Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

The quantisation and measurement of momentum observables

Kay-Kong Wan, Keith McFarlane

Published Aug 1, 1980• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Mackey's scheme (1963) for the quantisation of classical momenta generating complete vector fields (complete momenta) is introduced, the differential operators corresponding to these momenta are introduced and discussed, and an isomorphism is shown to exist between the subclass of first-order self-adjoint differential operators, whose symmetric restrictions are essentially self-adjoint, and the complete classical momenta. Difficulties in the quantisation of incomplete momenta are discussed, and a critique given. Finally, in an attempt to relate the concept of completeness to measurability, concepts of classical and quantum global measurability are introduced, and shown to require completeness. These results afford strong physical insight into the nature of complete momenta, and lead us to suggest a quantisability condition based upon global measurability.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/13/8/017

Related papers

On the quantization and measurement of momentum observables

Keith McFarlane

This thesis is the outcome of research conducted into the quantization of observables defined over a Riemannian configuration manifold, and is naturally divided into three chapters: \n \nThe first chapter is essentially concerned with the development from physical bases, of the concepts of classical and quantum “global measurability”, which, when combined with the requirement that all quantizable momenta shall be either classically or quantum mechanically globally measurable, result in the exclusion form the class of quantizable momenta of all those observables which are not quantizable in accordance with G. W. Mackey’s natural procedure. The refinement of exact global measurability is then introduced and the physically important class of “killing” momenta are found to be exactly classically and quantum mechanically globally measurable and moreover quantizable by means of Mackey’s scheme. \n \nThe second chapter seeks to analyse the algebraic structure of the Mackey-quantizable momenta, so as to compare and contrast his geometric scheme with the various algebraic schemes which have frequently been proposed. As an extension of this work, a natural geometric quantization is proposed for the more general class of observables “linear in momentum”, the set of quantizable such entities determines, and its algebraic properties discussed. It is concluded that, if Mackey’s procedure is, as we argue, correct and exhaustive of the quantizable momenta, then algebraic rules of quantization do not, in general, obtain among the momenta defined over a Riemannian space, ‘though in the case of momenta, such as the Killing momenta, reflecting the symmetry of the configuration manifold, such laws not only exist but are moreover of great practical importance. \n \nThe third chapter is concerned with the quantization of the observables “multilinear in momentum” and in particular with the delimitation of the possible operators of formal quantization as circumscribed by the requirement of operator symmetry, and the question of the essential self-adjointness of local observables associated with the multilinear momenta. Finally some possible means of determining and exact quantization are discussed and contrasted and a tentative selection made of a particular scheme which is then illustrated by concrete example on the real line with the usual metric. \n \nWe conclude this preface with a brief indication of the layout of the thesis: Each chapter or associated group of appendices has been treated for the purpose of all textual numbering and referencing systems, as a separate unit, and is prefixed by a detailed list of contents, and concluded by the appropriate group of reference, so that all pointers of a chapter or group of appendices refer, unless otherwise indicated, to the text of that chapter or group of appendices. Finally note that a bibliography has been included which will serve as a collected list of references to papers and books employed.

•Jan 1, 1980•0 citations

The quantisation and measurement of momentum observables. II

Kay-Kong Wan, Keith McFarlane

For pt.I see ibid., vol.13, no.8, p.2673-88 (1980). Concepts of classical and quantum global measurability introduced in an earlier paper are discussed in greater detail and in the context of an n-dimensional Riemannian manifold. The ideas are illustrated with diagrams and examples. A notion of exact measurability is introduced and is shown to imply quantum global measurability. The physically important Killing momenta are shown to be exactly, and hence quantum globally, measurable.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Oct 1, 1981•5 citations

Lie algebra and the quantisation of momenta and the Hamiltonian

Kay-Kong Wan, Caesar P. Viazminsky

A common assumption that quantisation is simply a representation of the Lie algebra of classical observables by a Lie algebra of self-adjoint operators in Hilbert space is shown to be generally invalid.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•May 1, 1979•5 citations

Investigations on classical symmetries theory of quantization

P. B. Guest

The thesis divides naturally into two parts. Part I raises, and in some cases answers, questions concerning symmetry in classical mechanics. The main result (Theorem 6.4) shows that the assumption of the existence of a realization puts an upper limit on the rank of the algebra. \n \n The heart of the thesis (covering three-quarters of the volume) is section II on the quantization of classical systems. §1 lists axioms desirable in any quantization rule for the 'functions of the q's'. The momentum observables are introduced in §2 prior to their quantization in §4. §5 essentially shows how conventional quantum mechanics fits into this scheme of things. By progressive specialization from a general manifold to a vector space, from a general quantization scheme to one which is linear on the linear momentum functions, and finally to an entirely well-behaved (admissible) quantization rule, into which conventional quantum mechanics fits nicely, we obtain in §7-§9 results which become progressively more and more powerful. The final theorem (Theorem 9.2) is perhaps the most significant of all. This result states that there exists a class of functions, which contains all functions of the q's and functions of the p's and all momentum observables and which is closed with respect to any linear canonical transformation L; a rule A assigning a unique self-adjoint operator to each such function f; a unitary operator WL corresponding to L and an equation \n \n𝛬(𝑓 ∘ 𝐿) = 𝑊[sub]𝐿⁻ 𝛬 𝑓 𝑊[sub]𝐿

•Jan 1, 1972•0 citations

Free semigroup non-relativistic phase space states quantisation

Georgii Koniukov

Quantisation is considered as an action of classical point operators on field states at the Planck scale of the phase space. Emphasis is placed on the sequence of physical variables. A "state language/Dirac notation" for classical mechanics is introduced; in many cases, it replaces the principle of stationary action for conservative systems. Observed classical and quantum dynamics are considered as different vectorisations of the free semigroup contribution of time. There is a dream of describing classical dynamics as complex transformations of state vectors over such a free semigroup, rather than solving differential equations. The transition from the alphabet to states, from states to state functions, and from state functions to measurable quantities is managed by projectors. An attempt is made to provide a derivation of the Legendre transformation. The trivial multiplication of the potential energy by the wave function in the coordinate representation and its non-trivial operator action in the momentum representation are obtained without a Fourier transform nor the Planck scale. The quantisation procedure is divided into two stages: first, the action of point-like classical operators on field functions; and second, accounting for the physically finite scale of the Planck length against the backdrop of the possible infinitesimality in the classical phase space. The concept of an angle between states is introduced, defining the measure of "quantumness". The free semigroup time contribution is studied in the context of the Born rule.

quant-pharXiv:2609.27004•Sep 24, 2026•0 citations

Measurement and self-adjoint operators

G.E. Johnson

The approximations of classical mechanics resulting from quantum mechanics are richer than a correspondence of classical dynamical variables with self-adjoint Hilbert space operators. Assertion that classical dynamic variables correspond to self-adjoint Hilbert space operators is disputable and sets unnatural limits on quantum mechanics. Well known examples of classical dynamical variables not associated with self-adjoint Hilbert space operators are discussed as a motivation for the realizations of quantum field theory that lack Hermitian field operators but exhibit interaction.

arXiv:1405.7224•May 28, 2014•3 citations
Mackey's scheme (1963) for the quantisation of classical momenta generating complete vector fields (complete momenta) is introduced, the differential operators corresponding to these momenta are introduced and discussed, and an isomorphism is shown to exist between the subclass of first-order self-adjoint differential operators, whose symmetric restrictions are essentially self-adjoint, and the complete classical momenta. Difficulties in the quantisation of incomplete momenta are discussed, and a critique given. Finally, in an attempt to relate the concept of completeness to measurability, concepts of classical and quantum global measurability are introduced, and shown to require completeness. These results afford strong physical insight into the nature of complete momenta, and lead us to suggest a quantisability condition based upon global measurability.
This thesis is the outcome of research conducted into the quantization of observables defined over a Riemannian configuration manifold, and is naturally divided into three chapters: \n \nThe first chapter is essentially concerned with the development from physical bases, of the concepts of classical and quantum “global measurability”, which, when combined with the requirement that all quantizable momenta shall be either classically or quantum mechanically globally measurable, result in the exclusion form the class of quantizable momenta of all those observables which are not quantizable in accordance with G. W. Mackey’s natural procedure. The refinement of exact global measurability is then introduced and the physically important class of “killing” momenta are found to be exactly classically and quantum mechanically globally measurable and moreover quantizable by means of Mackey’s scheme. \n \nThe second chapter seeks to analyse the algebraic structure of the Mackey-quantizable momenta, so as to compare and contrast his geometric scheme with the various algebraic schemes which have frequently been proposed. As an extension of this work, a natural geometric quantization is proposed for the more general class of observables “linear in momentum”, the set of quantizable such entities determines, and its algebraic properties discussed. It is concluded that, if Mackey’s procedure is, as we argue, correct and exhaustive of the quantizable momenta, then algebraic rules of quantization do not, in general, obtain among the momenta defined over a Riemannian space, ‘though in the case of momenta, such as the Killing momenta, reflecting the symmetry of the configuration manifold, such laws not only exist but are moreover of great practical importance. \n \nThe third chapter is concerned with the quantization of the observables “multilinear in momentum” and in particular with the delimitation of the possible operators of formal quantization as circumscribed by the requirement of operator symmetry, and the question of the essential self-adjointness of local observables associated with the multilinear momenta. Finally some possible means of determining and exact quantization are discussed and contrasted and a tentative selection made of a particular scheme which is then illustrated by concrete example on the real line with the usual metric. \n \nWe conclude this preface with a brief indication of the layout of the thesis: Each chapter or associated group of appendices has been treated for the purpose of all textual numbering and referencing systems, as a separate unit, and is prefixed by a detailed list of contents, and concluded by the appropriate group of reference, so that all pointers of a chapter or group of appendices refer, unless otherwise indicated, to the text of that chapter or group of appendices. Finally note that a bibliography has been included which will serve as a collected list of references to papers and books employed.
The thesis divides naturally into two parts. Part I raises, and in some cases answers, questions concerning symmetry in classical mechanics. The main result (Theorem 6.4) shows that the assumption of the existence of a realization puts an upper limit on the rank of the algebra. \n \n The heart of the thesis (covering three-quarters of the volume) is section II on the quantization of classical systems. §1 lists axioms desirable in any quantization rule for the 'functions of the q's'. The momentum observables are introduced in §2 prior to their quantization in §4. §5 essentially shows how conventional quantum mechanics fits into this scheme of things. By progressive specialization from a general manifold to a vector space, from a general quantization scheme to one which is linear on the linear momentum functions, and finally to an entirely well-behaved (admissible) quantization rule, into which conventional quantum mechanics fits nicely, we obtain in §7-§9 results which become progressively more and more powerful. The final theorem (Theorem 9.2) is perhaps the most significant of all. This result states that there exists a class of functions, which contains all functions of the q's and functions of the p's and all momentum observables and which is closed with respect to any linear canonical transformation L; a rule A assigning a unique self-adjoint operator to each such function f; a unitary operator WL corresponding to L and an equation \n \n𝛬(𝑓 ∘ 𝐿) = 𝑊[sub]𝐿⁻ 𝛬 𝑓 𝑊[sub]𝐿
Quantisation is considered as an action of classical point operators on field states at the Planck scale of the phase space. Emphasis is placed on the sequence of physical variables. A "state language/Dirac notation" for classical mechanics is introduced; in many cases, it replaces the principle of stationary action for conservative systems. Observed classical and quantum dynamics are considered as different vectorisations of the free semigroup contribution of time. There is a dream of describing classical dynamics as complex transformations of state vectors over such a free semigroup, rather than solving differential equations. The transition from the alphabet to states, from states to state functions, and from state functions to measurable quantities is managed by projectors. An attempt is made to provide a derivation of the Legendre transformation. The trivial multiplication of the potential energy by the wave function in the coordinate representation and its non-trivial operator action in the momentum representation are obtained without a Fourier transform nor the Planck scale. The quantisation procedure is divided into two stages: first, the action of point-like classical operators on field functions; and second, accounting for the physically finite scale of the Planck length against the backdrop of the possible infinitesimality in the classical phase space. The concept of an angle between states is introduced, defining the measure of "quantumness". The free semigroup time contribution is studied in the context of the Born rule.
The approximations of classical mechanics resulting from quantum mechanics are richer than a correspondence of classical dynamical variables with self-adjoint Hilbert space operators. Assertion that classical dynamic variables correspond to self-adjoint Hilbert space operators is disputable and sets unnatural limits on quantum mechanics. Well known examples of classical dynamical variables not associated with self-adjoint Hilbert space operators are discussed as a motivation for the realizations of quantum field theory that lack Hermitian field operators but exhibit interaction.