© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.
Physics Today
More on the demons of thermodynamics J. Jeener
Published Mar 1, 2023 • 1 citation
Abstract In her article “The demons haunting thermodynamics” (Physics Today, November 2021, page 44), Katie Robertson concludes the introductory historical summary by saying that modern developments in quantum foundations have banished the demons “once and for all.” Unfortunately, no explanation or reference is given for that optimistic but controversial conclusion.Robertson presents Erwin Hahn’s 1950 spin-echo experiments11. E. L. Hahn, Phys. Rev. 80, 580 (1950). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.80.580 as the realization of Josef Loschmidt’s vision of reversing momentum. But Hahn clearly described his spin-echo experiments as the effect of traditional spin dynamics for noninteracting spins in a spatially inhomogeneous magnetic field. Although the detailed explanation involves many particular subtleties of NMR dynamics in liquids, Hahn’s interpretation does not imply any violation of the “second law”; it uses only the mild assumption that the spin observables are at thermal equilibrium before each start signal. Robertson’s misunderstanding clearly appears when she writes that “atomic spins that have dephased and become disordered are taken back to their earlier state by an RF pulse” and, a few lines later, “it turns out that the spin-echo experiment is a special case; most systems approach equilibrium instead of retracing their steps back to nonequilibrium states.” The spins have not become disordered: The phase of each spin remains directly related to the magnetic field at the spin’s location, and that relationship explains the echo.Two illuminating articles by Won-Kyu Rhim, Alexander Pines, and John Waugh describe spin-echo experiments in which the irreversible time evolution of a coupled nuclear spin system in solids is apparently “reversed” for a limited duration.22. W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 218 (1970); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.25.218W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. B 3, 684 (1971). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.3.684 As the authors explain, the results arise from uniform spin manipulation and are still consistent with the laws of thermodynamics.Another aspect of Robertson’s article that disturbed me is the lack of discussion of the relations between the actual experiments performed on large (macroscopic) systems and the microscopic-scale models used in attempts to make predictions about those results.Consider a mixture of oxygen and hydrogen at atmospheric pressure and room temperature. Standard thermodynamics and statistical mechanics will lead to excellent predictions of the equation of state, specific heat, and the like. But the standard models ignore the possibility of the chemical reaction producing water. Improved models are needed if one is to allow for, say, a slow, isothermal catalytic reaction or—much more complicated—an explosion in an isolated system at constant volume. Spin systems offer a rich variety of experimental possibilities for external manipulation and observation, but the corresponding models are related to the real experimental situations by complicated transformations and approximations that must be chosen according to the situation under study.Robertson invokes two models in the context of Maxwell’s demon. One is a biological machine using a ratchet-style mechanism. But in the cited article, the abstract carefully indicates that the evolution does not violate the second law because the microscopic mechanism is coupled to the exterior of the system.33. V. Serreli et al., Nature 445, 523 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature05452 In the demon-style experiment of Robertson’s figure 3, a complete realistic discussion of an actual implementation of the experiment leads to the similar conclusion that the second law is not violated.My conclusion is that demons and the related controversies are features of models and that the interpretation of actual experiments should be subjected to critical examination, preferably by those who performed the experiment and have a complete knowledge of all details.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. E. L. Hahn, Phys. Rev. 80, 580 (1950). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.80.580, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 218 (1970); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.25.218, Google ScholarCrossref, ISIW.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. B 3, 684 (1971). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.3.684, , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. V. Serreli et al., Nature 445, 523 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1038/nature05452, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2023 American Institute of Physics.
DOI 10.1063/pt.3.5187 Related papers Bohr’s molecular model and the melding of classical and quantum mechanics
Petar Grujić
Anatoly Svidzinsky, Marlan Scully, and Dudley Herschbach have illustrated well how the molecular theory might have looked had quantum mechanics not been invented. It’s worth noting that Niels Bohr was not alone in his attempts to extend semiclassical mechanics to systems more complex than the hydrogen atom. From 1913 to 1925, many semiclassical models of two-electron systems were proposed.As we see from the authors’ figure 3a, Bohr assumed that electrons in hydrogen molecules move around the molecular axis out of phase. It is a remarkable fact that Werner Heisenberg put forward in 1922 a two-electron atomic model that had electrons moving similarly out of phase and that ascribed a fractional quantum number (½) to the bending mode of the configuration.11. G. Tanner, K. Richter, J.-M. Rost, Rev. Mod. Phys. 72, 497 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.72.497 Although Heisenberg’s model predicted the ground-state helium level, which was in excellent agreement with the spectroscopic data, Bohr opposed the model, since a noninteger quantum number was considered sacrilege. For the same reason, Bohr never published his own results. However, the asynchronous two-electron atomic model turned out to be the fertile one, though the corresponding classical configurations can have very complex structure.22. P. Grujic, N. Simonovic, J. Phys. B 28, 1159 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1088/0953-4075/28/7/011REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. G. Tanner, K. Richter, J.-M. Rost, Rev. Mod. Phys. 72, 497 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.72.497, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. P. Grujic, N. Simonovic, J. Phys. B 28, 1159 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1088/0953-4075/28/7/011, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2014 American Institute of Physics.
Physics Today • Aug 1, 2014• 1 citation
More variations on Aharonov-Bohm
Peter Andrew Sturrock, T. R. Groves
Having read “The Aharonov-Bohm Effects: Variations on a Subtle Theme” by Herman Batelaan and Akira Tono-mura (Physics Today, September 2009, page 38), we note with some dismay that the principal effect, that related to magnetic flux, continues to be attributed to its re-discoverers rather than to the original discoverers. Batelaan and Tonomura write, “The AB effect was already implicit in the 1926 Schrödinger equation, but it would be another three decades before theorists Yakir Aharonov and David Bohm pointed it out.” 1 1. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 115, 485 (1959). That is incorrect: It took only two decades before the effect was pointed out, not by Aharonov and Bohm but by Werner Ehrenberg and Raymond “Rory” Siday. 2 2. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Aharonov and Bohm cited that prior publication in their second article. 3 3. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 123, 1511(1961). According to Bohm’s biographer F. David Peat, “After their first paper had been published, Bohm learned that the effect had already been postulated by a maverick physicist called Rory E. Siday.” 4 4. F. D. Peat, Infinite Potential: The Life and Times of David Bohm, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA (1997), p. It seems curious that the biographer should use the term “postulated” rather than “proposed” and that he should comment on Siday’s personality but not on Ehrenberg’s. One of us (Sturrock) knew them both: Raymond was very smart but somewhat brash; Werner was erudite and a model of propriety, who would never have subscribed his name to an article unless he was convinced it was correct.It seems that the main scientific, rather than sociological, reason that the AB proposal was taken more seriously than the ES proposal is that the former was presented in the context of quantum mechanics, the latter in the context of electron optics. Aharonov and Bohm made a rapid transition from quantum mechanics to wave theory. Ehrenberg and Siday made a more detailed transition from geometrical optics to wave theory. For the case of magnetic flux, the two articles presented identical theoretical predictions. Our view is that the ES article was tedious but conceptually sound, whereas the AB article was lively but involved a questionable conceptual leap—namely, a relativistic generalization based on a noncovariant analysis. Soon after Sturrock arrived at Stanford University in 1955, and before the Aharonov-Bohm publication, he asked Leonard Schiff, Stanford’s quantum mechanics expert, whether Schiff found the Ehrenberg-Siday proposal convincing. He did.In the interests of accuracy and of giving credit where credit is due, we think it would be appropriate to use “Ehrenberg-Siday effect” for the case of magnetic interference and to reserve “Aharonov-Bohm effect” for electrical interference.We are indebted to Elliott Bloom, Dieter Kern, Walt Harrison, Peter Hawkes, Garret Moddel, Fabian Pease, Jeff Scargle, and Lenny Susskind for helpful discussions on this matter.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 115, 485 (1959). Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref3. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 123, 1511(1961). Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. F. D. Peat, Infinite Potential: The Life and Times of David Bohm, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA (1997), p. Google Scholar© 2010 American Institute of Physics.
Physics Today • Apr 1, 2010• 7 citations
BCS-to-BEC evolution details
D. M. Eagles
Again an article in Physics Today, (by Carlos Sá de melo October 2008, page 45), has incorrectly implied that Anthony Leggett was the first person to study the crossover from Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer to Bose–Einstein condensation. On page 47 of the article, it states that “a clear picture of the BCS-to-BEC evolution at zero temperature didn’t emerge until 1980, when Anthony Leggett realized that the physics could be captured by a simple description in real space of paired fermions with opposite spins.” Although the model I considered in my 1969 paper 1 1. D. M. Eagles, Phys. Rev. 186, 456 (1969). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.186.456 is slightly different from Leggett’s, figure 4 in my paper clearly shows regions where pairing without superconductivity occurs and where superconductivity is limited by the Bose- condensation temperature of pairs, and on page 458 I discuss a limit at which the diameter of pairs is small compared with the distance between them.I also disagree with a statement in the box on page 47 of Sá de Melo’s article that “the evolution from a Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer superfluid to a Bose–Einstein condensation superfluid cannot be studied in … superconductors.” At least in ceramic samples of SrTiO3 with 3% of the titanium replaced by zirconium, the transition has been studied by varying the carrier concentration via differing heat treatments to produce different concentrations of oxygen vacancies. 2 2. R. J. Tainsh, C. Andrikidis, Solid State Commun. 60, 517 (1986) https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-1098(86)90729-5 D. M. Eagles, Solid State Commun. 60, 521 (1986) https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-1098(86)90730-1 D. M. Eagles, R. J. Tainsh, C. Andrikidis, Physica C 157, 48 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1016/0921-4534(89)90466-8 It is possible that such a transition may be found in other superconducting semiconductors when people start to search for suitable materials. However, in three dimensions the pairing strength has to be above some threshold value to obtain the possibility of reaching the Bose-gas regime. Also, many authors think that the BEC regime occurs in underdoped cuprates, 3,4 3. Q. Chen, J. Stajic, S. Tan, K. Levin, Phys. Rep. 412, 1 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2005.02.005 4. A. S. Alexandrov, J. Supercond. Nov. Magn. 20, 481 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10948-007-0258-z while the consensus is that overdoped samples are BCS-like.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. D. M. Eagles, Phys. Rev. 186, 456 (1969). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.186.456 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. R. J. Tainsh, C. Andrikidis, Solid State Commun. 60, 517 (1986) https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-1098(86)90729-5 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI D. M. Eagles, Solid State Commun. 60, 521 (1986) https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-1098(86)90730-1 , , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI D. M. Eagles, R. J. Tainsh, C. Andrikidis, Physica C 157, 48 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1016/0921-4534(89)90466-8 , , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. Q. Chen, J. Stajic, S. Tan, K. Levin, Phys. Rep. 412, 1 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2005.02.005 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. A. S. Alexandrov, J. Supercond. Nov. Magn. 20, 481 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10948-007-0258-z , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2009 American Institute of Physics.
Physics Today • Jul 31, 2009• 3 citations
Trapping molecules for quantum chemistry
Mark G. Raizen
The Search and Discovery piece by Ashley Smart in the April 2017 issue of Physics Today (page 18) reported the excellent work on magnetic stopping and trapping of methyl radicals by the group of Takamasa Momose (University of British Columbia). I am writing to provide a different perspective on the field than what was conveyed by the author. The very first sentence of Smart’s article brings up a whole discussion: “By and large, physicists have succeeded in their quest to tame the atom.”The past few decades have seen remarkable advances in the ability to control and cool atoms in the gas phase. Those advances have been enabled by laser-cooling, which produces ultracold atomic gases. The atoms are then further cooled by evaporation to create quantum degenerate gases. However, those methods are far from ideal, even for atoms.Laser cooling is not a general method. Due to the requirements of a cycling transition and available lasers, it works on only a small set of elements in the periodic table. Evaporative cooling requires the right balance between elastic and inelastic collisions, again severely limiting generality. Furthermore, evaporative cooling leads to a large loss of atoms. For the alkalis, the optimum cases for laser cooling and evaporative cooling, the flux of ultracold atoms has been limited by optical density to around 109 atoms per second.It is natural to ask whether one can invent new methods that work on most elements and that break the current limit on flux. Such a development would open many new possibilities for fundamental science and for real-life applications. The challenges and limitations have motivated several groups to explore alternative approaches. One method is buffer-gas cooling, pioneered by John Doyle at Harvard University.11. J. M. Doyle et al., Phys. Rev. A 52, R2515 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.52.R2515 A different approach was developed independently and in parallel by Frédéric Merkt and his group at ETH Zürich and by my group at the University of Texas at Austin: magnetic stopping and trapping of paramagnetic atoms in a supersonic beam.22. S. D. Hogan et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 143001 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.101.143001,33. E. Narevicius et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 093003 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.100.093003 That work was summarized in an invited review article I wrote for Science.44. M. G. Raizen, Science 324, 1403 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1171506 Since then, many new developments have continued to advance the field.Now that the first sentence of the Search and Discovery piece is out of the way, I can discuss the rest—in particular, the motivation of studying quantum chemistry and the question of whether one actually needs to trap molecules. The goal of studying chemical reactions at ultralow temperatures is to observe unique quantum pathways that can dominate the reaction dynamics. Until recently it has been an elusive goal. Stopping and trapping molecules, either by electrostatic or magnetic forces, has produced a phase-space density that is too low for the study of chemical reactions. Molecules at much higher phase-space density can be produced by starting with Bose–Einstein condensates and “making” molecules with lasers. However, those experiments have so far been limited to alkali chemistry.Work by the Narevicius group at the Weizmann Institute of Science in Israel provided a major breakthrough in quantum chemistry without the need for stopping and trapping. Their approach relies on the merging of two supersonic beams by magnetically deflecting one of them.55. A. B. Henson et al., Science 338, 234 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1229141 The copropagating beams have controllable collision energies down to temperatures of several millikelvin. The resulting chemical reactions, observed as a function of energy, reveal striking quantum resonances in the reaction dynamics. That work is continuing, and it demonstrates the power of merged beams, which do not require trapping and cooling. To study slower chemical reactions, trapping at high phase-space density is necessary. New ideas and work along those lines are in progress and will hopefully prove successful.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. J. M. Doyle et al., Phys. Rev. A 52, R2515 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.52.R2515, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. S. D. Hogan et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 143001 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.101.143001, Google ScholarCrossref3. E. Narevicius et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 093003 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.100.093003, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. M. G. Raizen, Science 324, 1403 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1171506, Google ScholarCrossref5. A. B. Henson et al., Science 338, 234 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1229141, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2017 American Institute of Physics.
Physics Today • Dec 1, 2017• 1 citation
In her article “The demons haunting thermodynamics” (Physics Today, November 2021, page 44), Katie Robertson concludes the introductory historical summary by saying that modern developments in quantum foundations have banished the demons “once and for all.” Unfortunately, no explanation or reference is given for that optimistic but controversial conclusion.Robertson presents Erwin Hahn’s 1950 spin-echo experiments11. E. L. Hahn, Phys. Rev. 80, 580 (1950).
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.80.580 as the realization of Josef Loschmidt’s vision of reversing momentum. But Hahn clearly described his spin-echo experiments as the effect of traditional spin dynamics for noninteracting spins in a spatially inhomogeneous magnetic field. Although the detailed explanation involves many particular subtleties of NMR dynamics in liquids, Hahn’s interpretation does not imply any violation of the “second law”; it uses only the mild assumption that the spin observables are at thermal equilibrium before each start signal. Robertson’s misunderstanding clearly appears when she writes that “atomic spins that have dephased and become disordered are taken back to their earlier state by an RF pulse” and, a few lines later, “it turns out that the spin-echo experiment is a special case; most systems approach equilibrium instead of retracing their steps back to nonequilibrium states.” The spins have not become disordered: The phase of each spin remains directly related to the magnetic field at the spin’s location, and that relationship explains the echo.Two illuminating articles by Won-Kyu Rhim, Alexander Pines, and John Waugh describe spin-echo experiments in which the irreversible time evolution of a coupled nuclear spin system in solids is apparently “reversed” for a limited duration.22. W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 218 (1970);
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.25.218W.-K . Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. B 3, 684 (1971).
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.3.684 As the authors explain, the results arise from uniform spin manipulation and are still consistent with the laws of thermodynamics.Another aspect of Robertson’s article that disturbed me is the lack of discussion of the relations between the actual experiments performed on large (macroscopic) systems and the microscopic-scale models used in attempts to make predictions about those results.Consider a mixture of oxygen and hydrogen at atmospheric pressure and room temperature. Standard thermodynamics and statistical mechanics will lead to excellent predictions of the equation of state, specific heat, and the like. But the standard models ignore the possibility of the chemical reaction producing water. Improved models are needed if one is to allow for, say, a slow, isothermal catalytic reaction or—much more complicated—an explosion in an isolated system at constant volume. Spin systems offer a rich variety of experimental possibilities for external manipulation and observation, but the corresponding models are related to the real experimental situations by complicated transformations and approximations that must be chosen according to the situation under study.Robertson invokes two models in the context of Maxwell’s demon. One is a biological machine using a ratchet-style mechanism. But in the cited article, the abstract carefully indicates that the evolution does not violate the second law because the microscopic mechanism is coupled to the exterior of the system.33. V. Serreli et al., Nature 445, 523 (2007).
https://doi.org/10.1038/nature05452 In the demon-style experiment of Robertson’s figure 3, a complete realistic discussion of an actual implementation of the experiment leads to the similar conclusion that the second law is not violated.My conclusion is that demons and the related controversies are features of models and that the interpretation of actual experiments should be subjected to critical examination, preferably by those who performed the experiment and have a complete knowledge of all details.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. E. L. Hahn, Phys. Rev. 80, 580 (1950).
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.80.580 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. W.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 218 (1970);
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.25.218 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISIW.-K. Rhim, A. Pines, J. S. Waugh, Phys. Rev. B 3, 684 (1971).
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.3.684 , , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. V. Serreli et al., Nature 445, 523 (2007).
https://doi.org/10.1038/nature05452 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2023 American Institute of Physics.
Anatoly Svidzinsky, Marlan Scully, and Dudley Herschbach have illustrated well how the molecular theory might have looked had quantum mechanics not been invented. It’s worth noting that Niels Bohr was not alone in his attempts to extend semiclassical mechanics to systems more complex than the hydrogen atom. From 1913 to 1925, many semiclassical models of two-electron systems were proposed.As we see from the authors’ figure 3a, Bohr assumed that electrons in hydrogen molecules move around the molecular axis out of phase. It is a remarkable fact that Werner Heisenberg put forward in 1922 a two-electron atomic model that had electrons moving similarly out of phase and that ascribed a fractional quantum number (½) to the bending mode of the configuration.11. G. Tanner, K. Richter, J.-M. Rost, Rev. Mod. Phys. 72, 497 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.72.497 Although Heisenberg’s model predicted the ground-state helium level, which was in excellent agreement with the spectroscopic data, Bohr opposed the model, since a noninteger quantum number was considered sacrilege. For the same reason, Bohr never published his own results. However, the asynchronous two-electron atomic model turned out to be the fertile one, though the corresponding classical configurations can have very complex structure.22. P. Grujic, N. Simonovic, J. Phys. B 28, 1159 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1088/0953-4075/28/7/011REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. G. Tanner, K. Richter, J.-M. Rost, Rev. Mod. Phys. 72, 497 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.72.497, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. P. Grujic, N. Simonovic, J. Phys. B 28, 1159 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1088/0953-4075/28/7/011, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2014 American Institute of Physics.
Having read “The Aharonov-Bohm Effects: Variations on a Subtle Theme” by Herman Batelaan and Akira Tono-mura (Physics Today, September 2009, page 38), we note with some dismay that the principal effect, that related to magnetic flux, continues to be attributed to its re-discoverers rather than to the original discoverers. Batelaan and Tonomura write, “The AB effect was already implicit in the 1926 Schrödinger equation, but it would be another three decades before theorists Yakir Aharonov and David Bohm pointed it out.” 1 1. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 115, 485 (1959). That is incorrect: It took only two decades before the effect was pointed out, not by Aharonov and Bohm but by Werner Ehrenberg and Raymond “Rory” Siday. 2 2. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Aharonov and Bohm cited that prior publication in their second article. 3 3. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 123, 1511(1961). According to Bohm’s biographer F. David Peat, “After their first paper had been published, Bohm learned that the effect had already been postulated by a maverick physicist called Rory E. Siday.” 4 4. F. D. Peat, Infinite Potential: The Life and Times of David Bohm, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA (1997), p. It seems curious that the biographer should use the term “postulated” rather than “proposed” and that he should comment on Siday’s personality but not on Ehrenberg’s. One of us (Sturrock) knew them both: Raymond was very smart but somewhat brash; Werner was erudite and a model of propriety, who would never have subscribed his name to an article unless he was convinced it was correct.It seems that the main scientific, rather than sociological, reason that the AB proposal was taken more seriously than the ES proposal is that the former was presented in the context of quantum mechanics, the latter in the context of electron optics. Aharonov and Bohm made a rapid transition from quantum mechanics to wave theory. Ehrenberg and Siday made a more detailed transition from geometrical optics to wave theory. For the case of magnetic flux, the two articles presented identical theoretical predictions. Our view is that the ES article was tedious but conceptually sound, whereas the AB article was lively but involved a questionable conceptual leap—namely, a relativistic generalization based on a noncovariant analysis. Soon after Sturrock arrived at Stanford University in 1955, and before the Aharonov-Bohm publication, he asked Leonard Schiff, Stanford’s quantum mechanics expert, whether Schiff found the Ehrenberg-Siday proposal convincing. He did.In the interests of accuracy and of giving credit where credit is due, we think it would be appropriate to use “Ehrenberg-Siday effect” for the case of magnetic interference and to reserve “Aharonov-Bohm effect” for electrical interference.We are indebted to Elliott Bloom, Dieter Kern, Walt Harrison, Peter Hawkes, Garret Moddel, Fabian Pease, Jeff Scargle, and Lenny Susskind for helpful discussions on this matter.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 115, 485 (1959). Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref3. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 123, 1511(1961). Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. F. D. Peat, Infinite Potential: The Life and Times of David Bohm, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA (1997), p. Google Scholar© 2010 American Institute of Physics.
Again an article in Physics Today, (by Carlos Sá de melo October 2008, page 45), has incorrectly implied that Anthony Leggett was the first person to study the crossover from Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer to Bose–Einstein condensation. On page 47 of the article, it states that “a clear picture of the BCS-to-BEC evolution at zero temperature didn’t emerge until 1980, when Anthony Leggett realized that the physics could be captured by a simple description in real space of paired fermions with opposite spins.” Although the model I considered in my 1969 paper 1 1. D. M. Eagles, Phys. Rev. 186, 456 (1969). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.186.456 is slightly different from Leggett’s, figure 4 in my paper clearly shows regions where pairing without superconductivity occurs and where superconductivity is limited by the Bose- condensation temperature of pairs, and on page 458 I discuss a limit at which the diameter of pairs is small compared with the distance between them.I also disagree with a statement in the box on page 47 of Sá de Melo’s article that “the evolution from a Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer superfluid to a Bose–Einstein condensation superfluid cannot be studied in … superconductors.” At least in ceramic samples of SrTiO3 with 3% of the titanium replaced by zirconium, the transition has been studied by varying the carrier concentration via differing heat treatments to produce different concentrations of oxygen vacancies. 2 2. R. J. Tainsh, C. Andrikidis, Solid State Commun. 60, 517 (1986) https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-1098(86)90729-5 D. M. Eagles, Solid State Commun. 60, 521 (1986) https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-1098(86)90730-1 D. M. Eagles, R. J. Tainsh, C. Andrikidis, Physica C 157, 48 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1016/0921-4534(89)90466-8 It is possible that such a transition may be found in other superconducting semiconductors when people start to search for suitable materials. However, in three dimensions the pairing strength has to be above some threshold value to obtain the possibility of reaching the Bose-gas regime. Also, many authors think that the BEC regime occurs in underdoped cuprates, 3,4 3. Q. Chen, J. Stajic, S. Tan, K. Levin, Phys. Rep. 412, 1 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2005.02.005 4. A. S. Alexandrov, J. Supercond. Nov. Magn. 20, 481 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10948-007-0258-z while the consensus is that overdoped samples are BCS-like.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. D. M. Eagles, Phys. Rev. 186, 456 (1969). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.186.456 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. R. J. Tainsh, C. Andrikidis, Solid State Commun. 60, 517 (1986) https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-1098(86)90729-5 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI D. M. Eagles, Solid State Commun. 60, 521 (1986) https://doi.org/10.1016/0038-1098(86)90730-1 , , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI D. M. Eagles, R. J. Tainsh, C. Andrikidis, Physica C 157, 48 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1016/0921-4534(89)90466-8 , , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. Q. Chen, J. Stajic, S. Tan, K. Levin, Phys. Rep. 412, 1 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2005.02.005 , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. A. S. Alexandrov, J. Supercond. Nov. Magn. 20, 481 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10948-007-0258-z , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2009 American Institute of Physics.
Abstract The spin echo [1] is still striking to those who see it for the first time, as it probably was to Hahn. A nuclear magnetization, having disappeared in a free induction decay (FID), spontaneously reappears as a giant fluctuation. While the phenomenon is easily understood from a mechanical point of view, it seems to verge on a violation of the second law of thermodynamics. It is this problem, about which Hahn [2] and others [3] have written, that we approach here again from what is at least partly a fresh perspective. Our point of view will be that echoesdo violate the second law. After having defended this case we will discuss briefly how the problem can be avoided by appropriate statement of purely macroscopic thermodynamic principles.
The Search and Discovery piece by Ashley Smart in the April 2017 issue of Physics Today (page 18) reported the excellent work on magnetic stopping and trapping of methyl radicals by the group of Takamasa Momose (University of British Columbia). I am writing to provide a different perspective on the field than what was conveyed by the author. The very first sentence of Smart’s article brings up a whole discussion: “By and large, physicists have succeeded in their quest to tame the atom.”The past few decades have seen remarkable advances in the ability to control and cool atoms in the gas phase. Those advances have been enabled by laser-cooling, which produces ultracold atomic gases. The atoms are then further cooled by evaporation to create quantum degenerate gases. However, those methods are far from ideal, even for atoms.Laser cooling is not a general method. Due to the requirements of a cycling transition and available lasers, it works on only a small set of elements in the periodic table. Evaporative cooling requires the right balance between elastic and inelastic collisions, again severely limiting generality. Furthermore, evaporative cooling leads to a large loss of atoms. For the alkalis, the optimum cases for laser cooling and evaporative cooling, the flux of ultracold atoms has been limited by optical density to around 109 atoms per second.It is natural to ask whether one can invent new methods that work on most elements and that break the current limit on flux. Such a development would open many new possibilities for fundamental science and for real-life applications. The challenges and limitations have motivated several groups to explore alternative approaches. One method is buffer-gas cooling, pioneered by John Doyle at Harvard University.11. J. M. Doyle et al., Phys. Rev. A 52, R2515 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.52.R2515 A different approach was developed independently and in parallel by Frédéric Merkt and his group at ETH Zürich and by my group at the University of Texas at Austin: magnetic stopping and trapping of paramagnetic atoms in a supersonic beam.22. S. D. Hogan et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 143001 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.101.143001,33. E. Narevicius et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 093003 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.100.093003 That work was summarized in an invited review article I wrote for Science.44. M. G. Raizen, Science 324, 1403 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1171506 Since then, many new developments have continued to advance the field.Now that the first sentence of the Search and Discovery piece is out of the way, I can discuss the rest—in particular, the motivation of studying quantum chemistry and the question of whether one actually needs to trap molecules. The goal of studying chemical reactions at ultralow temperatures is to observe unique quantum pathways that can dominate the reaction dynamics. Until recently it has been an elusive goal. Stopping and trapping molecules, either by electrostatic or magnetic forces, has produced a phase-space density that is too low for the study of chemical reactions. Molecules at much higher phase-space density can be produced by starting with Bose–Einstein condensates and “making” molecules with lasers. However, those experiments have so far been limited to alkali chemistry.Work by the Narevicius group at the Weizmann Institute of Science in Israel provided a major breakthrough in quantum chemistry without the need for stopping and trapping. Their approach relies on the merging of two supersonic beams by magnetically deflecting one of them.55. A. B. Henson et al., Science 338, 234 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1229141 The copropagating beams have controllable collision energies down to temperatures of several millikelvin. The resulting chemical reactions, observed as a function of energy, reveal striking quantum resonances in the reaction dynamics. That work is continuing, and it demonstrates the power of merged beams, which do not require trapping and cooling. To study slower chemical reactions, trapping at high phase-space density is necessary. New ideas and work along those lines are in progress and will hopefully prove successful.ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. J. M. Doyle et al., Phys. Rev. A 52, R2515 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.52.R2515, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. S. D. Hogan et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 143001 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.101.143001, Google ScholarCrossref3. E. Narevicius et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 093003 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.100.093003, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. M. G. Raizen, Science 324, 1403 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1171506, Google ScholarCrossref5. A. B. Henson et al., Science 338, 234 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1229141, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2017 American Institute of Physics.