© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)

Direct observation of sub-binomial light

Tim J. Bartley, Gaia Donati, Xian‐Min Jin, Animesh Datta, Marco Barbieri, Ian A. Walmsley

Published May 1, 2013• 7 citations

Abstract

Nonclassical states of light are necessary resources for quantum technologies such as cryptography, computation and the definition of metrological standards. Distinguishing nonclassical states from those that can be described without invoking quantum mechanics is both a necessary practical task and of fundamental interest. In general, signatures of nonclassicality arise from apparently pathological behaviour of the quasi-probability distributions used to describe the states. While tomographic reconstruction of the state is therefore sufficient to show nonclassicality, it is often more convenient to probe photon-counting statistics of on-off detectors directly. This is formalised by the Mandel Q-parameter QM= 〈Δn〉 / 〈n〉 - 1, which is negative for sub-Poissonian statistics arising from nonclassical states. However, the Mandel Q-parameter can fail when using a multiplexed array of on-off detectors to measure states with several photons; splitting in this manner can corrupt its original statistics. A new parameter, QB= N 〈(Δ c) 2 〉 / 〈 c 〉 (N - 〈 c 〉) can be used to witness nonclassicality directly from such click statistics. For QB<; 0, such statistics are thus deemed sub-binomial and therefore arise from a nonclassical state.

DOI: 10.1109/cleoe-iqec.2013.6801663

Related papers

Direct Observation of Sub-Binomial Light

Tim J. Bartley, Gaia Donati, Xian‐Min Jin +3 more

Nonclassical states of light are necessary resources for quantum technologies such as cryptography, computation and the definition of metrological standards. Observing signatures of nonclassicality generally requires inferring either the photon number distribution or a quasiprobability distribution indirectly from a set of measurements. Here, we report an experiment in which the nonclassical character of families of quantum states is assessed by direct inspection of the outcomes from a multiplexed photon counter. This scheme does not register the actual photon number distribution; the statistics of the detector clicks alone serve as a witness of nonclassicality, as proposed by Sperling et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 093601 (2012)]. Our work paves a way for the practical characterization of increasingly sophisticated states and detectors.

arXiv:1302.0229•Physical Review Letters•Apr 25, 2013•72 citations

Sub-Binomial Light

Jan Sperling, W. Vogel, G. S. Agarwal

The click statistics from on-off detector systems is quite different from the counting statistics of the more traditional detectors. This necessitates the introduction of new parameters to characterize the nonclassicality of fields from measurements using on-off detectors. To properly replace the Mandel Q(M) parameter, we introduce a parameter Q(B). A negative value represents a sub-binomial statistics. This is possible only for quantum fields, even for super-Poisson light. It eliminates the problems encountered in discerning nonclassicality using Mandel's Q(M) for on-off data.

arXiv:1205.4669•Physical Review Letters•Aug 27, 2012•76 citations

Sub-Poisson-binomial light

Changhyoup Lee, Simone Ferrari, Wolfram H. P. Pernice +1 more

We introduce a general parameter ${Q}_{\mathrm{PB}}$ that provides an experimentally accessible nonclassicality measure for light. The parameter is quantified by the click statistics obtained from on-off detectors in a general multiplexing detection setup. Sub-Poisson-binomial statistics, observed by ${Q}_{\mathrm{PB}}<0$, indicates that a given state of light is nonclassical. Our parameter replaces the binomial parameter ${Q}_{\mathrm{B}}$ for more general cases, where any unbalance among the multiplexed modes is allowed, thus enabling the use of arbitrary multiplexing schemes. The significance of the parameter ${Q}_{\mathrm{PB}}$ is theoretically examined in a measurement setup that only consists of a ring resonator and a single on-off detector. The proposed setup exploits minimal experimental resources and is geared towards a fully integrated quantum nanophotonic circuit. The results show that nonclassical features remain noticeable even in the presence of significant losses, rendering our nonclassicality test more practical and sufficiently flexible to be used in various nanophotonic platforms.

arXiv:1606.04826•Physical Review A•Nov 22, 2016•14 citations

Learning to detect optical nonclassicality

Martina Jung, Suchitra Krishnaswamy, Timon Schapeler +4 more

Nonclassicality, defined in the quantum optical sense, serves as a resource for photon-based quantum technologies. Therefore, certifying the nonclassicality of a quantum state is crucial for gauging its potential for quantum advantage. However, traditional nonclassicality witnesses that assume perfect knowledge of the witness observables often fail in realistic scenarios with limited statistics and finite-resolution photon detectors. Furthermore, these witnesses do not exploit the fact that certain states are unlikely to be observed in a given experiment. Here, we train a variational model to distinguish classical from nonclassical states using finitely many measurement samples of multimode quantum states that are probed with different photon-number-resolving detection schemes. The learned decision rule is then an indicator of nonclassicality, tailored to a given set of physically relevant states. Our approach is both data-driven and interpretable in the sense that the learned analytical decision rule can be extracted. Training the model on experimental data measured with (i) a superconducting nanowire single-photon detector and (ii) a time-bin multiplexing detection scheme demonstrates the versatility of the approach, paving the way for efficient nonclassicality detection.

quant-pharXiv:2603.06319•Mar 9, 2026•0 citations

Measurements with on-off detector systems

Jan Sperling, W. Vogel, G. S. Agarwal

We study systems of on-off detectors. For coherent light, such kinds of measurements reveal a binomial statistics rather than a Poisson one. Hence, nonclassicality may be determined by a sub-binomial click statistics.

The Rochester Conferences on Coherence and Quantum Optics and the Quantum Information and Measurement meeting•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Identification of nonclassical properties of light with multiplexing layouts

Jan Sperling, A. Eckstein, William R. Clements +9 more

, 163602 (2017)], we introduced and applied a detector-independent method to uncover nonclassicality. Here, we extend those techniques and give more details on the performed analysis. We derive a general theory of the positive-operator-valued measure that describes multiplexing layouts with arbitrary detectors. From the resulting quantum version of a multinomial statistics, we infer nonclassicality probes based on a matrix of normally ordered moments. We discuss these criteria and apply the theory to our data which are measured with superconducting transition-edge sensors. Our experiment produces heralded multiphoton states from a parametric down-conversion light source. We show that the known notions of sub-Poisson and sub-binomial light can be deduced from our general approach, and we establish the concept of sub-multinomial light, which is shown to outperform the former two concepts of nonclassicality for our data.

arXiv:1701.07642•Physical Review A•Jul 6, 2017•16 citations

Nonclassical states of light are necessary resources for quantum technologies such as cryptography, computation and the definition of metrological standards. Distinguishing nonclassical states from those that can be described without invoking quantum mechanics is both a necessary practical task and of fundamental interest. In general, signatures of nonclassicality arise from apparently pathological behaviour of the quasi-probability distributions used to describe the states. While tomographic reconstruction of the state is therefore sufficient to show nonclassicality, it is often more convenient to probe photon-counting statistics of on-off detectors directly. This is formalised by the Mandel Q-parameter QM= 〈Δn〉 / 〈n〉 - 1, which is negative for sub-Poissonian statistics arising from nonclassical states. However, the Mandel Q-parameter can fail when using a multiplexed array of on-off detectors to measure states with several photons; splitting in this manner can corrupt its original statistics. A new parameter, QB= N 〈(Δ c) 2 〉 / 〈 c 〉 (N - 〈 c 〉) can be used to witness nonclassicality directly from such click statistics. For QB<; 0, such statistics are thus deemed sub-binomial and therefore arise from a nonclassical state.

Nonclassical states of light are necessary resources for quantum technologies such as cryptography, computation and the definition of metrological standards. Observing signatures of nonclassicality generally requires inferring either the photon number distribution or a quasiprobability distribution indirectly from a set of measurements. Here, we report an experiment in which the nonclassical character of families of quantum states is assessed by direct inspection of the outcomes from a multiplexed photon counter. This scheme does not register the actual photon number distribution; the statistics of the detector clicks alone serve as a witness of nonclassicality, as proposed by Sperling et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 093601 (2012)]. Our work paves a way for the practical characterization of increasingly sophisticated states and detectors.

The click statistics from on-off detector systems is quite different from the counting statistics of the more traditional detectors. This necessitates the introduction of new parameters to characterize the nonclassicality of fields from measurements using on-off detectors. To properly replace the Mandel Q(M) parameter, we introduce a parameter Q(B). A negative value represents a sub-binomial statistics. This is possible only for quantum fields, even for super-Poisson light. It eliminates the problems encountered in discerning nonclassicality using Mandel's Q(M) for on-off data.

We introduce a general parameter

{Q}_{\mathrm{PB}}

that provides an experimentally accessible nonclassicality measure for light. The parameter is quantified by the click statistics obtained from on-off detectors in a general multiplexing detection setup. Sub-Poisson-binomial statistics, observed by

{Q}_{\mathrm{PB}}<0

, indicates that a given state of light is nonclassical. Our parameter replaces the binomial parameter

{Q}_{\mathrm{B}}

for more general cases, where any unbalance among the multiplexed modes is allowed, thus enabling the use of arbitrary multiplexing schemes. The significance of the parameter

{Q}_{\mathrm{PB}}

is theoretically examined in a measurement setup that only consists of a ring resonator and a single on-off detector. The proposed setup exploits minimal experimental resources and is geared towards a fully integrated quantum nanophotonic circuit. The results show that nonclassical features remain noticeable even in the presence of significant losses, rendering our nonclassicality test more practical and sufficiently flexible to be used in various nanophotonic platforms.

Nonclassicality, defined in the quantum optical sense, serves as a resource for photon-based quantum technologies. Therefore, certifying the nonclassicality of a quantum state is crucial for gauging its potential for quantum advantage. However, traditional nonclassicality witnesses that assume perfect knowledge of the witness observables often fail in realistic scenarios with limited statistics and finite-resolution photon detectors. Furthermore, these witnesses do not exploit the fact that certain states are unlikely to be observed in a given experiment. Here, we train a variational model to distinguish classical from nonclassical states using finitely many measurement samples of multimode quantum states that are probed with different photon-number-resolving detection schemes. The learned decision rule is then an indicator of nonclassicality, tailored to a given set of physically relevant states. Our approach is both data-driven and interpretable in the sense that the learned analytical decision rule can be extracted. Training the model on experimental data measured with (i) a superconducting nanowire single-photon detector and (ii) a time-bin multiplexing detection scheme demonstrates the versatility of the approach, paving the way for efficient nonclassicality detection.

, 163602 (2017)], we introduced and applied a detector-independent method to uncover nonclassicality. Here, we extend those techniques and give more details on the performed analysis. We derive a general theory of the positive-operator-valued measure that describes multiplexing layouts with arbitrary detectors. From the resulting quantum version of a multinomial statistics, we infer nonclassicality probes based on a matrix of normally ordered moments. We discuss these criteria and apply the theory to our data which are measured with superconducting transition-edge sensors. Our experiment produces heralded multiphoton states from a parametric down-conversion light source. We show that the known notions of sub-Poisson and sub-binomial light can be deduced from our general approach, and we establish the concept of sub-multinomial light, which is shown to outperform the former two concepts of nonclassicality for our data.