IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering

Formulating and Solving Routing Problems on Quantum Computers

Stuart M. Harwood, Claudio Gambella, Dimitar Trenev, Andrea Simonetto, David E. Bernal, Donny Greenberg

Published Jan 1, 2021• 145 citations

Abstract

The determination of vehicle routes fulfilling connectivity, time, and operational constraints is a well-studied combinatorial optimization problem. The NP-hard complexity of vehicle routing problems has fostered the adoption of tailored exact approaches, matheuristics, and metaheuristics on classical computing devices. The ongoing evolution of quantum computing hardware and the recent advances of quantum algorithms (i.e., VQE, QAOA, and ADMM) for mathematical programming make decision-making for routing problems an avenue of research worthwhile to be explored on quantum devices. In this article, we propose several mathematical formulations for inventory routing cast as vehicle routing with time windows and comment on their strengths and weaknesses. The optimization models are compared from a quantum computing perspective, specifically with metrics to evaluate the difficulty in solving the underlying quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problems. Finally, the solutions obtained on simulated quantum devices demonstrate the relative benefits of different algorithms and their robustness when put into practice.

DOI: 10.1109/tqe.2021.3049230

Related papers

Variational Quantum Algorithms for Solving Vehicle Routing Problem

Muhammad Alsaiyari, Muhamad Felemban

Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) is considered one of the most challenging problems with application in several domains, including transportation and logistics distribution. VRP is known to be NP-Hard problem. Several algorithms have been proposed to solve VRP in polynomial time. However, these algorithms are inefficient if the VRP instance increases. Recently, researchers investigated how quantum computing can be used to solve VRP. In particular, two promising variational quantum algorithms have been studied, i.e., Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) and Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA). In this paper, we implement both algorithms on IBM Qiskit and compare their evaluation in solving several instances of VRP. We observe that current Noisy-Intermediate Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices cannot solve VRP instances beyond 5 nodes and 2 vehicles. Furthermore, we observe that classical optimizers still provide better results. However, we believe that with the rapid advancement of quantum computing manufacturing, VQE and QAOA can provide better performance as compared to classical computing,

International Conference on Smart Computing and Application (ICSCA)Feb 5, 20238 citations

An introduction to quantum annealing and review of QUBO models for Vehicle Routing Problem

Michał Jaroszczuk

Vehicle Routing Problem is a well-known optimization issue, which has many extensions resulting from practical appliances. The problem is NP-hard, therefore it may be impossible to find an optimal solution for big instances, with traditional computation methods. Recent development of quantum technology, may be a response for this challenge, which however requires a different formulation of the model. The problem is then modeled using Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) equations. Such model can be run using quantum annealers (QA), designed specifically for optimization purposes. This paper is a systematic survey of Vehicle Routing Problem models that are formulated using QUBO, to be solved on quantum computers. The main goal of the paper is to check research gaps in this subject, compare and explain different approaches of modeling various problem extensions with QUBO. The results obtained in reviewed papers will be presented and analyzed. Moreover, the theoretical basis for quantum computation will be presented, with focus on D-Wave company solutions.

IEEE International Symposium on Computational Intelligence and Informatics (CINTI)Nov 18, 20251 citation

Analysis of the Vehicle Routing Problem Solved via Hybrid Quantum Algorithms in the Presence of Noisy Channels

Nishikanta Mohanty, Bikash K. Behera, Christopher Ferrie

The vehicle routing problem (VRP) is an NP-hard optimization problem that has been an interest of research for decades in science and industry. The objective is to plan routes of vehicles to deliver goods to a fixed number of customers with optimal efficiency. Classical tools and methods provide good approximations to reach the optimal global solution. Quantum computing and quantum machine learning provide a new approach to solving combinatorial optimization of problems faster due to inherent speedups of quantum effects. Many solutions of VRP are offered across different quantum computing platforms using hybrid algorithms such as quantum approximate optimization algorithm and quadratic unconstrained binary optimization. In this work, we build a basic VRP solver for 3 and 4 cities using the variational quantum eigensolver on a fixed ansatz. The work is further extended to evaluate the robustness of the solution in several examples of noisy quantum channels. We find that the performance of the quantum algorithm depends heavily on what noise model is used. In general, noise is detrimental, but not equally so among different noise sources.

arXiv:2205.07630IEEE Transactions on Quantum EngineeringJan 1, 202337 citations

An Overview of Algorithms for Solving Vehicle Routing Problems in the Quantum-Classical Cloud

Leonid Hulianytskyi, Vyacheslav Yu. Korolyov, Oleksandr Khodzinskyi

Introduction. The hope of solving the problem of the avalanche-like growth of requirements for computing power, essential for solving complex routing problems and other problems of combinatorial optimization, relies on the latest quantum computers, in the development of which governments and corporations invest multi-billion investments. The article examines modern routing algorithms and performs their analysis and verification, if the authors of the algorithm provided appropriate test programs. The purpose of the article is to review the current state of development in the field of development of routing algorithms for hybrid quantum-classical clouds, analyze them and propose a classification of algorithms. Results. Modern quantum computers (QCs) make it possible to find approximate solutions to some of mathematical problems faster than classical computers. The inaccuracy of the solutions obtained by the QC is a consequence of physical and technological limitations: calculation errors are caused by thermal noise, a small number of computational elements - qubits and connections between them, which requires the decomposition of the problem and the use of heuristic algorithms. The analysis of approaches to the solution of optimization problems on QC allows us to single out: quantum response and variational search of eigenvalues based on quantum logic gates as the general directions of development of the vast majority of algorithms for solving routing problems. The considered algorithms reduce the vehicle routing problem to a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization problem, which is isomorphic to the Hamilton-Ising model. In this form, the problem is suitable for embedding in QC, which finds an approximate solution that has the best statistical reliability or corresponds to the quantum state with the lowest energy. As a separate class, vehicle routing algorithms for classical computers that use quantum computing to accelerate problem solving can be distinguished. For example, neural networks that calculate weighting factors using QC or an ant algorithm that calculates a pheromone trail in a hybrid cloud. It should be mentioned the quantum-inspired algorithms, which are based on software tools for the simulation of QC and the corresponding libraries and allow creating an effective class of algorithms for solving problems of vehicle routing. Conclusions. Combining hardware quantum annealing with a number of software tools for calculating optimization problems for classical computers in a hybrid quantum-classical cloud service allows to obtain advantages in speed and accuracy of some types of complex optimization problems of a commercial scale, in particular, routing vehicles, which is already bringing substantial profits to a number of corporations. Keywords: vehicle routing problem, quantum computer, annealing, combinatorial optimization, traveling salesman problem, clustering, qubit.

Cybernetics and Computer TechnologiesJul 28, 20231 citation

Analysis of Vehicle Routing Problem in Presence of Noisy Channels

Nishikanta Mohanty, Bikash K. Behera

Vehicle routing problem (VRP) is an NP-hard optimization problem that has been an interest of research for decades in science and industry. The objective is to plan routes of vehicles to deliver a fixed number of customers with optimal efficiency. Classical tools and methods provide good approximations to reach the optimal global solution. Quantum computing and quantum machine learning provide a new approach to solving combinatorial optimization of problems faster due to inherent speedups of quantum effects. Many solutions of VRP are offered across different quantum computing platforms using hybrid algorithms such as quantum approximate optimization algorithm and quadratic unconstrained binary optimization. Quantum computers such as IBM-Q experience along with Qiskit framework offer tools to solve combinatorial optimization problems. This work proposed here builds a basic VRP solution for 3 and 4 cities using variational quantum eigensolver on a variable ANSATZ. The work is further extended to evaluate the robustness of the solution in noisy channels available within the ambit of Qiskit framework.

arXiv:2112.15408Dec 28, 20210 citations

Qubit efficient quantum algorithms for the vehicle routing problem on NISQ processors

Ioannis D. Leonidas, Alexander Dukakis, Tan, Benjamin +1 more

The vehicle routing problem with time windows (VRPTW) is a common optimization problem faced within the logistics industry. In this work, we explore the use of a previously-introduced qubit encoding scheme to reduce the number of binary variables, to evaluate the effectiveness of NISQ devices when applied to industry relevant optimization problems. We apply a quantum variational approach to a testbed of multiple VRPTW instances ranging from 11 to 3964 routes. These intances were formulated as quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) problems based on realistic shipping scenarios. We compare our results with standard binary-to-qubit mappings after executing on simulators as well as various quantum hardware platforms, including IBMQ, AWS (Rigetti), and IonQ. These results are benchmarked against the classical solver, Gurobi. Our approach can find approximate solutions to the VRPTW comparable to those obtained from quantum algorithms using the full encoding, despite the reduction in qubits required. These results suggest that using the encoding scheme to fit larger problem sizes into fewer qubits is a promising step in using NISQ devices to find approximate solutions for industry-based optimization problems, although additional resources are still required to eke out the performance from larger problem sizes.

arXiv:2306.08507Jun 14, 20231 citation