Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Investigating Quantum Speedup for Track Reconstruction: Classical and Quantum Computational Complexity Analysis

Duarte Magano, Akshat Kumar, Mārtiņš Kālis, Andris Locāns, Adam Glos, Sagar Silva Pratapsi, Gonçalo M. Quinta, Maksims Dimitrijevs, Aleksander Rivošs, P. Bargassa, J. Seixas, Andris Ambainis, Yasser Omar

Published Apr 23, 2021• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

To investigate the fundamental nature of matter and its interactions, particles are accelerated to very high energies and collided inside detectors, producing a multitude of other particles that are scattered in all directions. As the charged particles traverse the detector, they leave signals of their passage. The problem of track reconstruction is to recover the original trajectories from these signals. This represents a very challenging data analysis problem, which will become even more demanding as the luminosity of future accelerators keeps increasing, leading to collision events with a more complex structure. Therefore, there is a pressing need to develop more efficient methods, capable of sieving through the vast amount of data produced by these machines, in order to find the extremely rare events that may contain the clues for new Physics. In light of these challenges, approaches to track reconstruction based on quantum computation have recently been put forward. In this work, we study track reconstruction from a computational complexity perspective. Namely, we analyse a standard algorithm for tracking, the Combinatorial Track Finder, in the asymptotic limit of infinitely many recorded particles. First, we show that it is possible to improve the classical algorithm in this regime. Then, we show how to use quantum search routines to reach a lower computational complexity. And - although the found quantum speed-up is modest and of limited practical advantage in finite scenarios - to the best of our knowledge this constitutes the first theoretical proof of a quantum advantage for a state-of-the-art track reconstruction method, which we hope can further inspire classical and quantum improvements to High-Energy Physics computational challenges.

Related papers

Quantum speedup for track reconstruction in particle accelerators

Duarte Magano, A. Kumar, Mārtiņš Kālis +10 more

To investigate the fundamental nature of matter and its interactions, particles are accelerated to very high energies and collided inside detectors, producing a multitude of other particles that are scattered in all directions. As charged particles traverse the detector, they leave signals of their passage. The problem of track reconstruction is to recover the original trajectories from these signals. This challenging data analysis task will become even more demanding as the luminosity of future accelerators increases, leading to collision events with a more complex structure. We identify four fundamental routines present in every local tracking method and analyze how they scale in the context of a standard tracking algorithm. We show that for some of these routines we can reach a lower computational complexity with quantum search algorithms. Although the found quantum speedups are mild, this constitutes, to the best of our knowledge, the first rigorous evidence of a quantum advantage for a high-energy physics data processing task.

arXiv:2104.11583•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Apr 19, 2022•20 citations

Particle Track Reconstruction with Quantum Algorithms

Cenk Tüysüz, Federico Carminati, Bilge Melahat Demirköz +6 more

Accurate determination of particle track reconstruction parameters will be a major challenge for the High Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC) experiments. The expected increase in the number of simultaneous collisions at the HL-LHC and the resulting high detector occupancy will make track reconstruction algorithms extremely demanding in terms of time and computing resources. The increase in number of hits will increase the complexity of track reconstruction algorithms. In addition, the ambiguity in assigning hits to particle tracks will be increased due to the finite resolution of the detector and the physical “closeness” of the hits. Thus, the reconstruction of charged particle tracks will be a major challenge to the correct interpretation of the HL-LHC data. Most methods currently in use are based on Kalman filters which are shown to be robust and to provide good physics performance. However, they are expected to scale worse than quadratically. Designing an algorithm capable of reducing the combinatorial background at the hit level, would provide a much “cleaner” initial seed to the Kalman filter, strongly reducing the total processing time. One of the salient features of Quantum Computers is the ability to evaluate a very large number of states simultaneously, making them an ideal instrument for searches in a large parameter space. In fact, different R&D initiatives are exploring how Quantum Tracking Algorithms could leverage such capabilities. In this paper, we present our work on the implementation of a quantum-based track finding algorithm aimed at reducing combinatorial background during the initial seeding stage. We use the publicly available dataset designed for the kaggle TrackML challenge.

arXiv:2003.08126•EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2020•29 citations

A quantum algorithm for track reconstruction in the LHCb vertex detector

Davide Nicotra, M. Lucio Martínez, Jacco Andreas De Vries +5 more

Abstract High-energy physics is facing increasingly demanding computational challenges in real-time event reconstruction for the near-future high-luminosity era. Using the LHCb vertex detector as a use case, we explore a new algorithm for particle track reconstruction based on the minimisation of an Ising-like Hamiltonian with a linear algebra approach. The use of a classical matrix inversion technique results in tracking performance similar to the current state-of-the-art but with worse scaling complexity in time. To solve this problem, we also present an implementation as a quantum algorithm, using the Harrow-Hassadim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm: this approach can potentially provide an exponential speedup as a function of the number of input hits over its classical counterpart, in spite of limitations due to the well-known HHL Hamiltonian simulation and readout problems. The findings presented in this paper shed light on the potential of leveraging quantum computing for real-time particle track reconstruction in high-energy physics.

arXiv:2308.00619•Journal of Instrumentation•Nov 1, 2023•10 citations

A Quantum Graph Neural Network Approach to Particle Track Reconstruction

Tüysüz, Cenk, Bilge Melahat Demirköz, Dobos, Daniel +7 more

The unprecedented increase of complexity and scale of data is expected in the necessary computation for tracking detectors of the High Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC) experiments. While currently used Kalman filter based algorithms are reaching their limits in terms of ambiguities from increasing number of simultaneous collisions, occupancy, and scalability (worse than quadratic), a variety of machine learning approaches to particle track reconstruction are explored. It has been demonstrated previously by HEP.TrkX using TrackML datasets, that graph neural networks, processing events as a graph connecting track measurements, are a promising solution and can reduce the combinatorial background to a manageable amount and are scaling to a computationally reasonable size. In previous work, we have shown a first attempt of Quantum Computing to Graph Neural Networks for track reconstruction of particles. We aim to leverage the capability of quantum computing to evaluate a very large number of states simultaneously and thus to effectively search in a large parameter space. As the next step in this paper, we present an improved model with an iterative approach to overcome the low accuracy convergence of the initial oversimplified Tree Tensor Network (TTN) model.

arXiv:2007.06868•Apr 20, 2020•14 citations

Quantum Graph Neural Networks for Track Reconstruction in Particle Physics and Beyond

Cenk Tüysüz, Bilge Melahat Demirköz, D. Dobos +6 more

The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at the European Organisation for Nuclear Research (CERN) will undergo an upgrade to further increase the instantaneous rate of particle collisions (luminosity) and become the High Luminosity LHC. This increase in luminosity, will yield many more detector hits (occupancy), and thus measurements will pose a challenge to track reconstruction algorithms being responsible to determine particle trajectories from those hits. Similar challenges exist in non-high energy physics (HEP) trajectory reconstruction use-cases. High occupancy, track density, complexity and fast growth exponentially increase the demand of algorithms in terms of time, memory and computing resources.

•Oct 22, 2020•0 citations

Track reconstruction of charged particles using a 4D quantum algorithm

David Spataro, Federico Meloni, Y. C. Yap

Particle track reconstruction plays a crucial role in the exploration of new physical phenomena, particularly when rare signal tracks are obscured by a significant background. In muon colliders where beam muons interacting with the detector produce secondary and tertiary background par- ticles, track reconstruction can be computationally intensive due to the large number of detector hits. The formulation of the reconstruction task as quadratic unconstrained binary optimisation (QUBO) enables the use of quantum computers, which are believed to offer an advantage over classical computers in such optimisation scenarios. The QUBO parameters are determined by combining spatial and temporal information from detector hits, resulting in a 4D quantum al- gorithm. To demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach, the quantum algorithm is used to reconstruct signal tracks from samples consisting of Monte Carlo simulated charged particles overlaid with background hits for a Muon Collider tracking detector. We will present the obtained reconstruction performance and discuss possible paths for further improvements.

European Physical Society Conference on High Energy Physics (EPS-HEP)•Jan 19, 2024•0 citations
To investigate the fundamental nature of matter and its interactions, particles are accelerated to very high energies and collided inside detectors, producing a multitude of other particles that are scattered in all directions. As the charged particles traverse the detector, they leave signals of their passage. The problem of track reconstruction is to recover the original trajectories from these signals. This represents a very challenging data analysis problem, which will become even more demanding as the luminosity of future accelerators keeps increasing, leading to collision events with a more complex structure. Therefore, there is a pressing need to develop more efficient methods, capable of sieving through the vast amount of data produced by these machines, in order to find the extremely rare events that may contain the clues for new Physics. In light of these challenges, approaches to track reconstruction based on quantum computation have recently been put forward.
In this work, we study track reconstruction from a computational complexity perspective. Namely, we analyse a standard algorithm for tracking, the Combinatorial Track Finder, in the asymptotic limit of infinitely many recorded particles. First, we show that it is possible to improve the classical algorithm in this regime. Then, we show how to use quantum search routines to reach a lower computational complexity. And - although the found quantum speed-up is modest and of limited practical advantage in finite scenarios - to the best of our knowledge this constitutes the first theoretical proof of a quantum advantage for a state-of-the-art track reconstruction method, which we hope can further inspire classical and quantum improvements to High-Energy Physics computational challenges.
To investigate the fundamental nature of matter and its interactions, particles are accelerated to very high energies and collided inside detectors, producing a multitude of other particles that are scattered in all directions. As charged particles traverse the detector, they leave signals of their passage. The problem of track reconstruction is to recover the original trajectories from these signals. This challenging data analysis task will become even more demanding as the luminosity of future accelerators increases, leading to collision events with a more complex structure. We identify four fundamental routines present in every local tracking method and analyze how they scale in the context of a standard tracking algorithm. We show that for some of these routines we can reach a lower computational complexity with quantum search algorithms. Although the found quantum speedups are mild, this constitutes, to the best of our knowledge, the first rigorous evidence of a quantum advantage for a high-energy physics data processing task.
Accurate determination of particle track reconstruction parameters will be a major challenge for the High Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC) experiments. The expected increase in the number of simultaneous collisions at the HL-LHC and the resulting high detector occupancy will make track reconstruction algorithms extremely demanding in terms of time and computing resources. The increase in number of hits will increase the complexity of track reconstruction algorithms. In addition, the ambiguity in assigning hits to particle tracks will be increased due to the finite resolution of the detector and the physical “closeness” of the hits. Thus, the reconstruction of charged particle tracks will be a major challenge to the correct interpretation of the HL-LHC data. Most methods currently in use are based on Kalman filters which are shown to be robust and to provide good physics performance. However, they are expected to scale worse than quadratically. Designing an algorithm capable of reducing the combinatorial background at the hit level, would provide a much “cleaner” initial seed to the Kalman filter, strongly reducing the total processing time. One of the salient features of Quantum Computers is the ability to evaluate a very large number of states simultaneously, making them an ideal instrument for searches in a large parameter space. In fact, different R&D initiatives are exploring how Quantum Tracking Algorithms could leverage such capabilities. In this paper, we present our work on the implementation of a quantum-based track finding algorithm aimed at reducing combinatorial background during the initial seeding stage. We use the publicly available dataset designed for the kaggle TrackML challenge.
Abstract High-energy physics is facing increasingly demanding computational challenges in real-time event reconstruction for the near-future high-luminosity era. Using the LHCb vertex detector as a use case, we explore a new algorithm for particle track reconstruction based on the minimisation of an Ising-like Hamiltonian with a linear algebra approach. The use of a classical matrix inversion technique results in tracking performance similar to the current state-of-the-art but with worse scaling complexity in time. To solve this problem, we also present an implementation as a quantum algorithm, using the Harrow-Hassadim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm: this approach can potentially provide an exponential speedup as a function of the number of input hits over its classical counterpart, in spite of limitations due to the well-known HHL Hamiltonian simulation and readout problems. The findings presented in this paper shed light on the potential of leveraging quantum computing for real-time particle track reconstruction in high-energy physics.
The unprecedented increase of complexity and scale of data is expected in the necessary computation for tracking detectors of the High Luminosity Large Hadron Collider (HL-LHC) experiments. While currently used Kalman filter based algorithms are reaching their limits in terms of ambiguities from increasing number of simultaneous collisions, occupancy, and scalability (worse than quadratic), a variety of machine learning approaches to particle track reconstruction are explored. It has been demonstrated previously by HEP.TrkX using TrackML datasets, that graph neural networks, processing events as a graph connecting track measurements, are a promising solution and can reduce the combinatorial background to a manageable amount and are scaling to a computationally reasonable size. In previous work, we have shown a first attempt of Quantum Computing to Graph Neural Networks for track reconstruction of particles. We aim to leverage the capability of quantum computing to evaluate a very large number of states simultaneously and thus to effectively search in a large parameter space. As the next step in this paper, we present an improved model with an iterative approach to overcome the low accuracy convergence of the initial oversimplified Tree Tensor Network (TTN) model.
The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at the European Organisation for Nuclear Research (CERN) will undergo an upgrade to further increase the instantaneous rate of particle collisions (luminosity) and become the High Luminosity LHC. This increase in luminosity, will yield many more detector hits (occupancy), and thus measurements will pose a challenge to track reconstruction algorithms being responsible to determine particle trajectories from those hits. Similar challenges exist in non-high energy physics (HEP) trajectory reconstruction use-cases. High occupancy, track density, complexity and fast growth exponentially increase the demand of algorithms in terms of time, memory and computing resources.
Particle track reconstruction plays a crucial role in the exploration of new physical phenomena, particularly when rare signal tracks are obscured by a significant background. In muon colliders where beam muons interacting with the detector produce secondary and tertiary background par- ticles, track reconstruction can be computationally intensive due to the large number of detector hits. The formulation of the reconstruction task as quadratic unconstrained binary optimisation (QUBO) enables the use of quantum computers, which are believed to offer an advantage over classical computers in such optimisation scenarios. The QUBO parameters are determined by combining spatial and temporal information from detector hits, resulting in a 4D quantum al- gorithm. To demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach, the quantum algorithm is used to reconstruct signal tracks from samples consisting of Monte Carlo simulated charged particles overlaid with background hits for a Muon Collider tracking detector. We will present the obtained reconstruction performance and discuss possible paths for further improvements.