Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Normalization errors in CHSH Bell inequalities

G. Coddens

Published Oct 7, 2022• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We consider two different definitions of determinism, the traditional one and a new alternative one. The alternative definition introduces a new description of what happens during a photon correlation measurement. The CHSH Bell-type inequality is derived according to the traditional definition of determinism. It can then not be applied in the usual way to the experiments it has been designed for, when in the analysis of the experiments we follow the alternative type of definition. In fact, the usual procedure introduces then a normalization error with a confusion between absolute and conditional probabilities. Within the frame work of the alternative definition the inequality is no longer violated and determinism is not defeated.

Related papers

Inadequacy of the CHSH Bell inequality for an application to the photon correlation experiments of Aspect et al

G. Coddens

\n We explain that the CHSH Bell inequality cannot be applied to the photon correlation experiments of Aspect {\\em et al.} In fact, when we apply the inequality to these experiments its derivation would imply that a single photon can have two different linear polarization states at the same time, while they cannot be measured at the same time. The issue is a consequence of the special experimental context we try to impose themathematics on. We are able to pinpoint the exact place in the derivation of the inequality where the application of the mathematics to the physics causes a problem.We then derive a Bell inequality that is appropriate for an application to the experiments.The boundaries of this corrected inequality are much less stringent and the experiments do not violate this inequality.\n

•Dec 16, 2021•0 citations

A Bell-type Inequality for Real Experiments and The Relevance of Fair Sampling Assumption

Afshin Shafiee, Mehdi Golshani

In the experimental verification of Bell’s inequalities in real photonic experiments, it is generally believed that the so-called fair sampling assumption (which means that a small fraction of results provide a fair statistical sample) has an unavoidable role. Here, we want to show that the interpretation of these experiments is really independent of the fair sampling assumption. For this purpose, we derive a more efficient Bell-type inequality which is a CHSH-type inequality in real experiments, using some alternative assumptions. Furthermore, Quantum mechanics violates our proposed inequality, In his celebrated 1964 paper, John Bell considered a system consisting of two spin-1 particles in a singlet state [1]. He showed that the correlation 2 between the results of two experiments done on such spatially separated particles

•May 20, 2003•0 citations

Determinism and Quantum Mechanics with time Bell inequalities

Ramón Lapiedra, Perez, A.

We propose a definition of determinism for a physical system that includes, besides the measurement device, the surrounding environment. This enlarged system is assumed to follow a predefined trajectory starting from some (unknown) initial conditions that play the role of hidden variables for the experiment. These assumptions, which are different from realism, allow us to derive a type of time Bell inequalities, which are violated by Quantum Mechanics. In order to illustrate this violation, we discuss the particular case of measurements on a spin 1/2 particle.

arXiv:1010.5049•Oct 25, 2010•0 citations

CHSH Inequality on a single probability space

C. M. Care

A number of papers have suggested that it is inappropriate to combine data from different experiments when undertaking experimental tests of Bell's inequalities. It has been suggested that a correct analysis, using a single probability space, leads to inequalities which are not violated by experiment. If correct, this would be contrary to the normal interpretation of such experimental data. However, in this note, a generalised Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality is derived for a system of four experiments constructed on a single probability space which combines the data from the four experiments. It is shown that this leads to the standard CHSH inequality which is normally used to interpret experimental data. Thus the commonly accepted conclusion that experimental violations of Bell's inequality imply that local realistic models are inconsistent with the predictions of quantum mechanics has not been challenged.

arXiv:1602.02628•Feb 8, 2016•1 citation

On the relevance of fair sampling assumption in the recent Bell photonic experiments

Afshin Shafiee, Mehdi Golshani

In the experimental verification of Bell's inequalities in real photonic experiments, it is generally believed that the so-called fair sampling assumption (which means that a small fraction of results provide a fair statistical sample) has an unavoidable role. Here, we want to show that the interpretation of these experiments could be feasible, if some different alternative assumptions other than the fair sampling were used. For this purpose, we derive an efficient Bell-type inequality which is a CHSH-type inequality in real experiments. Quantum mechanics violates our proposed inequality, independent of the detection-efficiency problems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0305110•Journal of Modern Optics•Jul 10, 2005•4 citations

The Violation of Bell-CHSH Inequalities Leads to Different Conclusions Depending on the Description Used

Aldo F. G. Solis-Labastida, Melina Gastélum Vargas, Jorge G. Hirsch

Since the experimental observation of the violation of the Bell-CHSH inequalities, much has been said about the non-local and contextual character of the underlying system. However, the hypothesis from which Bell's inequalities are derived differ according to the probability space used to write them. The violation of Bell's inequalities can, alternatively, be explained by assuming that the hidden variables do not exist at all, that they exist but their values cannot be simultaneously assigned, that the values can be assigned but joint probabilities cannot be properly defined, or that averages taken in different contexts cannot be combined. All of the above are valid options, selected by different communities to provide support to their particular research program.

arXiv:2107.02808•Entropy•Jul 8, 2021•3 citations
We consider two different definitions of determinism, the traditional one and a new alternative one. The alternative definition introduces a new description of what happens during a photon correlation measurement. The CHSH Bell-type inequality is derived according to the traditional definition of determinism. It can then not be applied in the usual way to the experiments it has been designed for, when in the analysis of the experiments we follow the alternative type of definition. In fact, the usual procedure introduces then a normalization error with a confusion between absolute and conditional probabilities. Within the frame work of the alternative definition the inequality is no longer violated and determinism is not defeated.
\n We explain that the CHSH Bell inequality cannot be applied to the photon correlation experiments of Aspect {\\em et al.} In fact, when we apply the inequality to these experiments its derivation would imply that a single photon can have two different linear polarization states at the same time, while they cannot be measured at the same time. The issue is a consequence of the special experimental context we try to impose themathematics on. We are able to pinpoint the exact place in the derivation of the inequality where the application of the mathematics to the physics causes a problem.We then derive a Bell inequality that is appropriate for an application to the experiments.The boundaries of this corrected inequality are much less stringent and the experiments do not violate this inequality.\n
In the experimental verification of Bell’s inequalities in real photonic experiments, it is generally believed that the so-called fair sampling assumption (which means that a small fraction of results provide a fair statistical sample) has an unavoidable role. Here, we want to show that the interpretation of these experiments is really independent of the fair sampling assumption. For this purpose, we derive a more efficient Bell-type inequality which is a CHSH-type inequality in real experiments, using some alternative assumptions. Furthermore, Quantum mechanics violates our proposed inequality, In his celebrated 1964 paper, John Bell considered a system consisting of two spin-1 particles in a singlet state [1]. He showed that the correlation 2 between the results of two experiments done on such spatially separated particles
We propose a definition of determinism for a physical system that includes, besides the measurement device, the surrounding environment. This enlarged system is assumed to follow a predefined trajectory starting from some (unknown) initial conditions that play the role of hidden variables for the experiment. These assumptions, which are different from realism, allow us to derive a type of time Bell inequalities, which are violated by Quantum Mechanics. In order to illustrate this violation, we discuss the particular case of measurements on a spin 1/2 particle.
A number of papers have suggested that it is inappropriate to combine data from different experiments when undertaking experimental tests of Bell's inequalities. It has been suggested that a correct analysis, using a single probability space, leads to inequalities which are not violated by experiment. If correct, this would be contrary to the normal interpretation of such experimental data. However, in this note, a generalised Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequality is derived for a system of four experiments constructed on a single probability space which combines the data from the four experiments. It is shown that this leads to the standard CHSH inequality which is normally used to interpret experimental data. Thus the commonly accepted conclusion that experimental violations of Bell's inequality imply that local realistic models are inconsistent with the predictions of quantum mechanics has not been challenged.
In the experimental verification of Bell's inequalities in real photonic experiments, it is generally believed that the so-called fair sampling assumption (which means that a small fraction of results provide a fair statistical sample) has an unavoidable role. Here, we want to show that the interpretation of these experiments could be feasible, if some different alternative assumptions other than the fair sampling were used. For this purpose, we derive an efficient Bell-type inequality which is a CHSH-type inequality in real experiments. Quantum mechanics violates our proposed inequality, independent of the detection-efficiency problems.
Since the experimental observation of the violation of the Bell-CHSH inequalities, much has been said about the non-local and contextual character of the underlying system. However, the hypothesis from which Bell's inequalities are derived differ according to the probability space used to write them. The violation of Bell's inequalities can, alternatively, be explained by assuming that the hidden variables do not exist at all, that they exist but their values cannot be simultaneously assigned, that the values can be assigned but joint probabilities cannot be properly defined, or that averages taken in different contexts cannot be combined. All of the above are valid options, selected by different communities to provide support to their particular research program.