Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)

Critical velocity and dissipation of an ultracold Bose-Fermi counterflow

Marion Delehaye, Sébastien Laurent, Igor Ferrier-Barbut, Frédéric Chevy, Christophe Salomon

Published Jun 1, 2017• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Summary form only given. Superfluidity is amongst the most impressive macroscopic manifestations of quantum behavior. Frictionless flow has been observed in several low-temperature quantum systems, such as liquid helium [1, 2], or more recently ultracold gases [3-5]. Several hallmarks of superfluidity such as critical velocity, quantized vortices, and second sound have been observed [6-11], in both liquid helium and ultracold gases, and in both Bose and Fermi systems.Here, we use the high level of tunability offered by ultracold gases to control their interactions and obtain a double Bose-Fermi superfluid of fermionic 6Li and bosonic ,Li. We have typically Nf = 3.5 . 105 fermionic atoms and Nb = 4 . 104 bosonic atoms at a temperature of about 100 nK, which is below the critical temperature for superfluidity for both the Bose and the Fermi cloud [13].

DOI
10.1109/cleoe-eqec.2017.8087445

Related papers

Critical Velocity and Dissipation of an Ultracold Bose-Fermi Counterflow

Marion Delehaye, Sébastien Laurent, Igor Ferrier-Barbut +3 more

We study the dynamics of counterflowing bosonic and fermionic lithium atoms. First, by tuning the interaction strength we measure the critical velocity v(c) of the system in the BEC-BCS crossover in the low temperature regime and we compare it to the recent prediction of Castin et al., C. R. Phys. 16, 241 (2015). Second, raising the temperature of the mixture slightly above the superfluid transitions reveals an unexpected phase locking of the oscillations of the clouds induced by dissipation.

arXiv:1510.06709•Physical Review Letters•Dec 23, 2015•99 citations

Second sound and the superfluid fraction in a resonantly interacting Fermi gas

Leonid A. Sidorenkov, Meng Khoon Tey, Rudolf Grimm +3 more

Superfluidity is a macroscopic quantum phenomenon, which shows up below a critical temperature and leads to a peculiar behavior of matter, with frictionless flow, the formation of quantized vortices, and the quenching of the moment of inertia being intriguing examples. A remarkable explanation for many phenomena exhibited by a superfluid at finite temperature can be given in terms of a two-fluid mixture comprised of a normal component that behaves like a usual fluid and a superfluid component with zero viscosity and zero entropy. Important examples of superfluid systems are liquid helium and neutron stars. More recently, ultracold atomic gases have emerged as new superfluid systems with unprecedented possibilities to control interactions and external confinement. Here we report the first observation of `second sound' in an ultracold Fermi gas with resonant interactions. Second sound is a striking manifestation of the two-component nature of a superfluid and corresponds to an entropy wave, where the superfluid and the non-superfluid components oscillate in opposite phase, different from ordinary sound (`first sound'), where they oscillate in phase. The speed of second sound depends explicitly on the value of the superfluid fraction, a quantity sensitive to the spectrum of elementary excitations. Our measurements allow us to extract the temperature dependence of the superfluid fraction, which in strongly interacting quantum gases has been an inaccessible quantity so far.

arXiv:1302.2871•Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Feb 12, 2013•1 citation

Mixtures of Bose and Fermi Superfluids

Igor Ferrier-Barbut

Manifestations of Quantum Physics at the thermodynamical level are found in a broadrange of physical systems. A famous example is superfluidity, discovered at the beginningof the 20th century and found in many different situations, from liquid helium to neutronstars. Dilute ultracold gases offer a unique versatility to engineer quantum many-bodysystems, which can be directly compared with theory thanks to the controllability of theirenvironment. In this thesis we present several experimental investigations led on ultracoldlithium gases. Lithium provides the possibility to study ensembles of bosons andfermions, with controllable interactions between the constituents. We present experimentaltechniques for preparation and studies of degenerate gases of lithium, with prospects forimprovement of the existing methods. We first report on an investigation of three-bodyrecombination of bosons under a resonant two-body interaction. This study, quantitativelycompared with theory constitutes a benchmark for further studies of the unitary Bose gas.Finally, we present the first experimental realization of a mixture of a Bose superfluid witha Fermi superfluid. We demon- strate that both components are in the superfluid regime,and that the counter-flow motion between them possesses the characteristics of superfluidflow, with the absence of viscosity below a critical velocity, and an onset of friction above.Using collective oscillations of the mixture, we measure the coupling between the twosuperfluids in close agreement with a theoretical model.

•Oct 31, 2014•0 citations

A mixture of Bose and Fermi superfluids

Igor Ferrier-Barbut, Marion Delehaye, Sébastien Laurent +5 more

Superconductivity and superfluidity of fermionic and bosonic systems are remarkable many-body quantum phenomena. In liquid helium and dilute gases, Bose and Fermi superfluidity has been observed separately, but producing a mixture in which both the fermionic and the bosonic components are superfluid is challenging. Here we report on the observation of such a mixture with dilute gases of two lithium isotopes, lithium-6 and lithium-7. We probe the collective dynamics of this system by exciting center-of-mass oscillations that exhibit extremely low damping below a certain critical velocity. Using high-precision spectroscopy of these modes, we observe coherent energy exchange and measure the coupling between the two superfluids. Our observations can be captured theoretically using a sum-rule approach that we interpret in terms of two coupled oscillators.

arXiv:1404.2548•Science•Jul 18, 2014•293 citations

Observing second sound in ultracold Fermi gases

Li You

Water flowing down a pipe experiences viscous drag that causes it to lose energy and slow down. A superfluid, such as liquid helium (3He and 4He) or electrons in a superconductor, can flow without friction when in contact with a wall. This fascinating phenomenon, or superfluidity, was discovered by Kapitza [1], Allen and Misener [2] in 1937. The formation of a superfluid is related to the formation of a Bose--Einstein condensate (BEC). 4He is a boson as its total spin is zero, an integer. Condensation in fermionic 3He liquid occurs through composite bosons of paired atoms in a process similar to electron pairing in a superconductor. To explain the peculiar properties of superfluid helium, Landau considered a superfluid to be comprised of two parts: a ‘pure’ superfluid component with zero entropy and viscosity, and a normal component that behaves like ordinary fluid. An interesting manifestation of this two-fluid model is the existence of two types of oscillations, the ‘first and second sounds’ as named by Landau. The ‘first sound’ is a wave that propagates at constant entropy per particle, just like sounds in ordinary fluids. It propagates with pressure and density oscillations. ‘Second sound’, unlike what its name suggests, is not audible as it propagates at nearly constant pressure (isobaric oscillation). Here, entropy density takes the role of pressure/density in normal sound waves. Historically, the observation of the second sound in superfluid helium, and the measurement of its speed, played a crucial role in understanding the nature of superfluid helium. The speed of the second sound can be used to determine the superfluid fraction, i.e. the ratio of the superfluid density to the total fluid density [3,4]. In the past decades, the field of ultracold atomic gases has developed into a fertile ground for studying superfluid physics, as the inter-particle interactions between two atoms can be tuned using the so-called Fano–Feshbach resonances. Systematic studies on Fermi gases can be preformed in the limit of strong interactions, whose properties are difficult to predict but important to the understanding of strongly correlated quantum systems of many particles, such as high-temperature superconductors, quark–gluon plasmas and neutron stars. Quantitative determination of the superfluid fraction in strongly interacting Fermi gases has been an elusive goal of scientists for many years, as the methods that allow the determination of the superfluid fraction in liquid helium cannot be directly applied to ultracold gases. For example, to excite the second sound in liquid helium, a local heat pulse can be created by passing a current through a heating wire submersed in the liquid. The heat pulse can then be detected at the other end of the liquid using a temperature sensitive sensor as illustrated in Fig. 1(a). Such methods cannot be implemented with ultracold atomic gas ensembles that typically contain only about hundreds of thousand atoms at μK (1 millionth of a kelvin) temperatures. Further adding to the difficulties, the propagation of the second sound in liquid helium usually involves no density variation/oscillation. This means that the second sound could not be detected easily with the absorption imaging technique typically used for probing cold atoms, assuming that the strongly interacting Fermi gases behave very much like strongly interacting bosonic liquid helium (4He). (a) Excitation and detection of the second sound in superfluid helium; (b) local heating through the power modulation of an excitation laser beam; (c) the detection of the second sound in a strongly interacting Fermi gas with direct absorption imaging. Recently, the group of Professor Rudolf Grimm from the University of Innsbruck (Austria), in collaboration with a theoretical team from the Trento University (Italy) led by Professors Sandro Stringari and Lev Pitaevskii, successfully measured the speed of second sound in a resonantly interacting Fermi gas using a simple and elegant method. Their results were published in [5]. To observe the second sound, the authors created a local heat pulse at the center of an elongated trapped gas by creating a short burst of modulation to the power of a light beam intercepting this gas (see Fig. 1b). They then measured the speed of the second sound by observing the movement of a thermal-induced density dip along the elongated gas (Fig. 1c). Taking advantage of the inhomogeneous density distributions of the superfluid atoms in the trap, they ingeniously determined the temperature dependence of the superfluid fraction without needing to vary the temperature of the samples. The observation of the second sound in the strongly interacting Fermi gases opens up a new horizon for studying the superfluid properties with tunable interactions. Knowing the speed of second sound can provide a lot of valuable information, allowing physicists working on many-body theories to falsify their models and theories. It demonstrates the importance of using experimentally measured quantities, such as the equation of state employed here, to calibrate and to supplement theoretical investigations. Significant new advances will follow in the understanding of superfluidity of many strongly interacting particles, where faithful theoretical modeling and calculations are impossible at the microscopic level.

National Science Review•Dec 6, 2013•1 citation

Superfluidity of Bose—Einstein condensates in ultracold atomic gases

Qi-Zhong Zhu, Biao Wu

Liquid helium 4 had been the only bosonic superfluid available in experiments for a long time. This situation was changed in 1995, when a new superfluid was born with the realization of the Bose–Einstein condensation in ultracold atomic gases. The liquid helium 4 is strongly interacting and has no spin; there is almost no way to change its parameters, such as interaction strength and density. The new superfluid, Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC), offers various advantages over liquid helium. On the one hand, BEC is weakly interacting and has spin degrees of freedom. On the other hand, it is convenient to tune almost all the parameters of a BEC, for example, the kinetic energy by spin–orbit coupling, the density by the external potential, and the interaction by Feshbach resonance. Great efforts have been devoted to studying these new aspects, and the results have greatly enriched our understanding of superfluidity. Here we review these developments by focusing on the stability and critical velocity of various superfluids. The BEC systems considered include a uniform superfluid in free space, a superfluid with its density periodically modulated, a superfluid with artificially engineered spin–orbit coupling, and a superfluid of pure spin current. Due to the weak interaction, these BEC systems can be well described by the mean-field Gross–Pitaevskii theory and their superfluidity, in particular critical velocities, can be examined with the aid of Bogoliubov excitations. Experimental proposals to observe these new aspects of superfluidity are discussed.

arXiv:1501.04153•Chinese Physics B•Apr 30, 2015•14 citations
Summary form only given. Superfluidity is amongst the most impressive macroscopic manifestations of quantum behavior. Frictionless flow has been observed in several low-temperature quantum systems, such as liquid helium [1, 2], or more recently ultracold gases [3-5]. Several hallmarks of superfluidity such as critical velocity, quantized vortices, and second sound have been observed [6-11], in both liquid helium and ultracold gases, and in both Bose and Fermi systems.Here, we use the high level of tunability offered by ultracold gases to control their interactions and obtain a double Bose-Fermi superfluid of fermionic 6Li and bosonic ,Li. We have typically Nf = 3.5 . 105 fermionic atoms and Nb = 4 . 104 bosonic atoms at a temperature of about 100 nK, which is below the critical temperature for superfluidity for both the Bose and the Fermi cloud [13].
Superfluidity is a macroscopic quantum phenomenon, which shows up below a critical temperature and leads to a peculiar behavior of matter, with frictionless flow, the formation of quantized vortices, and the quenching of the moment of inertia being intriguing examples. A remarkable explanation for many phenomena exhibited by a superfluid at finite temperature can be given in terms of a two-fluid mixture comprised of a normal component that behaves like a usual fluid and a superfluid component with zero viscosity and zero entropy. Important examples of superfluid systems are liquid helium and neutron stars. More recently, ultracold atomic gases have emerged as new superfluid systems with unprecedented possibilities to control interactions and external confinement. Here we report the first observation of `second sound' in an ultracold Fermi gas with resonant interactions. Second sound is a striking manifestation of the two-component nature of a superfluid and corresponds to an entropy wave, where the superfluid and the non-superfluid components oscillate in opposite phase, different from ordinary sound (`first sound'), where they oscillate in phase. The speed of second sound depends explicitly on the value of the superfluid fraction, a quantity sensitive to the spectrum of elementary excitations. Our measurements allow us to extract the temperature dependence of the superfluid fraction, which in strongly interacting quantum gases has been an inaccessible quantity so far.
Manifestations of Quantum Physics at the thermodynamical level are found in a broadrange of physical systems. A famous example is superfluidity, discovered at the beginningof the 20th century and found in many different situations, from liquid helium to neutronstars. Dilute ultracold gases offer a unique versatility to engineer quantum many-bodysystems, which can be directly compared with theory thanks to the controllability of theirenvironment. In this thesis we present several experimental investigations led on ultracoldlithium gases. Lithium provides the possibility to study ensembles of bosons andfermions, with controllable interactions between the constituents. We present experimentaltechniques for preparation and studies of degenerate gases of lithium, with prospects forimprovement of the existing methods. We first report on an investigation of three-bodyrecombination of bosons under a resonant two-body interaction. This study, quantitativelycompared with theory constitutes a benchmark for further studies of the unitary Bose gas.Finally, we present the first experimental realization of a mixture of a Bose superfluid witha Fermi superfluid. We demon- strate that both components are in the superfluid regime,and that the counter-flow motion between them possesses the characteristics of superfluidflow, with the absence of viscosity below a critical velocity, and an onset of friction above.Using collective oscillations of the mixture, we measure the coupling between the twosuperfluids in close agreement with a theoretical model.
Superconductivity and superfluidity of fermionic and bosonic systems are remarkable many-body quantum phenomena. In liquid helium and dilute gases, Bose and Fermi superfluidity has been observed separately, but producing a mixture in which both the fermionic and the bosonic components are superfluid is challenging. Here we report on the observation of such a mixture with dilute gases of two lithium isotopes, lithium-6 and lithium-7. We probe the collective dynamics of this system by exciting center-of-mass oscillations that exhibit extremely low damping below a certain critical velocity. Using high-precision spectroscopy of these modes, we observe coherent energy exchange and measure the coupling between the two superfluids. Our observations can be captured theoretically using a sum-rule approach that we interpret in terms of two coupled oscillators.
Water flowing down a pipe experiences viscous drag that causes it to lose energy and slow down. A superfluid, such as liquid helium (3He and 4He) or electrons in a superconductor, can flow without friction when in contact with a wall. This fascinating phenomenon, or superfluidity, was discovered by Kapitza [1], Allen and Misener [2] in 1937. The formation of a superfluid is related to the formation of a Bose--Einstein condensate (BEC). 4He is a boson as its total spin is zero, an integer. Condensation in fermionic 3He liquid occurs through composite bosons of paired atoms in a process similar to electron pairing in a superconductor. To explain the peculiar properties of superfluid helium, Landau considered a superfluid to be comprised of two parts: a ‘pure’ superfluid component with zero entropy and viscosity, and a normal component that behaves like ordinary fluid. An interesting manifestation of this two-fluid model is the existence of two types of oscillations, the ‘first and second sounds’ as named by Landau. The ‘first sound’ is a wave that propagates at constant entropy per particle, just like sounds in ordinary fluids. It propagates with pressure and density oscillations. ‘Second sound’, unlike what its name suggests, is not audible as it propagates at nearly constant pressure (isobaric oscillation). Here, entropy density takes the role of pressure/density in normal sound waves. Historically, the observation of the second sound in superfluid helium, and the measurement of its speed, played a crucial role in understanding the nature of superfluid helium. The speed of the second sound can be used to determine the superfluid fraction, i.e. the ratio of the superfluid density to the total fluid density [3,4]. In the past decades, the field of ultracold atomic gases has developed into a fertile ground for studying superfluid physics, as the inter-particle interactions between two atoms can be tuned using the so-called Fano–Feshbach resonances. Systematic studies on Fermi gases can be preformed in the limit of strong interactions, whose properties are difficult to predict but important to the understanding of strongly correlated quantum systems of many particles, such as high-temperature superconductors, quark–gluon plasmas and neutron stars. Quantitative determination of the superfluid fraction in strongly interacting Fermi gases has been an elusive goal of scientists for many years, as the methods that allow the determination of the superfluid fraction in liquid helium cannot be directly applied to ultracold gases. For example, to excite the second sound in liquid helium, a local heat pulse can be created by passing a current through a heating wire submersed in the liquid. The heat pulse can then be detected at the other end of the liquid using a temperature sensitive sensor as illustrated in Fig. 1(a). Such methods cannot be implemented with ultracold atomic gas ensembles that typically contain only about hundreds of thousand atoms at μK (1 millionth of a kelvin) temperatures. Further adding to the difficulties, the propagation of the second sound in liquid helium usually involves no density variation/oscillation. This means that the second sound could not be detected easily with the absorption imaging technique typically used for probing cold atoms, assuming that the strongly interacting Fermi gases behave very much like strongly interacting bosonic liquid helium (4He). (a) Excitation and detection of the second sound in superfluid helium; (b) local heating through the power modulation of an excitation laser beam; (c) the detection of the second sound in a strongly interacting Fermi gas with direct absorption imaging. Recently, the group of Professor Rudolf Grimm from the University of Innsbruck (Austria), in collaboration with a theoretical team from the Trento University (Italy) led by Professors Sandro Stringari and Lev Pitaevskii, successfully measured the speed of second sound in a resonantly interacting Fermi gas using a simple and elegant method. Their results were published in [5]. To observe the second sound, the authors created a local heat pulse at the center of an elongated trapped gas by creating a short burst of modulation to the power of a light beam intercepting this gas (see Fig. 1b). They then measured the speed of the second sound by observing the movement of a thermal-induced density dip along the elongated gas (Fig. 1c). Taking advantage of the inhomogeneous density distributions of the superfluid atoms in the trap, they ingeniously determined the temperature dependence of the superfluid fraction without needing to vary the temperature of the samples. The observation of the second sound in the strongly interacting Fermi gases opens up a new horizon for studying the superfluid properties with tunable interactions. Knowing the speed of second sound can provide a lot of valuable information, allowing physicists working on many-body theories to falsify their models and theories. It demonstrates the importance of using experimentally measured quantities, such as the equation of state employed here, to calibrate and to supplement theoretical investigations. Significant new advances will follow in the understanding of superfluidity of many strongly interacting particles, where faithful theoretical modeling and calculations are impossible at the microscopic level.
Liquid helium 4 had been the only bosonic superfluid available in experiments for a long time. This situation was changed in 1995, when a new superfluid was born with the realization of the Bose–Einstein condensation in ultracold atomic gases. The liquid helium 4 is strongly interacting and has no spin; there is almost no way to change its parameters, such as interaction strength and density. The new superfluid, Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC), offers various advantages over liquid helium. On the one hand, BEC is weakly interacting and has spin degrees of freedom. On the other hand, it is convenient to tune almost all the parameters of a BEC, for example, the kinetic energy by spin–orbit coupling, the density by the external potential, and the interaction by Feshbach resonance. Great efforts have been devoted to studying these new aspects, and the results have greatly enriched our understanding of superfluidity. Here we review these developments by focusing on the stability and critical velocity of various superfluids. The BEC systems considered include a uniform superfluid in free space, a superfluid with its density periodically modulated, a superfluid with artificially engineered spin–orbit coupling, and a superfluid of pure spin current. Due to the weak interaction, these BEC systems can be well described by the mean-field Gross–Pitaevskii theory and their superfluidity, in particular critical velocities, can be examined with the aid of Bogoliubov excitations. Experimental proposals to observe these new aspects of superfluidity are discussed.