Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Hilbert space shattering and dynamical freezing in the quantum Ising model

Oliver Hart, Rahul Nandkishore

Published Dec 21, 2022• 39 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We discuss quantum dynamics in the transverse field Ising model in two spatial dimensions. We show that, up to a prethermal timescale, which we quantify, the Hilbert space ``shatters'' into dynamically disconnected subsectors. We identify this shattering as originating from the interplay of a $\text{U}(1)$ conservation law and a one-form ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ constraint. We show that the number of dynamically disconnected sectors is exponential in system volume, and includes a subspace exponential in system volume within which the dynamics is exactly localized, even in the absence of quenched disorder. Depending on the emergent sector in which we work, the shattering can be weak (such that typical initial conditions thermalize with respect to their emergent symmetry sector), or strong (such that typical initial conditions exhibit localized dynamics). We present analytical and numerical evidence that a first-order-like ``freezing transition'' between weak and strong shattering occurs as a function of the symmetry sector, in a nonstandard thermodynamic limit. We further numerically show that on the ``weak'' (melted) side of the transition domain wall dynamics follows ordinary diffusion.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.106.214426

Related papers

Hilbert space shattering and dynamical freezing in the quantum Ising model

Hart, Oliver, Rahul Nandkishore

We discuss quantum dynamics in the transverse field Ising model in two spatial dimensions. We show that, up to a prethermal timescale, which we quantify, the Hilbert space 'shatters' into dynamically disconnected subsectors. We identify this shattering as originating from the interplay of a $\mathrm{U}(1)$ conservation law and a one-form $\mathbb{Z}_2$ constraint. We show that the number of dynamically disconnected sectors is exponential in system volume, and includes a subspace exponential in system volume within which the dynamics is exactly localized, even in the absence of quenched disorder. Depending on the emergent sector in which we work, the shattering can be weak (such that typical initial conditions thermalize with respect to their emergent symmetry sector), or strong (such that typical initial conditions exhibit localized dynamics). We present analytical and numerical evidence that a first order-like 'freezing transition' between weak and strong shattering occurs as a function of the symmetry sector, in a non-standard thermodynamic limit. We further numerically show that on the 'weak' (melted) side of the transition domain wall dynamics follows ordinary diffusion.

arXiv:2203.06188•Mar 11, 2022•3 citations

Emergence of Hilbert Space Fragmentation in Ising Models with a Weak Transverse Field

Atsuki Yoshinaga, Hideaki Hakoshima, Takashi Imoto +2 more

The transverse-field Ising model is one of the fundamental models in quantum many-body systems, yet a full understanding of its dynamics remains elusive in higher than one dimension. Here, we show for the first time the breakdown of ergodicity in d-dimensional Ising models with a weak transverse field in a prethermal regime. We demonstrate that novel Hilbert-space fragmentation occurs in the effective nonintegrable model with d≥2 as a consequence of only one emergent global conservation law of the domain wall number. Our results indicate nontrivial initial-state dependence for nonequilibrium dynamics of the Ising models with a weak transverse field.

arXiv:2111.05586•Physical Review Letters•Aug 26, 2022•48 citations

Localization from Hilbert space shattering: From theory to physical realizations

Vedika Khemani, Michael Hermele, Rahul Nandkishore

Known routes to ergodicity breaking -- integrability and many-body localization -- require extensively many explicit or emergent conservation laws. Here we show that two conservation laws are sufficient to provably and robustly break ergodicity by ``shattering'' Hilbert space into exponentially many dynamically disconnected sectors. This represents a new paradigm for localization, which does not rely on disorder or energy conservation, which works in any number of spatial dimensions, and which should be realizable in near-term ultracold atom experiments.

arXiv:1910.01137•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 15, 2020•480 citations

Thermalization in a Height-Conserving Quantum Dimer Model

Junsheng Feng, Jie Ren, Zheng Yan

Strongly constrained quantum systems, in which local rules forbid most configurations, play a central role in condensed matter and lattice gauge theory. Their thermalization is often thought to be delicate: extensive conservation laws and dynamically frozen states can shatter the Hilbert space into many disconnected sectors. A natural question is whether, once the frozen states are removed, the dynamics within a single sector still thermalizes. We address this in the height-conserving quantum dimer model on the square lattice, whose local plaquette flips conserve an emergent height field. Resolving the winding numbers, the four sublattice heights, and lattice momentum , we isolate the dominant connected Krylov component of each fragmented sector and analyze its spectral spectral statistics, entanglement, and connectivity. The two standard chaos diagnostics then show different behavior:across momentum sectors the level-spacing statistics range from near-Poisoon to Wigner-Dyson, yet in every sector the eigenstate entanglement entropy collapses onto a narrow, dome-shaped curve characteristic of eigenstate thermalization. Only a handful of low-entanglement outliers interrupt this thermal pattern, in selected sectors. Thus, strong kinematic constraints can lead to a situation where spectral correlations and eigenstate thermalization need not follow the same universal signatures -- a manifestation of constrained quantum chaos.

arXiv:2607.09580•Jul 10, 2026•0 citations

Hilbert-Space Fragmentation from Strict Confinement

Zhi-Cheng Yang, Fangli Liu, Alexey Vyacheslavovich Gorshkov +1 more

We study one-dimensional spin-1/2 models in which strict confinement of Ising domain walls leads to the fragmentation of Hilbert space into exponentially many disconnected subspaces. Whereas most previous works emphasize dipole moment conservation as an essential ingredient for such fragmentation, we instead require two commuting U(1) conserved quantities associated with the total domain-wall number and the total magnetization. The latter arises naturally from the confinement of domain walls. Remarkably, while some connected components of the Hilbert space thermalize, others are integrable by Bethe ansatz. We further demonstrate how this Hilbert-space fragmentation pattern arises perturbatively in the confining limit of Z_{2} gauge theory coupled to fermionic matter, leading to a hierarchy of timescales for motion of the fermions. This model can be realized experimentally in two complementary settings.

arXiv:1912.04300•Physical Review Letters•May 22, 2020•199 citations

Dissipative dynamical phase transition as a complex Ising model

Stephen W. Yan, Diego Barberena, Matthew P. A. Fisher +1 more

We investigate a quantum dynamical phase transition induced by the competition between local unitary evolution and dissipation in a qubit chain with a strong, on-site $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry. While the steady-state of this evolution is always maximally-mixed, we show that the dynamical behavior of certain non-local observables on the approach to this steady-state is dictated by a quantum Ising model with a complex transverse-field (cTFIM). A crucial feature of our mapping to the cTFIM is an extensive number of local, weak, $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetries possessed by the dynamics, allowing us to investigate these observables analytically and uncover a dynamical phase transition as the relative rate of unitary evolution and dissipation is tuned. We show that the weak-dissipation limit corresponds to a cTFIM with a large magnitude of the imaginary transverse-field, for which the many-body "ground-state" (with smallest real eigenvalue) is gapless, exhibiting quasi-long-range correlations of the local magnetization with a continuously-varying exponent. Correspondingly, the dynamics of the non-local observables show oscillatory behavior with an amplitude decaying exponentially in time. The strong-dissipation limit corresponds to a gapped ferromagnetic phase of the cTFIM, and non-local observables show exponential decay on the approach to equilibrium. This transition in (1+1)-dimensions has a peculiar, "two-sided" nature appearing as either first- or second-order depending on the phase from which the transition is approached, an analytic result which is corroborated by numerical studies. In higher dimensions, we present a field-theoretic understanding of the first-order nature of this transition, when approaching from the ferromagnetic phase of the cTFIM, though the nature of the phase with large imaginary transverse-field remains to be understood.

arXiv:2412.09591•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 28, 2026•0 citations
We discuss quantum dynamics in the transverse field Ising model in two spatial dimensions. We show that, up to a prethermal timescale, which we quantify, the Hilbert space shatters'' into dynamically disconnected subsectors. We identify this shattering as originating from the interplay of a $\text{U}(1)$ conservation law and a one-form ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ constraint. We show that the number of dynamically disconnected sectors is exponential in system volume, and includes a subspace exponential in system volume within which the dynamics is exactly localized, even in the absence of quenched disorder. Depending on the emergent sector in which we work, the shattering can be weak (such that typical initial conditions thermalize with respect to their emergent symmetry sector), or strong (such that typical initial conditions exhibit localized dynamics). We present analytical and numerical evidence that a first-order-like freezing transition'' between weak and strong shattering occurs as a function of the symmetry sector, in a nonstandard thermodynamic limit. We further numerically show that on the ``weak'' (melted) side of the transition domain wall dynamics follows ordinary diffusion.
We discuss quantum dynamics in the transverse field Ising model in two spatial dimensions. We show that, up to a prethermal timescale, which we quantify, the Hilbert space 'shatters' into dynamically disconnected subsectors. We identify this shattering as originating from the interplay of a U(1)\mathrm{U}(1)U(1) conservation law and a one-form Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ constraint. We show that the number of dynamically disconnected sectors is exponential in system volume, and includes a subspace exponential in system volume within which the dynamics is exactly localized, even in the absence of quenched disorder. Depending on the emergent sector in which we work, the shattering can be weak (such that typical initial conditions thermalize with respect to their emergent symmetry sector), or strong (such that typical initial conditions exhibit localized dynamics). We present analytical and numerical evidence that a first order-like 'freezing transition' between weak and strong shattering occurs as a function of the symmetry sector, in a non-standard thermodynamic limit. We further numerically show that on the 'weak' (melted) side of the transition domain wall dynamics follows ordinary diffusion.
The transverse-field Ising model is one of the fundamental models in quantum many-body systems, yet a full understanding of its dynamics remains elusive in higher than one dimension. Here, we show for the first time the breakdown of ergodicity in d-dimensional Ising models with a weak transverse field in a prethermal regime. We demonstrate that novel Hilbert-space fragmentation occurs in the effective nonintegrable model with d≥2 as a consequence of only one emergent global conservation law of the domain wall number. Our results indicate nontrivial initial-state dependence for nonequilibrium dynamics of the Ising models with a weak transverse field.
Known routes to ergodicity breaking -- integrability and many-body localization -- require extensively many explicit or emergent conservation laws. Here we show that two conservation laws are sufficient to provably and robustly break ergodicity by ``shattering'' Hilbert space into exponentially many dynamically disconnected sectors. This represents a new paradigm for localization, which does not rely on disorder or energy conservation, which works in any number of spatial dimensions, and which should be realizable in near-term ultracold atom experiments.
Strongly constrained quantum systems, in which local rules forbid most configurations, play a central role in condensed matter and lattice gauge theory. Their thermalization is often thought to be delicate: extensive conservation laws and dynamically frozen states can shatter the Hilbert space into many disconnected sectors. A natural question is whether, once the frozen states are removed, the dynamics within a single sector still thermalizes. We address this in the height-conserving quantum dimer model on the square lattice, whose local plaquette flips conserve an emergent height field. Resolving the winding numbers, the four sublattice heights, and lattice momentum , we isolate the dominant connected Krylov component of each fragmented sector and analyze its spectral spectral statistics, entanglement, and connectivity. The two standard chaos diagnostics then show different behavior:across momentum sectors the level-spacing statistics range from near-Poisoon to Wigner-Dyson, yet in every sector the eigenstate entanglement entropy collapses onto a narrow, dome-shaped curve characteristic of eigenstate thermalization. Only a handful of low-entanglement outliers interrupt this thermal pattern, in selected sectors. Thus, strong kinematic constraints can lead to a situation where spectral correlations and eigenstate thermalization need not follow the same universal signatures -- a manifestation of constrained quantum chaos.
We study one-dimensional spin-1/2 models in which strict confinement of Ising domain walls leads to the fragmentation of Hilbert space into exponentially many disconnected subspaces. Whereas most previous works emphasize dipole moment conservation as an essential ingredient for such fragmentation, we instead require two commuting U(1) conserved quantities associated with the total domain-wall number and the total magnetization. The latter arises naturally from the confinement of domain walls. Remarkably, while some connected components of the Hilbert space thermalize, others are integrable by Bethe ansatz. We further demonstrate how this Hilbert-space fragmentation pattern arises perturbatively in the confining limit of Z_{2} gauge theory coupled to fermionic matter, leading to a hierarchy of timescales for motion of the fermions. This model can be realized experimentally in two complementary settings.
We investigate a quantum dynamical phase transition induced by the competition between local unitary evolution and dissipation in a qubit chain with a strong, on-site Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ symmetry. While the steady-state of this evolution is always maximally-mixed, we show that the dynamical behavior of certain non-local observables on the approach to this steady-state is dictated by a quantum Ising model with a complex transverse-field (cTFIM). A crucial feature of our mapping to the cTFIM is an extensive number of local, weak, Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ symmetries possessed by the dynamics, allowing us to investigate these observables analytically and uncover a dynamical phase transition as the relative rate of unitary evolution and dissipation is tuned. We show that the weak-dissipation limit corresponds to a cTFIM with a large magnitude of the imaginary transverse-field, for which the many-body "ground-state" (with smallest real eigenvalue) is gapless, exhibiting quasi-long-range correlations of the local magnetization with a continuously-varying exponent. Correspondingly, the dynamics of the non-local observables show oscillatory behavior with an amplitude decaying exponentially in time. The strong-dissipation limit corresponds to a gapped ferromagnetic phase of the cTFIM, and non-local observables show exponential decay on the approach to equilibrium. This transition in (1+1)-dimensions has a peculiar, "two-sided" nature appearing as either first- or second-order depending on the phase from which the transition is approached, an analytic result which is corroborated by numerical studies. In higher dimensions, we present a field-theoretic understanding of the first-order nature of this transition, when approaching from the ferromagnetic phase of the cTFIM, though the nature of the phase with large imaginary transverse-field remains to be understood.