Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Discrete Dynamics in Nature and Society

Microscopic irreversibility

Karl Gustafson

Published Jan 1, 2004• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

First, I will recount the substance of several important conversations I had with Ilya Prigogine over the years. There is no doubt in my mind that Professor Prigogine firmly believed in the underlying stochasticity of the universe. Second, I will summarize my curiosity about the principle of detailed balance. In my opinion, so far it has always been put in by hand. Third, I will advance my own theory of microscopic irreversibility, that is, irreversibility at the quantum level. This involves new concepts of probability preference and probability violation. A manifestation of this irreversibility may be seen during emission of bound‐free photons during field‐matter interactions. Entropy increase is tied to radiation increase, and the notion of heat bath becomes light bath.

DOI
10.1155/s1026022604310034

Related papers

Quantum statistical mechanics, extended

William C. Schieve, Lawrence Paul Horwitz

Intrinsic theory of irreversibility In connection with the previous chapter on Wigner–Weisskopf, quantum irreversibility, Gamov states and the Lax–Phillips theory of decay, we shall examine the recent program in statistical mechanics carried forward by Ilya Prigogine and his colleagues since his early book in 1962 (Prigogine, 1962). This discussion is somewhat out of the focus of the present book, since the work to be discussed has principally been devoted to isolated quantum systems, not those in interaction with “reservoirs.” In addition, Prigogine's work is very classical in its content. We shall not attempt the task of reviewing the many changes that have taken place between 1962 and the present. Fine texts describing some of this work are those of Balescu (1963, 1975). A recent critical overview of the “modern view” is in the unpublished thesis of B. C. Bishop of the University of Texas Philosophy Department (Bishop, 1999). In many ways this is related to the use of Gel'fand triplets (Gel'fand and Vilenkin, 1968), mentioned in Chapter 17.6, to describe irreversible quantum states, i.e. Gamov states. See Chapter 17, the book of Bohm and Gadella (1989) and also the more recent review article by Bohm and colleagues (Bohm et al. , 1997). The object in statistical mechanics is to extend the range of the Liouville operator (classical and quantum) such that its eigenvalues are complex and intrinsically irreversible. Statistical mechanics has always been focused on many particle systems and the appearance of a continuum spectrum in the thermodynamic limit, already used in many places in this book. In the classical case Antoniou and Tasaki carried out the adaptation of the Gel'fand triplet approach to the Liouville operator, but this is, apparently, not possible quantum mechanically (Antoniou and Tasaki, 1993). Thus, another route must be taken in what Prigogine has termed, for emphasis, “large Poincaré systems” which have a continuum spectrum (Prigogine, 1997).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 16, 2009•0 citations

If EM waves don't interfere, what causes interferograms?

Stanley J. Wellard

Photonics engineers involved in designing and operating Fourier transform spectrometers (FTS) often rely on Maxwell’s wave equations and time-frequency (distance-wavenumber) Fourier theory as models to understand and predict the conversion of optical energy to electrical signals in their instruments. Dr. Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri and his colleagues, at last year’s conference, presented three significant concepts that might completely change the way we comprehend the interaction of light and matter and the way interference information is generated. The first concept is his non-interaction of waves (NIW) formulation, which puts in place an optical wave description that more accurately describe the properties of the finite time and spatial signals of an optical system. The second is a new description for the cosmic EM environment that recognizes that space is really filled with the ether of classical electromagnetics. The third concept is a new metaphysics or metaphotonics that compares the photon as a particle in a void against the photon as a wave in a medium to see which best explain the twelve different aspects of light. Dr. Henry Lindner presents a compelling case that photons are waves in a medium and particles (electrons, protons, atoms) are wave-structures embedded in the new ether. Discussion of the three new principles is intended to increase the curiosity of photonics engineers to investigate these changes in the nature of light and matter.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Oct 24, 2012•0 citations

A novel extension of Quantum Mechanics: Entropy, Irreversibility, and the Quantum-Classical Transition

Palemkota Maithresh

•Mar 19, 2026•0 citations

A review of recent developments in quantum thermodynamics and a proposal for redefining entropy as a process, to facilitate reconciling quantum mechanics and relativity

S.J. Palmer

Journal of Biological Physics and Chemistry•Jun 30, 2022•1 citation

A solution of the time paradox of physics

Grit Kalies

Abstract Quantum mechanics for describing the behavior of microscopic entities and thermodynamics for describing macroscopic systems exhibit separate time concepts. Whereas many theories of modern physics interpret processes as reversible, in thermodynamics, an expression for irreversibility and the so-called time arrow has been developed: the increase of entropy. The divergence between complete reversibility on the one hand and irreversibility on the other is called the paradox of time. Since more than hundred years many efforts have been devoted to unify the time concepts. So far, the efforts were not successful. In this paper a solution is proposed on the basis of matter-energy equivalence with an energetic distinction between matter and mass. By refraining from interpretations predominant in modern theoretical physics, the first and second laws of thermodynamics can be extended to fundamental laws of nature, which are also valid at quantum level.

Zeitschrift für Physikalische Chemie•Aug 31, 2020•6 citations

My God, He Plays Dice! How Albert Einstein Invented Most Of Quantum Mechanics

Bob Doyle

Is it possible that the most famous critic of quantum mechanics actually invented most of its fundamentally important concepts? In his 1905 Brownian motion paper, Einstein quantized matter, proving the existence of atoms. His light quantum hypothesis showed that energy itself comes in particles (photons). He showed energy and matter are interchangeable, E = mc2. In 1905 Einstein was first to see nonlocality and instantaneous action-at-a-distance. In 1907 he saw quantum “jumps” between energy levels in matter, six years before Bohr postulated them in his atomic model. Einstein saw wave-particle duality and the “collapse” of the wave in 1909. And in 1916 his transition probabilities for emission and absorption processes introduced ontological chance when matter and radiation interact, making quantum mechanics statistical. He discovered the indistinguishability and odd quantum statistics of elementary particles in 1925 and in 1935 speculated about the nonseparability of interacting identical particles. It took physicists over twenty years to accept Einstein’s light-quantum. He explained the relation of particles to waves fifteen years before Heisenberg matrices and Schrödinger wave functions. He saw indeterminism ten years before the uncertainty principle. And he saw nonlocality as early as 1905, presenting it formally in 1927, but was ignored. In the 1935 Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paper, he explored nonseparability, which was dubbed “entanglement” by Schrödinger. The EPR paper has gone from being irrelevant to Einstein’s most cited work and the basis for today’s “second revolution in quantum mechanics.” In a radical revision of the history of quantum physics, Bob Doyle develops Einstein’s idea of objective reality to resolve several of today’s most puzzling quantum mysteries, including the two-slit experiment, quantum entanglement, and microscopic irreversibility.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations
First, I will recount the substance of several important conversations I had with Ilya Prigogine over the years. There is no doubt in my mind that Professor Prigogine firmly believed in the underlying stochasticity of the universe. Second, I will summarize my curiosity about the principle of detailed balance. In my opinion, so far it has always been put in by hand. Third, I will advance my own theory of microscopic irreversibility, that is, irreversibility at the quantum level. This involves new concepts of probability preference and probability violation. A manifestation of this irreversibility may be seen during emission of bound‐free photons during field‐matter interactions. Entropy increase is tied to radiation increase, and the notion of heat bath becomes light bath.
Intrinsic theory of irreversibility In connection with the previous chapter on Wigner–Weisskopf, quantum irreversibility, Gamov states and the Lax–Phillips theory of decay, we shall examine the recent program in statistical mechanics carried forward by Ilya Prigogine and his colleagues since his early book in 1962 (Prigogine, 1962). This discussion is somewhat out of the focus of the present book, since the work to be discussed has principally been devoted to isolated quantum systems, not those in interaction with “reservoirs.” In addition, Prigogine's work is very classical in its content. We shall not attempt the task of reviewing the many changes that have taken place between 1962 and the present. Fine texts describing some of this work are those of Balescu (1963, 1975). A recent critical overview of the “modern view” is in the unpublished thesis of B. C. Bishop of the University of Texas Philosophy Department (Bishop, 1999). In many ways this is related to the use of Gel'fand triplets (Gel'fand and Vilenkin, 1968), mentioned in Chapter 17.6, to describe irreversible quantum states, i.e. Gamov states. See Chapter 17, the book of Bohm and Gadella (1989) and also the more recent review article by Bohm and colleagues (Bohm et al. , 1997). The object in statistical mechanics is to extend the range of the Liouville operator (classical and quantum) such that its eigenvalues are complex and intrinsically irreversible. Statistical mechanics has always been focused on many particle systems and the appearance of a continuum spectrum in the thermodynamic limit, already used in many places in this book. In the classical case Antoniou and Tasaki carried out the adaptation of the Gel'fand triplet approach to the Liouville operator, but this is, apparently, not possible quantum mechanically (Antoniou and Tasaki, 1993). Thus, another route must be taken in what Prigogine has termed, for emphasis, “large Poincaré systems” which have a continuum spectrum (Prigogine, 1997).
Photonics engineers involved in designing and operating Fourier transform spectrometers (FTS) often rely on Maxwell’s wave equations and time-frequency (distance-wavenumber) Fourier theory as models to understand and predict the conversion of optical energy to electrical signals in their instruments. Dr. Chandrasekhar Roychoudhuri and his colleagues, at last year’s conference, presented three significant concepts that might completely change the way we comprehend the interaction of light and matter and the way interference information is generated. The first concept is his non-interaction of waves (NIW) formulation, which puts in place an optical wave description that more accurately describe the properties of the finite time and spatial signals of an optical system. The second is a new description for the cosmic EM environment that recognizes that space is really filled with the ether of classical electromagnetics. The third concept is a new metaphysics or metaphotonics that compares the photon as a particle in a void against the photon as a wave in a medium to see which best explain the twelve different aspects of light. Dr. Henry Lindner presents a compelling case that photons are waves in a medium and particles (electrons, protons, atoms) are wave-structures embedded in the new ether. Discussion of the three new principles is intended to increase the curiosity of photonics engineers to investigate these changes in the nature of light and matter.
Abstract Quantum mechanics for describing the behavior of microscopic entities and thermodynamics for describing macroscopic systems exhibit separate time concepts. Whereas many theories of modern physics interpret processes as reversible, in thermodynamics, an expression for irreversibility and the so-called time arrow has been developed: the increase of entropy. The divergence between complete reversibility on the one hand and irreversibility on the other is called the paradox of time. Since more than hundred years many efforts have been devoted to unify the time concepts. So far, the efforts were not successful. In this paper a solution is proposed on the basis of matter-energy equivalence with an energetic distinction between matter and mass. By refraining from interpretations predominant in modern theoretical physics, the first and second laws of thermodynamics can be extended to fundamental laws of nature, which are also valid at quantum level.
Is it possible that the most famous critic of quantum mechanics actually invented most of its fundamentally important concepts? In his 1905 Brownian motion paper, Einstein quantized matter, proving the existence of atoms. His light quantum hypothesis showed that energy itself comes in particles (photons). He showed energy and matter are interchangeable, E = mc2. In 1905 Einstein was first to see nonlocality and instantaneous action-at-a-distance. In 1907 he saw quantum “jumps” between energy levels in matter, six years before Bohr postulated them in his atomic model. Einstein saw wave-particle duality and the “collapse” of the wave in 1909. And in 1916 his transition probabilities for emission and absorption processes introduced ontological chance when matter and radiation interact, making quantum mechanics statistical. He discovered the indistinguishability and odd quantum statistics of elementary particles in 1925 and in 1935 speculated about the nonseparability of interacting identical particles. It took physicists over twenty years to accept Einstein’s light-quantum. He explained the relation of particles to waves fifteen years before Heisenberg matrices and Schrödinger wave functions. He saw indeterminism ten years before the uncertainty principle. And he saw nonlocality as early as 1905, presenting it formally in 1927, but was ignored. In the 1935 Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paper, he explored nonseparability, which was dubbed “entanglement” by Schrödinger. The EPR paper has gone from being irrelevant to Einstein’s most cited work and the basis for today’s “second revolution in quantum mechanics.” In a radical revision of the history of quantum physics, Bob Doyle develops Einstein’s idea of objective reality to resolve several of today’s most puzzling quantum mysteries, including the two-slit experiment, quantum entanglement, and microscopic irreversibility.