Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Consequences of X-Time Independence Within a Quantum Wavelength

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Published Nov 29, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We have argued in previous notes (1) that x and t are independent within a wavelength. This we will argue follows from special relativity applied to uniform motion i.e. -Et+px. In particular, v=x/t on average, not dx/dt, a mathematical abstraction which breaks down within the wavelength, because one cannot follow the particle in time. We argue that the notion of independent x and t within a wavelength implies a probability distribution of x i.e F(p,x) = the probability to find the particle with momentum p at x. From special relativity we suggest that E is associated with t and so an E(x) suggests also a t(x). (In fact, for KE(x), there is an associated time at each x, but for KE(x)+V(x)=E all x are the same and there is no need for a distinguishing variable time.) What about the spatial distribution F(p,x)? For a free particle F(p,x) is a function of x, but one which must map into a P(x)=constant. (For a bound state there is a spatial distribution and so the idea of time should exist in that a particle spends “more time” in a high probability region. This is linked to the idea of a p(rms) or velocity(rms)). Even for a bound quantum state we argue that for x and t to be independent, E must be constant at each x. One may argue that a constant E with a p(x) and an introduced V(x) is already present in special relativity i.e. (E-V(x))(E-V(x)) = pp + momo (c=1) which it is, but we argue that x-t independence within a wavelength also follows from special relativity so this seems to be consistent. In earlier notes we suggested that E constant at each x is an example of equilibrium being linked with a minimum amount of information. Here we show that x-t leads to this minimum amount of information in describing E. (One may note that given a spatial density, there is quite an amount of information present there, but it is linked with the -id/dx operator which is associated with momentum and KE(x) which has time information.) A second related point which follows from x-t independence is the following. Consider an ensemble of classical bounds states. At an instant of time and a given x, the probability to find the particle moving in the forward and backward directions is the same. If x and t are independent there is no instant of time and F(p,x) and F(-p,x) are not the same. In fact, F(p,x) must show how the particle moves in a forward direction and F(-p,x), motion in a negative direction. As a result, one has constant E at each x in a quantum bound state (i.e. locality), but F(p,x) and F(-p,x) being different suggests that there is nonlocality associated with momentum as it is linked with d/dx and hence x and a wavelength (which is nonlocal i.e. does not exist at a point). Thus conservation of momentum i.e. an average momentum of zero in a bound state may only be established by integrating over space - it does not hold at a point on average like in a classical system where P(p,x) = P(-p,x). There are in a sense two average momenta in a quantum bound state. The first is linked with F(p,x) not equalling F(-p,x), but E being constant at each x. This is a nonlocal average momentum and includes both p and -p with no time present. We argued above that spatial density varies in x and so one may assign a time to the system. This time is associated with a prms(x) which follows form KE(x) = prms(x)prms(x)/2m used in KE(x)+V(x)= En. Thus there are two “velocities” or momenta. One is a prms (which is classical and associated with time and spatial density) and the other which is nonlocal and linked to x-t being independent meaning that E must be constant at each x.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.7378871

Related papers

Special Relativity, Legendre Transformations and Fluctuations

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Momentum and velocity are two well-known physical observables in classical physics (and quantum physics as well because quantum particles have impulse and move through space in a certain amount of time based on an external clock and ruler). They are, however, measured in different ways. Velocity describes motion through x in some time t, while p is measured through impulses. Thus one does not need a clock to measure momentum. It may be measured in terms of the damage done to a foil, compression of a spring etc. Thus p=m1v1=m2v2 etc., i.e. a numerical number associated with momentum does not automatically yield the velocity unless one knows rest mass. In many situations rest mass is known (i.e. one deals with an electron etc) and so there seems to be a tendency to consider momentum and velocity to be almost the same thing when they are distinctly different. In fact, we argue that the notion of wavefunction W(x) and density P(x)=W*(x)W(x) are associated with momentum and velocity respectively. In fact, for a free particle these two measurables are linked with completely different spatial probabilities. Constant velocity impies P(x)=constant while exp(ipx) describes the two-dimensional x-probability associated with p which is based on a constant mo and v. In special relativity for a free particle (i.e. p constant, v constant), there are two well known Lorentz invariants: EE = pp + momo (c=1) and A = -Et + px. One may note that v does not appear explicitly even though one may write E and p in terms of v i.e. E = mo/sqrt(1-vv) and p=Ev. The first invariant describes E in terms of rest mass and p (measured through impulse). The second involves p,E and x,t with x and t appearing as independent even though ultimately x(t) and v=dx/dt=constant = x/t if x and t both start at 0. This independence is crucial because it means one may consider fluctuations which keep A constant separately. For example, if t→ t+ hbar/E and x→ x+hbar/p, then A remains constant. This leads to the idea of the quantum wavelength and a spatial probability independent of t, namely exp(ipx). One average, however, x=vt, but how does this appear in Lorentz invariants? There is no explicit v. We argue that the Lorentz invariant A = -Et + px must convert E from a function of p to one in v and that this occurs through a Legendre transformation. Thus the form of the invariant is itself a Legendre transformation with E being transformed into L, the Lagrangian. There is, however, a second important feature because p=dL/dv (partial) and given that p is constant, dp/dt=0 so d/dt dL/dv partial =0 which is in the form of an extremization. We argue that this is not an accident. dL/dv=p follows from E being constant, so, in other words, it follows from the px term. This same term leads to exp(ipx) which means that one does not have smooth x=vt motion within a wavelength. Thus, we argue that when one transforms to the second measurable v, the notion of this fluctuation behaviour must also be manifested. In other words, v=constant or dv/dt is not enough. The extremization behaviour of the Lagrangian, we argue, is thus not a mathematical convenience, but gives an indication that even though the extreme path x=vt is followed on average, other paths are sampled. We argue that this idea is incorporated into special relativity, in fact within a single Lorentz invariant A = -Et + px.

•Mar 16, 2023•0 citations

Classical Limit of Quantum Mechanics and the Breakdown of -id/dx

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In a classical bound state, conservation of energy: p(x)p(x)/2m + V(x) = E holds for all x. Examined in a statistical sense, one may consider each constant dx to have a probability density proportional to dt(x) where v(x)=velocity =dx/ dt(x). Thus the particle is followed in time. In quantum mechanics, even for a free particle exp(ipx), there exists a wavelength hbar/p. Within this region one cannot follow the particle in time. In fact, there are two probability distributions cos(px) and the shifted sin(px). The two dimensional nature of exp(ipx) is required to describe the direction of motion. There exists a mathematical abstraction or average which holds for any x within the wavelength and yields the classical x= p/m t. Thus there is a duality, but within a wavelength one cannot follow the particle exactly using x=p/m t. Rather there is no time and one thinks of probabilities to be at one x or another. The operator -id/dx yields the abstracted or average momentum at any x and (-id/dx)(-id/dx) average pp if one divides by probability. In other words: (-id/dx) exp(ipx)/ exp(ipx) = p and (-id/dx) (-id/dx) exp(ipx) / exp(ipx) = pp. These then apply to any x point. For a bound state, exp(ipx) is replaced with W(x)= Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). Thus p and -p are included together. From a statistical point of view this is fine because a quantum bound state is described in terms of energy conservation (time-independent Schrodinger equation). Unlike the classical case, the probabilities of p and -p differ, i.e. exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx). The sum exp(ipx)+exp(-ipx) yields cos(px) which is the resolution probability distribution. Taking -d/dx d/dx of W(x) and then dividing by W(x) yields the average kinetic energy at any x within the wavelength. In other words this is the average kinetic energy which matches the classical result for any energy level. As a result, prms(x)prms(x)/2m + V(x) = En holds for any quantum level, but prms(x) is an rms average value which bypasses wave structure. That is why the exp(ipx) for p,-p and -id/dx must be used to calculate average quantities within a wavelength. Many different p,-p combinations are needed so that at each x within a wavelength the correct average kinetic energy value appears. Now consider a high energy level and choose a fixed dx length to represent a tiny region in the system, a cutoff for which there is no further resolution. p(x) is constant within this region. If hbar/ prms(x) <= dx, the wave structure of quantum mechanics does not play a role. (Note that for an oscillator, W(x) is a set of crests and troughs with different heights and widths.) As a result, there is no need for d/dx acting on W(x) to describe average kinetic energy within dx. The average kinetic energy is prms(x)prms(x)/2m and dx is treated like a point. Only if exp(ipx) is used does -id/dx yield the proper classical result. (An alternative scenario is that d/dx acting on a function divided by the function yields the same result as acting on exp(ipx) divided by exp(ipx) e.g. -d/dx d/dx cos(px)/cos(px) = -d/dx d/dx exp(ipx) / exp(ipx). If one has the quantum kinetic energy expression -1/2m d/dx dW/dx / W ((1)) and considers one momentum, namely prms(x), and uses W(x)= cos( prms(x) x), then with prms(x) constant at x, ((1)) yields prms(x) prms(x)/ 2m. Thus d/dx has not broken down even though it does not describe motion within dx which is now a point. A problem arises, however, if one considers Wn(x)= Wn1(x)Wn2(x) as this yields an equation containing dW1/dx dW2/dx/ (W1W2). Then the above procedure yields: dW1/dx/W1 (prms(x) sin(prms(x) x) / cos(prms(x) x). This does not match the classical value. Furthermore, dW2/dx/ W2 contains +prms(x) and -prms(x) with different weights while a classical scenario is -pP(-p,x) + pP(p,x) = 0 because P(-p,x)=P(p,x) while quantum mechanically it doesn’t. We analyze this situation and conclude that d/dx breaks down/ does not apply in the classical limit because it is used to calculate average values within a wavelength only. It only “works” if the effect of the derivative(s) on a function divided by the function is the same as the effect on exp(ipx) divided by exp(ipx). If a wavelength fits within dx, there is no need to calculate values at any lower x level and d/dx is not needed. In fact, there is a single prms(x) value in dx and the average time links different dx’s so that one follows the particle (on average in the sense that one ignores structure within each x) by x(t). As a practical consequence, using -id/dx together with the wavefunction W(x) can lead to problems in the classical limit because d/dx does apply. In short, using -id/dx operating on Wn(x) divided by Wn(x) leads to issues unless it produces the same effect as acting on exp(ipx) divided by exp(ipx).

•Dec 1, 2022•0 citations

Quantum Dynamical Probability and the Uncertainty Principle

Francesco R. Ruggeri

The uncertainty principle (linked to p,x or E,t) plays an important role in quantum mechanics. For example, an electron with an exact momentum p is described by a wavefunction exp(ipx). This function exists at all x points and so it is suggested in the literature that there is complete uncertainty as to the electron’s position. (More specifically P(x)=exp(-ipx)exp(ipx) normalization constant=constant and so all x points have the same probability.) Thus if p is completely certain, it is said that position x is completely unknown. We note, however, that exp(ipx) consists of cos(px) and sin(px) which are repeated probability distributions (with zero endpoints). Thus even though they exist in all of space, due to repetition which in turn is due to spatial invariance, there is a specific length number, namely the wavelength. Thus we argue that in classical physics there is a set of points (x,p), but in quantum mechanics ( p , x with its dx interval), with the latter being equal to hbar/p. Then the only uncertainty is within the dx interval i.e. the wavelength and spatial density is linked to momentum i.e. there is dynamical probability. In particular, there is a frequency hbar/E and a wavelength hbar/p which define an internal clock and ruler and the two are independent. Thus within a wavelength one has a probabilistic picture (in order to have endpoints defining the dx interval) and no sense of time, yet on average time exists because of hbar/E and the particle moves in space with a constant v. This begs the question: How do time and space x arise in such a scenario? We speculate the following. Assume there exists a property called energy which defines an object. This object, however, may break into two different objects. As a result, one introduces a parameter called time to distinguish between the two systems (E) and (E1,E2). For a certain time range one has a single object, while for a later time interval, one has two objects. Each of the two objects in the second system, however, needs to be distinguished as well and so another parameter, namely space x is used for this. If the two objects existed at the same x and t, how would one know there were two unless another parameter were introduced? We use t and x as the distinguishing parameters and furthermore give these a measure i.e. dt and dx. We then argue that from these ideas one may show the notion of speed and direction (because there are two objects) as well as conservation of momentum arises. Given the notion of an interval, we argue it must be described by a probability distribution and we link this to constant/p and exp(ipx). We finally note that since spatial density is linked to dynamical probability, one must consider motion associated with a density which may lead even to collective motion.

•Dec 21, 2022•0 citations

Momentum and Wavelength in Quantum Bound States

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Early experiments linked to bound state quantum mechanics noticed discrete energy E levels. (Ignoring the issue of radiation from accelerating charges), classical physics predicts continuous E levels. If one tries a statistical approach i.e. thinks in terms of a “perceived” density dt=C dx/v(x) where v(x) is velocity, one again has continuous energy levels. Thus, experimental results may suggest a non-classical condition which affects both acceptable densities and energy levels. Bypassing Newtonian mechanics which traces a particle through x(t), we note that even classically a potential interacts with p and not v i.e. pp/2m - popo/2m = -V(x)+V(xo). This equation holds for p= mo v = (.5mo) 2v etc. Thus, energy flow i.e. p is of interest and if one does not trace the particle as x(t) or consider acceleration (which is not considered statistically), one may view energy flux p as being “spread” over the x axis, it seems. The length 1/p then corresponds to one unit of energy flux for the case of p. In other words, each p is associated with a length 1/p. If this length may be physically resolved, one immediate trial result suggests a spatial probability which varies over 1/p. In other words one may have a periodic function such as cos(px). This physical scenario seems to arise only when the quantum particle interacts with a potential. Calling 2*3.14/p = wavelength, this length is not associated with the velocity of the particle, but with energy flow. Each particle has an identical type of cycling within its own wavelength i.e. cos(px) behaviour as each wavelength represents one unit of energy flux. The wavelength limits resolution and leads to a probability scheme. In a bound quantum system dx associated with V(x) is usually much smaller than the larger wavelengths and so classical ideas such as p and pp/2m still apply, but are modified i.e. multiplied by probabilities which may be positive or negative. Having a spatial probability linked to density which also creates a probability scheme used to calculate average kinetic energy at each x based on 1/p type wavelengths is independent of classical physics. Trying to force average kinetic energy at x in the wavelength scheme to match KE(x) classical leads to discrete E values.

•Jul 15, 2021•0 citations

The Role of Time and Lorentz Invariances in the Quantum Wavelength

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In general, x and t are considered free variables taking on all real values (with t>0). A particle’s velocity may be calculated from x(t). For the Lorentz invariant A= -Et+px one may consider E for a free particle to follow from Integral F dx and p from Integral Fdt. If one wishes to put these on an equal footing, then Fdx requires a dt and Fdt a dx. This means t is replaced with dt and x with dx in -Et+px. What does it mean to have t and x intervals associated with a specific E,p and continuous x(t) motion? There does not seem to be either an x or t interval. There are, however, dx and dt intervals associated with the creation of E and p from p=0.In other words, these dt, dx intervals are physically real properties just like p and E and are manifested experimentally. If one imposes time reversal symmetry, not only should these intervals represent a kind of probability, but they should be symmetric. Thus, x=0 and t=0 are starting points such that A=0. A is a Lorentz invariant and so the end point should also have A=0 for time reversal to apply. This time reversal leads to two symmetric distributions, one in time with hbar/E as a period and one in space with hbar/p as a wavelength.This, however, does not show the direction of motion, say in the spatial distribution. Thus the symmetric x-probability distribution should ultimately be linked to both p and -p i.e should have a vector nature, although this has to be formally proved. A full x-probability distribution linked with p should show the direction of motion. One may write F(px) for the even symmetric function described above and G(px) and G(-px) for skewed full probability distributions such that G(px) + G(-px) = 2F(px). This implies G(px) = F(xp) + B(px) where B is an odd function. We discussed the idea of G(px) being the sum of an odd and even function in previous notes, but did not try to give a reason why F(px) should be an even function with probability endpoints of 0. In this note, we argue that this is due to time reversal invariance. A free Newtonian particle follows x= vt and this should hold on average for a quantum particle which travels through space measured by an external ruler and clock. Above, however, we discussed probability distributions due to p. In fact their sharpness d/dx is proportional to p. How does one eliminate x dependence? As we argued in a previous note (2), one may take the AND condition G(px)G(-px) which should remove all motion.This should be a constant. It is not just motion which is removed, but overall impulse which is the cause of the x-distributions. The square nature of G(px)G(-px) explains why quantum mechanics deals with square root probabilities. These are the probabilities which are linked to impulse, hence to interactions, but the spatial distribution cos(px) from exp(ipx), does not describe the motion x=vt which is also real.The problem, as we show, is that G(px) cannot be real. This forces one to adopt a two dimensional probability and ultimately obtain exp(ipx) i.e. the two dimensional vector one might expect.

•Feb 23, 2023•0 citations

Nonlocality Imposed by Special Relativity on Quantum Free Particles?

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In a previous note (1) we considered a rest mass mo at x=0 and t=to and argued this transforms to E’, p’ with x’/t’=v. Thus a single system may be Lorentz transformed to create particles with mo and all velocities. We suggested that all of these particles are on the same footing in a sense. In this note we try to investigate what this “footing” is. In particular, we suggest nonlocality. A particle with rest mass mo, likely occupies some region of space, but is treated as a point (i.e. x=0) which may be the center of mass.The idea of a particle considered as a point is carried over into special relativity i.e motion. In Newtonian mechanics the particle is also considered to be a point. We argue that even though a particle “system” with mo at x=0 and t=to is a point and that after moving there may still be an x’/t’ = v pertaining to one point representing the system, the localization of mo at x=0 may be transformed into a localization in every constant moving frame. This localization seems to be linked to the idea of x and t being independent in -Et+px just as a particle at x=0 and t=to at rest treats x and t as independent. Thus we argue that the localization is the “same footing” of particles with different v and hence momenta mov. The dot product -Et+px = A is -moto for the rest frame which tends to 0 for to→0 . For any frame, t=b/E and x=b/p yields the same A=0. Furthermore x=b/p and t=b/E is a recipe which holds in all frames and describes nonlocality or a “trapped” length associated with the moving particle. This trapped length is not associated with time because x and t are independent. In other words the system moves with a speed of v=x’/t’, but the particle is “trapped” within a wavelength of the order 1/p in the sense that there is a cycling probability as the particle moves through space ignoring time. One does not simply have a point at rest transformed into a point in motion describing all aspects of the moving particle. If one considers x=0 and x=1/p, particles with different p values may follow the same probability distribution associated with energy flow in the region of one wavelength. If one ignores the motion v=x’/t’, then since time is ignored it is as if one has a particle with different probabilities to be at different x points. In a bound quantum state, time is physically dropped and these probabilities are linked to actual densities. For a moving particle (in one direction) one must consider the point motion v=x’/t’, but also kind of periodic trapping of the particle in space (not linked to time). In order to quantify this for a quantum free particle, one may consider the idea of a particle system with a length proportional to 1/p which is consistent with P(x)=constant. In particular, one may take the square root of 1 so to speak to obtain exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx). This also follows from eigenvalue equations of A= -Et+px i.e. -id/dx exp(ipx) = p exp(ipx). It should be noted (as stated above) that exp(ipx) does not involve time. Thus the trapping is in space and may occur over a long period of time if the velocity is very slow i.e. 1/p is very large. In a sense the particle is trapped in a kind of periodic motion in space. There is locality in the sense of position x’/t’=v, but not in the sense of the trapped periodic motion. The nonlocality seems to exist one opposite scales than the usual point velocity. For example, if a particle has a very small velocity then x’/t’=v→0 i.e. one thinks in terms of a very small x’, but 1/p is very large.

•Jul 28, 2022•0 citations
We have argued in previous notes (1) that x and t are independent within a wavelength. This we will argue follows from special relativity applied to uniform motion i.e. -Et+px. In particular, v=x/t on average, not dx/dt, a mathematical abstraction which breaks down within the wavelength, because one cannot follow the particle in time. We argue that the notion of independent x and t within a wavelength implies a probability distribution of x i.e F(p,x) = the probability to find the particle with momentum p at x. From special relativity we suggest that E is associated with t and so an E(x) suggests also a t(x). (In fact, for KE(x), there is an associated time at each x, but for KE(x)+V(x)=E all x are the same and there is no need for a distinguishing variable time.) What about the spatial distribution F(p,x)? For a free particle F(p,x) is a function of x, but one which must map into a P(x)=constant. (For a bound state there is a spatial distribution and so the idea of time should exist in that a particle spends “more time” in a high probability region. This is linked to the idea of a p(rms) or velocity(rms)). Even for a bound quantum state we argue that for x and t to be independent, E must be constant at each x. One may argue that a constant E with a p(x) and an introduced V(x) is already present in special relativity i.e. (E-V(x))(E-V(x)) = pp + momo (c=1) which it is, but we argue that x-t independence within a wavelength also follows from special relativity so this seems to be consistent. In earlier notes we suggested that E constant at each x is an example of equilibrium being linked with a minimum amount of information. Here we show that x-t leads to this minimum amount of information in describing E. (One may note that given a spatial density, there is quite an amount of information present there, but it is linked with the -id/dx operator which is associated with momentum and KE(x) which has time information.) A second related point which follows from x-t independence is the following. Consider an ensemble of classical bounds states. At an instant of time and a given x, the probability to find the particle moving in the forward and backward directions is the same. If x and t are independent there is no instant of time and F(p,x) and F(-p,x) are not the same. In fact, F(p,x) must show how the particle moves in a forward direction and F(-p,x), motion in a negative direction. As a result, one has constant E at each x in a quantum bound state (i.e. locality), but F(p,x) and F(-p,x) being different suggests that there is nonlocality associated with momentum as it is linked with d/dx and hence x and a wavelength (which is nonlocal i.e. does not exist at a point). Thus conservation of momentum i.e. an average momentum of zero in a bound state may only be established by integrating over space - it does not hold at a point on average like in a classical system where P(p,x) = P(-p,x). There are in a sense two average momenta in a quantum bound state. The first is linked with F(p,x) not equalling F(-p,x), but E being constant at each x. This is a nonlocal average momentum and includes both p and -p with no time present. We argued above that spatial density varies in x and so one may assign a time to the system. This time is associated with a prms(x) which follows form KE(x) = prms(x)prms(x)/2m used in KE(x)+V(x)= En. Thus there are two “velocities” or momenta. One is a prms (which is classical and associated with time and spatial density) and the other which is nonlocal and linked to x-t being independent meaning that E must be constant at each x.
Momentum and velocity are two well-known physical observables in classical physics (and quantum physics as well because quantum particles have impulse and move through space in a certain amount of time based on an external clock and ruler). They are, however, measured in different ways. Velocity describes motion through x in some time t, while p is measured through impulses. Thus one does not need a clock to measure momentum. It may be measured in terms of the damage done to a foil, compression of a spring etc. Thus p=m1v1=m2v2 etc., i.e. a numerical number associated with momentum does not automatically yield the velocity unless one knows rest mass. In many situations rest mass is known (i.e. one deals with an electron etc) and so there seems to be a tendency to consider momentum and velocity to be almost the same thing when they are distinctly different. In fact, we argue that the notion of wavefunction W(x) and density P(x)=W*(x)W(x) are associated with momentum and velocity respectively. In fact, for a free particle these two measurables are linked with completely different spatial probabilities. Constant velocity impies P(x)=constant while exp(ipx) describes the two-dimensional x-probability associated with p which is based on a constant mo and v. In special relativity for a free particle (i.e. p constant, v constant), there are two well known Lorentz invariants: EE = pp + momo (c=1) and A = -Et + px. One may note that v does not appear explicitly even though one may write E and p in terms of v i.e. E = mo/sqrt(1-vv) and p=Ev. The first invariant describes E in terms of rest mass and p (measured through impulse). The second involves p,E and x,t with x and t appearing as independent even though ultimately x(t) and v=dx/dt=constant = x/t if x and t both start at 0. This independence is crucial because it means one may consider fluctuations which keep A constant separately. For example, if t→ t+ hbar/E and x→ x+hbar/p, then A remains constant. This leads to the idea of the quantum wavelength and a spatial probability independent of t, namely exp(ipx). One average, however, x=vt, but how does this appear in Lorentz invariants? There is no explicit v. We argue that the Lorentz invariant A = -Et + px must convert E from a function of p to one in v and that this occurs through a Legendre transformation. Thus the form of the invariant is itself a Legendre transformation with E being transformed into L, the Lagrangian. There is, however, a second important feature because p=dL/dv (partial) and given that p is constant, dp/dt=0 so d/dt dL/dv partial =0 which is in the form of an extremization. We argue that this is not an accident. dL/dv=p follows from E being constant, so, in other words, it follows from the px term. This same term leads to exp(ipx) which means that one does not have smooth x=vt motion within a wavelength. Thus, we argue that when one transforms to the second measurable v, the notion of this fluctuation behaviour must also be manifested. In other words, v=constant or dv/dt is not enough. The extremization behaviour of the Lagrangian, we argue, is thus not a mathematical convenience, but gives an indication that even though the extreme path x=vt is followed on average, other paths are sampled. We argue that this idea is incorporated into special relativity, in fact within a single Lorentz invariant A = -Et + px.
In a classical bound state, conservation of energy: p(x)p(x)/2m + V(x) = E holds for all x. Examined in a statistical sense, one may consider each constant dx to have a probability density proportional to dt(x) where v(x)=velocity =dx/ dt(x). Thus the particle is followed in time. In quantum mechanics, even for a free particle exp(ipx), there exists a wavelength hbar/p. Within this region one cannot follow the particle in time. In fact, there are two probability distributions cos(px) and the shifted sin(px). The two dimensional nature of exp(ipx) is required to describe the direction of motion. There exists a mathematical abstraction or average which holds for any x within the wavelength and yields the classical x= p/m t. Thus there is a duality, but within a wavelength one cannot follow the particle exactly using x=p/m t. Rather there is no time and one thinks of probabilities to be at one x or another. The operator -id/dx yields the abstracted or average momentum at any x and (-id/dx)(-id/dx) average pp if one divides by probability. In other words: (-id/dx) exp(ipx)/ exp(ipx) = p and (-id/dx) (-id/dx) exp(ipx) / exp(ipx) = pp. These then apply to any x point. For a bound state, exp(ipx) is replaced with W(x)= Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). Thus p and -p are included together. From a statistical point of view this is fine because a quantum bound state is described in terms of energy conservation (time-independent Schrodinger equation). Unlike the classical case, the probabilities of p and -p differ, i.e. exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx). The sum exp(ipx)+exp(-ipx) yields cos(px) which is the resolution probability distribution. Taking -d/dx d/dx of W(x) and then dividing by W(x) yields the average kinetic energy at any x within the wavelength. In other words this is the average kinetic energy which matches the classical result for any energy level. As a result, prms(x)prms(x)/2m + V(x) = En holds for any quantum level, but prms(x) is an rms average value which bypasses wave structure. That is why the exp(ipx) for p,-p and -id/dx must be used to calculate average quantities within a wavelength. Many different p,-p combinations are needed so that at each x within a wavelength the correct average kinetic energy value appears. Now consider a high energy level and choose a fixed dx length to represent a tiny region in the system, a cutoff for which there is no further resolution. p(x) is constant within this region. If hbar/ prms(x) <= dx, the wave structure of quantum mechanics does not play a role. (Note that for an oscillator, W(x) is a set of crests and troughs with different heights and widths.) As a result, there is no need for d/dx acting on W(x) to describe average kinetic energy within dx. The average kinetic energy is prms(x)prms(x)/2m and dx is treated like a point. Only if exp(ipx) is used does -id/dx yield the proper classical result. (An alternative scenario is that d/dx acting on a function divided by the function yields the same result as acting on exp(ipx) divided by exp(ipx) e.g. -d/dx d/dx cos(px)/cos(px) = -d/dx d/dx exp(ipx) / exp(ipx). If one has the quantum kinetic energy expression -1/2m d/dx dW/dx / W ((1)) and considers one momentum, namely prms(x), and uses W(x)= cos( prms(x) x), then with prms(x) constant at x, ((1)) yields prms(x) prms(x)/ 2m. Thus d/dx has not broken down even though it does not describe motion within dx which is now a point. A problem arises, however, if one considers Wn(x)= Wn1(x)Wn2(x) as this yields an equation containing dW1/dx dW2/dx/ (W1W2). Then the above procedure yields: dW1/dx/W1 (prms(x) sin(prms(x) x) / cos(prms(x) x). This does not match the classical value. Furthermore, dW2/dx/ W2 contains +prms(x) and -prms(x) with different weights while a classical scenario is -pP(-p,x) + pP(p,x) = 0 because P(-p,x)=P(p,x) while quantum mechanically it doesn’t. We analyze this situation and conclude that d/dx breaks down/ does not apply in the classical limit because it is used to calculate average values within a wavelength only. It only “works” if the effect of the derivative(s) on a function divided by the function is the same as the effect on exp(ipx) divided by exp(ipx). If a wavelength fits within dx, there is no need to calculate values at any lower x level and d/dx is not needed. In fact, there is a single prms(x) value in dx and the average time links different dx’s so that one follows the particle (on average in the sense that one ignores structure within each x) by x(t). As a practical consequence, using -id/dx together with the wavefunction W(x) can lead to problems in the classical limit because d/dx does apply. In short, using -id/dx operating on Wn(x) divided by Wn(x) leads to issues unless it produces the same effect as acting on exp(ipx) divided by exp(ipx).
The uncertainty principle (linked to p,x or E,t) plays an important role in quantum mechanics. For example, an electron with an exact momentum p is described by a wavefunction exp(ipx). This function exists at all x points and so it is suggested in the literature that there is complete uncertainty as to the electron’s position. (More specifically P(x)=exp(-ipx)exp(ipx) normalization constant=constant and so all x points have the same probability.) Thus if p is completely certain, it is said that position x is completely unknown. We note, however, that exp(ipx) consists of cos(px) and sin(px) which are repeated probability distributions (with zero endpoints). Thus even though they exist in all of space, due to repetition which in turn is due to spatial invariance, there is a specific length number, namely the wavelength. Thus we argue that in classical physics there is a set of points (x,p), but in quantum mechanics ( p , x with its dx interval), with the latter being equal to hbar/p. Then the only uncertainty is within the dx interval i.e. the wavelength and spatial density is linked to momentum i.e. there is dynamical probability. In particular, there is a frequency hbar/E and a wavelength hbar/p which define an internal clock and ruler and the two are independent. Thus within a wavelength one has a probabilistic picture (in order to have endpoints defining the dx interval) and no sense of time, yet on average time exists because of hbar/E and the particle moves in space with a constant v. This begs the question: How do time and space x arise in such a scenario? We speculate the following. Assume there exists a property called energy which defines an object. This object, however, may break into two different objects. As a result, one introduces a parameter called time to distinguish between the two systems (E) and (E1,E2). For a certain time range one has a single object, while for a later time interval, one has two objects. Each of the two objects in the second system, however, needs to be distinguished as well and so another parameter, namely space x is used for this. If the two objects existed at the same x and t, how would one know there were two unless another parameter were introduced? We use t and x as the distinguishing parameters and furthermore give these a measure i.e. dt and dx. We then argue that from these ideas one may show the notion of speed and direction (because there are two objects) as well as conservation of momentum arises. Given the notion of an interval, we argue it must be described by a probability distribution and we link this to constant/p and exp(ipx). We finally note that since spatial density is linked to dynamical probability, one must consider motion associated with a density which may lead even to collective motion.
Early experiments linked to bound state quantum mechanics noticed discrete energy E levels. (Ignoring the issue of radiation from accelerating charges), classical physics predicts continuous E levels. If one tries a statistical approach i.e. thinks in terms of a “perceived” density dt=C dx/v(x) where v(x) is velocity, one again has continuous energy levels. Thus, experimental results may suggest a non-classical condition which affects both acceptable densities and energy levels. Bypassing Newtonian mechanics which traces a particle through x(t), we note that even classically a potential interacts with p and not v i.e. pp/2m - popo/2m = -V(x)+V(xo). This equation holds for p= mo v = (.5mo) 2v etc. Thus, energy flow i.e. p is of interest and if one does not trace the particle as x(t) or consider acceleration (which is not considered statistically), one may view energy flux p as being “spread” over the x axis, it seems. The length 1/p then corresponds to one unit of energy flux for the case of p. In other words, each p is associated with a length 1/p. If this length may be physically resolved, one immediate trial result suggests a spatial probability which varies over 1/p. In other words one may have a periodic function such as cos(px). This physical scenario seems to arise only when the quantum particle interacts with a potential. Calling 2*3.14/p = wavelength, this length is not associated with the velocity of the particle, but with energy flow. Each particle has an identical type of cycling within its own wavelength i.e. cos(px) behaviour as each wavelength represents one unit of energy flux. The wavelength limits resolution and leads to a probability scheme. In a bound quantum system dx associated with V(x) is usually much smaller than the larger wavelengths and so classical ideas such as p and pp/2m still apply, but are modified i.e. multiplied by probabilities which may be positive or negative. Having a spatial probability linked to density which also creates a probability scheme used to calculate average kinetic energy at each x based on 1/p type wavelengths is independent of classical physics. Trying to force average kinetic energy at x in the wavelength scheme to match KE(x) classical leads to discrete E values.
In general, x and t are considered free variables taking on all real values (with t>0). A particle’s velocity may be calculated from x(t). For the Lorentz invariant A= -Et+px one may consider E for a free particle to follow from Integral F dx and p from Integral Fdt. If one wishes to put these on an equal footing, then Fdx requires a dt and Fdt a dx. This means t is replaced with dt and x with dx in -Et+px. What does it mean to have t and x intervals associated with a specific E,p and continuous x(t) motion? There does not seem to be either an x or t interval. There are, however, dx and dt intervals associated with the creation of E and p from p=0.In other words, these dt, dx intervals are physically real properties just like p and E and are manifested experimentally. If one imposes time reversal symmetry, not only should these intervals represent a kind of probability, but they should be symmetric. Thus, x=0 and t=0 are starting points such that A=0. A is a Lorentz invariant and so the end point should also have A=0 for time reversal to apply. This time reversal leads to two symmetric distributions, one in time with hbar/E as a period and one in space with hbar/p as a wavelength.This, however, does not show the direction of motion, say in the spatial distribution. Thus the symmetric x-probability distribution should ultimately be linked to both p and -p i.e should have a vector nature, although this has to be formally proved. A full x-probability distribution linked with p should show the direction of motion. One may write F(px) for the even symmetric function described above and G(px) and G(-px) for skewed full probability distributions such that G(px) + G(-px) = 2F(px). This implies G(px) = F(xp) + B(px) where B is an odd function. We discussed the idea of G(px) being the sum of an odd and even function in previous notes, but did not try to give a reason why F(px) should be an even function with probability endpoints of 0. In this note, we argue that this is due to time reversal invariance. A free Newtonian particle follows x= vt and this should hold on average for a quantum particle which travels through space measured by an external ruler and clock. Above, however, we discussed probability distributions due to p. In fact their sharpness d/dx is proportional to p. How does one eliminate x dependence? As we argued in a previous note (2), one may take the AND condition G(px)G(-px) which should remove all motion.This should be a constant. It is not just motion which is removed, but overall impulse which is the cause of the x-distributions. The square nature of G(px)G(-px) explains why quantum mechanics deals with square root probabilities. These are the probabilities which are linked to impulse, hence to interactions, but the spatial distribution cos(px) from exp(ipx), does not describe the motion x=vt which is also real.The problem, as we show, is that G(px) cannot be real. This forces one to adopt a two dimensional probability and ultimately obtain exp(ipx) i.e. the two dimensional vector one might expect.
In a previous note (1) we considered a rest mass mo at x=0 and t=to and argued this transforms to E’, p’ with x’/t’=v. Thus a single system may be Lorentz transformed to create particles with mo and all velocities. We suggested that all of these particles are on the same footing in a sense. In this note we try to investigate what this “footing” is. In particular, we suggest nonlocality. A particle with rest mass mo, likely occupies some region of space, but is treated as a point (i.e. x=0) which may be the center of mass.The idea of a particle considered as a point is carried over into special relativity i.e motion. In Newtonian mechanics the particle is also considered to be a point. We argue that even though a particle “system” with mo at x=0 and t=to is a point and that after moving there may still be an x’/t’ = v pertaining to one point representing the system, the localization of mo at x=0 may be transformed into a localization in every constant moving frame. This localization seems to be linked to the idea of x and t being independent in -Et+px just as a particle at x=0 and t=to at rest treats x and t as independent. Thus we argue that the localization is the “same footing” of particles with different v and hence momenta mov. The dot product -Et+px = A is -moto for the rest frame which tends to 0 for to→0 . For any frame, t=b/E and x=b/p yields the same A=0. Furthermore x=b/p and t=b/E is a recipe which holds in all frames and describes nonlocality or a “trapped” length associated with the moving particle. This trapped length is not associated with time because x and t are independent. In other words the system moves with a speed of v=x’/t’, but the particle is “trapped” within a wavelength of the order 1/p in the sense that there is a cycling probability as the particle moves through space ignoring time. One does not simply have a point at rest transformed into a point in motion describing all aspects of the moving particle. If one considers x=0 and x=1/p, particles with different p values may follow the same probability distribution associated with energy flow in the region of one wavelength. If one ignores the motion v=x’/t’, then since time is ignored it is as if one has a particle with different probabilities to be at different x points. In a bound quantum state, time is physically dropped and these probabilities are linked to actual densities. For a moving particle (in one direction) one must consider the point motion v=x’/t’, but also kind of periodic trapping of the particle in space (not linked to time). In order to quantify this for a quantum free particle, one may consider the idea of a particle system with a length proportional to 1/p which is consistent with P(x)=constant. In particular, one may take the square root of 1 so to speak to obtain exp(ipx) and exp(-ipx). This also follows from eigenvalue equations of A= -Et+px i.e. -id/dx exp(ipx) = p exp(ipx). It should be noted (as stated above) that exp(ipx) does not involve time. Thus the trapping is in space and may occur over a long period of time if the velocity is very slow i.e. 1/p is very large. In a sense the particle is trapped in a kind of periodic motion in space. There is locality in the sense of position x’/t’=v, but not in the sense of the trapped periodic motion. The nonlocality seems to exist one opposite scales than the usual point velocity. For example, if a particle has a very small velocity then x’/t’=v→0 i.e. one thinks in terms of a very small x’, but 1/p is very large.