Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)

All Inequalities for the Relative Entropy

Ben Ibinson, Noah Linden, Andreas Winter

Published Jul 1, 2006• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The relative entropy of two distributions of n random variables, and more generally of two n-party quantum states, is an important quantity exhibiting, for example, the extent to which the two distributions/states are different. The relative entropy of the states formed by restricting to a smaller number m of parties is always less than or equal to the relative entropy of the two original n-party states. This is the monotonicity of relative entropy. Using techniques from convex geometry, we prove that monotonicity under restrictions is the only general inequality satisfied by relative entropies. In doing so we make a connection to secret sharing schemes with general access structures: indeed, it turns out that the extremal rays of the cone defined by monotonicity are populated by classical secret sharing schemes. A surprising outcome is that the structure of allowed relative entropy values of subsets of multiparty states is much simpler than the structure of allowed entropy values. And the structure of allowed relative entropy values (unlike that of entropies) is the same for classical probability distributions and quantum states

DOI
10.1109/isit.2006.261841

Related papers

The structure of Rényi entropic inequalities

Noah Linden, Milán Mosonyi, Andreas Winter

We investigate the universal inequalities relating the α -Rényi entropies of the marginals of a multi-partite quantum state. This is in analogy to the same question for the Shannon and von Neumann entropies ( α =1), which are known to satisfy several non-trivial inequalities such as strong subadditivity. Somewhat surprisingly, we find for 0< α <1 that the only inequality is non-negativity: in other words, any collection of non-negative numbers assigned to the non-empty subsets of n parties can be arbitrarily well approximated by the α -entropies of the 2 n −1 marginals of a quantum state. For α >1, we show analogously that there are no non-trivial homogeneous (in particular, no linear) inequalities. On the other hand, it is known that there are further, nonlinear and indeed non-homogeneous, inequalities delimiting the α -entropies of a general quantum state. Finally, we also treat the case of Rényi entropies restricted to classical states (i.e. probability distributions), which, in addition to non-negativity, are also subject to monotonicity. For α ≠0,1, we show that this is the only other homogeneous relation.

arXiv:1212.0248•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Aug 21, 2013•76 citations

Classical and quantum relative entropy

Patrícia Szokol

The concept of entropy rst arose in the study of thermodynamics and statistical me- chanics. In information theory the so-called Shannon entropy plays a signi cant role, which measures how much information we gain, on average, when we learn the value of a random variable. An alternative interpretation is that the entropy of the random variable quanti es the amount of uncertainty about the random variable before we learn its value. The concept was introduced by Claude E. Shannon in his 1948 paper "A Mathematical Theory of Communication". In the rst part of the present work we consider this fundamental measure of information and show some of its properties, such as non-negativity. The relative entropy or the Kullback-Leibler divergence is a very useful measure of the distance between two prob- ability distributions. After introducing its de nition and other notions (joint entropy, conditional entropy or mutual information) we can prove additional assertions about the Shannon entropy and present statements about the relations between the above men- tioned quantities. In quantum information theory, there is a quantity, namely von Neumann entropy, which corresponds to Shannon entropy and originates from it. In the section Von Neu- mann entropy we will introduce this quantity which is a continuous functional on the states, or on their mathematical representatives, the density operators, and it ful ls in- equalities such as subadditivity and strong subaddititvity. Just as with the Shannon entropy, it is extremely useful to de ne a quantum version of the relative entropy, which is one of the most important numerical quantities appearing in quantum information theory. It is used as a measure of distinguishability between quantum states. Among others its properties are jointly convexity, monotonicity which are speci cally convenient. Transformations on structures which preserve operations, quantities or relations among elements appear in many areas of mathematics. These are the so-called preservers which show up also in physics and even in chemistry where they are usually called symmetries. Therefore, the study of preserver transformations is an important area of research. The third section of this work is based on a paper, in which Lajos Molnár described the structure every bijective map on the space of all density operators on a given Hilbert space, which preserves the relative entropy. This result is closely related to Wigner's famous theorem on the form of quantum mechanical symmetry transformations. The above theorem of Molnár can be extended into two directions. On the one hand, the result holds also in the case when the transformation under consideration acts on the space of all positive semide nite operators not only on density operators (i.e., we omit the condition of unit trace). On the other hand the statement remains valid even if we omit the strongly restrictive condition that the transformation is bijective. The second result is a joint work with Prof. Lajos Molnár which appeared in the journal Linear Algebra and Its Applications.

•May 6, 2010•0 citations

Bounds on general entropy measures

Dominic William Berry, Barry C. Sanders

Abstract. We show how to determine the maximum and minimum possible values of one measure of entropy for a given value of another measure of entropy. These maximum and minimum values are obtained for two standard forms of probability distribution (or quantum state) independent of the entropy measures, provided the entropy measures satisfy a concavity/convexity relation. These results may be applied to entropies for classical probability distributions, entropies of mixed quantum states and measures of entanglement for pure states. PACS numbers: 03.67.–a

•Jan 1, 2004•18 citations

Monotonicity versions of Epstein's Concavity Theorem and related inequalities

Eric A. Carlen, Haonan Zhang

Many trace inequalities can be expressed either as concavity/convexity theorems or as monotonicity theorems. A classic example is the joint convexity of the quantum relative entropy which is equivalent to the Data Processing Inequality. The latter says that quantum operations can never increase the relative entropy. The monotonicity versions often have many advantages, and often have direct physical application, as in the example just mentioned. Moreover, the monotonicity results are often valid for a larger class of maps than, say, quantum operations (which are completely positive). In this paper we prove several new monotonicity results, the first of which is a monotonicity theorem that has as a simple corollary a celebrated concavity theorem of Epstein. Our starting points are the monotonicity versions of the Lieb Concavity and the Lieb Convexity Theorems. We also give two new proofs of these in their general forms using interpolation. We then prove our new monotonicity theorems by several duality arguments.

arXiv:2205.02342•Linear Algebra and its Applications•Sep 7, 2022•7 citations

Inequalities for Quantum Entropy: A Review with Conditions for Equality

Mary Beth Ruskai

This paper presents self-contained proofs of the strong subadditivity inequality for quantum entropy and some related inequalities for the quantum relative entropy, most notably its convexity and its monotonicity under stochastic maps. Moreover, the approach presented here, which is based on Klein's inequality and one of Lieb's less well-known concave trace functions, allows one to obtain conditions for equality. Using the fact that the Holevo bound on the accessible information in a quantum ensemble can be obtained as a consequence of the monotonicity of relative entropy, we show that equality can be attained for that bound only when the states in the ensemble commute. The paper concludes with an Appendix giving a short description of Epstein's elegant proof of the relevant concavity theorem of Lieb.

•May 13, 2002•159 citations

Constraints on Multipartite Quantum Entropies

Christian Majenz

The von Neumann entropy plays a vital role in quantum information theory. The von Neumann entropy determines, e.g., the capacities of quantum channels. Also, entropies of composite quantum systems are important for future quantum networks, and their characterization is related to the quantum marginal problem. Furthermore, they play a role in quantum thermodynamics. In this thesis the set of quantum entropies of multipartite quantum systems is studied. The problem of its characterization is not new -- however, progress has been sparse, indicating that the problem might be hard and that new methods might be needed. Here, a variety of different and complementary approaches are taken. First, I look at global properties. It is known that the von Neumann entropy region -- just like its classical counterpart -- forms a convex cone. I describe the symmetries of this cone and highlight geometric similarities and differences to the classical entropy cone. In a different approach, I utilize the local geometric properties of extremal rays of a cone. I show that quantum states whose entropy lies on such an extremal ray of the quantum entropy cone have a very simple structure. As the set of all quantum states is very complicated, I look at a simple subset called stabilizer states. I improve on previously known results by showing that under a technical condition on the local dimension, entropies of stabilizer states respect an additional class of information inequalities that is valid for random variables from linear codes. In a last approach I find a representation-theoretic formulation of the classical marginal problem simplifying the comparison with its quantum mechanical counterpart. This novel correspondence yields a simplified formulation of the group characterization of classical entropies (IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, 48(7):1992-1995, 2002) in purely combinatorial terms.

arXiv:1810.12845•Oct 30, 2018•2 citations
The relative entropy of two distributions of n random variables, and more generally of two n-party quantum states, is an important quantity exhibiting, for example, the extent to which the two distributions/states are different. The relative entropy of the states formed by restricting to a smaller number m of parties is always less than or equal to the relative entropy of the two original n-party states. This is the monotonicity of relative entropy. Using techniques from convex geometry, we prove that monotonicity under restrictions is the only general inequality satisfied by relative entropies. In doing so we make a connection to secret sharing schemes with general access structures: indeed, it turns out that the extremal rays of the cone defined by monotonicity are populated by classical secret sharing schemes. A surprising outcome is that the structure of allowed relative entropy values of subsets of multiparty states is much simpler than the structure of allowed entropy values. And the structure of allowed relative entropy values (unlike that of entropies) is the same for classical probability distributions and quantum states
We investigate the universal inequalities relating the α -Rényi entropies of the marginals of a multi-partite quantum state. This is in analogy to the same question for the Shannon and von Neumann entropies ( α =1), which are known to satisfy several non-trivial inequalities such as strong subadditivity. Somewhat surprisingly, we find for 0< α <1 that the only inequality is non-negativity: in other words, any collection of non-negative numbers assigned to the non-empty subsets of n parties can be arbitrarily well approximated by the α -entropies of the 2 n −1 marginals of a quantum state. For α >1, we show analogously that there are no non-trivial homogeneous (in particular, no linear) inequalities. On the other hand, it is known that there are further, nonlinear and indeed non-homogeneous, inequalities delimiting the α -entropies of a general quantum state. Finally, we also treat the case of Rényi entropies restricted to classical states (i.e. probability distributions), which, in addition to non-negativity, are also subject to monotonicity. For α ≠0,1, we show that this is the only other homogeneous relation.
The concept of entropy rst arose in the study of thermodynamics and statistical me- chanics. In information theory the so-called Shannon entropy plays a signi cant role, which measures how much information we gain, on average, when we learn the value of a random variable. An alternative interpretation is that the entropy of the random variable quanti es the amount of uncertainty about the random variable before we learn its value. The concept was introduced by Claude E. Shannon in his 1948 paper "A Mathematical Theory of Communication". In the rst part of the present work we consider this fundamental measure of information and show some of its properties, such as non-negativity. The relative entropy or the Kullback-Leibler divergence is a very useful measure of the distance between two prob- ability distributions. After introducing its de nition and other notions (joint entropy, conditional entropy or mutual information) we can prove additional assertions about the Shannon entropy and present statements about the relations between the above men- tioned quantities. In quantum information theory, there is a quantity, namely von Neumann entropy, which corresponds to Shannon entropy and originates from it. In the section Von Neu- mann entropy we will introduce this quantity which is a continuous functional on the states, or on their mathematical representatives, the density operators, and it ful ls in- equalities such as subadditivity and strong subaddititvity. Just as with the Shannon entropy, it is extremely useful to de ne a quantum version of the relative entropy, which is one of the most important numerical quantities appearing in quantum information theory. It is used as a measure of distinguishability between quantum states. Among others its properties are jointly convexity, monotonicity which are speci cally convenient. Transformations on structures which preserve operations, quantities or relations among elements appear in many areas of mathematics. These are the so-called preservers which show up also in physics and even in chemistry where they are usually called symmetries. Therefore, the study of preserver transformations is an important area of research. The third section of this work is based on a paper, in which Lajos Molnár described the structure every bijective map on the space of all density operators on a given Hilbert space, which preserves the relative entropy. This result is closely related to Wigner's famous theorem on the form of quantum mechanical symmetry transformations. The above theorem of Molnár can be extended into two directions. On the one hand, the result holds also in the case when the transformation under consideration acts on the space of all positive semide nite operators not only on density operators (i.e., we omit the condition of unit trace). On the other hand the statement remains valid even if we omit the strongly restrictive condition that the transformation is bijective. The second result is a joint work with Prof. Lajos Molnár which appeared in the journal Linear Algebra and Its Applications.
Abstract. We show how to determine the maximum and minimum possible values of one measure of entropy for a given value of another measure of entropy. These maximum and minimum values are obtained for two standard forms of probability distribution (or quantum state) independent of the entropy measures, provided the entropy measures satisfy a concavity/convexity relation. These results may be applied to entropies for classical probability distributions, entropies of mixed quantum states and measures of entanglement for pure states. PACS numbers: 03.67.–a
Many trace inequalities can be expressed either as concavity/convexity theorems or as monotonicity theorems. A classic example is the joint convexity of the quantum relative entropy which is equivalent to the Data Processing Inequality. The latter says that quantum operations can never increase the relative entropy. The monotonicity versions often have many advantages, and often have direct physical application, as in the example just mentioned. Moreover, the monotonicity results are often valid for a larger class of maps than, say, quantum operations (which are completely positive). In this paper we prove several new monotonicity results, the first of which is a monotonicity theorem that has as a simple corollary a celebrated concavity theorem of Epstein. Our starting points are the monotonicity versions of the Lieb Concavity and the Lieb Convexity Theorems. We also give two new proofs of these in their general forms using interpolation. We then prove our new monotonicity theorems by several duality arguments.
This paper presents self-contained proofs of the strong subadditivity inequality for quantum entropy and some related inequalities for the quantum relative entropy, most notably its convexity and its monotonicity under stochastic maps. Moreover, the approach presented here, which is based on Klein's inequality and one of Lieb's less well-known concave trace functions, allows one to obtain conditions for equality. Using the fact that the Holevo bound on the accessible information in a quantum ensemble can be obtained as a consequence of the monotonicity of relative entropy, we show that equality can be attained for that bound only when the states in the ensemble commute. The paper concludes with an Appendix giving a short description of Epstein's elegant proof of the relevant concavity theorem of Lieb.
The von Neumann entropy plays a vital role in quantum information theory. The von Neumann entropy determines, e.g., the capacities of quantum channels. Also, entropies of composite quantum systems are important for future quantum networks, and their characterization is related to the quantum marginal problem. Furthermore, they play a role in quantum thermodynamics. In this thesis the set of quantum entropies of multipartite quantum systems is studied. The problem of its characterization is not new -- however, progress has been sparse, indicating that the problem might be hard and that new methods might be needed. Here, a variety of different and complementary approaches are taken. First, I look at global properties. It is known that the von Neumann entropy region -- just like its classical counterpart -- forms a convex cone. I describe the symmetries of this cone and highlight geometric similarities and differences to the classical entropy cone. In a different approach, I utilize the local geometric properties of extremal rays of a cone. I show that quantum states whose entropy lies on such an extremal ray of the quantum entropy cone have a very simple structure. As the set of all quantum states is very complicated, I look at a simple subset called stabilizer states. I improve on previously known results by showing that under a technical condition on the local dimension, entropies of stabilizer states respect an additional class of information inequalities that is valid for random variables from linear codes. In a last approach I find a representation-theoretic formulation of the classical marginal problem simplifying the comparison with its quantum mechanical counterpart. This novel correspondence yields a simplified formulation of the group characterization of classical entropies (IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, 48(7):1992-1995, 2002) in purely combinatorial terms.