Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

From Schrödinger to Sisyphus

Antti J. Niemi

Published Mar 31, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A Hamiltonian time crystal can emerge when a Noether symmetry is subject to a condition that prevents the energy minimum from being a critical point of the Hamiltonian. A somewhat trivial example is the Schrödinger equation of a harmonic oscillator. The Noether charge for its particle number coincides with the square norm of the wave function, and the energy eigenvalue is a Lagrange multiplier for the condition that the wave function is properly normalized. A more elaborate example is the Gross-Pitaevskii equation that models vortices in a cold atom Bose-Einstein condensate. In an oblate, essentially two-dimensional harmonic trap the energy minimum is a topologically protected timecrystalline vortex that rotates around the trap center. Additional examples are constructed using coarse grained Hamiltonian models of closed molecular chains. When knotted, the topology of a chain can support a time crystal. As a physical example, high precision all-atom molecular dynamics is used to analyze an isolated cyclopropane molecule. The simulation reveals that the molecular D 3 h symmetry becomes spontaneously broken. When the molecule is observed with sufficiently long stroboscopic time steps it appears to rotate like a simple Hamiltonian time crystal. When the length of the stroboscopic time step is decreased the rotational motion becomes increasingly ratcheting and eventually it resembles the back-and-forth oscillations of Sisyphus dynamics. The stroboscopic rotation is entirely due to atomic level oscillatory shape changes, so that cyclopropane is an example of a molecule that can rotate without angular momentum. Finally, the article is concluded with a personal recollection how Frank’s and Betsy’s Stockholm journey started.

DOI
10.1142/9789811251948_0016

Related papers

Autonomous topological time crystals and knotty molecular motors

Jin Dai, Xubiao Peng, Antti J. Niemi

We show that topology is a very effective tool, to construct classical Hamiltonian time crystals. For this we numerically analyze a general class of time crystalline Hamiltonians that are designed to model the dynamics of molecular closed strings. We demonstrate how the time crystalline qualities of a closed string are greatly enhanced when the string becomes knotted. The Hamiltonians that we investigate include a generalized Kratky-Porod wormlike chain model in combination with long range Coulomb and Lennard-Jones interactions. Such energy functions are commonplace in coarse grained molecular modeling. Thus we expect that physical realizations of Hamiltonian time crystals can be constructed in terms of knotted ring molecules.

arXiv:1910.13787•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Sep 9, 2020•2 citations

Timecrystalline vorticity and anyonic exchange in a cold atom Bose-Einstein condensate

Julien Garaud, Jin Dai, Antti J. Niemi

Vortices in a cold alkali atom Bose-Einstein condensate can be modelled as minimum energy solutions of the time dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation. In a non-rotating axially symmetric trap, the core of a single vortex precesses around the trap center and, at the same time, the phase of its wave function shifts at a constant rate. The precession velocity, the speed of phase shift, and the distance between the vortex core and the trap center, depend continuously on the value of the conserved angular momentum that is carried by the entire condensate. The precessing vortex is an example of an autonomous Hamiltonian time crystal. In the case of a symmetric pair of identical vortices, the precession engages an emergent gauge field akin to the anyon gauge field, with a statistical parameter equal to the ratio between the precession and shift velocities.

•Oct 9, 2020•0 citations

Time crystal minimizes its energy by performing Sisyphus motion

Krzysztof Sacha, Peter Hannaford

We all know about ordinary space crystals, which are often beautiful objects and also useful in various practical applications. Briefly speaking, they consist of atoms which due to mutual interactions are able to self-organize their distribution in a regular way in space if certain conditions are fulfilled—ideally they form in the lowest-energy state at zero temperature. In 2012 the ideas of time crystals were invented. Shapere and Wilczek proposed classical time crystals and Wilczek alone proposed quantum time crystals (1, 2). Basically, time crystals refer to regular periodic behavior not in the spatial dimensions but in the time domain (3). In the classical case, time crystals are related to the periodic evolution of a system possessing the lowest energy. Motion and minimal energy seem to contradict each other but Shapere and Wilczek (2) showed that if the kinetic energy of a particle on a ring is a quartic function of its velocity, it may happen that the minimal energy corresponds to a particle moving along a ring with non-zero velocity. This counterintuitive situation also seems to be in contradiction to the condition for the minimal value of the Hamiltonian (energy expressed in terms of particle momentum that is commonly used by physicists) because its minimum implies zero velocity. Shapere and Wilczek (2) showed that precisely at the minimum the particle velocity cannot be expressed in terms of the momentum and we indeed can observe periodic motion of a particle even if its … [↵][1]1To whom correspondence may be addressed. Email: krzysztof.sacha{at}uj.edu.pl. [1]: #xref-corresp-1-1

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Aug 22, 2019•1 citation

Poincaré index formula and analogy with the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in a non-rotated cold atom Bose-Einstein condensate

Julien Garaud, Antti J. Niemi

Abstract A dilute gas of Bose-Einstein condensed atoms in a non-rotated and axially symmetric harmonic trap is modelled by the time dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation. When the angular momentum carried by the condensate does not vanish, the minimum energy state describes vortices (or antivortices) that propagate around the trap center. The number of (anti)vortices increases with the angular momentum, and they repel each other to form Abrikosov lattices. Besides vortices and antivortices there are also stagnation points where the superflow vanishes; to our knowledge the stagnation points have not been analyzed previously, in the context of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation. The Poincaré index formula states that the difference in the number of vortices and stagnation points can never change. When the number of stagnation points is small, they tend to aggregate into degenerate propagating structures. But when the number becomes sufficiently large, the stagnation points tend to pair up with the vortex cores, to propagate around the trap center in regular lattice arrangements. There is an analogy with the geometry of the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition, with the angular momentum of the condensate as the external control parameter instead of the temperature.

arXiv:2108.03155•Journal of High Energy Physics•Sep 20, 2022•2 citations

Quantum Hamiltonian time crystals from covariant quantum Landau--Lifshitz--Gilbert relaxation

Antti J. Niemi

Classical Hamiltonian time crystals are constrained energy minima that move along symmetry orbits at frequencies set by Lagrange multipliers. We construct quantum counterparts by minimizing the energy over density matrices with fixed spectrum and charge expectations. A symmetry-covariant quantum Landau--Lifshitz--Gilbert equation selects them as periodic attractors, preserving the spectrum and fixing the multipliers dynamically. A chiral spin trimer motivated by Cu$_3$ molecular magnets realizes this motion at a prepared magnetization, without a Zeeman term.

arXiv:2610.39886•Oct 29, 2026•0 citations

Poincar\'e index formula, vortices and superflow saddle points in a non-rotating cold atom Bose-Einstein condensate

Julien Garaud, Antti J. Niemi

A dilute gas of Bose-Einstein condensed atoms, in a non-rotating and axially symmetric harmonic trap, can be modeled by the time dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation. The minimum energy solutions describe vortices that propagate around the trap center. The number of vortices increases with increasing angular momentum, and the vortices repel each other to form Abrikosov lattices. Besides vortices there are also saddle points, where the velocities of the superflow of distinct vortices cancel each other. The Poincare index formula states that the difference in the number vortices and saddles points can never change. When the number of saddle points is small, they aggregate and form degenerate propagating structures. However, when their number becomes sufficiently large there is a transition and the saddle points start dispersing. They pair up with vortices and propagate around the trap center in regular arrangements akin Abrikosov lattices.

•Aug 6, 2021•0 citations
A Hamiltonian time crystal can emerge when a Noether symmetry is subject to a condition that prevents the energy minimum from being a critical point of the Hamiltonian. A somewhat trivial example is the Schrödinger equation of a harmonic oscillator. The Noether charge for its particle number coincides with the square norm of the wave function, and the energy eigenvalue is a Lagrange multiplier for the condition that the wave function is properly normalized. A more elaborate example is the Gross-Pitaevskii equation that models vortices in a cold atom Bose-Einstein condensate. In an oblate, essentially two-dimensional harmonic trap the energy minimum is a topologically protected timecrystalline vortex that rotates around the trap center. Additional examples are constructed using coarse grained Hamiltonian models of closed molecular chains. When knotted, the topology of a chain can support a time crystal. As a physical example, high precision all-atom molecular dynamics is used to analyze an isolated cyclopropane molecule. The simulation reveals that the molecular D 3 h symmetry becomes spontaneously broken. When the molecule is observed with sufficiently long stroboscopic time steps it appears to rotate like a simple Hamiltonian time crystal. When the length of the stroboscopic time step is decreased the rotational motion becomes increasingly ratcheting and eventually it resembles the back-and-forth oscillations of Sisyphus dynamics. The stroboscopic rotation is entirely due to atomic level oscillatory shape changes, so that cyclopropane is an example of a molecule that can rotate without angular momentum. Finally, the article is concluded with a personal recollection how Frank’s and Betsy’s Stockholm journey started.
We show that topology is a very effective tool, to construct classical Hamiltonian time crystals. For this we numerically analyze a general class of time crystalline Hamiltonians that are designed to model the dynamics of molecular closed strings. We demonstrate how the time crystalline qualities of a closed string are greatly enhanced when the string becomes knotted. The Hamiltonians that we investigate include a generalized Kratky-Porod wormlike chain model in combination with long range Coulomb and Lennard-Jones interactions. Such energy functions are commonplace in coarse grained molecular modeling. Thus we expect that physical realizations of Hamiltonian time crystals can be constructed in terms of knotted ring molecules.
Vortices in a cold alkali atom Bose-Einstein condensate can be modelled as minimum energy solutions of the time dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation. In a non-rotating axially symmetric trap, the core of a single vortex precesses around the trap center and, at the same time, the phase of its wave function shifts at a constant rate. The precession velocity, the speed of phase shift, and the distance between the vortex core and the trap center, depend continuously on the value of the conserved angular momentum that is carried by the entire condensate. The precessing vortex is an example of an autonomous Hamiltonian time crystal. In the case of a symmetric pair of identical vortices, the precession engages an emergent gauge field akin to the anyon gauge field, with a statistical parameter equal to the ratio between the precession and shift velocities.
We all know about ordinary space crystals, which are often beautiful objects and also useful in various practical applications. Briefly speaking, they consist of atoms which due to mutual interactions are able to self-organize their distribution in a regular way in space if certain conditions are fulfilled—ideally they form in the lowest-energy state at zero temperature. In 2012 the ideas of time crystals were invented. Shapere and Wilczek proposed classical time crystals and Wilczek alone proposed quantum time crystals (1, 2). Basically, time crystals refer to regular periodic behavior not in the spatial dimensions but in the time domain (3). In the classical case, time crystals are related to the periodic evolution of a system possessing the lowest energy. Motion and minimal energy seem to contradict each other but Shapere and Wilczek (2) showed that if the kinetic energy of a particle on a ring is a quartic function of its velocity, it may happen that the minimal energy corresponds to a particle moving along a ring with non-zero velocity. This counterintuitive situation also seems to be in contradiction to the condition for the minimal value of the Hamiltonian (energy expressed in terms of particle momentum that is commonly used by physicists) because its minimum implies zero velocity. Shapere and Wilczek (2) showed that precisely at the minimum the particle velocity cannot be expressed in terms of the momentum and we indeed can observe periodic motion of a particle even if its … [↵][1]1To whom correspondence may be addressed. Email: krzysztof.sacha{at}uj.edu.pl. [1]: #xref-corresp-1-1
Abstract A dilute gas of Bose-Einstein condensed atoms in a non-rotated and axially symmetric harmonic trap is modelled by the time dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation. When the angular momentum carried by the condensate does not vanish, the minimum energy state describes vortices (or antivortices) that propagate around the trap center. The number of (anti)vortices increases with the angular momentum, and they repel each other to form Abrikosov lattices. Besides vortices and antivortices there are also stagnation points where the superflow vanishes; to our knowledge the stagnation points have not been analyzed previously, in the context of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation. The Poincaré index formula states that the difference in the number of vortices and stagnation points can never change. When the number of stagnation points is small, they tend to aggregate into degenerate propagating structures. But when the number becomes sufficiently large, the stagnation points tend to pair up with the vortex cores, to propagate around the trap center in regular lattice arrangements. There is an analogy with the geometry of the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition, with the angular momentum of the condensate as the external control parameter instead of the temperature.
Classical Hamiltonian time crystals are constrained energy minima that move along symmetry orbits at frequencies set by Lagrange multipliers. We construct quantum counterparts by minimizing the energy over density matrices with fixed spectrum and charge expectations. A symmetry-covariant quantum Landau--Lifshitz--Gilbert equation selects them as periodic attractors, preserving the spectrum and fixing the multipliers dynamically. A chiral spin trimer motivated by Cu3_33​ molecular magnets realizes this motion at a prepared magnetization, without a Zeeman term.
A dilute gas of Bose-Einstein condensed atoms, in a non-rotating and axially symmetric harmonic trap, can be modeled by the time dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation. The minimum energy solutions describe vortices that propagate around the trap center. The number of vortices increases with increasing angular momentum, and the vortices repel each other to form Abrikosov lattices. Besides vortices there are also saddle points, where the velocities of the superflow of distinct vortices cancel each other. The Poincare index formula states that the difference in the number vortices and saddles points can never change. When the number of saddle points is small, they aggregate and form degenerate propagating structures. However, when their number becomes sufficiently large there is a transition and the saddle points start dispersing. They pair up with vortices and propagate around the trap center in regular arrangements akin Abrikosov lattices.