a stability statement we argue) other than ln of permutations is to consider the stability of the variation of the variance of pp subject to a change in the probability, with pp written in terms of P(p). Average kinetic energy in a statistical problem represents such a variance and should be invariant under changes of the probability subject to an average kinetic energy constraint, we suggest. How does this idea apply to quantum mechanics? In quantum mechanics, one has a statistical function exp(ipx) and for bound states creates W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). a(p)a(p) is formally the probability for p, but this does not mean that a(p)a(p) is a random variable because one has the constraint: Sum over p a(p)a(p) pp2/m + Integral dx V(x) W(x)W(x) = En. In the case of a harmonic oscillator, however, one knows a priori that the two summands are each equal to En/2. Furthermore there are a set of En values, starting at a ground state and increasing. All En values, except the ground state, are metastable. Thus the ground state is a special state. Given that Sum over p a(p)a(p)pp2/m = Eo/2, a priori, one may consider that all of the information of a(p)a(p) is associated with Eo. This is exactly the case for a Gaussian from the central limit theorem. Alternatively, from information theory, information = ln(probability) which yields the same result. If this is the case, then pp/2m a(p)a(p) written strictly in terms of P(p)=a(p)a(p) should be stationary upon changing P(p) subject to the E/2 constraint. This special situation, however, only holds for the ground state oscillator. What about average potential energy for the ground state oscillator? If the probability for p (momentum) is a Gaussian due to the Central Limit theorem, this means that the standard deviation is the information (and is linked with randomness). Taking a Fourier transform of a(p) cannot add more information to the picture, we argue. W(x)W(x) should also be a Gaussian, as it is. As a result, xxW(x)W(x), written in terms of P(x)=W(x)W(x) subject to the same Eo/2 constraint should represent a maximization or stationary situation, we argue.
Historically statistical mechanics was developed for gasses for which there are very large numbers of molecules (i.e. on the order of 10 to 23rd power). As a result factorial schemes were developed to count the number of arrangements possible, the ln taken of this result and Stirling’s approximation for large N applied. The Shannon’s entropy form S/(-k) = Sum over i P(ei)ln(P(ei)) is consistent with this large N approach. Furthermore, large N statistical mechanics was linked to thermodynamics, in particular the first law dE=TdS - PdV. Surprisingly then, statistical mechanical results were applied to systems with small numbers of particles (e.g. a nucleus with about 100 nucleons etc). In Parts I and II we argued that the first law of thermodynamics describes two separate kinds of changes associated with energy changes. The second, work, is linked to the change of a mechanical parameter such as the volume of a box etc. The energy of a bound quantum particle in a box with an infinite potential is proportional to nn/LL. Thus we argued that a pure quantum bound state may also be associated with the first law of thermodynamics with changes in L with n, the energy level, held constant representing pure work. We further argued that for a bound state two classical like probabilities exists P(x)=W(x)W(x) and P(p)=a(p)a(p) where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) with P(x) being proportional to 1/L and P(p) to L. For a quantum adiabatic transformation (i.e. changing L with n staying constant) the term dS=0. If one wishes to create S from P(x) and P(p) and desires linearity i.e. S=Sp(n)+Sx, then Sp=Integral dp P(p)ln(P(p)) and Sx= Integral dx P(x) ln(P(x)) is a solution. If one next considers a quantum wavefunction for two levels W(x,t) = a(1)exp(-i E1 t) W1(x) + a(2) exp(-iE2 t) W2(x) with Eave = Sum over n en P(en) where Wn=a(n)a(n), one may again utilize the first law of thermodynamics. In Parts I and II we carried over the entropy form P(ei)ln(P(ei)). In this note we wish to argue that this form follows at the two energy level picture by considerations of a function which consists entirely of probabilities i.e. P(ei) and is linear in the sense that such a function for two identical two state systems should yield S1+S2 as the first law should apply to each system. Furthermore P(ei) should be a function of P(ei/T) where T is a parameter which behaves as 1/LL because ei is proportional to 1/LL. In this way any function of P(ei) remains unchanged under a quantum adiabatic transformation for which i’s stay constant, but L changes. As a result, the entropy at the quantum level seems to follow from such arguments and not from large N approximations of factorial counting approaches. In large N situations it is argued that P(ei)=C(T)exp(-ei/T) follows from maximizing S with respect to the form of P(ei) subject to constant average energy. For small N situations (e.g. the 2 level example) one may solve Sum over i ei d(a(i)a(i)) = T dS directly without maximization. The maximization approach follows directly from dE=TdS (work=0) because dE= Sum ei dP(ei) in such scenarios. This is of the form of a Lagrange constraint This has been pointed out in Part II. In this note, we argue that the maximization of entropy is not needed at all. For dE=Sum over i ei dP(ei) and the ln form of entropy P(ei) is the inverse function of ln. Thus we argue that linearity and not large N arguments are enough to obtain Shannon’s form of entropy and that this ln form suggests P(ei/T) = C(T)exp(-ei/T) if dE=Sum over ei dP(ei)= TdS (for dW=0). Thus maximization of entropy subject to constant average energy is also not needed (although it does follow mathematically from dE=TdS.)
Classical statistical mechanics is often derived using counting methods applied to all possible configurations a system may take subject to a total volume and a total energy constraint. Given that there are numerous configurations, there should also be an average of these configurations described by f(e) for the Maxwell-Boltzmann (MB), Fermi-Dirac (FD) and Bose-Einstein (BE) distributions. In previous notes we have argued that one may apply a dynamical constraint to the average configuration. In particular, we argued that there should be a time reversal balance for two body elastic collisions. This immediately yields the various distributions with only consideration given to the average state and no counting techniques used. The counting of configurations, however, emphasizes that statistical mechanical systems contain “fluctuations” and that a specific dynamic constraint (i.e. time reversal two body scattering) applies only to the average. Quantum bound states, we argue, are very similar. They represent a statistical system which has many fluctuations (i.e. a particle may be knocked out with an momentum p with probability a*(p)a(p) where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx)). There is, however, also a dynamical constraint which applies to the average, namely KE(x)+V(x)=E which is a classical mechanical constraint. Here KE(x)= [-1/2m d/dx dW/dx /W] ((1)). If fluctuations disappear in the high energy scenario, one may assume there is an almost fixed momentum p at each x. ((1)) still applies and there is still a wavefunction which is often in the form of crests and troughs. If an almost unique p exists at each x, one expects W(x) to vary in height at peak values. This may be verified from actual W(x) solutions. Given that the constraint on the statistical average is KE(x)+V(x)=E, one would expect that as p becomes an almost unique value at each x, that the quantum expectation Integral dx WW KE(x) with KE(x) given by ((1)) should also approach a classical value in other words Integral dx WW —> integral dt. One does not need to impose the correspondence principle to arrive at this result, one only needs to consider the case in which fluctuations in a quantum system disappear allowing the average p at each x to consist of almost a single p value.