Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physica Scripta

Probability flow for a free particle: new quantum effects

Anthony J. Bracken

Published Jan 20, 2021• 21 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract New quantum probability flow bounds and associated eigenfunctions are determined numerically for a free non-relativistic particle, with momentum lying in the range ( p 0 , ∞), for each fixed p 0 chosen in the range (−∞ , ∞). It is found that as p 0 increases through positive values, the maximum possible probability backflow from right-to left (R to L), opposite to the direction of all contributing momenta, decreases monotonically from the well-known value ≈0.038452 at p 0 = 0 but never reaches 0. As p 0 decreases through negative values, the maximum R to L flow increases monotonically but never reaches 1. These new quantum effects are compared and contrasted with the corresponding classical behaviour. A surprising new effect is revealed: Even when p 0 is negative, L to R directed momenta contribute to the maximum R to L flow. The size of this contribution is indicated by comparing with the maximum R to L flow possible when only negative momenta with values between p 0 and 0 are allowed. The extended modeling admits a simple interpretation of the classical limit without the introduction of a mechanism external to the system, as an effective value of Planck’s constant approaches zero.

DOI
10.1088/1402-4896/abdd54

Related papers

Probability backflow and a new dimensionless quantum number

Anthony J. Bracken, G.F. Melloy

Pure states of a free particle in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are described, in which the probability of finding the particle to have a negative x-coordinate increases over an arbitrarily long, but finite, time interval, even though the x-component of the particle's velocity is certainly positive throughout that time interval. It is shown that, for any state of this type, the greatest amount of probability which can flow back from positive to negative x-values in this counter-intuitive way, over any given time interval, is equal to the largest eigenvalue of a certain Hermitian operator, and it is estimated numerically to have a value near 0.04. This value is not only independent of the length of the time interval and the mass of the particle, but is also independent of the value of Planck's constant. It reflects the structure of Schrodinger's equation, rather than the values of the parameters appearing there. Backflow of positive probability is related to the non-positivity of Wigner's density function, and can be regarded as arising from a flow of negative probability in the same direction as the velocity. Generalizations are indicated, to the relativistic free electron, and to non-relativistic cases in which probability backflow occurs even in opposition to an arbitrarily strong constant force.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Mar 21, 1994•140 citations

An introduction to the quantum backflow effect

James M. Yearsley, J. J. Halliwell

We present an introduction to the backflow effect in quantum mechanics – the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We show that the effect is present even for simple states consisting of superpositions of gaussian wave packets, although the size of the effect is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al, we present a wave function whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which has periods of significant backflow, with a backwards flux equal to about 70 percent of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number c bm ≈ 0.04, discovered by Bracken and Melloy. This number has the unusual property of being independent of ℏ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to a quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We conclude by discussing a specific measurement model in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.

arXiv:1301.4893•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 10, 2013•30 citations

Remarks on Quantum Probability Backflow

Anthony J. Bracken, James McGuire

It is known that for a non-relativistic quantum particle traveling freely on the $x$-axis, the positional probability can flow in the opposite direction to the particle's velocity. The maximum possible amount of such backflow that can occur over any time interval has been determined previously as the largest positive eigenvalue of a certain hermitian observable, with the value $0.0384517\dots$, or about $4\%$ of the total probability on the line. The eigenvalue problem is now considered numerically in the more general case of states with momentum restricted to the range $p_0

arXiv:1608.07644•Aug 27, 2016•1 citation

Analytical examples, measurement models, and classical limit of quantum backflow

James M. Yearsley, J. J. Halliwell, R. Hartshorn +1 more

We investigate the backflow effect in elementary quantum mechanics---the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We compute the current and flux for states consisting of superpositions of Gaussian wave packets. These are experimentally realizable but the amount of backflow is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al. [Penz, Gr\"ubl, Kreidl, and Wagner, J. Phys. A 39, 423 (2006)], we find two nontrivial wave functions whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which have periods of significant backflow, in one case with a backward flux equal to about 70$%$ of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number ${c}_{bm}\ensuremath{\approx}0.04$, discovered by Bracken and Melloy [Bracken and Melloy, J. Phys. A 27, 2197 (1994)]. This number has the unusual property of being independent of $\ensuremath{\hbar}$ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to an obviously quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We discuss some specific measurement models in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.

arXiv:1202.1783•Physical Review A•Oct 15, 2012•42 citations

Repeated quantum backflow and overflow

Christopher J. Fewster, Harkan J. Kirk-Karakaya

Abstract Quantum particles moving in one dimension with rightwards momentum can exhibit the surprising phenomenon of quantum backflow (QB): a net probability transfer to the left-hand half-line over a finite time interval. We generalize this phenomenon by considering the sum of probability differences for M disjoint time intervals. In classical mechanics, the total backflow lies in the interval [−1,0] for all M, indicating rightwards probability transfer. By contrast, we show that the maximum M-fold QB is positive and unbounded from above as M increases, demonstrating the existence of repeated backflow. For M≥2, a new phenomenon of ‘quantum overflow’ is discovered: there are states whose total backflow is below −1, which is impossible for classical particles. The extent of the backflow and overflow effects is described by a hierarchy of backflow and overflow functions and constants, of which the M=1 backflow constant was first studied by Bracken and Melloy. Limiting cases of the backflow and overflow functions are studied, including cases in which two disjoint intervals merge. The analytical results are supported by detailed numerical investigations. Using numerical acceleration methods, we obtain a new estimate of the Bracken–Melloy constant of 0.0384506, slightly lower than the previously accepted value of 0.038452.

arXiv:2505.13184•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 15, 2025•2 citations

Quantum backflow for a free-particle hermite wavepacket

P. Strange

Abstract Quantum backflow is the unexpected effect that wavepackets consisting of only positive momentum components can apparently move in the negative direction. This is usually described in terms of the backflow constant, which is a dimensionless quantity describing least upper bound on the amount of probability that can flow backwards during a given time interval. Backflow is usually calculated for wavepackets that can be written as a sum of positive momentum plane waves. Here we present a calculation of the backflow constant using the localised free particle hermite wavefunctions where equal weights of positive and negative momentum eigenfunctions occur. The resulting backflow constant is substantially smaller than the accepted value. The reasons for this are discussed and finally we draw conclusions about the calculation of backflow more generally.

Physica Scripta•Jan 4, 2024•5 citations
Abstract New quantum probability flow bounds and associated eigenfunctions are determined numerically for a free non-relativistic particle, with momentum lying in the range ( p 0 , ∞), for each fixed p 0 chosen in the range (−∞ , ∞). It is found that as p 0 increases through positive values, the maximum possible probability backflow from right-to left (R to L), opposite to the direction of all contributing momenta, decreases monotonically from the well-known value ≈0.038452 at p 0 = 0 but never reaches 0. As p 0 decreases through negative values, the maximum R to L flow increases monotonically but never reaches 1. These new quantum effects are compared and contrasted with the corresponding classical behaviour. A surprising new effect is revealed: Even when p 0 is negative, L to R directed momenta contribute to the maximum R to L flow. The size of this contribution is indicated by comparing with the maximum R to L flow possible when only negative momenta with values between p 0 and 0 are allowed. The extended modeling admits a simple interpretation of the classical limit without the introduction of a mechanism external to the system, as an effective value of Planck’s constant approaches zero.
Pure states of a free particle in non-relativistic quantum mechanics are described, in which the probability of finding the particle to have a negative x-coordinate increases over an arbitrarily long, but finite, time interval, even though the x-component of the particle's velocity is certainly positive throughout that time interval. It is shown that, for any state of this type, the greatest amount of probability which can flow back from positive to negative x-values in this counter-intuitive way, over any given time interval, is equal to the largest eigenvalue of a certain Hermitian operator, and it is estimated numerically to have a value near 0.04. This value is not only independent of the length of the time interval and the mass of the particle, but is also independent of the value of Planck's constant. It reflects the structure of Schrodinger's equation, rather than the values of the parameters appearing there. Backflow of positive probability is related to the non-positivity of Wigner's density function, and can be regarded as arising from a flow of negative probability in the same direction as the velocity. Generalizations are indicated, to the relativistic free electron, and to non-relativistic cases in which probability backflow occurs even in opposition to an arbitrarily strong constant force.
We present an introduction to the backflow effect in quantum mechanics – the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We show that the effect is present even for simple states consisting of superpositions of gaussian wave packets, although the size of the effect is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al, we present a wave function whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which has periods of significant backflow, with a backwards flux equal to about 70 percent of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number c bm ≈ 0.04, discovered by Bracken and Melloy. This number has the unusual property of being independent of ℏ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to a quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We conclude by discussing a specific measurement model in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.
It is known that for a non-relativistic quantum particle traveling freely on the xxx-axis, the positional probability can flow in the opposite direction to the particle's velocity. The maximum possible amount of such backflow that can occur over any time interval has been determined previously as the largest positive eigenvalue of a certain hermitian observable, with the value 0.0384517…0.0384517\dots0.0384517…, or about 4%4\%4% of the total probability on the line. The eigenvalue problem is now considered numerically in the more general case of states with momentum restricted to the range $p_0
We investigate the backflow effect in elementary quantum mechanics---the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We compute the current and flux for states consisting of superpositions of Gaussian wave packets. These are experimentally realizable but the amount of backflow is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al. [Penz, Gr\"ubl, Kreidl, and Wagner, J. Phys. A 39, 423 (2006)], we find two nontrivial wave functions whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which have periods of significant backflow, in one case with a backward flux equal to about 70% of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number ${c}_{bm}\ensuremath{\approx}0.04$, discovered by Bracken and Melloy [Bracken and Melloy, J. Phys. A 27, 2197 (1994)]. This number has the unusual property of being independent of $\ensuremath{\hbar}$ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to an obviously quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We discuss some specific measurement models in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.
Abstract Quantum particles moving in one dimension with rightwards momentum can exhibit the surprising phenomenon of quantum backflow (QB): a net probability transfer to the left-hand half-line over a finite time interval. We generalize this phenomenon by considering the sum of probability differences for M disjoint time intervals. In classical mechanics, the total backflow lies in the interval [−1,0] for all M, indicating rightwards probability transfer. By contrast, we show that the maximum M-fold QB is positive and unbounded from above as M increases, demonstrating the existence of repeated backflow. For M≥2, a new phenomenon of ‘quantum overflow’ is discovered: there are states whose total backflow is below −1, which is impossible for classical particles. The extent of the backflow and overflow effects is described by a hierarchy of backflow and overflow functions and constants, of which the M=1 backflow constant was first studied by Bracken and Melloy. Limiting cases of the backflow and overflow functions are studied, including cases in which two disjoint intervals merge. The analytical results are supported by detailed numerical investigations. Using numerical acceleration methods, we obtain a new estimate of the Bracken–Melloy constant of 0.0384506, slightly lower than the previously accepted value of 0.038452.
Abstract Quantum backflow is the unexpected effect that wavepackets consisting of only positive momentum components can apparently move in the negative direction. This is usually described in terms of the backflow constant, which is a dimensionless quantity describing least upper bound on the amount of probability that can flow backwards during a given time interval. Backflow is usually calculated for wavepackets that can be written as a sum of positive momentum plane waves. Here we present a calculation of the backflow constant using the localised free particle hermite wavefunctions where equal weights of positive and negative momentum eigenfunctions occur. The resulting backflow constant is substantially smaller than the accepted value. The reasons for this are discussed and finally we draw conclusions about the calculation of backflow more generally.