Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics

VACSEN : A V isualization A pproa c h for Noi s e Awaren e ss in Qua n tum Computing

Shaolun Ruan, Yong Wang, Weiwen Jiang, Ying Mao, Qiang Guan

Published Sep 27, 2022• 21 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum computing has attracted considerable public attention due to its exponential speedup over classical computing. Despite its advantages, today's quantum computers intrinsically suffer from noise and are error-prone. To guarantee the high fidelity of the execution result of a quantum algorithm, it is crucial to inform users of the noises of the used quantum computer and the compiled physical circuits. However, an intuitive and systematic way to make users aware of the quantum computing noise is still missing. In this paper, we fill the gap by proposing a novel visualization approach to achieve noise-aware quantum computing. It provides a holistic picture of the noise of quantum computing through multiple interactively coordinated views: a Computer Evolution View with a circuit-like design overviews the temporal evolution of the noises of different quantum computers, a Circuit Filtering View facilitates quick filtering of multiple compiled physical circuits for the same quantum algorithm, and a Circuit Comparison View with a coupled bar chart enables detailed comparison of the filtered compiled circuits. We extensively evaluate the performance of VACSEN through two case studies on quantum algorithms of different scales and in-depth interviews with 12 quantum computing users. The results demonstrate the effectiveness and usability of VACSEN in achieving noise-aware quantum computing.

DOI
10.1109/tvcg.2022.3209455

Related papers

VACSEN: A Visualization Approach for Noise Awareness in Quantum Computing

Shaolun Ruan, Yong Wang, Weiwen Jiang +2 more

Quantum computing has attracted considerable public attention due to its exponential speedup over classical computing. Despite its advantages, today's quantum computers intrinsically suffer from noise and are error-prone. To guarantee the high fidelity of the execution result of a quantum algorithm, it is crucial to inform users of the noises of the used quantum computer and the compiled physical circuits. However, an intuitive and systematic way to make users aware of the quantum computing noise is still missing. In this paper, we fill the gap by proposing a novel visualization approach to achieve noise-aware quantum computing. It provides a holistic picture of the noise of quantum computing through multiple interactively coordinated views: a Computer Evolution View with a circuit-like design overviews the temporal evolution of the noises of different quantum computers, a Circuit Filtering View facilitates quick filtering of multiple compiled physical circuits for the same quantum algorithm, and a Circuit Comparison View with a coupled bar chart enables detailed comparison of the filtered compiled circuits. We extensively evaluate the performance of VACSEN through two case studies on quantum algorithms of different scales and an in-depth interviews with 12 quantum computing users. The results demonstrate the effectiveness and usability of VACSEN in achieving noise-aware quantum computing.

arXiv:2207.14135•Jul 28, 2022•4 citations

Visual analytics for interpretable quantum computing

Shaolun Ruan

Quantum computing has entered a stage of increasing practicality. Many quantum hardware vendors such as IBM, Rigetti, Honeywell, and IonQ now enable experiments on real devices in the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. These platforms show computational advantages in domains such as optimization, machine learning, and materials science. However, they remain limited by hardware noise and the absence of human-interpretable information. Existing visual metaphors, such as the Bloch Sphere for single-qubit states or circuit schematics for algorithm design, struggle to convey multi-qubit entanglement or measurement probabilities in ways accessible to human reasoning. Likewise, the rise of variational quantum circuits and quantum neural networks (QNNs) introduces new layers of opacity: how data are encoded into quantum states and how parameters evolve through training remain largely under-explored. These challenges motivate a need for visual explanation frameworks that unveil the invisible processes of quantum computing visible, interpretable, and reasonable.To address these challenges, this dissertation presents a coherent sequence of visual analytics systems that progressively enhance explainability across the hardware, state, circuit, and model layers of quantum computing. First, VACSEN supports noise-aware execution by visually correlating hardware fidelity metrics with compiled quantum circuits, allowing users to identify unstable qubits, track temporal noise evolution, and select optimal execution strategies. Second, VENUS introduces a geometric representation for quantum state visualization, combining right triangles and semicircles to jointly encode amplitude and probability information, thereby enabling intuitive exploration of superposition and entanglement beyond the traditional Bloch Sphere. Third, QuantumEyes extends interpretability to quantum circuit behavior, integrating coordinated views to reveal how quantum gates transform amplitudes and probabilities during algorithm execution (e.g., Grover’s search or the Quantum Fourier Transform). Finally, VIOLET applies visual explainability to quantum neural networks, bridging concepts from explainable AI and quantum computing. It visualizes the encoding of classical data into quantum states, tracks parameter dynamics during variational training, and exposes learned features and measurement distributions, establishing the first end-to-end system for understanding QNNs.Each system was designed through iterative co-design with quantum computing experts and evaluated through case studies, task analyses, and in-depth interviews involving researchers and practitioners from academia and industry. Across evaluations, participants reported that visualization significantly enhanced their ability to reason about noise effects, understand quantum-state evolution, and interpret the learning behavior of QNNs. These findings demonstrate that visualization not only accelerates analysis and debugging but also strengthens conceptual understanding and user trust in quantum computing. To sum up, this dissertation establishes visualization

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

QuantumEyes: Towards Better Interpretability of Quantum Circuits

Shaolun Ruan, Qiang Guan, Paul Griffin +2 more

Quantum computing offers significant speedup compared to classical computing, which has led to a growing interest among users in learning and applying quantum computing across various applications. However, quantum circuits, which are fundamental for implementing quantum algorithms, can be challenging for users to understand due to their underlying logic, such as the temporal evolution of quantum states and the effect of quantum amplitudes on the probability of basis quantum states. To fill this research gap, we propose QuantumEyes, an interactive visual analytics system to enhance the interpretability of quantum circuits through both global and local levels. For the global-level analysis, we present three coupled visualizations to delineate the changes of quantum states and the underlying reasons: a Probability Summary View to overview the probability evolution of quantum states; a State Evolution View to enable an in-depth analysis of the influence of quantum gates on the quantum states; a Gate Explanation View to show the individual qubit states and facilitate a better understanding of the effect of quantum gates. For the local-level analysis, we design a novel geometrical visualization dandelion chart to explicitly reveal how the quantum amplitudes affect the probability of the quantum state. We thoroughly evaluated QuantumEyes as well as the novel dandelion chart integrated into it through two case studies on different types of quantum algorithms and in-depth expert interviews with 12 domain experts. The results demonstrate the effectiveness and usability of our approach in enhancing the interpretability of quantum circuits.

arXiv:2311.07980•IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics•Nov 15, 2023•12 citations

Noise-Aware Quantum Circuit Simulation With Decision Diagrams

Thomas Grurl, Jurgen Fus, Robert Wille

Since quantum computers can solve important problems faster than classical computers, many resources have gone into the development of this technology in recent decades. Despite the tremendous progress that has already been made toward the development of quantum computers, they are still an emerging technology, which restricts access and reliability. Thus, research on quantum algorithms still heavily relies on quantum circuit simulators that run on classical hardware. However, simulating the execution of a quantum computer on conventional hardware is exponentially difficult, which is also the reason why quantum computing is an interesting technology in the first place. Particularly complex is noise-aware simulation of quantum computers, i.e., the consideration of noise effects that are common in today’s quantum hardware during quantum circuit simulation. In this work, we investigate the use of decision diagrams for this task. To this end, we present two distinct approaches for noise-aware quantum circuit simulation, investigate how they can be realized using decision diagrams, and implement decision diagram-based solutions for each of the presented noise-aware simulation schemes. In an extensive evaluation, we unveil potential for further improvements and also demonstrate substantial speed-ups compared to the current state of the art.

IEEE Transactions on Computer-Aided Design of Integrated Circuits and Systems•Jun 13, 2022•23 citations

Quantum Image Visualizer: Visual Debugging of Quantum Image Processing Circuits

Anja Heim, Lang, Thomas, Alexander Gall +2 more

Quantum computing is an emerging field that utilizes the unique principles of quantum mechanics to offer significant advantages in algorithm execution over classical approaches. This potential is particularly promising in the domain of quantum image processing, which aims to manipulate all pixels simultaneously. However, the process of designing and verifying these algorithms remains a complex and error-prone task. To address this challenge, new methods are needed to support effective debugging of quantum circuits. The Quantum Image Visualizer is an interactive visual analysis tool that allows for the examination of quantum images and their transformation throughout quantum circuits. The framework incorporates two overview visualizations that trace image evolution across a sequence of gates based on the most probable outcomes. Interactive exploration allows users to focus on relevant gates, and select pixels of interest. Upon selection, detailed visualizations enable in-depth inspection of individual pixels and their probability distributions, revealing how specific gates influence the likelihood of pixel color values and the magnitude of these changes. An evaluation of the Quantum Image Visualizer was conducted through in-depth interviews with eight domain experts. The findings demonstrate the effectiveness and practical value of our approach in supporting visual debugging of quantum image processing circuits.

arXiv:2504.09902•Apr 14, 2025•0 citations

Interaction Techniques for User-Friendly Interfaces for Gate-Based Quantum Computing

Hyeok Kim, Kaitlin N. Smith

Quantum computers offer promising approaches to various fields. To use current noisy quantum computers, developers need to examine the compilation of a logical circuit, the status of available hardware, and noises in results. As those tasks are less common in classical computing, quantum developers may not be familiar with performing them. Therefore, easier and more intuitive interfaces are necessary to make quantum computers more approachable. While existing notebook-based toolkits like Qiskit offer application programming interfaces and visualization techniques, it is still difficult to navigate the vast space of quantum program design and hardware status. Inspired by human-computer interaction (HCI) work in data science and visualization, our work introduces four user interaction techniques that can augment existing notebook-based toolkits for gate-based quantum computing: (1) a circuit writer that lets users provide high-level information about a circuit and generates a code snippet to build it; (2) a machine explorer that provides detailed properties and configurations of a hardware with a code to load selected information; (3) a circuit viewer that allows for comparing logical circuit, compiled circuit, and hardware configurations; and (4) a visualization for adjusting measurement outcomes with hardware error rates.

arXiv:2409.16475•IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Sep 15, 2024•1 citation
Quantum computing has attracted considerable public attention due to its exponential speedup over classical computing. Despite its advantages, today's quantum computers intrinsically suffer from noise and are error-prone. To guarantee the high fidelity of the execution result of a quantum algorithm, it is crucial to inform users of the noises of the used quantum computer and the compiled physical circuits. However, an intuitive and systematic way to make users aware of the quantum computing noise is still missing. In this paper, we fill the gap by proposing a novel visualization approach to achieve noise-aware quantum computing. It provides a holistic picture of the noise of quantum computing through multiple interactively coordinated views: a Computer Evolution View with a circuit-like design overviews the temporal evolution of the noises of different quantum computers, a Circuit Filtering View facilitates quick filtering of multiple compiled physical circuits for the same quantum algorithm, and a Circuit Comparison View with a coupled bar chart enables detailed comparison of the filtered compiled circuits. We extensively evaluate the performance of VACSEN through two case studies on quantum algorithms of different scales and in-depth interviews with 12 quantum computing users. The results demonstrate the effectiveness and usability of VACSEN in achieving noise-aware quantum computing.
Quantum computing has attracted considerable public attention due to its exponential speedup over classical computing. Despite its advantages, today's quantum computers intrinsically suffer from noise and are error-prone. To guarantee the high fidelity of the execution result of a quantum algorithm, it is crucial to inform users of the noises of the used quantum computer and the compiled physical circuits. However, an intuitive and systematic way to make users aware of the quantum computing noise is still missing. In this paper, we fill the gap by proposing a novel visualization approach to achieve noise-aware quantum computing. It provides a holistic picture of the noise of quantum computing through multiple interactively coordinated views: a Computer Evolution View with a circuit-like design overviews the temporal evolution of the noises of different quantum computers, a Circuit Filtering View facilitates quick filtering of multiple compiled physical circuits for the same quantum algorithm, and a Circuit Comparison View with a coupled bar chart enables detailed comparison of the filtered compiled circuits. We extensively evaluate the performance of VACSEN through two case studies on quantum algorithms of different scales and an in-depth interviews with 12 quantum computing users. The results demonstrate the effectiveness and usability of VACSEN in achieving noise-aware quantum computing.
Quantum computing has entered a stage of increasing practicality. Many quantum hardware vendors such as IBM, Rigetti, Honeywell, and IonQ now enable experiments on real devices in the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. These platforms show computational advantages in domains such as optimization, machine learning, and materials science. However, they remain limited by hardware noise and the absence of human-interpretable information. Existing visual metaphors, such as the Bloch Sphere for single-qubit states or circuit schematics for algorithm design, struggle to convey multi-qubit entanglement or measurement probabilities in ways accessible to human reasoning. Likewise, the rise of variational quantum circuits and quantum neural networks (QNNs) introduces new layers of opacity: how data are encoded into quantum states and how parameters evolve through training remain largely under-explored. These challenges motivate a need for visual explanation frameworks that unveil the invisible processes of quantum computing visible, interpretable, and reasonable.To address these challenges, this dissertation presents a coherent sequence of visual analytics systems that progressively enhance explainability across the hardware, state, circuit, and model layers of quantum computing. First, VACSEN supports noise-aware execution by visually correlating hardware fidelity metrics with compiled quantum circuits, allowing users to identify unstable qubits, track temporal noise evolution, and select optimal execution strategies. Second, VENUS introduces a geometric representation for quantum state visualization, combining right triangles and semicircles to jointly encode amplitude and probability information, thereby enabling intuitive exploration of superposition and entanglement beyond the traditional Bloch Sphere. Third, QuantumEyes extends interpretability to quantum circuit behavior, integrating coordinated views to reveal how quantum gates transform amplitudes and probabilities during algorithm execution (e.g., Grover’s search or the Quantum Fourier Transform). Finally, VIOLET applies visual explainability to quantum neural networks, bridging concepts from explainable AI and quantum computing. It visualizes the encoding of classical data into quantum states, tracks parameter dynamics during variational training, and exposes learned features and measurement distributions, establishing the first end-to-end system for understanding QNNs.Each system was designed through iterative co-design with quantum computing experts and evaluated through case studies, task analyses, and in-depth interviews involving researchers and practitioners from academia and industry. Across evaluations, participants reported that visualization significantly enhanced their ability to reason about noise effects, understand quantum-state evolution, and interpret the learning behavior of QNNs. These findings demonstrate that visualization not only accelerates analysis and debugging but also strengthens conceptual understanding and user trust in quantum computing. To sum up, this dissertation establishes visualization
Quantum computing offers significant speedup compared to classical computing, which has led to a growing interest among users in learning and applying quantum computing across various applications. However, quantum circuits, which are fundamental for implementing quantum algorithms, can be challenging for users to understand due to their underlying logic, such as the temporal evolution of quantum states and the effect of quantum amplitudes on the probability of basis quantum states. To fill this research gap, we propose QuantumEyes, an interactive visual analytics system to enhance the interpretability of quantum circuits through both global and local levels. For the global-level analysis, we present three coupled visualizations to delineate the changes of quantum states and the underlying reasons: a Probability Summary View to overview the probability evolution of quantum states; a State Evolution View to enable an in-depth analysis of the influence of quantum gates on the quantum states; a Gate Explanation View to show the individual qubit states and facilitate a better understanding of the effect of quantum gates. For the local-level analysis, we design a novel geometrical visualization dandelion chart to explicitly reveal how the quantum amplitudes affect the probability of the quantum state. We thoroughly evaluated QuantumEyes as well as the novel dandelion chart integrated into it through two case studies on different types of quantum algorithms and in-depth expert interviews with 12 domain experts. The results demonstrate the effectiveness and usability of our approach in enhancing the interpretability of quantum circuits.
Since quantum computers can solve important problems faster than classical computers, many resources have gone into the development of this technology in recent decades. Despite the tremendous progress that has already been made toward the development of quantum computers, they are still an emerging technology, which restricts access and reliability. Thus, research on quantum algorithms still heavily relies on quantum circuit simulators that run on classical hardware. However, simulating the execution of a quantum computer on conventional hardware is exponentially difficult, which is also the reason why quantum computing is an interesting technology in the first place. Particularly complex is noise-aware simulation of quantum computers, i.e., the consideration of noise effects that are common in today’s quantum hardware during quantum circuit simulation. In this work, we investigate the use of decision diagrams for this task. To this end, we present two distinct approaches for noise-aware quantum circuit simulation, investigate how they can be realized using decision diagrams, and implement decision diagram-based solutions for each of the presented noise-aware simulation schemes. In an extensive evaluation, we unveil potential for further improvements and also demonstrate substantial speed-ups compared to the current state of the art.
Quantum computing is an emerging field that utilizes the unique principles of quantum mechanics to offer significant advantages in algorithm execution over classical approaches. This potential is particularly promising in the domain of quantum image processing, which aims to manipulate all pixels simultaneously. However, the process of designing and verifying these algorithms remains a complex and error-prone task. To address this challenge, new methods are needed to support effective debugging of quantum circuits. The Quantum Image Visualizer is an interactive visual analysis tool that allows for the examination of quantum images and their transformation throughout quantum circuits. The framework incorporates two overview visualizations that trace image evolution across a sequence of gates based on the most probable outcomes. Interactive exploration allows users to focus on relevant gates, and select pixels of interest. Upon selection, detailed visualizations enable in-depth inspection of individual pixels and their probability distributions, revealing how specific gates influence the likelihood of pixel color values and the magnitude of these changes. An evaluation of the Quantum Image Visualizer was conducted through in-depth interviews with eight domain experts. The findings demonstrate the effectiveness and practical value of our approach in supporting visual debugging of quantum image processing circuits.
Quantum computers offer promising approaches to various fields. To use current noisy quantum computers, developers need to examine the compilation of a logical circuit, the status of available hardware, and noises in results. As those tasks are less common in classical computing, quantum developers may not be familiar with performing them. Therefore, easier and more intuitive interfaces are necessary to make quantum computers more approachable. While existing notebook-based toolkits like Qiskit offer application programming interfaces and visualization techniques, it is still difficult to navigate the vast space of quantum program design and hardware status. Inspired by human-computer interaction (HCI) work in data science and visualization, our work introduces four user interaction techniques that can augment existing notebook-based toolkits for gate-based quantum computing: (1) a circuit writer that lets users provide high-level information about a circuit and generates a code snippet to build it; (2) a machine explorer that provides detailed properties and configurations of a hardware with a code to load selected information; (3) a circuit viewer that allows for comparing logical circuit, compiled circuit, and hardware configurations; and (4) a visualization for adjusting measurement outcomes with hardware error rates.