In this chapter, the authors propose the thesis that randomness is unpredictability with respect to an intended theory and measurement. From this point of view, they briefly discuss various forms of randomness that physics, mathematics and computer science have proposed. The authors also discuss biological randomness its peculiar nature and role in ontogenesis and in evolutionary dynamics (phylogenesis). Classical systems are deterministic, yet they may be unpredictable, in the sense that randomness is not in the world nor it is just in the eyes of the beholder, but it pops out at the interface between us and the world by theory and measurement. Quantum randomness is hailed to be more than “epistemic”, that is, “intrinsic”. The authors use sequences to discuss some subtle differences in the quality of randomness.
In this chapter, the authors propose the thesis that randomness is unpredictability with respect to an intended theory and measurement. From this point of view, they briefly discuss various forms of randomness that physics, mathematics and computer science have proposed. The authors also discuss biological randomness its peculiar nature and role in ontogenesis and in evolutionary dynamics (phylogenesis). Classical systems are deterministic, yet they may be unpredictable, in the sense that randomness is not in the world nor it is just in the eyes of the beholder, but it pops out at the interface between us and the world by theory and measurement. Quantum randomness is hailed to be more than “epistemic”, that is, “intrinsic”. The authors use sequences to discuss some subtle differences in the quality of randomness.
The classical deterministic worldview that dominated science from the seventeenth to the nineteenth century has been profoundly challenged by developments in modern physics and biology. Quantum mechanics has revealed that indeterminacy and probability are not merely epistemic limitations, but intrinsic features of physical reality. At the same time, evolutionary biology has shown that random genetic variation, filtered by natural selection, is the fundamental driver of biological diversity and adaptation. This article explores the conceptual parallel between quantum indeterminacy and evolutionary randomness, not as a reduction of biology to physics, but as an epistemological reflection on how stability and order emerge from probabilistic processes across different levels of organization. By examining emergence, contingency, historical irreversibility, and the limits of prediction, the paper argues that determinism is best understood as a scale-dependent approximation rather than a foundational ontological principle. The absence of finality in nature does not imply chaos or nihilism, but invites a renewed philosophical understanding of explanation, responsibility, and scientific humility in a probabilistic universe.
The topic of random numbers is investigated in such a way as to illustrate links between mathematics, physics and computer science. First, the generation of random numbers by a classical computer using the linear congruential generator and logistic map is considered. It is noted that these procedures yield only pseudo-random numbers since deterministic algorithms are used. The paper then discusses the strange behaviour of the quantum world and briefly describes how its properties could be exploited in a quantum computer to produce numbers that are genuinely random. The final section considers how different ways of looking at a problem can yield insights into the concept of randomness.
Quantum mechanics is a physical theory supplying probabilities corresponding to expectation values for measurement outcomes. Indeed, its formalism can be constructed with measurement as a fundamental process, as was done by Schwinger, provided that individual measurements outcomes occur in a random way. The randomness appearing in quantum mechanics, as with other forms of randomness, has often been considered equivalent to a form of indeterminism. Here, it is argued that quantum randomness should instead be understood as a form of unpredictability because, amongst other things, indeterminism is not a necessary condition for randomness. For concreteness, an explication of the randomness of quantum mechanics as the unpredictability of quantum measurement outcomes is provided. Finally, it is shown how this view can be combined with the recently introduced view that the very appearance of individual quantum measurement outcomes can be grounded in the Plenitude principle of Leibniz, a principle variants of which have been utilized in physics by Dirac and Gell‐Mann in relation to the fundamental processes. This move provides further support to Schwinger's “symbolic” derivation of quantum mechanics from measurement.
This paper provides a conceptual analysis of the role of the mathematical continuumversusthe discrete in the understanding of randomness as a notion with a physical meaning or origin. The presentation is ‘informal’ as we will not write formulas; however, we will refer to non-obvious technical results from various scientific domains, and we will also propose a conceptual framework for understanding randomness (and predictability), which we believe is, essentially, original. As a matter of fact, unpredictability and randomness may be conveniently identified in various physico-mathematical contexts. This will allow us to explore these concepts in continuousversusdiscrete frameworks, with particular emphasis on the relationships and differences between classical approaches and quantum theories in Physics.
Quantum Physics is usually defined as a theory that affirms a primary role of randomness and probability. Eleven well-known quantum experiments are examined and the result is the coexistence of both random and causal type behaviour. We need both to describe experiments. Quantum Mechanics states the general overcoming of causality and this statement constitutes an unlimited generalization, not supported by experience. Determinism and indeterminism are philosophical systems, that universalize causality or chance. The crucial point is the difference between epistemic and intrinsic randomness. In the first aspect, randomness does not have a fundamental meaning, in the second, randomness of the individual event is explained, but the detection of high stable regularities remains to be explained. The article addresses the question of entanglement and various aspects of probability theory, including the law of large numbers, arriving at the thesis that many relevant questions are unresolved. A causal description is in quantum mechanics impossible in principle, given its assumptions. In order not to contradict experience, both points of view are necessary, causal and random. This is the state of the research, to return to and start again from.
In this thesis we study the generation of randomness from quantum mechanical sources: quantum random number generators (QRNGs). Such devices are thought to provide a better quality of randomness than is possible with classical devices, but the issue is in need of more rigorous study. In Chapter 1 we provide the necessary background for the thesis from both computability and probability theory. We then present and extend some recent results providing a more theoretical grounding for the indeterminism in quantum mechanics. In particular, we show that sequences of quantum random bits are incomputable in the strongest sense: no bit can be provably computed in advance. In Chapter 2 we study in detail the use of von Neumann normalisation for QRNGs producing both finite strings and infinite sequences of bits; such normalisation methods are necessary in order to counter for experimental imperfections. We show that, in the case of a constantly biased source, this normalisation gives the desired uniform distribution. The effect of this normalisation on the (in)computability of the generated sequences is studied, and it is shown that algorithmic randomness and Borel normality are preserved, but e-randomness (and thus incomputability) is, in general, not. Experimental bounds for the extent of departure from the uniform distribution in the non-ideal case of a slowly drifting bias are derived. In Chapter 3 we propose a new QRNG which uses entangled photon pairs and is certified to produce incomputable bits by value indefiniteness; this is the first QRNG with explicit certification by a physical principle. The effects of various experimental imperfections are discussed in detail, and care is taken to make the proposed QRNG as robust as is possible to these. A robust method based on XORing the produced bitstrings together is proposed to further improve the quality of the distribution produced by the QRNG. Various improvements and optimisations to this scheme are discussed.