The Heisenberg limit to laser coherence C-the number of photons in the maximally populated mode of the laser beam-is the fourth power of the number of excitations inside the laser. We generalize the previous proof of this upper bound scaling by dropping the requirement that the beam photon statistics be Poissonian (i.e., Mandel's Q=0). We then show that the relation between C and sub-Poissonianity (Q<0) is win-win, not a tradeoff. For both regular (non-Markovian) pumping with semiunitary gain (which allows Q→-1), and random (Markovian) pumping with optimized gain, C is maximized when Q is minimized.
Recently it has been shown that it is possible for a laser to produce a stationary beam with a coherence (quantified as the mean photon number at spectral peak) which scales as the fourth power of the mean number of excitations stored within the laser, this being quadratically larger than the standard or Schawlow-Townes limit [Baker et al., Nat. Phys. 17, 179 (2021)]. Moreover, this was analytically proven to be the ultimate quantum limit (Heisenberg limit) scaling under defining conditions for CW lasers, plus a strong assumption about the properties of the output beam. In our related work [Ostrowski et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 183602 (2023)] we show that the latter can be replaced by a weaker assumption, which allows for highly sub-Poissonian output beams, without changing the upper bound scaling or its achievability. In this paper we provide details of the calculations given in our related paper and introduce three families of laser models which may be considered as generalizations of those presented in that work. Each of these families of laser models is parameterized by a real number,
p, with
p=4 corresponding to the original models. The parameter space of these laser families is numerically investigated in detail, where we explore the influence of these parameters on both the coherence and photon statistics of the laser beams. Two distinct regimes for the coherence may be identified based on the choice of
p, where for
p>3, each family of models exhibits Heisenberg-limited beam coherence, while for
p<3, the Heisenberg limit is no longer attained. Moreover, in the former regime, we derive formulas for the beam coherence of each of these three laser families which agree with the numerics. We find that the optimal parameter is in fact $p\ensuremath{\approx}4.15$, not
p=4.
Recent advances in laser theory have demonstrated that a quantum enhancement is possible for the production of coherence
C by a continuous-wave laser device. Curiously, natural families of laser models that achieve Heisenberg-limited scaling for coherence produce the most coherence when the beam exhibits sub-Poissonian photon statistics. In this work, we provide an analytical treatment of those novel families of laser models by specializing to a parameter regime that permits a linearization. We characterize the dynamics of each laser system, and find that some of the intuitions from standard laser theory may be applied here. Specifically, the intracavity number dynamics are well-described as an Ornstein-Uhlenbeck process, while the intracavity phase dynamics are well-described in terms of a physically realizable ensemble of pure states, which evolve according to pure phase diffusion. Unlike a standard laser, however, we find that the pure states comprising the ensemble in the Heisenberg-limited lasers are substantially phase squeezed. From our dynamical analysis, we deduce various quantities of the beam for each laser family, including the first- and second-order Glauber coherence functions, intensity noise spectrum, Mandel-Q parameter and coherence
C. In addition, inspired from these phase diffusion dynamics, we derive an upper bound on laser coherence
C≲1.1156μ4 -- which is tighter by a factor of
3/8 when compared to that derived in [Baker et al., Nat. Phys. 17 179 (2021)] -- by making one of the assumptions of that paper slightly stronger.
If a beam of light is coherent, then the photons constituting the beam arrive at random moments in time. Consequently, the photon counting statistics in a given time interval below the coherence time, should in theory follow a Poissonian distribution. When the measurement interval exceeds the coherence time, the distribution should broaden and become a super-Poissonian distribution. The aim of this study is to experimentally demonstrate the Poissonian nature of light, as well as quantifying the transition to a super-Poissonian distribution. In the experiment, a low-intensity laser beam was measured with single-photon detectors, able to capture individual photons. The arrival time of the photons was detected with an oscilloscope, and the data further analysed with our own Python code. The probability distribution of the arrival time of photons was constructed and fitted with a Poissonian distribution for different time intervals. The results showed a clear Poissonian distribution for all intervals from 0.2 μs up to 2000 μs. We did however, observe tendencies of randomness for the longest measured intervals. A Poissonian distribution is defined by the variance being equal to the mean, whilst for a super-Poissonian distribution the variance is higher. The biggest measured ratio between the variance and the mean in our experiment was 1.06 for interval time 2000 μs, which is too small to infer super-Poissonian. Due to limited data memory, our dataset was restricted in length and resolution. Therefore, longer intervals could not be studied without statistical uncertainty. To cross-check the result we also calculated the probability distribution for the arrival time itself. The result perfectly fitted an exponential distribution which was in accordance with the theory of coherent light. Hence, within the given measurement accuracy and statistical uncertainty, it is safe to conclude that the laser beam is coherent for all tested time intervals. However, this does not allow us to conclude that it is a single-mode laser.
Photon anti-bunching, measured via the Hanbury-Brown-Twiss experiment, is one of the key signatures of quantum light and is tied to sub-Poissonian photon number statistics. Recently, it has been reported that photon anti-bunching or conditional sub-Poissonian photon number statistics can be obtained via second-order interference of mutually incoherent weak lasers and heralding based on photon counting [Phys. Rev. A92, 033855 (2015)10.1103/PhysRevA.92.033855; Opt. Express24, 19574 (2016)10.1364/OE.24.019574; https://arxiv.org/abs/1601.08161]. Here, we report theoretical analysis on the limits of manipulating conditional photon statistics via interference of weak lasers. It is shown that conditional photon number statistics can become super-Poissonian in such a scheme. We, however, demonstrate explicitly that it cannot become sub-Poissonian, i.e., photon anti-bunching cannot be obtained in such a scheme. We point out that incorrect results can be obtained if one does not properly account for seemingly negligible higher-order photon number expansions of the coherent state.