Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Invalidating the Robustness Conjecture for Geometric Quantum Gates

Ralph Kenneth Colmenar, Utkan Güngördü, J. P. Kestner

Published May 6, 2021• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Geometric quantum gates are conjectured to be more resilient than dynamical gates against certain types of error, which makes them ideal for robust quantum computing. However, there are conflicting claims within the literature about the validity of that robustness conjecture. Here we use dynamical invariant theory in conjunction with filter functions in order to analytically characterize the noise sensitivity of an arbitrary quantum gate. Under certain conditions, we find that there exists a transformation of the Hamiltonian that leaves invariant the final gate and noise sensitivity (as characterized by the filter function) while changing the phase from geometric to dynamical. Our result holds for a Hilbert space of arbitrary dimensions, but we illustrate our result by examining experimentally relevant single-qubit scenarios and providing explicit constructions of such a transformation.

Related papers

Conditions for Equivalent Noise Sensitivity of Geometric and Dynamical Quantum Gates

Ralph Kenneth Colmenar, Utkan Güngördü, J. P. Kestner

Geometric quantum gates are often expected to be more resilient than dynamical gates against certain types of error, which would make them ideal for robust quantum computing.However, this is still up for debate due to seemingly conflicting results in the literature.Here we use dynamical invariant theory in conjunction with filter functions in order to analytically characterize the noise sensitivity of an arbitrary quantum gate.For any control Hamiltonian that produces a geometric gate, we find that, under certain common conditions, one can construct another control Hamiltonian that produces an equivalent dynamical gate with identical noise sensitivity (as characterized by the filter function).Our result holds for a Hilbert space of arbitrary dimensions, but we illustrate our result by examining experimentally relevant singlequbit scenarios and providing explicit examples of equivalent geometric and dynamical gates.

arXiv:2105.02882•PRX Quantum•Jul 19, 2022•12 citations

Designing Robust Quantum Gates

Yuanxing Hao, Marin Bukov

For given control channels, quantum control theory determines whether quantum gates can be realized, but not their resilience to errors. We address this problem by establishing existence criteria for robust gate implementation in $d$-level systems. Our criteria reveal that implementability of all gates is not enough: a universal family of robust gates exists if and only if the driven Hamiltonians share no common symmetry. When these criteria hold, we can make gates resilient to any combination of static perturbations, uniform Hamiltonian rescaling, perturbations at a finite set of selected frequencies, and perturbations with arbitrary selected waveforms. We can impose robustness conditions broadly with limited information about errors, e.g., against any static perturbations; we can also tailor these conditions to the platform, e.g., against environment-induced noise with dominant spectral peaks, requiring no spectral details beyond the peak frequencies. We numerically construct explicit protocols for robust gates, reducing average gate infidelity by approximately two to seven orders of magnitude under Hamiltonian perturbations and environment-induced noise. Together, our existence criteria and numerical constructions provide practical guidance for evaluating the potential of quantum platforms and designing robust quantum gates.

quant-pharXiv:2610.24039•Oct 19, 2026•0 citations

Geometric quantum gates that are robust against stochastic control errors

Shi-Liang Zhu, Paolo Zanardi A

The realistic application of geometric quantum computation is crucially dependent on an unproved robustness conjecture, claiming that geometric quantum gates are more resilient against random noise than dynamic gates. We propose a suitable model that allows a direct and fair comparison between geometrical and dynamical operations. In the presence of stochastic control errors we find that the maximum of gate fidelity corresponds to quantum gates with a vanishing dynamical phase. This is a clear evidence for the robustness of nonadiabatic geometric quantum computation. The predictions here presented can be experimentally tested in almost all of the already existing quantum computer candidates.

arXiv:quant-ph/0407177•Physical Review A•Aug 15, 2005•180 citations

Optimizing nonadiabatic geometric quantum gates against off-resonance error in a silicon-based spin qubit

Liu-Jun Guo, Hai Li Xu, Zi-Yu Fang +3 more

Geometric quantum gates are performed by using the geometric phase, making them particularly robust to the pulse amplitude error. However, in many systems, such as the silicon-based spin qubits, the off-resonance error is the dominant noise, which can cause dephasing and is always difficult to deal with for a geometric gate. Thus how to combat with the off-resonance error is very significant for the application of the geometric gates. A recent work [S. Li and Z.-Y. Xue, Phys. Rev. Appl. 16, 044005 (2021).] revealed that by inserting two $\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulses into the evolution paths, the holonomic quantum gate is effective to suppress the pulse amplitude error, however, it is still useless for combating the off-resonance error. Inspired by this work, we combine using the techniques of dynamical correction and path design. Surprisingly, we find that, by picking up a specific evolution path inserted by only a $\ensuremath{\pi}$-pulse, the obtained optimized geometric gate is robust to the off-resonance error, assuming the noise is static. Further, by calculating the filter function considering the realistic $1/f$-type noise in silicon, the related results show that the performance of the optimized geometric gate can also surpass both the conventional geometric gate and the naive dynamical gate constructed without using the geometric phase. Our results indicate dynamical correction is a powerful tool to improve the geometric quantum computation to achieve a high-fidelity quantum gate in silicon.

arXiv:2207.04597•Physical Review A•Jan 5, 2023•8 citations

Geometric formalism for constructing arbitrary single-qubit dynamically corrected gates

Junkai Zeng, Chih Hwan Yang, Andrew S. Dzurak +1 more

Implementing high-fidelity quantum control and reducing the effect of the coupling between a quantum system and its environment is a major challenge in developing quantum information technologies. Here, we show that there exists a geometrical structure hidden within the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation that provides a simple way to view the entire solution space of pulses that suppress noise errors in a system's evolution. In this framework, any single-qubit gate that is robust against quasistatic noise to first order corresponds to a closed three-dimensional space curve, where the driving fields that implement the robust gate can be read off from the curvature and torsion of the space curve. Gates that are robust to second order are in one-to-one correspondence with closed curves whose projections onto three mutually orthogonal planes each enclose a vanishing net area. We use this formalism to derive examples of dynamically corrected gates generated from smooth pulses. We also show how it can be employed to analyze the noise-cancellation properties of pulses generated from numerical algorithms such as grape. A similar geometrical framework exists for quantum systems of arbitrary Hilbert space dimension.

arXiv:1811.04864•Physical Review A•May 15, 2019•55 citations

Geometric Phase in Quantum Computation

J. T. Thomas

A fundamental challenge of quantum computation is being able to scale up a large number of high fidelity quantum gates while noise and error are affecting the gate’s physical control parameters. This dissertation focuses on the fidelity of single-qubit quantum gates constructed by a change in quantum geometric phase, while the control parameters are affected by random noise and systematic error. A unified model of geometric quantum computation is developed, in which a qubit state is controlled by a composite Hamiltonian, resulting in a multiple-segment rotation of the quantum state and allowing characterization of evolution paths depending on the associated geometric and dynamic phase. The fidelity of the quantum gates in the presence of different noise error is compared for pu rely geometric, hybrid (having both geometric and dynamic phase), and conventional dynamic quantum gates built on single Hamiltonians. Results showed hybrid quantum gates had the highest fidelities, followed by geometric gates, and conventional dynamic gates had the lowest fidelities. In addition, there was indication in some cases higher fidelities result from gates created from a larger number of segments in the quantum state rotation. These results can be understood by the relation of the control parameters with the evolution path geometry. By translating between control parameters, our model can be applied to different systems for quantum computation, including: the laser manipulation of a two-level atom, laser manipulation of trapped ions, nuclear magnetic resonance, polarization states of photons, superconducting qubits in cavity QED, and quantum dots.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations
Geometric quantum gates are conjectured to be more resilient than dynamical gates against certain types of error, which makes them ideal for robust quantum computing. However, there are conflicting claims within the literature about the validity of that robustness conjecture. Here we use dynamical invariant theory in conjunction with filter functions in order to analytically characterize the noise sensitivity of an arbitrary quantum gate. Under certain conditions, we find that there exists a transformation of the Hamiltonian that leaves invariant the final gate and noise sensitivity (as characterized by the filter function) while changing the phase from geometric to dynamical. Our result holds for a Hilbert space of arbitrary dimensions, but we illustrate our result by examining experimentally relevant single-qubit scenarios and providing explicit constructions of such a transformation.
Geometric quantum gates are often expected to be more resilient than dynamical gates against certain types of error, which would make them ideal for robust quantum computing.However, this is still up for debate due to seemingly conflicting results in the literature.Here we use dynamical invariant theory in conjunction with filter functions in order to analytically characterize the noise sensitivity of an arbitrary quantum gate.For any control Hamiltonian that produces a geometric gate, we find that, under certain common conditions, one can construct another control Hamiltonian that produces an equivalent dynamical gate with identical noise sensitivity (as characterized by the filter function).Our result holds for a Hilbert space of arbitrary dimensions, but we illustrate our result by examining experimentally relevant singlequbit scenarios and providing explicit examples of equivalent geometric and dynamical gates.
For given control channels, quantum control theory determines whether quantum gates can be realized, but not their resilience to errors. We address this problem by establishing existence criteria for robust gate implementation in ddd-level systems. Our criteria reveal that implementability of all gates is not enough: a universal family of robust gates exists if and only if the driven Hamiltonians share no common symmetry. When these criteria hold, we can make gates resilient to any combination of static perturbations, uniform Hamiltonian rescaling, perturbations at a finite set of selected frequencies, and perturbations with arbitrary selected waveforms. We can impose robustness conditions broadly with limited information about errors, e.g., against any static perturbations; we can also tailor these conditions to the platform, e.g., against environment-induced noise with dominant spectral peaks, requiring no spectral details beyond the peak frequencies. We numerically construct explicit protocols for robust gates, reducing average gate infidelity by approximately two to seven orders of magnitude under Hamiltonian perturbations and environment-induced noise. Together, our existence criteria and numerical constructions provide practical guidance for evaluating the potential of quantum platforms and designing robust quantum gates.
The realistic application of geometric quantum computation is crucially dependent on an unproved robustness conjecture, claiming that geometric quantum gates are more resilient against random noise than dynamic gates. We propose a suitable model that allows a direct and fair comparison between geometrical and dynamical operations. In the presence of stochastic control errors we find that the maximum of gate fidelity corresponds to quantum gates with a vanishing dynamical phase. This is a clear evidence for the robustness of nonadiabatic geometric quantum computation. The predictions here presented can be experimentally tested in almost all of the already existing quantum computer candidates.
Geometric quantum gates are performed by using the geometric phase, making them particularly robust to the pulse amplitude error. However, in many systems, such as the silicon-based spin qubits, the off-resonance error is the dominant noise, which can cause dephasing and is always difficult to deal with for a geometric gate. Thus how to combat with the off-resonance error is very significant for the application of the geometric gates. A recent work [S. Li and Z.-Y. Xue, Phys. Rev. Appl. 16, 044005 (2021).] revealed that by inserting two $\ensuremath{\pi}$ pulses into the evolution paths, the holonomic quantum gate is effective to suppress the pulse amplitude error, however, it is still useless for combating the off-resonance error. Inspired by this work, we combine using the techniques of dynamical correction and path design. Surprisingly, we find that, by picking up a specific evolution path inserted by only a $\ensuremath{\pi}$-pulse, the obtained optimized geometric gate is robust to the off-resonance error, assuming the noise is static. Further, by calculating the filter function considering the realistic 1/f1/f1/f-type noise in silicon, the related results show that the performance of the optimized geometric gate can also surpass both the conventional geometric gate and the naive dynamical gate constructed without using the geometric phase. Our results indicate dynamical correction is a powerful tool to improve the geometric quantum computation to achieve a high-fidelity quantum gate in silicon.
Implementing high-fidelity quantum control and reducing the effect of the coupling between a quantum system and its environment is a major challenge in developing quantum information technologies. Here, we show that there exists a geometrical structure hidden within the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation that provides a simple way to view the entire solution space of pulses that suppress noise errors in a system's evolution. In this framework, any single-qubit gate that is robust against quasistatic noise to first order corresponds to a closed three-dimensional space curve, where the driving fields that implement the robust gate can be read off from the curvature and torsion of the space curve. Gates that are robust to second order are in one-to-one correspondence with closed curves whose projections onto three mutually orthogonal planes each enclose a vanishing net area. We use this formalism to derive examples of dynamically corrected gates generated from smooth pulses. We also show how it can be employed to analyze the noise-cancellation properties of pulses generated from numerical algorithms such as grape. A similar geometrical framework exists for quantum systems of arbitrary Hilbert space dimension.
A fundamental challenge of quantum computation is being able to scale up a large number of high fidelity quantum gates while noise and error are affecting the gate’s physical control parameters. This dissertation focuses on the fidelity of single-qubit quantum gates constructed by a change in quantum geometric phase, while the control parameters are affected by random noise and systematic error. A unified model of geometric quantum computation is developed, in which a qubit state is controlled by a composite Hamiltonian, resulting in a multiple-segment rotation of the quantum state and allowing characterization of evolution paths depending on the associated geometric and dynamic phase. The fidelity of the quantum gates in the presence of different noise error is compared for pu rely geometric, hybrid (having both geometric and dynamic phase), and conventional dynamic quantum gates built on single Hamiltonians. Results showed hybrid quantum gates had the highest fidelities, followed by geometric gates, and conventional dynamic gates had the lowest fidelities. In addition, there was indication in some cases higher fidelities result from gates created from a larger number of segments in the quantum state rotation. These results can be understood by the relation of the control parameters with the evolution path geometry. By translating between control parameters, our model can be applied to different systems for quantum computation, including: the laser manipulation of a two-level atom, laser manipulation of trapped ions, nuclear magnetic resonance, polarization states of photons, superconducting qubits in cavity QED, and quantum dots.