The free particle action (relativistic or nonrelativistic) may be written as A = -Et+px. This same expression is also associated with a photon which has no rest mass mo and is linked to the classical wave result E=pv. dA=0 for a photon suggests one may have both a group velocity dE/dp as well as a phase velocity E=pv which are the same and both portions are 0 in dA, so dA=0 overall. Given that dE/dp and E=pv yield the same velocity, one may argue that either a wave or particle approach to a photon holds. This argument is given in (1). We show using dx/dt =x/t for a free particle that this must follow if dA=0. For a particle with rest mass mo, a group velocity portion of dA is 0 if dE/dp is taken as dE/dv / dp/dv. The overall dA, however, is not 0 for constant mo. A phase velocity portion is completely at odds with p=Ev. Thus we suggest that the form exp(-iEt+ipx) used in quantum mechanics for a free particle be separated into exp(-Et) and exp(ipx) and not be combined to describe an overall wave. Thus for the photon and particle with a mass, dA portions corresponding to velocities are 0. For the photon, both dA(group velocity)=0 and dA(phase velocity)=0 and vgroup=vphase, while for a particle with rest mass only dA (group velocity)=0 and dA (overall) is not zero for fixed mass. Thus the photon and particle with a free mass have a group velocity portion of dA being 0 in common. This suggests a similarity of the two at a “particle” level as group velocity is usually associated with particle motion. In (1) the particle properties of the photon are also stressed.
The free particle action (relativistic or nonrelativistic) may be written as A = -Et+px. This same expression is also associated with a photon which has no rest mass mo and is linked to the classical wave result E=pv. dA=0 for a photon suggests one may have both a group velocity dE/dp as well as a phase velocity E=pv which are the same and both portions are 0 in dA, so dA=0 overall. Given that dE/dp and E=pv yield the same velocity, one may argue that either a wave or particle approach to a photon holds. This argument is given in (1). We show using dx/dt =x/t for a free particle that this must follow if dA=0. For a particle with rest mass mo, a group velocity portion of dA is 0 if dE/dp is taken as dE/dv / dp/dv. The overall dA, however, is not 0 for constant mo. A phase velocity portion is completely at odds with p=Ev. Thus we suggest that the form exp(-iEt+ipx) used in quantum mechanics for a free particle be separated into exp(-Et) and exp(ipx) and not be combined to describe an overall wave. Thus for the photon and particle with a mass, dA portions corresponding to velocities are 0. For the photon, both dA(group velocity)=0 and dA(phase velocity)=0 and vgroup=vphase, while for a particle with rest mass only dA (group velocity)=0 and dA (overall) is not zero for fixed mass. Thus the photon and particle with a free mass have a group velocity portion of dA being 0 in common. This suggests a similarity of the two at a “particle” level as group velocity is usually associated with particle motion. In (1) the particle properties of the photon are also stressed.
We take as our starting point the free particle classical action which may be written as A= -Et+px if t and x are treated as independent variables. It is possible to find two relationships linking v (velocity) to x and t from dA=0. The first is the classical wave result vp = E while the second is p=Ev where E=mo/sqrt(1-vv) (c=1). Furthermore one may write dA/dx partial = p ((1a)) and dA/dt partial = -E. ((1b)) This may be generalized to two eigenvalue differential equations, but this immediately begs the question: Why do this? We argue that Lorentz invariant form -Et+px represents scaling of both t and x. For example, p scales x and we argue there should be physical relevance to this. This physical relevance results in the wavelength proportional to 1/p. In other words, -Et+px represents more than velocity. The treatment of the scaling for a quantum wave and classical wave differ, we argue, in that the former keeps E,t and p,x separate while a classical wave does not. In other words pv=E applies to a classical wave which is described by cos(-Et+px). In other words, one takes ((1a)) and ((1b)) which separate E,t and p,x into two independent equations and takes account of scaling by combining the two (to include both x and t) i.e. creating the classical wave equation: 1/vv d/dt d/dt partial W(x,t) = d/dx d/dx partial W(x,t). We argue that quantum mechanics on the other hand keeps ((1a)) and ((1b)) separate. The velocity (relativistic) p=Ev is not a wave velocity. A solution to ((1a)) is exp(ipx) and to ((1b)) exp(-iEt). These are usually combined for a free particle to give exp(-iEt+ipx) and a wave is described with a phase velocity pv(phase)=E. We prefer to keep exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx) separate . For example, for two slit interference one does not make use of phase velocity or exp(-iEt). For a bound state one uses p=Ev, but a single free particle is represented by exp(ipx) in W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). exp(-iEn t) appears after one has found En, using the exp(ipx)’s in the sense that one does not include an exp(- i pp/2m t) for each exp(ipx). We argue that by separating E,t and p,x, the latter leads to a scheme for which there is “no time”. It is true that the particle moves at a speed x/t, but p=m1v1=m2v2 etc so p does not uniquely define velocity, rather it defines an impulse hit 2p = Integral F dt . Thus the scaling px which leads to an x, p only wave exp(ipx) is linked to an interaction. If the particle is moving freely and not interacting, then one has classical determinism i.e. v=constant = x/t. As soon as an interaction occurs, one changes from variables x,t which are linked to x, P conditional (x/p) and there is uncertainty in the position of x within a wavelength. The phase in exp(ipx) is only dependent on x not on the time the particle reaches x. exp(ipx) thus represents a probability and one must consider a sum of different possible outcomes (as in a two slit experiment) in order to describe an interaction. This is very different from the local interaction of classical mechanics. Nevertheless for a bound state one makes use of the two formalisms i.e. KE(x)= Sum over p pp/2m a(p)exp(ipx) / W(x) = KEclassical(x). We try to discuss some of these ideas in this note.
In Part I we argued that two flow equations for a free particle, namely: d/dx (partial) A(x,t) = p ((1a)) and d/dt (partial) A(x,t) = -E ((1a)) may be applied to both particles with rest mass and those without. In fact we argue that there are at least three scenarios associated with ((1a)) and ((1b)). The first is classical mechanics for a particle with rest mass mo and constant velocity. Using ((1a)) and ((1b)) with p=E(v)v this scenario yields special relativity. A second solution is to write ((1a)) and ((1b)) as eigenvalue equations: -id/dx (partial) exp(iA) = p exp(iA) and id/dt (partial) exp(iA)= E exp(iA) where A=-Et+px. This yields a quantum mechanical solution for a particle with rest mo if one assumes p=Ev. In such a case one may use the special relativistic result EE = pp + momo and establish the Klein-Gordon equation. A third solution pertains to objects with zero rest mass. As argued in Part I, these do not follow p=E(v)v, but rather the classical wave result: v=E/p. In this note we examine massless particles, namely waves on a string, photons and sound, in more detail. For the zero mass case, dA=0 so there is motion in such a way as to keep A constant. If one considers periodic motion and uses ((1a)) and ((1b)), a solution which is real and periodic is: d/dt d/dt cos(A) = vv d/dx d/dx cos(A) ((2)) A second order partial differential equation is needed as one insists the solution be real. This differs from the quantum mechanical solution of exp(-iEt+ipx) which is complex for a reason. The modulus must be linked to a probability of 1 for a free particle. The zero mass solution is one of a smeared-out physical wave. We note that ((1a)) and ((1b)) deal strictly with E energy and p momentum, but cos(A)=cos(-Et+px) is associated with a period proportional to 1/E and a wavelength proportional to 1/p. This raises two questions. First, what physical entity is periodic? Secondly, how does the energy appear in the problem as energy and not just 2*3.14 frequency of the physical entity? We try to consider this issue for a wave on a string, photon and sound wave.
The classical action (relativistic or nonrelativistic) may be written with v=x/t and x and t varied independently to yield dA/dx partial = p and dA/dt partial = -E. Thus A = -Et+px is a solution. This expression also appears in classical wave forms and in the electromagnetic description of a photon (from Maxwell’s laws). -Et+px is a Lorentz invariant and so is directly linked to special relativity and different frames moving with constant velocity. In (1) we argued that x and t should be treated as independent in A. This suggests that p is a scaling in space and E in time. Thus there should be physical lengths proportional to 1/p and physical time intervals proportional to 1/E. Special relativity considers different frames (moving with constant velocity) and 4-vectors so it seems to be quite different from a scenario with t and x separated and scaling of x by p. We argue that although -Et+px is a Lorentz invariant and as such may be used to find E(v) and p(v), quantum mechanics is usually performed in a special frame, namey one in which V(x) or V(x,v) the potential is at rest. (For electromagnetism one treats (A, phi) as a 4-vector, but this is not the norm.) As a result, energy En found in a rest frame of the potential also represents “rest energy” so En is binding energy which is added to rest mass energy. In other words motion in the rest frame of a potential creates rest energy = rest mass. We argue that V(x) may be written as a sum over k Vk exp(ikx) and so no time related terms appear, only momentum linked ones. Thus momentum is the key feature for the interaction, even though velocity and time are still in the picture (just sometimes not directly in the interaction scheme). For example, a two slit interference or single slit diffraction does not depend on time or speed although these are certainly in the problem. For a bound state v and t are also in the problem as one calculates average kinetic energy using pp/2m = .5 p v which is rate dependent, but there is no acceleration which is a time-dependent phenomenon. Rather one deals with an ensemble of exp(ipx)’s because these interact with the potential in a wavelike manner to create the effect of acceleration. exp(ipx) a momentum wave linked to the scaling of x by p in px is not only involved in an interaction with V(x), but represents extra information from the classical mechanical picture. exp(ipx) for a known rest mass mo means one knows v=x/t=dx/dt, yet there is an extra piece of information namely the phase px which is involved in even “free” interactions such as two idendical particle with different phases arriving at the same x at the same t or the average kinetic energy in a bound state. Velocity v is converted into a momentum expression through p/mo in the norelativistic case and so exp(ipx) governs the whole scenario. Acceleration then becomes a mathematical abstraction of the motion of vrms(x) for any quantum bound energy level with the real physics associated with exp(ipx) being ignored.
In a previous note (1) we argued that two flux/flow equations d/dx partial A(x,t)=p ((1a)) and ddt partial A(x,t) = -E ((1b)) lead to the Lorentz invariant solution A(x,t)= -Et+px. These have two stationary solutions (dA=0), namely dE/dv= dp/dv with x/t=v and p=E(v)v (rest mass nonzero) and dx/dt = E/p (rest mass i.e. a classical wave). The first solution leads to relativistic/nonrelativistic quantum mechanics if ((1a)) and ((1b)) are written as eigenvalue equations. The second represents classical waves and their eigenfunction equation is the classical wave equation d/dt d/dt cos(A) = 1/vv d/dx docs(A)/dx. A periodic solution, we argue, implies action-reaction suggesting force or tension in the system. This seems to be the case for a classical wave on a string with fixed ends or for a sound wave in a gas with pressure. Light treated as a classical wave, however, is more complicated because there is no medium with tension, but rather one has periodically varying electric and magnetic fields. An electric field, however, is considered a force field and so there is an analogy with a periodically changing pressure. A classical wave requires a real periodic solution. A quantum mechanical free particle solution (nonzero rest mass) does not require a real periodic solution because there is no medium or obvious real entity changing periodically, but one may establish a complex solution using eigenvalue equations:id/dt partial exp(i A) = E exp(iA) and -id/dx partial exp(iA) = p exp(iA). At first a complex solution seems unphysical, but one may note that for a fixed t (for example), exp(ipx) is 1 at x=0 and again at pL=2*3.14. Thus there is a special length in the problem which yields the classical mechanical result d/dx partial A = p namely the wavelength 2.*3.14/p. In other words the quantum solution describes the classical solution at each x= n * wavelength. Within each wavelength region one has an exp(ipx) solution which consists of two out of phase periodic functions such that the modulus is 1. We try to argue that like in a classical wave there should be some impedance to a disturbance (like tension of a string or pressure of a gas). This impedance, however, is not represented by one physical entity (e.g. pressure in a sound wave) as one has a complex solution. A complex solution exp(ipx) is not alarming because light treated as a classical wave has two perpendicular entities, namely the electric and magnetic fields, that are both periodic. One may write a classical wave equation for each, but one may write a combined quantum-like wave equation for a photon: i d/dt partial Wi + eijk (-id/dxj) Wk = 0 (where eikj is the Levi-Civita symbol) which has a vector wavefunction Wi= Electric field (i) (x,t) + i Magnetic field (i) (x,t). The only impedance in the zero rest mass problem seems to be the rest mass (inertia) which resists motion. To be more general, it seems that momentum overall should be an impedance to motion. The entire momentum (E(v)v) is associated with an impact and a change in the momentum of a quantum particle (with rest mass) may be resisted by the entire momentum. In classical physics constant velocity motion seems to be a simple translation from one x point to another. The exp(ipx) solution to ((1a)) and ((1b)) shows that this interpretation only holds for n *wavelength points. Within each wavelength region out of phase two dimensional periodic motion occurs which suggests a kind of action-reaction. This behaviour occurs for various objects such as an electron, nucleon, nucleus, atom or even fairly large molecules etc. It has been argued that this quantum motion may apply for even objects in the macroscopic world e.g. mirrors. Impedance for nonzero rest mass quantum objects is velocity dependent as one may many different velocities associated with a nonzero rest mass momentum while classical waves have one velocity (for a given tension scenario). E.g. light always as a velocity of c because it has only one tension scenario i.e. electric and magnetic fields. Changing wavelengths and frequencies are linked to changing energy and momentum, but not velocity. We try to investigate some of these ideas.
Quantum free particles (with nonzero rest mass) and photons both appear in the quantum world. In a previous note (1) we argued one may write the relativistic or nonrelativistic classical action as -Et+px and in (2) we argued that this same form appears as a solution of the Poynting continuity equation for a photon. In both cases -Et+px is a Lorentz invariant as is -EE+pp= momo where mo is the rest mass (0 in the photon case). As a result, there seems to be much similarity between the nonzero rest mass free particle and the photon, yet they have different dispersion relationships (c=E/p photon and v=p/E c=1 for a free particle) and the free particle is linked with a two dimensional wave type object exp(ipx-iEt) while the photon with a wavefunction of E+iB (E=electric field, B= magnetic) which may be linked to the single cos(-Et+px). We investigate these ideas and suggest that perhaps momentum (or its change) should be considered in terms of impulse as the idea of an energy flow, which works nicely for a particle with rest mass i.e. p=Ev, does not work so well for a photon. A change in momentum yielding an impulse hit, however, works for both and we have argued in previous notes that a quantum bound state may be thought of in terms of impulse hits i.e. writing V(x)=potential=Sum over p Vkexp(ikx).
Newton’s second law dp/dt = F(x)=-dV/dx may be written in terms of x alone i.e. dp/dx v(x) = -dV/dx or 1/(2m) d/dx pp = -dV/dx leading to the idea of kinetic energy pp/2m and potential energy V(x). In (1) we argued that there is velocity, rest mass mo, and momentum in quantum mechanics. A free particle, however, does not undergo smooth acceleration as in classical mechanics, and we argued there exists a momentum space wave exp(ipx) accompanying the moving particle. In such a scenario, force is considered to be probabilistic momentum hits of the form Vk exp(ikx) leading to a free particle momentum distribution W(x)= Sum over p a(p) exp(ipx). Both of these expressions involve interference due to momentum waves which do not track a particle in time. A mass flux mov or energy flux p=Ev relativistically seems to be the main consideration. Nevertheless, summing Vkexp(ikx) over k to obtain V(x) yields a function varying in x alone. This is a kind of average based on interference and Sum k Vk exp(ikx) is an average linked to momentum hits. We speculate that average momentum hits i.e. -d/dx V(x) are linked to momentum flux changes. In other words, even though an impulse is based on p and does not distinguish v i.e. p=m1v1=m2v2, momentum flux is velocity dependent and appears for an average momentum hit i.e. -dV/dx. In such a case (pave+dpave)(vave + dv ave) = 2 pave dv(ave) . This expression, however, contains both forward and backward motion which is part of quantum mechanics. Moving to an average picture seems to introduce time and direction i.e one uses pave d v(ave). This is already a change from a quantum to a classical scenario albeit for averages (which have not been specifically defined). Thus we consider pave dv(ave). If this is the case, then: d/dx pave 1/m space = -dV/dx or 1/(2m) pave pave = -d/dx V(x). Instead of treating pave pave as two separate averages one considers pave=prms or pavepave=<pp>. Thus the quantum bound picture (at any energy level) becomes a classical type of scenario which includes time and velocity. Note that for a two slit interference pattern, one does not need velocity and time because the interaction with the potentials from both slits is based on exp(ipx). One does not even need the form of the potential. Interference is the same for p=m1v1=m2v2 (even though the process takes place during different time intervals, the pattern is not affected). In other words, we argue that Newton’s second law might follow from a picture of momentum hits in which a flux i.e. p=mov is treated as a quantity which in an average scenario leads to a second flux i.e. an average momentum flux which reintroduces direction, time and velocity.. This is somewhat like a hydrodynamics scenario.