Mermin habitually answers opinions, real and abstract

Fletcher J. Goldin

Amin N. Dharamsi

(First paragraph) Because QFT is so neglected by the public (and by many physicists), I am writing a book that presents it without equations. A draft copy of the work, The Theory That Escaped Einstein, can be found through an internet search. Feedback is appreciated.

Allen D. Allen

Daniel M. Greenberger, Abner Shimony

A. Burov

David Mermin seems to advocate the view of theoretical paradoxes and controversies of quantum mechanics and field theory as problems of “tools” of a linguistic or otherwise technical nature. His advice is not to “make life harder than it needs to be.” First, philosophical reduction of a fundamental science to a human tool goes against the main quest of science – the quest for objective truth about the universe. Second, the suggested advice seems more conducive to peace of mind than to scientific inquiry. Paradoxes and contradictions have always been a rich source of inspiration and contemplation for those who are seeking new knowledge.© 2009 American Institute of Physics.

Detlef Dürr