Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE International Symposium on High-Performance Computer Architecture (HPCA)

HyQSAT: A Hybrid Approach for 3-SAT Problems by Integrating Quantum Annealer with CDCL

Siwei Tan, Mingqian Yu, André Python, Yongheng Shang, Tingting Li, Liqiang Lu, Jianwei Yin

Published Feb 1, 2023• 15 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Propositional satisfiability problem (SAT) is represented in a conjunctive normal form with multiple clauses, which is an important non-deterministic polynomial-time (NP) complete problem that plays a major role in various applications including artificial intelligence, graph colouring, and circuit analysis. Quantum annealing (QA) is a promising methodology for solving complex SAT problems by exploiting the parallelism of quantum entanglement, where the SAT variables are embedded to the qubits. However, the long embedding time fundamentally limits existing QA-based methods, leading to inefficient hardware implementation and poor scalability.In this paper, we propose HyQSAT, a hybrid approach that integrates QA with the classical Conflict-Driven Clause Learning (CDCL) algorithm to enable end-to-end acceleration for solving SAT problems. Instead of embedding all clauses to QA hardware, we quantitatively estimate the conflict frequency of clauses and apply breadth-first traversal to choose their embedding order. We also consider the hardware topology to maximize the utilization of physical qubits in embedding to QA hardware. Besides, we adjust the embedding coefficients to improve the computation accuracy under qubit noise. Finally, we present how to interpret the satisfaction probability based on QA energy distribution and use this information to guide the CDCL search. Our experiments demonstrate that HyQSAT can effectively support larger-scale SAT problems that are beyond the capability of existing QA approaches, achieve up to 12.62X end-to-end speedup using D-Wave 2000Q compared to the classic CDCL algorithm on Intel E5 CPU, and considerably reduce the QA embedding time from 17.2s to 15.7µs compared to the D-Wave Minorminer algorithm [11].

DOI
10.1109/hpca56546.2023.10071022

Related papers

Efficient digital quadratic unconstrained binary optimization solvers for SAT problems

Robert Simon Fong, Yanming Song, Alexander Yosifov

Abstract Boolean satisfiability (SAT) is a propositional logic problem of determining whether an assignment of variables satisfies a Boolean formula. Many combinatorial optimization problems can be formulated in Boolean SAT logic—either as k-SAT decision problems or Max k-SAT optimization problems, with conflict-driven clause learning (CDCL) solvers being the most prominent. Despite their ability to handle large instances, CDCL-based solvers have fundamental scalability limitations. In light of this, we propose recently-developed quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) solvers as an alternative platform for 3-SAT problems. To utilize them, we implement a 2-step [3-SAT]-[Max 2-SAT]-[QUBO] conversion procedure and present a novel approach using linear systems and Diophantine equation to calculate the number of both satisfied and violated clauses of the original 3-SAT instance from the transformed Max 2-SAT formulation. We then demonstrate, through numerical simulations on several benchmark instances, that digital QUBO solvers can achieve state-of-the-art accuracy on 78-variable 3-SAT benchmark problems. Our work facilitates the broader use of quantum annealers on noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, as well as their quantum-inspired digital counterparts, for solving 3-SAT problems.

arXiv:2408.03757•New Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 2025•3 citations

Experimental Analysis of Quantum Annealing for Satisfiability Problems

Remma Ukaku, Tomohisa Kawakami, Hiroyuki Tomiyama

Quantum computing has emerged as a promising method for solving combinatorial optimization problems. These problems are often encoded as the Satisfiability (SAT) problem. In this study, we explore the quantum annealing based approach to solving the SAT problems. We conduct experiments on uniformly random 3-CNF instances that have 400 propositional variables and 1,000 to 2,499 clauses. We measure the time required to solve them using Fixstars Amplify Annealing Engine. The results show that the monotonic increase in solving time as the number of clauses increases, except for a discontinuity point at approximately 1,800 clauses. In addition, we observe some cases of false UNSAT reports. Our findings demonstrate both the characteristics and the limitations of this quantum annealing based solver. We plan to reproduce the solver on a local machine to inspect the performance when varying the parameters of the quantum annealing and the environment.

IEEE Asia Pacific Conference on Circuits and Systems (APCCAS)•Oct 12, 2025•0 citations

Leveraging Artificial Intelligence to Advance Problem-Solving with Quantum Annealers

Ramin Ayanzadeh

We show how to advance quantum information processing, specifically problem-solving with quantum annealers, in the realm of artificial intelligence. We introduce SAT++, as a novel quantum programming paradigm, that can compile classical algorithms (implemented in classical programming languages) and execute them on quantum annealers. Moreover, we introduce a post-quantum error correction method that can find samples with significantly lower energy values, compared to the state-of-the-art techniques in quantum annealing. We also demonstrate that performing post-quantum error correction methods can make results of quantum annealers reproducible?i.e., more robust behavior of quantum annealers, compared to recent software and hardware advancements in quantum annealing. In addition, we offer to conjugate both optimization and sampling aspects of the quantum annealers and introduce two AI hybrid approaches. In reinforcement quantum annealing (RQA) scheme, an intelligent agent interacts with a quantum annealer that plays the stochastic environment role of learning automata and searches in the space of Hamiltonians, rather than exploring the Hilbert space of a given Ising model. In the same manner, greedy quantum annealing (GQA) is a novel model that utilizes quantum annealers to better select candidates in greedy algorithms. We experimentally demonstrate that our proposed AI hybrid approaches outperform the best-known techniques in quantum annealing, specifically when problems require longer chains for forming virtual qubits with higher connectivity. Furthermore, we introduce the theory of ensemble quantum annealing (EQA) that generates multiple (distinct) Ising Hamiltonians whose ground states are all identical to a solution to the problem of interest. Our experimental results reveal that applying EQA can significantly boost the performance of the quantum annealers. After benchmarking the D-Wave 2000Q quantum processors, as a proof-of-concept, we apply our proposed models on two real-world problems. As our first study case, we use SAT++ for factoring pseudo-prime numbers on a D-Wave quantum processor that can jeopardize the security of modern public-key cryptography systems. As our second case of study, we address the NP-hard problem of compressive sensing (i.e., the $\ell_0$-norm problem of sparse recovery) through reducing the original problem of compressive sensing to Weighted-MAX-SAT instances, casting the $\ell_0$-norm problem of binary compressive sensing to quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO), and proposing to solve the original problems of binary compressive sensing and binary compressive sensing with matrix uncertainty on quantum annealers.

•Jan 20, 2020•5 citations

Towards Quantum Computing: Solving Satisfiability Problem by Quantum Annealing

Juexiao Su

To date, conventional computers have never been able to efficiently handle certain tasks, where the number of computation steps is likely to blow up as the problem size increases. As an emerging technology and new computing paradigm, quantum computing has a great potential to tackle those hard tasks efficiently. Among all the existing quantum computation models, quantum annealing has drawn significant attention in recent years due to the realization of the commercialized quantum annealer, sparking research interests in developing applications to solve problems that are intractable for classical computers.However, designing and implementing algorithms that manage to harness the enormous computation power from quantum annealer remains a challenging task. Generally, it requires mapping of the given optimization problem into quadratic unconstrained binary optimization(QUBO) problem and embedding the subsequent QUBO onto the physical architecture of quantum annealer. Additionally, practical quantum annealers are susceptible to errors leading to low probability of the correct solution.In this study, we focus on solving Boolean satisfiability (SAT) problem using quantum annealer while addressing practical limitations. We have proposed a mapping technique that maps SAT problem to QUBO, and we have further devised a tool flow that embeds the QUBO onto the architecture of a quantum annealing device. Additionally, We have optimized the proposed embedding flow to reduce run-time in addition to shortening the qubit chain length, leading to robust quantum annealing. To further improve the reliability of quantum annealing, we have also developed a post processing embedding technique that enlarges the energy gap between ground state and the first excited state. To demonstrate the effectiveness of proposed methods, we have conducted experiments on real quantum annealing devices manufactured by D-Wave Systems, showing compelling result of using quantum annealer to solve SAT problem.

•Jan 1, 2018•4 citations

Parallel Quantum Annealing: A Novel Approach to Solving Multiple NP-Hard Problems Concurrently

Jargalsaikhan Artag, Moe Shimada, Jun‐ichi Shirakashi

This study introduces an innovative application of Parallel Quantum Annealing (PQA) to concurrently solve multiple NP-hard problems on a quantum annealer, leveraging unused qubits on D-Wave's Pegasus architecture to enhance efficiency and accuracy. While parallel execution of different problems on the same quantum annealing device has been previously explored, our application extends the current PQA method, which typically solves a single problem multiple times or different problems with minor embedded combinatorial optimization. This study primarily focuses on three NP-hard problems relevant to integrated circuit design: the Graph Coloring Problem (GCP), the Minimum Vertex Cover Problem (MVCP), and the Graph Partitioning Problem (GPP). After formulating these problems as Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO), they were embedded into the D-Wave quantum annealing machine, and the annealing process was run on the combined QUBO. The results were subsequently decoded into individual problems. Our results, quantified via the Time-To-Target (TTT) metric, showcased enhanced efficiency and accuracy in reaching target solutions, indicating a substantial improvement over traditional Quantum Annealing (QA) and Simulated Annealing (SA) methods. The research illustrates the potential of quantum computing for solving complex real-world problems more efficiently and emphasizes the importance of leveraging all available qubits in quantum annealers. The findings can significantly contribute to the development and optimization of quantum computing methods and have broad application implications, particularly in areas where NP-hard problems are prevalent.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 17, 2023•3 citations

A quantum annealing approach for boolean satisfiability problem

Juexiao Su, Tianheng Tu, Lei He

Quantum annealing device has shown a great potential in solving discrete problems that are theoretically and empirically hard. Boolean Satisfiability (SAT) problem, determining if there is an assignment of variables that satisfies a given Boolean function, is the first proven NP-complete problem widely used in various domains. Here, we present a novel mapping of the SAT problem to the quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problem (QUBO), and further develop a tool flow embedding the proposed QUBO to the architecture of the commercialized quantum computer D-Wave. By leveraging electronic design automation techniques including synthesis, placement and routing, this is not only the first work providing the detail flow that embeds the QUBO, but also a technique scalable for real world applications and some hard SAT problems with over 6000 variables in QUBO. Based on our results, we discuss the challenges in solving SAT using the current generation of annealing device, and explore the problem solving capability of future quantum annealing computers.

ACM/IEEE Design Automation Conference (DAC)•May 25, 2016•39 citations
Propositional satisfiability problem (SAT) is represented in a conjunctive normal form with multiple clauses, which is an important non-deterministic polynomial-time (NP) complete problem that plays a major role in various applications including artificial intelligence, graph colouring, and circuit analysis. Quantum annealing (QA) is a promising methodology for solving complex SAT problems by exploiting the parallelism of quantum entanglement, where the SAT variables are embedded to the qubits. However, the long embedding time fundamentally limits existing QA-based methods, leading to inefficient hardware implementation and poor scalability.In this paper, we propose HyQSAT, a hybrid approach that integrates QA with the classical Conflict-Driven Clause Learning (CDCL) algorithm to enable end-to-end acceleration for solving SAT problems. Instead of embedding all clauses to QA hardware, we quantitatively estimate the conflict frequency of clauses and apply breadth-first traversal to choose their embedding order. We also consider the hardware topology to maximize the utilization of physical qubits in embedding to QA hardware. Besides, we adjust the embedding coefficients to improve the computation accuracy under qubit noise. Finally, we present how to interpret the satisfaction probability based on QA energy distribution and use this information to guide the CDCL search. Our experiments demonstrate that HyQSAT can effectively support larger-scale SAT problems that are beyond the capability of existing QA approaches, achieve up to 12.62X end-to-end speedup using D-Wave 2000Q compared to the classic CDCL algorithm on Intel E5 CPU, and considerably reduce the QA embedding time from 17.2s to 15.7µs compared to the D-Wave Minorminer algorithm [11].
Abstract Boolean satisfiability (SAT) is a propositional logic problem of determining whether an assignment of variables satisfies a Boolean formula. Many combinatorial optimization problems can be formulated in Boolean SAT logic—either as k-SAT decision problems or Max k-SAT optimization problems, with conflict-driven clause learning (CDCL) solvers being the most prominent. Despite their ability to handle large instances, CDCL-based solvers have fundamental scalability limitations. In light of this, we propose recently-developed quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) solvers as an alternative platform for 3-SAT problems. To utilize them, we implement a 2-step [3-SAT]-[Max 2-SAT]-[QUBO] conversion procedure and present a novel approach using linear systems and Diophantine equation to calculate the number of both satisfied and violated clauses of the original 3-SAT instance from the transformed Max 2-SAT formulation. We then demonstrate, through numerical simulations on several benchmark instances, that digital QUBO solvers can achieve state-of-the-art accuracy on 78-variable 3-SAT benchmark problems. Our work facilitates the broader use of quantum annealers on noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, as well as their quantum-inspired digital counterparts, for solving 3-SAT problems.
Quantum computing has emerged as a promising method for solving combinatorial optimization problems. These problems are often encoded as the Satisfiability (SAT) problem. In this study, we explore the quantum annealing based approach to solving the SAT problems. We conduct experiments on uniformly random 3-CNF instances that have 400 propositional variables and 1,000 to 2,499 clauses. We measure the time required to solve them using Fixstars Amplify Annealing Engine. The results show that the monotonic increase in solving time as the number of clauses increases, except for a discontinuity point at approximately 1,800 clauses. In addition, we observe some cases of false UNSAT reports. Our findings demonstrate both the characteristics and the limitations of this quantum annealing based solver. We plan to reproduce the solver on a local machine to inspect the performance when varying the parameters of the quantum annealing and the environment.
We show how to advance quantum information processing, specifically problem-solving with quantum annealers, in the realm of artificial intelligence. We introduce SAT++, as a novel quantum programming paradigm, that can compile classical algorithms (implemented in classical programming languages) and execute them on quantum annealers. Moreover, we introduce a post-quantum error correction method that can find samples with significantly lower energy values, compared to the state-of-the-art techniques in quantum annealing. We also demonstrate that performing post-quantum error correction methods can make results of quantum annealers reproducible?i.e., more robust behavior of quantum annealers, compared to recent software and hardware advancements in quantum annealing. In addition, we offer to conjugate both optimization and sampling aspects of the quantum annealers and introduce two AI hybrid approaches. In reinforcement quantum annealing (RQA) scheme, an intelligent agent interacts with a quantum annealer that plays the stochastic environment role of learning automata and searches in the space of Hamiltonians, rather than exploring the Hilbert space of a given Ising model. In the same manner, greedy quantum annealing (GQA) is a novel model that utilizes quantum annealers to better select candidates in greedy algorithms. We experimentally demonstrate that our proposed AI hybrid approaches outperform the best-known techniques in quantum annealing, specifically when problems require longer chains for forming virtual qubits with higher connectivity. Furthermore, we introduce the theory of ensemble quantum annealing (EQA) that generates multiple (distinct) Ising Hamiltonians whose ground states are all identical to a solution to the problem of interest. Our experimental results reveal that applying EQA can significantly boost the performance of the quantum annealers. After benchmarking the D-Wave 2000Q quantum processors, as a proof-of-concept, we apply our proposed models on two real-world problems. As our first study case, we use SAT++ for factoring pseudo-prime numbers on a D-Wave quantum processor that can jeopardize the security of modern public-key cryptography systems. As our second case of study, we address the NP-hard problem of compressive sensing (i.e., the ℓ0\ell_0ℓ0​-norm problem of sparse recovery) through reducing the original problem of compressive sensing to Weighted-MAX-SAT instances, casting the ℓ0\ell_0ℓ0​-norm problem of binary compressive sensing to quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO), and proposing to solve the original problems of binary compressive sensing and binary compressive sensing with matrix uncertainty on quantum annealers.
To date, conventional computers have never been able to efficiently handle certain tasks, where the number of computation steps is likely to blow up as the problem size increases. As an emerging technology and new computing paradigm, quantum computing has a great potential to tackle those hard tasks efficiently. Among all the existing quantum computation models, quantum annealing has drawn significant attention in recent years due to the realization of the commercialized quantum annealer, sparking research interests in developing applications to solve problems that are intractable for classical computers.However, designing and implementing algorithms that manage to harness the enormous computation power from quantum annealer remains a challenging task. Generally, it requires mapping of the given optimization problem into quadratic unconstrained binary optimization(QUBO) problem and embedding the subsequent QUBO onto the physical architecture of quantum annealer. Additionally, practical quantum annealers are susceptible to errors leading to low probability of the correct solution.In this study, we focus on solving Boolean satisfiability (SAT) problem using quantum annealer while addressing practical limitations. We have proposed a mapping technique that maps SAT problem to QUBO, and we have further devised a tool flow that embeds the QUBO onto the architecture of a quantum annealing device. Additionally, We have optimized the proposed embedding flow to reduce run-time in addition to shortening the qubit chain length, leading to robust quantum annealing. To further improve the reliability of quantum annealing, we have also developed a post processing embedding technique that enlarges the energy gap between ground state and the first excited state. To demonstrate the effectiveness of proposed methods, we have conducted experiments on real quantum annealing devices manufactured by D-Wave Systems, showing compelling result of using quantum annealer to solve SAT problem.
This study introduces an innovative application of Parallel Quantum Annealing (PQA) to concurrently solve multiple NP-hard problems on a quantum annealer, leveraging unused qubits on D-Wave's Pegasus architecture to enhance efficiency and accuracy. While parallel execution of different problems on the same quantum annealing device has been previously explored, our application extends the current PQA method, which typically solves a single problem multiple times or different problems with minor embedded combinatorial optimization. This study primarily focuses on three NP-hard problems relevant to integrated circuit design: the Graph Coloring Problem (GCP), the Minimum Vertex Cover Problem (MVCP), and the Graph Partitioning Problem (GPP). After formulating these problems as Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO), they were embedded into the D-Wave quantum annealing machine, and the annealing process was run on the combined QUBO. The results were subsequently decoded into individual problems. Our results, quantified via the Time-To-Target (TTT) metric, showcased enhanced efficiency and accuracy in reaching target solutions, indicating a substantial improvement over traditional Quantum Annealing (QA) and Simulated Annealing (SA) methods. The research illustrates the potential of quantum computing for solving complex real-world problems more efficiently and emphasizes the importance of leveraging all available qubits in quantum annealers. The findings can significantly contribute to the development and optimization of quantum computing methods and have broad application implications, particularly in areas where NP-hard problems are prevalent.
Quantum annealing device has shown a great potential in solving discrete problems that are theoretically and empirically hard. Boolean Satisfiability (SAT) problem, determining if there is an assignment of variables that satisfies a given Boolean function, is the first proven NP-complete problem widely used in various domains. Here, we present a novel mapping of the SAT problem to the quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problem (QUBO), and further develop a tool flow embedding the proposed QUBO to the architecture of the commercialized quantum computer D-Wave. By leveraging electronic design automation techniques including synthesis, placement and routing, this is not only the first work providing the detail flow that embeds the QUBO, but also a technique scalable for real world applications and some hard SAT problems with over 6000 variables in QUBO. Based on our results, we discuss the challenges in solving SAT using the current generation of annealing device, and explore the problem solving capability of future quantum annealing computers.