Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Nature Communications

Simultaneous bicolor interrogation in thulium optical clock providing very low systematic frequency shifts

Artem A. Golovizin, Dmitry O. Tregubov, E.S. Fedorova, D. Mishin, Daniil I. Provorchenko, Ksenia Yu. Khabarova, Vadim N Sorokin, N. Kolachevsky

Published Aug 27, 2021• 33 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Optical atomic clocks have already overcome the eighteenth decimal digit of instability and uncertainty, demonstrating incredible control over external perturbations of the clock transition frequency. At the same time, there is an increasing demand for atomic (ionic) transitions and new interrogation and readout protocols providing minimal sensitivity to external fields and possessing practical operational wavelengths. One of the goals is to simplify the clock operation while maintaining the relative uncertainty at a low 10−18 level achieved at the shortest averaging time. This is especially important for transportable and envisioned space-based optical clocks. Here, we demonstrate implementation of a synthetic frequency approach for a thulium optical clock with simultaneous optical interrogation of two clock transitions. Our experiment shows suppression of the quadratic Zeeman shift by at least three orders of magnitude. The effect of the tensor lattice Stark shift in thulium can also be reduced to below 10−18 in fractional frequency units. This makes the thulium optical clock almost free from hard-to-control systematic shifts. The “simultaneous” protocol demonstrates very low sensitivity to the cross-talks between individual clock transitions during interrogation and readout.

DOI
10.1038/s41467-021-25396-8

Related papers

Extraordinary low systematic frequency shifts in bi-colour thulium optical clock

Artem A. Golovizin, Dmitry O. Tregubov, E.S. Fedorova +5 more

Optical atomic clocks have already overcome the eighteenth decimal digit of instability and uncertainty demonstrating incredible control over external perturbations of the clock transition frequency. At the same time there is an increasing demand for atomic and ionic transitions with minimal sensitivity to external fields, with practical operational wavelengths and robust readout protocols. One of the goals is to simplify clock's operation maintaining its relative uncertainty at low 10-18 level. It is especially important for transportable and envisioned space-based optical clocks. We proved earlier that the 1.14um inner-shell magnetic dipole transition in neutral thulium possesses very low blackbody radiation shift compared to other neutrals. Here we demonstrate operation of a bi-colour thulium optical clock with extraordinary low sensitivity to the Zeeman shift due to a simultaneous interrogation of two clock transitions and data processing. Our experiment shows suppression of the quadratic Zeeman shift by at least three orders of magnitude. The effect of tensor lattice Stark shift can be also reduced to below 10-18 in fractional frequency units. All these features make thulium optical clock almost free from hard-to-control systematic shifts. Together with convenient cooling and trapping laser wavelengths, it provides great perspectives for thulium lattice clock as a high-performance transportable system.

arXiv:2102.07468•Feb 15, 2021•0 citations

Continuous operation of a bicolor thulium optical lattice clock

D. Mishin, Daniil I. Provorchenko, Dmitry O. Tregubov +2 more

We discuss the extension of a recently proposed method based on continuous spectroscopy of 88 Sr atoms trapped in a moving optical lattice [Appl. Phys. Express, 14 , 072 006 (2021)] to the operation of bicolor thulium optical clocks. Simultaneous interrogation of two clock transitions at 1.14 μ m and build-up of a synthetic frequency provides a straightforward way to significantly suppress the first-order Doppler shift and cancel out the second-order Zeeman shift, the latter being one of the major sources of uncertainty in the originally proposed 88 Sr setup. In our configuration, the total systematic frequency shift is 4 × 10 −16 and instability is at or lower than 10 −18 after 1 h of integration.

Applied Physics Express•Oct 20, 2021•5 citations

Elimination of second-order Zeeman shift in thulium optical clock by simultaneous interrogation of two clock transitions

Dmitry O. Tregubov, Artem A. Golovizin, E.S. Fedorova +5 more

We eliminate the largest systematic shift in thulium optical clock — the second-order Zeeman shift — using average frequency of two clock transitions. This reduces the total systematic shift down to mHz level.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Simultaneous preparation of two initial clock states in a thulium optical clock

E.S. Fedorova, Artem A. Golovizin, Dmitry O. Tregubov +5 more

Because of the low sensitivity of a thulium optical clock to black-body radiation and good accuracy and stability estimations, it is considered as a promising transportable optical clock. One of the leading systematic effects for Tm clock transition, i.e., the second-order Zeeman effect, can be canceled by probing two clock transitions between different hyperfine levels of ground and metastable states during clock operation. Herein, we demonstrate efficient optical pumping into the ${m}_{F}=0$ state of both ground hyperfine levels using single-frequency radiation at 418.8 nm. We prepared the atoms in both target states simultaneously and excited two clock transitions alternately. The resulting population of ${m}_{F}=0$ states of ground hyperfine levels was 36% and 3.8% of the initial number of atoms with less than 4% and 0.4% on nonzero magnetic sublevels, respectively. We performed numerical simulations of the optical pumping process, which is able to explain experimental results well.

arXiv:2008.02050•Physical Review A•Dec 17, 2020•22 citations

A multi-ion optical clock with $\mathbf{5 \times 10^{-19}}$ uncertainty

Melina Filzinger, Martin R. Steinel, Jian Jiang +4 more

Today's most accurate clocks are based on laser spectroscopy of electronic transitions in single trapped ions and feature fractional frequency uncertainties below $1\times10^{-18}$. Scaling these systems to multiple, simultaneously interrogated ions reduces measurement times, driving recent advances in multi-ion clocks. However, maintaining state-of-the-art systematic uncertainties while increasing the number of ions remains a central challenge. Here, we report on a multi-ion optical atomic clock with a fractional frequency uncertainty of $5.3\times10^{-19}$ and up to 10 \Sr ions. Ion-resolved state detection enables minimization of position-dependent shifts, with residual effects suppressed below the $10^{-20}$-level. Clock operation with eight to ten ions reduces the measurement time by a factor of 4.8 compared to single-ion operation. A comparison with an established \Yb single-ion clock yields an unperturbed frequency ratio of $0.6926711632159660405(20)$, with a statistical uncertainty of $0.9\times10^{-18}$ and a combined uncertainty of $2.9\times 10^{-18}$. These results demonstrate robust multi-ion clock operation with reduced averaging time and state-of-the-art accuracy.

physics.atom-phCross-listedarXiv:2603.23446•Mar 25, 2026•0 citations

Clock with 8 × 10 − 19 Systematic Uncertainty

Alexander Aeppli, Kyungtae Kim, William Warfield +2 more

We report an optical lattice clock with a total systematic uncertainty of 8.1×10^{-19} in fractional frequency units, representing the lowest uncertainty of any clock to date. The clock relies on interrogating the ultranarrow ^{1}S_{0}→^{3}P_{0} transition in a dilute ensemble of fermionic strontium atoms trapped in a vertically-oriented, shallow, one-dimensional optical lattice. Using imaging spectroscopy, we previously demonstrated record high atomic coherence time and measurement precision enabled by precise control of collisional shifts and the lattice light shift. In this work, we revise the black body radiation shift correction by evaluating the 5s4d ^{3}D_{1} lifetime, necessitating precise characterization and control of many body effects in the 5s4d ^{3}D_{1} decay. Last, we measure the second order Zeeman coefficient on the least magnetically sensitive clock transition. All other systematic effects have uncertainties below 1×10^{-19}.

arXiv:2403.10664•Physical Review Letters•Jul 10, 2024•211 citations
Abstract Optical atomic clocks have already overcome the eighteenth decimal digit of instability and uncertainty, demonstrating incredible control over external perturbations of the clock transition frequency. At the same time, there is an increasing demand for atomic (ionic) transitions and new interrogation and readout protocols providing minimal sensitivity to external fields and possessing practical operational wavelengths. One of the goals is to simplify the clock operation while maintaining the relative uncertainty at a low 10−18 level achieved at the shortest averaging time. This is especially important for transportable and envisioned space-based optical clocks. Here, we demonstrate implementation of a synthetic frequency approach for a thulium optical clock with simultaneous optical interrogation of two clock transitions. Our experiment shows suppression of the quadratic Zeeman shift by at least three orders of magnitude. The effect of the tensor lattice Stark shift in thulium can also be reduced to below 10−18 in fractional frequency units. This makes the thulium optical clock almost free from hard-to-control systematic shifts. The “simultaneous” protocol demonstrates very low sensitivity to the cross-talks between individual clock transitions during interrogation and readout.
Optical atomic clocks have already overcome the eighteenth decimal digit of instability and uncertainty demonstrating incredible control over external perturbations of the clock transition frequency. At the same time there is an increasing demand for atomic and ionic transitions with minimal sensitivity to external fields, with practical operational wavelengths and robust readout protocols. One of the goals is to simplify clock's operation maintaining its relative uncertainty at low 10-18 level. It is especially important for transportable and envisioned space-based optical clocks. We proved earlier that the 1.14um inner-shell magnetic dipole transition in neutral thulium possesses very low blackbody radiation shift compared to other neutrals. Here we demonstrate operation of a bi-colour thulium optical clock with extraordinary low sensitivity to the Zeeman shift due to a simultaneous interrogation of two clock transitions and data processing. Our experiment shows suppression of the quadratic Zeeman shift by at least three orders of magnitude. The effect of tensor lattice Stark shift can be also reduced to below 10-18 in fractional frequency units. All these features make thulium optical clock almost free from hard-to-control systematic shifts. Together with convenient cooling and trapping laser wavelengths, it provides great perspectives for thulium lattice clock as a high-performance transportable system.
We discuss the extension of a recently proposed method based on continuous spectroscopy of 88 Sr atoms trapped in a moving optical lattice [Appl. Phys. Express, 14 , 072 006 (2021)] to the operation of bicolor thulium optical clocks. Simultaneous interrogation of two clock transitions at 1.14 μ m and build-up of a synthetic frequency provides a straightforward way to significantly suppress the first-order Doppler shift and cancel out the second-order Zeeman shift, the latter being one of the major sources of uncertainty in the originally proposed 88 Sr setup. In our configuration, the total systematic frequency shift is 4 × 10 −16 and instability is at or lower than 10 −18 after 1 h of integration.
Because of the low sensitivity of a thulium optical clock to black-body radiation and good accuracy and stability estimations, it is considered as a promising transportable optical clock. One of the leading systematic effects for Tm clock transition, i.e., the second-order Zeeman effect, can be canceled by probing two clock transitions between different hyperfine levels of ground and metastable states during clock operation. Herein, we demonstrate efficient optical pumping into the mF=0{m}_{F}=0mF​=0 state of both ground hyperfine levels using single-frequency radiation at 418.8 nm. We prepared the atoms in both target states simultaneously and excited two clock transitions alternately. The resulting population of mF=0{m}_{F}=0mF​=0 states of ground hyperfine levels was 36% and 3.8% of the initial number of atoms with less than 4% and 0.4% on nonzero magnetic sublevels, respectively. We performed numerical simulations of the optical pumping process, which is able to explain experimental results well.
A multi-ion optical clock with 5×10−19\mathbf{5 \times 10^{-19}}5×10−19 uncertainty
Today's most accurate clocks are based on laser spectroscopy of electronic transitions in single trapped ions and feature fractional frequency uncertainties below 1×10−181\times10^{-18}1×10−18. Scaling these systems to multiple, simultaneously interrogated ions reduces measurement times, driving recent advances in multi-ion clocks. However, maintaining state-of-the-art systematic uncertainties while increasing the number of ions remains a central challenge. Here, we report on a multi-ion optical atomic clock with a fractional frequency uncertainty of 5.3×10−195.3\times10^{-19}5.3×10−19 and up to 10 \Sr ions. Ion-resolved state detection enables minimization of position-dependent shifts, with residual effects suppressed below the 10−2010^{-20}10−20-level. Clock operation with eight to ten ions reduces the measurement time by a factor of 4.8 compared to single-ion operation. A comparison with an established \Yb single-ion clock yields an unperturbed frequency ratio of 0.6926711632159660405(20)0.6926711632159660405(20)0.6926711632159660405(20), with a statistical uncertainty of 0.9×10−180.9\times10^{-18}0.9×10−18 and a combined uncertainty of 2.9×10−182.9\times 10^{-18}2.9×10−18. These results demonstrate robust multi-ion clock operation with reduced averaging time and state-of-the-art accuracy.
We report an optical lattice clock with a total systematic uncertainty of 8.1×10^{-19} in fractional frequency units, representing the lowest uncertainty of any clock to date. The clock relies on interrogating the ultranarrow ^{1}S_{0}→^{3}P_{0} transition in a dilute ensemble of fermionic strontium atoms trapped in a vertically-oriented, shallow, one-dimensional optical lattice. Using imaging spectroscopy, we previously demonstrated record high atomic coherence time and measurement precision enabled by precise control of collisional shifts and the lattice light shift. In this work, we revise the black body radiation shift correction by evaluating the 5s4d ^{3}D_{1} lifetime, necessitating precise characterization and control of many body effects in the 5s4d ^{3}D_{1} decay. Last, we measure the second order Zeeman coefficient on the least magnetically sensitive clock transition. All other systematic effects have uncertainties below 1×10^{-19}.