A macroscopic object passively cooled into its quantum ground state of motion
Dylan Cattiaux, Ilya Golokolenov, Sumit Kumar, Mika A. Sillanpää, Laure Mercier de Lépinay, R. R. Gazizulin, Xin Zhou, Andrew D. Armour, Olivier Bourgeois, Andrew D. Fefferman, Eddy Collin
The building blocks of Nature, namely atoms and elementary particles, are described by quantum mechanics. This fundamental theory is the ground on which physicists have built their major mathematical models [1]. Today, the unique features of quantum objects have led to the advent of promising quantum technologies [2, 3]. However, the macroscopic world is manifestly classical, and the nature of the quantum-to-classical crossover remains one of the most challenging open question of Science to date. In this respect, moving objects play a specific role [4, 5]. Pioneering experiments over the last few years have begun exploring quantum behaviour of micron-sized mechanical systems, adapting laser cooling techniques developed in atomic physics to cool specific modes far below the temperature of their surroundings [6-11]. Here instead we describe a very different approach, passive cooling of a micromechanical system down to 500 microK, reducing the average number of quanta in the fundamental vibrational mode to just 0.3; the challenge being to be still able to detect the motion without disturbing the system noticeably. With such an approach higher harmonics and the surrounding environment are also cooled, leading to potentially much longer mechanical coherence times, and enabling experiments questioning mechanical wave-function collapse [12], potentially from the gravitational background [13, 14], and quantum thermodynamics [15]. Beyond the average behaviour, here we also report on the fluctuations of the fundamental vibrational mode of the device in-equilibrium with the cryostat. These reveal a surprisingly complex interplay with the local environment and allow characteristics of two distinct thermodynamic baths to be probed.
The building blocks of Nature, namely atoms and elementary particles, are described by quantum mechanics. This fundamental theory is the ground on which physicists have built their major mathematical models [1]. Today, the unique features of quantum objects have led to the advent of promising quantum technologies [2, 3]. However, the macroscopic world is manifestly classical, and the nature of the quantum-to-classical crossover remains one of the most challenging open question of Science to date. In this respect, moving objects play a specific role [4, 5]. Pioneering experiments over the last few years have begun exploring quantum behaviour of micron-sized mechanical systems, adapting laser cooling techniques developed in atomic physics to cool specific modes far below the temperature of their surroundings [6-11]. Here instead we describe a very different approach, passive cooling of a micromechanical system down to 500 microK, reducing the average number of quanta in the fundamental vibrational mode to just 0.3; the challenge being to be still able to detect the motion without disturbing the system noticeably. With such an approach higher harmonics and the surrounding environment are also cooled, leading to potentially much longer mechanical coherence times, and enabling experiments questioning mechanical wave-function collapse [12], potentially from the gravitational background [13, 14], and quantum thermodynamics [15]. Beyond the average behaviour, here we also report on the fluctuations of the fundamental vibrational mode of the device in-equilibrium with the cryostat. These reveal a surprisingly complex interplay with the local environment and allow characteristics of two distinct thermodynamic baths to be probed.
In the last decade, experimentalists have demonstrated their impressive ability to control mechanical modes within mesoscopic objects down to the quantum level: it is now possible to create mechanical Fock states, to entangle mechanical modes from distinct objects, and to store quantum information or transfer it from one quantum bit to another, among the many possibilities found in today's literature. Indeed, mechanics is quantum, very much like spins or electromagnetic degrees of freedom; and all of this is, in particular, referred to as a new engineering resource for quantum technologies. However, there is also much more beyond this utilitarian aspect: invoking the original discussions of Braginsky and Caves, where a quantum oscillator is thought of as a quantum detector for a classical field, namely, a gravitational wave, which is also a unique sensing capability for quantum fields. The subject of study is then the baths to which the mechanical mode is coupled to, let them be known or unknown in nature. This Perspective is about this new potentiality that addresses stochastic thermodynamics, potentially down to its quantum version, the search for a fundamental underlying (random) field postulated in recent theories that can be affiliated to the class of the wave-function collapse models, and more generally open questions of condensed matter like the actual nature of the elusive (and ubiquitous) two-level systems present within all mechanical objects. However, such research turns out to be much more demanding than the use of a few quantum mechanical modes: all the known baths have to be identified, experiments have to be conducted in-equilibrium, and the word “mechanics” needs to be justified by a real ability to move substantially the center-of-mass when a proper drive tone is applied to the system.
The field of cavity optomechanics is based on the coupling of optical cavities to mechanical degrees of freedom. Over the past two decades, it has led to remarkable and surprising discoveries. A cavity optomechanical system enabled the first observation of gravitational waves, a discovery awarded with the 2017 Nobel prize, confirming Einstein's 100-year-old prediction. It was also a cavity optomechanical system that has for the first time enabled ground state cooling of the motion of an object containing ~1012 atoms, and entanglement of mechanical oscillators of similar size. Moreover, cavity optomechanical systems have facilitated significant progress in precision-sensing technologies, with diverse applications such as biosensing, magnetometry, and many more.But this may only be the beginning. The field is still in its early days and experimental capabilities are improving fast. For instance, cavity optomechanical systems have the potential to test predicted signatures of quantum gravity such as modifications to the canonical commutator, short-distance modifications to Newtonian gravity, dark matter and dark energy, and even extra dimensions. In this sense, they form an economical platform with a short experimental turnover time, that can compete in its predictive power with mega-scale, multi-billion-dollar experiments such as the Large Hadron Collider.This thesis is dedicated to utilizing cavity optomechanics to explore the maybe most challenging and unexplored frontier in quantum mechanics: The dynamics of macroscopic quantum systems. Quantum physics, since its discovery in the early 20th century, has revolutionized our understanding of the microworld, but has long been thought to apply exclusively to extremely small objects. However, over the past decades, ever-larger quantum systems have emerged in laboratories around the world. On one hand, these are collective, macroscopic quantum phenomena such as superfluidity, superconductivity, and Bose-Einstein condensation. On the other hand, they are quantum states of relatively massive mechanical objects. While our understanding of the interplay of quantum mechanical and classical systems has greatly improved over the past decades, as described by theories of decoherence and open quantum systems, many basic questions about macroscopic quantum systems still remain unanswered. Quantum fluids such as Bose-Einstein condensates and superfluid helium are inherently hard to understand due to their complex dynamics, and difficult to probe experimentally due to the weakness of their interactions with the environment and their fragile nature. This is especially true in the strongly-interacting regime, which is, for instance, found in superfluid helium.Another long-standing, unanswered set of questions in quantum mechanics is related to the quantum measurement problem. What constitutes a quantum measurement? What happens if we engineer a quantum state that is large enough to be, in principle, part of our everyday world? What if we attempt to create a quantum superposition of a living being? Do the laws of physics even permit either of these scenarios?Cavity optomechanics is a unique and powerful platform to investigate macroscopic quantum systems. The extreme sensitivity of cavity optomechanical sensors in readout of mechanical motion makes them susceptible to minute quantum effects. The strong coupling between single photons and phonons in these systems allows engineering and measurement of quantum states of mechanical systems. Furthermore, most cavity optomechanical experiments are cryo-compatible and small in size, which allows integration with other quantum systems to be analyzed, such as superfluid helium.
Optomechanics
Cooling massive particles to the quantum ground state allows fundamental tests of quantum mechanics to be made; it would provide an experimental probe of the boundary between the classical and quantum worlds. Delic et al. laser-cooled an optically trapped solid-state object (a ∼150-nanometer-diameter silic a nanoparticle) into its quantum ground state of motion starting from room temperature. Because the object is levitated using optical forces, the experimental configuration can be switched to free fall, thereby providing a test bed for several macroscopic quantum experiments.
Science , this issue p. [892][1]
[1]: /lookup/doi/10.1126/science.aba3993
The coupling of nanomechanical resonators to controllable quantum systems represents a growing and promising area of research. Recent advances in this field have brought to astonishing results, such as the initialization of a mechanical resonator into its quantum ground state and even the preparation of non-classical coherent states of motion. These achievements open up appealing scenarios to quantum information technologies and to the exploration of the quantum-classical boundary. From an application perspective, such quantum-mechanical hybrid systems provide a versatile and attractive tool for a variety of precision measurements, like ultra-sensitive detection of force, mass, and displacement. \n \nQuantum control over a mechanical resonator, or, conversely, the prospect of using resonator's motion for probing quantum states, both involve some tight requirements. First of all, the interaction between the mechanics and its quantum partner has to be large on the scale of the decoherence rates of the coupled systems. In most cases, the coupling mechanism has to be activated by engineering the resonator with electrodes, magnets, or mirrors, or by using tailored laser fields. For this reason, the search for a strong coupling typically competes with the requirement of overcoming decoherence effects. In addition, for quantum effects to be observable, strong coupling has to be accompanied by the preparation of zero entropy initial states, for instance by cooling the resonator into its ground state of motion. \n \nThe motivation pursued by this thesis is to contribute to the inspiring field of hybrid systems by walking through each of the aforementioned directions. We in fact demonstrate a promising system in which optically active quantum dots, embedded in fully self-assembled core-shell nanowires, are coupled to the nanowire motion. Mechanical vibrations of the nanowire modulate the quantum dot emission energy over a broad range exceeding 14 meV, by means of deformation potential coupling. In our system, therefore, both the coupling mechanism and the quantum states themselves are intrinsic to the resonator's structure. Besides revealing unusually strong, such a built-in opto-mechanical interaction produces a hybrid system whose inherent coherence is unspoiled by any functionalization or external field and whose fabrication is simpler than top-down techniques. \n \nWe further demonstrate the use of a quantum point contact as a displacement transducer to measure and control the low-temperature thermal motion of a nearby micromechanical cantilever. We show that by including the QPC in a suitable feedback loop, we are able to cool the cantilever's fundamental mechanical mode down to the level of the measurement noise, achieving a squashing of the QPC noise at high gain. Due to its off-board design, our system is particularly versatile and suitable to force-sensing applications. Since the QPC transducer is sensitive to local modifications of the nearby electric field, our approach is in principle compatible with any nanoscale resonator, without requiring any functionalization to activate the coupling. By improving the performance of the QPC as a one-dimensional conductor and the cantilever-QPC capacitive coupling, our system has the potential to achieve quantum-limited displacement resolution and ground state cooling. We then report on some ongoing attempts to overcome the current limitations of our system and couple mechanical motion to different mesoscopic transport devices. \n \nWe remark that our demonstration of an as-grown quantum-dot-in-nanowire hybrid system opens up bright prospects on future experiments, as also testified by the very recent ferment of the scientific community around this topic. We find that the opto-mechanical coupling rate is not far from the nanowire mechanical frequency. This fact makes our system particularly promising for the quantum non-demolition readout of a quantum dot state through a measurement of the nanowire position. On the other hand, we show that the coupling can be further optimized, and the nanowire mechanical heating rate reduced, thus disclosing the captivating perspective of using quantum dots to probe and control the mechanical state of a nanowire. In this context, it would be important to investigate a possible spin-oscillator coupling in our system, given the long coherence time offered by a spin state in a quantum dot. The wide range of control over the quantum dots emission energy and the ability to tune two neighboring dots into resonance pave the way to mechanically induced emitter-emitter coupling. In addition, our monolithic opto-mechanical system constitutes a good candidate for recent proposals of a tripartite hybrid system, which would integrate an optical cavity, a quantum two-level system and a mechanical resonator. The intrinsically strong coupling between the quantum dots and the nanowire motion would enhance the interaction between the mechanics and the cavity field, leading for instance to efficient cooling of the resonator to the ground state. Finally, the quantum dot sensitivity to the nanowire resonant vibration could also support the use of our system as an integrated force probe or as a nanomechanical mass sensor. In other words, the results reported in this dissertation constitute not only a relevant proof-of-principle, moreover they open up intriguing challenges for future research.
A nanoparticle trapped and cooled Cooling massive particles to the quantum ground state allows fundamental tests of quantum mechanics to be made; it would provide an experimental probe of the boundary between the classical and quantum worlds. Delić et al. laser-cooled an optically trapped solid-state object (a ∼150-nanometer-diameter silic a nanoparticle) into its quantum ground state of motion starting from room temperature. Because the object is levitated using optical forces, the experimental configuration can be switched to free fall, thereby providing a test bed for several macroscopic quantum experiments. Science , this issue p. 892
Why are classical theories often sufficient to describe the physics of our world even though everything around us is entirely composed of microscopic quantum systems? The boundary between these two fundamentally dissimilar theories remains an unsolved problem in modern physics. Position measurements of small objects allow us to probe the area where the classical approximation breaks down. In quantum mechanics, Heisenbergâ s uncertainty principle dictates that any measurement of the position must be accompanied by measurement induced back-action---in this case manifested as an uncertainty in the momentum. In recent years, cavity optomechanics has become a powerful tool to perform precise position measurements and investigate their fundamental limitations. The utilization of optical micro-cavities greatly enhances the interaction between light and state-of-the-art nanomechanical oscillators. Therefore, quantum mechanical phenomena have been successfully observed in systems far beyond the microscopic world. In such a cavity optomechanical system, the fluctuations in the position of the oscillator are transduced onto the phase of the light, while fluctuations in the amplitude of the light disturb the momentum of the oscillator during the measurement. As a consequence, correlations are established between the amplitude and phase quadrature of the probe light. However, so far, observation of quantum effects has been limited exclusively to cryogenic experiments, and access to the quantum regime at room temperature has remained an elusive goal because the overwhelming amount of thermal motion masks the weak quantum effects. This thesis describes the engineering of a high-performance cavity optomechanical device and presents experimental results showing, for the first time, the broadband effects of quantum back-action at room temperature. The device strongly couples mechanical and optical modes of exceptionally high quality factors to provide a measurement sensitivity ∼104 times below the requirement to resolve the zero-point fluctuations of the mechanical oscillator. The quantum back-action is then observed through the correlations created between the probe light and the motion of the nanomechanical oscillator. A so-called â variational measurementâ , which detects the transmitted light in a homodyne detector tuned close to the amplitude quadrature, resolves the quantum noise due to these correlations at the level of 10\% of the thermal noise over more than an octave of Fourier frequencies around mechanical resonance. Moreover, building on this result, an additional experiment demonstrates the ability to achieve quantum enhanced metrology. In this case, the generated quantum correlations are used to cancel quantum noise in the measurement record, which then leads to an improved relative signal-to-noise ratio in measurements of an external force. In conclusion, the successful observation of broadband quantum behavior on a macroscopic object at room temperature is an important milestone in the field of cavity optomechanics. Specifically, this result heralds the rise of optomechanical systems as a platform for quantum physics at room temperature and shows promise for generation of ponderomotive squeezing in room-temperature interferometers.