The No Low-energy Trivial States (NLTS) conjecture of Freedman and Hastings, 2014 -- which posits the existence of a local Hamiltonian with a super-constant quantum circuit lower bound on the complexity of all low-energy states -- identifies a fundamental obstacle to the resolution of the quantum PCP conjecture. In this work, we provide new techniques, based on entropic and local indistinguishability arguments, that prove circuit lower bounds for all the low-energy states of local Hamiltonians arising from quantum error-correcting codes. For local Hamiltonians arising from nearly linear-rate or nearly linear-distance LDPC stabilizer codes, we prove super-constant circuit lower bounds for the complexity of all states of energy o(n). Such codes are known to exist and are not necessarily locally testable, a property previously suspected to be essential for the NLTS conjecture. Curiously, such codes can also be constructed on a two-dimensional lattice, showing that low-depth states cannot accurately approximate the ground-energy even in physically relevant systems.
Understanding the complexity of low-energy quantum states is a central problem in quantum complexity theory and many-body physics. Here we prove the no low-energy trivial magic (NLTM) conjecture, constructing a family of local Hamiltonians for which every state within a positive energy density window requires circuit depth
Ω(logn) to prepare from arbitrary stabilizer state that may themselves be highly entangled. Notably, our result is intrinsic in the sense that the same Hamiltonian family and energy density threshold apply to arbitrary qudit stabilizer inputs with any bounded local dimensions. Our construction builds on non-Abelian gauged sheaf codes obtained using the cup product structure on good quantum locally testable codes. We establish constant operator soundness for the associated Hamiltonians, enabling their protected logical structure to constrain all states at sufficiently low energy density. By excluding shallow stabilizer-based classical witnesses, Our result substantially strengthens NLTS and advances our understanding of low-energy complexity relevant to quantum PCP.
The NLTS (No Low-Energy Trivial State) conjecture [M. H. Freedman and M. B. Hastings, Quantum Inf. Comput. 14, 144 (2014)] posits that there exist families of Hamiltonians with all low energy states of high complexity (with complexity measured by the quantum circuit depth preparing the state). Here, we prove a weaker version called the combinatorial no low error trivial states (NLETS), where a quantum circuit lower bound is shown against states that violate a (small) constant fraction of local terms. This generalizes the prior NLETS results [L. Eldar and A. W. Harrow, in 2017 IEEE 58th Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science (FOCS) (IEEE, 2017), pp. 427–438] and [Nirkhe et al., in 45th International Colloquium on Automata, Languages, and Programming (ICALP 2018), Leibniz International Proceedings in Informatics (LIPIcs), edited by Chatzigiannakis et al. (Schloss Dagstuhl–Leibniz-Zentrum fuer Informatik, Dagstuhl, Germany, 2018), Vol. 107, pp. 1–11]. Our construction is obtained by combining tensor networks with expander codes [M. Sipser and D. Spielman, IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 42, 1710 (1996)]. The Hamiltonian is the parent Hamiltonian of a perturbed tensor network, inspired by the “uncle Hamiltonian” of Fernández-González et al. [Commun. Math. Phys. 333, 299 (2015)]. Thus, we deviate from the quantum Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) code Hamiltonians considered in most prior works.
The No Low-energy Trivial States (NLTS) conjecture of Freedman and Hastings
(Quantum Information and Computation, 2014) -- which posits the existence of a
local Hamiltonian with a super-constant circuit lower bound on the complexity
of all low-energy states -- identifies a fundamental obstacle to the resolution
of the quantum PCP conjecture. In this paper, we provide new techniques, based
on entropic and local indistinguishability arguments, for proving circuit lower
bounds for the low-energy states of local Hamiltonians arising from quantum
error-correcting codes. For local Hamiltonians arising from nearly linear-rate and
polynomial-distance LDPC stabilizer codes, we prove a super-constant circuit
lower bounds for the complexity of all states of energy o(n) (which can be
viewed as an almost linear NLTS theorem). Such codes are known to exist and, in
general, are not locally-testable, a property previously suspected to be
essential for the NLTS conjecture. Curiously, such codes can also be
constructed on a constant-dimensional lattice, showing that complex
entanglement at high energies can persist in physically relevant systems.
A central question in quantum information theory is the circuit complexity of states arising from standard many-body models. We study this question for quantum
p-spin glasses, random Hamiltonians whose interactions act on
p-tuples of qubits through Pauli strings. Anschuetz, Gamarnik, and Kiani (arXiv:2404.07231) showed that the optimum energy is separated from the best energy achievable by product states. This leaves open whether shallow circuits can close the gap, since even depth-one circuits can generate entanglement.
We show that the entanglement needed to close the product-state gap cannot be generated at shallow depth. When the average interaction degree grows with
n, we prove that, for all sufficiently large fixed
p, any circuit preparing an
n-qubit state whose normalized energy is within a fixed positive constant of the optimum must have depth
Ωp(logn). In the bounded-average-degree regime, we prove a fixed-depth obstruction: for every fixed
D, a sufficiently large degree prefactor rules out depth-
D preparation of near-ground states. Both results hold uniformly over circuits with an arbitrary number of ancilla qubits.
Our results give an obstruction in the spirit of the No Low-Energy Trivial States problem of Freedman and Hastings (arXiv:1301.1363), but for random quantum spin glasses rather than code-based Hamiltonians such as those of Anshu, Breuckmann, and Nirkhe (arXiv:2206.13228), whose ground states admit polynomial-size preparation circuits. This setting opens a probabilistic route to NLTS-like questions: we recast state-preparation lower bounds for random quantum Hamiltonians as uniform control of Gaussian processes indexed by shallow circuits.