Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Comment on “On a contextual model refuting Bell's theorem” by Muchowski Eugen

Justo Pastor Lambare

Published Jun 1, 2021• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

EPLAIntroduction.-We briefly address the following points.First, we explain the relationship between the Bell theorem and the concept of contextuality.Secondly, we see why the hidden variables model proposed in ref.[1] is nonlocal.Finally, we clarify some misunderstandings existing in the literature regarding the meaning of contextuality and its relation to the Bell theorem.

DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/ac0fb3

Related papers

Contextuality

We already met the concept of contextuality in several places, when we stated and loosely explained that the Bohm’s pilot wave is a contextual theory, but also regarding the proofs of impossibility of Gleason, and Kochen and Specker, when we restated their results, saying that, actually, what they proved is that admissible hidden-variables theories have to be contextual. This result may be viewed as a theorem, often named KS-theorem, or for reasons that we shall make clear Bell–KS theorem. There is another important result, that admissible hidden-variables theories must be non-local, a result which may also be viewed as a theorem, named Bell’s theorem (much more famous than KS-theorem). Non-locality will be discussed in the next chapter. In the present chapter, we are going to deal with contextuality (a concept that we have now to understand clearly), and with the proof that hidden-variables theories must be contextual, that is to say: The properties assigned to hidden variables must be determined by the experimental context of the measurement.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 2025•0 citations

On a contextual model refuting Bell's theorem

Eugen Muchowski

Abstract Bell's theorem is refuted by presenting a counterexample that correctly predicts the expectation values of QM. As Bell only ruled out non-contextual models, a contextual model with hidden variables can refute his theorem. Such a model, which is able to explain the spin measurement results with entangled photons or electrons, is presented herein. It is not ruled out by the Kochen-Specker theorem. A physical justification for the contextual behaviour of entangled systems is provided. Consequences for the feasibility of quantum computers are discussed.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Apr 1, 2021•11 citations

Defining the local part of a hidden variable model: a comment

Roger Colbeck, Renato Renner

In [Physical Review Letters 101, 050403 (2008)], we showed that quantum theory cannot be explained by a hidden variable model with a non-trivial local part. The purpose of this comment is to clarify our notion of local part, which seems to have caused some confusion in the recent literature. This notion is based on Bell's and demands that local hidden variables are physical, the idea being that, if discovered, they would not contradict basic physical principles. We explain why the recent supposed "counterexamples" that have appeared are not counterexamples to our theorem--in fact they are based on a definition of local hidden variables which would allow signalling and is therefore not physical.

arXiv:0907.4967•Jul 28, 2009•2 citations

Hidden variable theories and quantum nonlocality

A. David. Boozer

We clarify the meaning of Bell's theorem and its implications for the construction of hidden variable theories by considering an example system consisting of two entangled spin-1/2 particles. Using this example, we present a simplified version of Bell's theorem and describe several hidden variable theories that agree with the predictions of quantum mechanics. These example theories clarify some subtle points, which are often misunderstood, regarding what it is that Bell's theorem actually establishes. \n

European Journal of Physics•Feb 9, 2009•2 citations

Comments on "Disproof of Bell's theorem"

Florin Moldoveanu

In a series of very interesting papers [1-7], Joy Christian constructed a counterexample to Bell's theorem. This counterexample does not have the same assumptions as the original Bell's theorem, and therefore it does not represent a genuine disproof in a strict mathematical sense. However, assuming the physical relevance of the new assumptions, the counterexample is shown to be a contextual hidden variable theory. If Bell's theorem's importance is to rule out contextual hidden variable theories obeying relativistic locality, then Joy Christian's counterexample achieves its aim. If however contextual hidden variables theories are not considered genuine physically theories and Bell's theorem's importance stems from its ability to be experimentally confirmed, then Joy Christian's counterexample does not diminish the importance of Bell's theorem. The implications of Joy Christian's counterexample are discussed in the context of information theory. Version 2 note: Subsequent analysis disproved the mathematical consistency of Joy Christian's model. This paper was based on the assumption of the mathematical validity of the model. Except for the addition of this note, the content of this paper was not modified in any other way.

arXiv:1107.1007•Jul 6, 2011•2 citations

Misunderstandings for Bell's Inequality

Tan Tian-rong

It is pointed that Bell had two misunderstandings for his work: Firstly,the hidden variable theory that he applied for deriving Bell's inequality keeps wholly intact the operating rules of classical probabilistic theory,but he regarded it as the general local hidden variable theory.Secondly,in Bell's work,the promise actually deriving Bell's inequality is not the one that Bell regarded as the character of local hidden variable theory.Also,other versions can prove Bell's inequality without local hidden variable theory and the Lochak's objection against Bell's theory are examined.

Journal of Hechi University•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations
EPLAIntroduction.-We briefly address the following points.First, we explain the relationship between the Bell theorem and the concept of contextuality.Secondly, we see why the hidden variables model proposed in ref.[1] is nonlocal.Finally, we clarify some misunderstandings existing in the literature regarding the meaning of contextuality and its relation to the Bell theorem.
We already met the concept of contextuality in several places, when we stated and loosely explained that the Bohm’s pilot wave is a contextual theory, but also regarding the proofs of impossibility of Gleason, and Kochen and Specker, when we restated their results, saying that, actually, what they proved is that admissible hidden-variables theories have to be contextual. This result may be viewed as a theorem, often named KS-theorem, or for reasons that we shall make clear Bell–KS theorem. There is another important result, that admissible hidden-variables theories must be non-local, a result which may also be viewed as a theorem, named Bell’s theorem (much more famous than KS-theorem). Non-locality will be discussed in the next chapter. In the present chapter, we are going to deal with contextuality (a concept that we have now to understand clearly), and with the proof that hidden-variables theories must be contextual, that is to say: The properties assigned to hidden variables must be determined by the experimental context of the measurement.
Abstract Bell's theorem is refuted by presenting a counterexample that correctly predicts the expectation values of QM. As Bell only ruled out non-contextual models, a contextual model with hidden variables can refute his theorem. Such a model, which is able to explain the spin measurement results with entangled photons or electrons, is presented herein. It is not ruled out by the Kochen-Specker theorem. A physical justification for the contextual behaviour of entangled systems is provided. Consequences for the feasibility of quantum computers are discussed.
In [Physical Review Letters 101, 050403 (2008)], we showed that quantum theory cannot be explained by a hidden variable model with a non-trivial local part. The purpose of this comment is to clarify our notion of local part, which seems to have caused some confusion in the recent literature. This notion is based on Bell's and demands that local hidden variables are physical, the idea being that, if discovered, they would not contradict basic physical principles. We explain why the recent supposed "counterexamples" that have appeared are not counterexamples to our theorem--in fact they are based on a definition of local hidden variables which would allow signalling and is therefore not physical.
We clarify the meaning of Bell's theorem and its implications for the construction of hidden variable theories by considering an example system consisting of two entangled spin-1/2 particles. Using this example, we present a simplified version of Bell's theorem and describe several hidden variable theories that agree with the predictions of quantum mechanics. These example theories clarify some subtle points, which are often misunderstood, regarding what it is that Bell's theorem actually establishes. \n
In a series of very interesting papers [1-7], Joy Christian constructed a counterexample to Bell's theorem. This counterexample does not have the same assumptions as the original Bell's theorem, and therefore it does not represent a genuine disproof in a strict mathematical sense. However, assuming the physical relevance of the new assumptions, the counterexample is shown to be a contextual hidden variable theory. If Bell's theorem's importance is to rule out contextual hidden variable theories obeying relativistic locality, then Joy Christian's counterexample achieves its aim. If however contextual hidden variables theories are not considered genuine physically theories and Bell's theorem's importance stems from its ability to be experimentally confirmed, then Joy Christian's counterexample does not diminish the importance of Bell's theorem. The implications of Joy Christian's counterexample are discussed in the context of information theory. Version 2 note: Subsequent analysis disproved the mathematical consistency of Joy Christian's model. This paper was based on the assumption of the mathematical validity of the model. Except for the addition of this note, the content of this paper was not modified in any other way.
It is pointed that Bell had two misunderstandings for his work: Firstly,the hidden variable theory that he applied for deriving Bell's inequality keeps wholly intact the operating rules of classical probabilistic theory,but he regarded it as the general local hidden variable theory.Secondly,in Bell's work,the promise actually deriving Bell's inequality is not the one that Bell regarded as the character of local hidden variable theory.Also,other versions can prove Bell's inequality without local hidden variable theory and the Lochak's objection against Bell's theory are examined.