High-Resolution Momentum Imaging—From Stern’s Molecular Beam Method to the COLTRIMS Reaction Microscope
T. Jahnke, V. Mergel, O. Jagutzki, A. Czasch, K. Ullmann, R. Ali, V. Frohne, Th. Weber, L. Ph. H. Schmidt, S. Eckart, Markus S Schöffler, Sven Schössler, S. Voss, A. L. Landers, D. Fischer, Michael Schulz, Alexander Dorn, Lutz Spielberger, R. Moshammer, R. E. Olson, Michael H. Prior, R. Dörner, J. Ullrich, C. Lewis Cocke, H. Schmidt‐Böcking
Abstract Multi-particle momentum imaging experiments are now capable of providing detailed information on the properties and the dynamics of quantum systems in Atomic, Molecular and Photon (AMO) physics. Historically, Otto Stern can be considered the pioneer of high-resolution momentum measurements of particles moving in a vacuum and he was the first to obtain sub-atomic unit (a.u.) momentum resolution (Schmidt-Böcking et al. in The precision limits in a single-event quantum measurement of electron momentum and position, these proceedings [1]). A major contribution to modern experimental atomic and molecular physics was his so-called molecular beam method [2], which Stern developed and employed in his experiments. With this method he discovered several fundamental properties of atoms, molecules and nuclei [2, 3]. As corresponding particle detection techniques were lacking during his time, he was only able to observe the averaged footprints of large particle ensembles. Today it is routinely possible to measure the momenta of single particles, because of the tremendous progress in single particle detection and data acquisition electronics. A “state-of-the-art” COLTRIMS reaction microscope [4–11] can measure, for example, the momenta of several particles ejected in the same quantum process in coincidence with sub-a.u. momentum resolution. Such setups can be used to visualize the dynamics of quantum reactions and image the entangled motion of electrons inside atoms and molecules. This review will briefly summarize Stern’s work and then present in longer detail the historic steps of the development of the COLTRIMS reaction microscope. Furthermore, some benchmark results are shown which initially paved the way for a broad acceptance of the COLTRIMS approach. Finally, a small selection of milestone work is presented which has been performed during the last two decades.
Abstract Multi-particle momentum imaging experiments are now capable of providing detailed information on the properties and the dynamics of quantum systems in Atomic, Molecular and Photon (AMO) physics. Historically, Otto Stern can be considered the pioneer of high-resolution momentum measurements of particles moving in a vacuum and he was the first to obtain sub-atomic unit (a.u.) momentum resolution (Schmidt-Böcking et al. in The precision limits in a single-event quantum measurement of electron momentum and position, these proceedings [1]). A major contribution to modern experimental atomic and molecular physics was his so-called molecular beam method [2], which Stern developed and employed in his experiments. With this method he discovered several fundamental properties of atoms, molecules and nuclei [2, 3]. As corresponding particle detection techniques were lacking during his time, he was only able to observe the averaged footprints of large particle ensembles. Today it is routinely possible to measure the momenta of single particles, because of the tremendous progress in single particle detection and data acquisition electronics. A “state-of-the-art” COLTRIMS reaction microscope [4–11] can measure, for example, the momenta of several particles ejected in the same quantum process in coincidence with sub-a.u. momentum resolution. Such setups can be used to visualize the dynamics of quantum reactions and image the entangled motion of electrons inside atoms and molecules. This review will briefly summarize Stern’s work and then present in longer detail the historic steps of the development of the COLTRIMS reaction microscope. Furthermore, some benchmark results are shown which initially paved the way for a broad acceptance of the COLTRIMS approach. Finally, a small selection of milestone work is presented which has been performed during the last two decades.
With the continuous advancement and maturation of laser cooling techniques for atoms and molecules and full-dimensional electron and ion imaging technology, using momentum imaging techniques to investigate the characteristic properties of cold atoms and collision dynamics has emerged as a burgeoning research direction. This progress has driven the development of a series of high-resolution electron and ion detection devices, leading to innovative breakthroughs in fields such as cold molecule reactions, Rydberg atoms, nuclear decay, photoionization of Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) and cold plasmas, collisions between cold atoms and ions/electrons, coherent control of cold atoms, and strong-field ultrafast physics. This article reviews representative instruments and their corresponding seminal achievements in the following domains: In cold molecular/cold chemical reactions, imaging technology has revealed new insights into reaction mechanisms; For cold Rydberg atom interactions, it demonstrates high-precision quantum state manipulation capabilities, advancing quantum information processing; In nuclear decay research, it provides ultra-sensitive detection methods, deepening understanding of decay processes; For BEC photoionization and cold plasma control, it can precisely monitor and manipulate microscopic processes; In cold atomic collision studies, it reveals new details in collision dynamics, refining collision theories; Regarding coherent control of cold atoms, it achieves accurate quantum state manipulation and interference; In strong-field ultrafast processes, it elucidates complex electron dynamics under intense fields, providing innovative methods for ultrafast laser control. Furthermore, this article summarizes the applications of imaging technologies in the aforementioned research areas involving cold atoms, and provides prospects for future developments in this evolving field.
Abstract A modern state-of-the-art “quantum measurement” [The term “quantum measurement” as used here implies that parameters of atomic particles are measured that emerge from a single scattering process of quantum particles.] of momentum and position of a single electron at a given time [“at a given time” means directly after the scattering process. (It should be noticed that the duration of the reaction process is typically extremely short => attoseconds).] and the precision limits for their experimental determination are discussed from an experimentalists point of view. We show—by giving examples of actually performed experiments—that in a single reaction between quantum particles at a given time only the momenta of the emitted particles but not their positions can be measured with sub-atomic resolution. This fundamental disparity between the conjugate variables of momentum and position is due to the fact that during a single-event measurement only the total momentum but not position is conserved as function of time. We highlight, that (other than prevalently perceived) Heisenberg’s “Uncertainty Relation” UR [1] does not limit the achievable resolution of momentum in a single-event measurement. Thus, Heisenberg’s statement that in a single-event measurement only either the position or the momentum (velocity) of a quantum particle can be measured with high precision contradicts a real experiment. The UR states only a correlation between the mean statistical fluctuations of a large number of repeated single-event measurements of two conjugate variables. A detailed discussion of the real measurement process and its precision with respect to momentum and position is presented.
Abstract Motivated by his interest in thermodynamics and the emerging quantum mechanics, Otto Stern (1888–1969) launched in 1919 his molecular beam method to examine the fundamental assumptions of theory that transpire in atomic, molecular, optical, and nuclear physics. Stern’s experimental endeavors at Frankfurt (1919–1922), Hamburg (1923–1933), and Pittsburgh (1933–1945) provided insights into the quantum world that were independent of spectroscopy and that concerned well-defined isolated systems, hitherto accessible only toGedankenexperiments. In this chapter we look at how Stern’s molecular beam research came about and review six of his seminal experiments along with their context and reception by the physics community: the Stern-Gerlach experiment; the three-stage Stern-Gerlach experiment; experimental evidence for de Broglie’s matter waves; measurements of the magnetic dipole moment of the proton and the deuteron; experimental demonstration of momentum transfer upon absorption or emission of a photon; the experimental verification of the Maxwell-Boltzmann velocity distribution via deflection of a molecular beam by gravity. Regarded as paragons of thoroughness and ingenuity, these experiments entail accurate transversal momentum measurements with resolution better than 0.1 atomic units. Some of these experiments would be taken up by others where Stern left off only decades later (matter-wave scattering or photon momentum transfer). We conclude by highlighting aspects of Stern’s legacy as reflected by the honors that have been bestowed upon him to date.
Imagine a new generation of computers that dramatically surpasses the most powerful supercomputers, being able to tackle the most challenging of computational problems. These problems arise, for example, in quantum physics where the computational power required to model a many-particle system increases exponentially with the number of its constituents, and as a consequence the calculations become prohibitively time-consuming. Nobel laureate Richard Feynman proposed this new type of computer in the early 1980s: ‘Let the computer itself be built of quantum mechanical elements which obey quantum mechanical laws.’ Such a quantum simulator would allow researchers to tackle challenging problems in condensed-matter physics. In particular many-body fermionic quantum systems are very difficult to compute due to the antisymmetric nature of the wave function, and the resulting sign problem for quantum Monte Carlo methods. This is why a quantum simulator will be an excellent test bed to investigate phenomena and properties of strongly correlated fermionic quantum systems. A powerful experimental platform to realize a quantum simulator is laser-cooled atoms [1] held in an artificial crystal of light, generated by superimposing laser beams. The atoms are kept in this optical lattice similar to marbles in the hollows of an egg carton, and they can mimic the behaviour of electrons in a real crystal. These systems interface atomic physics with condensed matter physics in a new way, as the tools of atomic physics allow for exquisite control of many experimental parameters, which are often inaccessible in solid state experiments. In-situ imaging techniques [2] using ‘quantum-gas microscopes’ constitute a new approach to the study of many-body quantum systems in an optical lattice with unprecedented resolution at the single-particle and single-site level [3,4]. This new method is complementary to earlier optical lattice experiments measuring distributions in momentum space after a time-of-flight expansion. A quantum-gas microscope uses an optical imaging system (Fig. 1a) for collecting the fluorescence light of ultracold atoms in an optical lattice with high spatial resolution comparable to the lattice spacing of ≈ 500 nm. (a) Atoms in optical lattice atoms are imaged with a high-resolution microscope objective [4]. (b) Single-site addressing is achieved by focussing a laser beam through the microscope onto selected atoms, bringing them into resonance with microwave radiation which produces spin flips [12]. (c) and (d) Single-atom-resolved fluorescence images of bosonic Mottinsulators [4,9]. (e) Deterministically prepared atom distribution using single-site addressing [12]. (f) Direct observation of single-atom quantum walks [15]. Fluorescence imaging of atoms in a quantum-gas microscope has made it possible to directly observe bosonic Mott insulators with single-atom resolution [4–6], giving access to in-situ measurements of temperature and entropy distributions. Subsequently, ground-breaking experiments in many-body quantum dynamics have been performed, such as the first direct observation of correlation spreading after quenches of the system to lower lattice depths [7]. Other experiments include the quantum simulation of an antiferromagnetic spin-1/2 chain [8], the realization of algorithmic cooling [9], the direct measurement of correlations across the superfluid-to-Mott-insulator transition [10], or the observation of the ‘Higgs’ amplitude mode [11]. The high-resolution imaging system is also capable of optically addressing individual atoms with sub-diffraction-limited resolution. For this purpose, a laser beam is focussed though the microscope objective onto selected lattice sites, bringing the atoms into resonance with microwave radiation which produces spin flips [12,13]. The preparation of arbitrary atom distributions in the lattice not only opens perspectives for neutral-atom quantum information processing, but also allows the deterministic creation of specific out-of-equilibrium situations, and their ensuing system dynamics can be studied with single-atom resolution. Examples include the creation of spin impurities and the study of their dynamics in a many-body system [14], the observation of quantum walks [15] and magnon-bound states [16], and the measurement of entanglement entropy [17]. The technique used for single-site-resolved detection of individual atoms in the optical lattice is fluorescence imaging. It requires laser cooling of the atoms to sub-Doppler temperatures while detecting the fluorescence photons emitted during this process. A challenge is to achieve a low particle loss rate and to prevent the atoms from hopping between lattice sites. In the case of the first quantum-gas microscopes, this has been implemented with bosonic rubidium-87 atoms, and also recently for ytterbium-174. However, it has proven more challenging for fermionic alkaline species such as potassium-40 and lithium-6, as their low mass and small excited state hyperfine splitting-prevented standard sub-Doppler cooling from working. As a result, it took several years to extend the quantum-gas microscope technique to fermionic species, and in 2015 several groups have demonstrated single-atom-resolved imaging of fermions [18]. In these setups, the direct observation of band insulators [19], fermionic Mott insulators [20,21] and even antiferromagnetic correlations [22] has been reported most recently. These developments provide fascinating opportunities to study many-body fermionic quantum systems with single-particle access. The fermionic nature of the electron is vital to understanding a range of phenomena within solid-state physics, such as electron pairing in superconductivity, and quantum magnetism. In this context, the quantum simulator will allow, e.g. for direct measurement of ordered quantum phases and out-of-equilibrium dynamics, with access to quantities such as spin--spin correlation functions and the growth of many-body entanglement. The high-resolution imaging systems could also be used to project tailored time-varying light fields onto the atoms, allowing the removal of high-entropy regions by locally modifying the confining potential to attain very low-entropy states. Attaining these low-entropy many-particle states is one of the key challenges in our field. In summary, quantum-gas microscopes offer unprecedented access to many-body quantum systems, and they will allow us to gain an even deeper insight into the intriguing world of quantum physics that governs the properties of strongly correlated materials. Using a well-controlled quantum system to simulate other quantum systems could help resolve some of the most challenging problems scientists face in condensed matter physics and materials science, but it will also provide new insights in quantum chemistry, high-energy physics and biology. SK acknowledges funding from the EU (ERC FERMILATT, SIQS, QuProCs) and SUPA.
Abstract Over the past century, the molecular beam methods pioneered by Otto Stern have advanced our knowledge and understanding of the world enormously. Stern and his colleagues used these new techniques to measure the magnetic dipole moments of fundamental particles with results that challenged the prevailing ideas in fundamental physics at that time. Similarly, recent measurements of fundamental electric dipole moments challenge our present day theories of what lies beyond the Standard Model of particle physics. Measurements of the electron’s electric dipole moment (eEDM) rely on the techniques invented by Stern and later developed by Rabi and Ramsey. We give a brief review of this historical development and the current status of eEDM measurements. These experiments, and many others, are likely to benefit from ultracold molecules produced by laser cooling. We explain how laser cooling can be applied to molecules, review recent progress in this field, and outline some eagerly anticipated applications.
Abstract Dear Chairmen Profs. Herschbach and Toennies, dear organizers Profs. Schmidt-Böcking and Friedrich, dear Colleagues, dear Ladies and Gentlemen. The occasion for our gathering today in this location is a truly historic one: the centenary of the first quantitative experiment with molecular beams, a technique that would enable, in 1922, the first convincing proof of quantum mechanics—the fundamental theory of light and matter—and to give due honor to the pioneer physicist who developed this technique: Otto Stern.