The rate-equation approximation is one of the most fundamental and universally employed simplifications in laser analyses. The accuracy and regions of applicability of this approximation are explored in comparisons with more rigorous semiclassical models. Higher-order rate-equation approximations are also developed, and these improved models can yield much better accuracy than conventional rate equations with little added complexity. The modified adiabatic elimination methods reported here would also be useful in reducing the mathematical models governing other physical systems.
I classify multiphoton absorption into separable, linked, and simultaneous processes. The first and second types can be distinguished when the rate-equation approximation is valid whereas the third type refers to the case when the full description of multiphoton absorption is essential. For this purpose, rate equations are solved analytically without decay processes which shows that even if many photons are absorbed the interaction with the light field is linear and one has the case of separable multiphoton absorption. Next a short-pulse approximation is investigated in which I first solve the rate equations without decay processes and then solve only rate equations for the ensuing decay. Finally, the full rate equations are examined and a successive approximation of the underlying Volterra integral equation of the second kind is derived leading to linked multiphoton absorption by the involved decay widths. The three methods are applied to a nitrogen atom in intense and ultrafast x rays from free-electron lasers (FELs). The linearity theorem barely approximates the results in the presence of decay processes which is also not satisfactorily corrected for by the short-pulse approximation. The successive approximation gives excellent agreement with the numerically-exact solution of the rate equations.