Information Scrambling versus Decoherence—Two Competing Sinks for Entropy

Akram Touil, Sebastian Deffner

Published Aug 12, 2020• 44 citations

Abstract

A possible solution of the information paradox can be sought in quantum information scrambling. In this paradigm, it is postulated that all information entering a black hole is rapidly and chaotically distributed across the event horizon, making it impossible to reconstruct the information by means of any local measurement. However, in this scenario, the effects of decoherence are typically ignored, which may render information scrambling moot in cosmological settings. In this work, we develop key steps toward a thermodynamic description of information scrambling in open quantum systems. In particular, we separate the entropy change into contributions arising from scrambling and decoherence, for which we derive statements of the second law. This is complemented with a numerical study of the SachdevYe-Kitaev, Maldacena-Qi, XXX, mixed-field Ising, and Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick models in the presence of decoherence in the energy or in the computational basis.

DOI: 10.13016/m2cr8t-eoh8

Related papers

Information Scrambling versus Decoherence—Two Competing Sinks for Entropy

Akram Touil, Sebastian Deffner

A possible solution of the information paradox can be sought in quantum information scrambling.In this paradigm, it is postulated that all information entering a black hole is rapidly and chaotically distributed across the event horizon, making it impossible to reconstruct the information by means of any local measurement.However, in this scenario, the effects of decoherence are typically ignored, which may render information scrambling moot in cosmological settings.In this work, we develop key steps toward a thermodynamic description of information scrambling in open quantum systems.In particular, we separate the entropy change into contributions arising from scrambling and decoherence, for which we derive statements of the second law.This is complemented with a numerical study of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev, Maldacena-Qi, XXX, mixed-field Ising, and Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick models in the presence of decoherence in the energy or in the computational basis.

arXiv:2008.05559PRX QuantumJan 13, 202157 citations

Information Scrambling at Quantum Hall Interfaces and Their Analog to Black Hole Event Horizon

Ken K. W., Kun Yang

The black hole information paradox has been hotly debated for the last few decades without a full resolution. This makes it desirable to find analogues of this paradox in simple and experimentally accessible systems, whose resolutions may shed light on this longstanding and fundamental problem. Here, we review and resolve the apparent "information paradox" in two different interfaces separating Abelian and non-Abelian quantum Hall states. In both cases, the information carried by the pseudospin degree of freedom of the Abelian anyons get scrambled when they cross the interface and enter the non-Abelian quantum Hall liquid. Nevertheless, it is found that the scrambling mechanism depends on the nature of the interface. The corresponding analogues of different concepts in black hole physics such as event horizon, black hole interior, Hawking radiation, and Page curve will also be discussed.

arXiv:2408.00058Jul 31, 20240 citations

Quantum scrambling and the growth of mutual information

Akram Touil, Sebastian Deffner

Abstract Quantum information scrambling refers to the loss of local recoverability of quantum information, which has found widespread attention from high energy physics to quantum computing. In the present analysis we propose a possible starting point for the development of a comprehensive framework for the thermodynamics of scrambling. To this end, we prove that the growth of entanglement as quantified by the mutual information is lower bounded by the time-dependent change of out-of-time-ordered correlator. We further show that the rate of increase of the mutual information can be upper bounded by the sum of local entropy productions, and the exchange entropy arising from the flow of information between separate partitions of a quantum system. Our results are illustrated for the ion trap system, that was recently used to verify information scrambling in an experiment, and for the Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev model.

arXiv:2002.02867Quantum Science and TechnologyApr 30, 202044 citations

Quantum Information Scrambling in Adiabatically Driven Critical Systems

Ricardo Puebla, Fernando J. Gómez-Ruiz

Quantum information scrambling refers to the spread of the initially stored information over many degrees of freedom of a quantum many-body system. Information scrambling is intimately linked to the thermalization of isolated quantum many-body systems, and has been typically studied in a sudden quench scenario. Here, we extend the notion of quantum information scrambling to critical quantum many-body systems undergoing an adiabatic evolution. In particular, we analyze how the symmetry-breaking information of an initial state is scrambled in adiabatically driven integrable systems, such as the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick and quantum Rabi models. Following a time-dependent protocol that drives the system from symmetry-breaking to a normal phase, we show how the initial information is scrambled, even for perfect adiabatic evolutions, as indicated by the expectation value of a suitable observable. We detail the underlying mechanism for quantum information scrambling, its relation to ground- and excited-state quantum phase transitions, and quantify the degree of scrambling in terms of the number of eigenstates that participate in the encoding of the initial symmetry-breaking information. While the energy of the final state remains unaltered in an adiabatic protocol, the relative phases among eigenstates are scrambled, and so is the symmetry-breaking information. We show that a potential information retrieval, following a time-reversed protocol, is hindered by small perturbations, as indicated by a vanishingly small Loschmidt echo and out-of-time-ordered correlators. The reported phenomenon is amenable for its experimental verification, and may help in the understanding of information scrambling in critical quantum many-body systems.

arXiv:2408.02735EntropyNov 5, 20241 citation

Negative entropy in scrambling black holes

Koji Azuma

We present a microscopic statistical-mechanical foundation for interpreting the horizon area of a scrambling black hole as coherent information, equivalently negative conditional quantum entropy, in Hawking's pair-creation picture. We derive the entropy increase induced in a black hole when an infalling object is absorbed and scrambled into its microscopic degrees of freedom. Up to finite-reservoir corrections, this increase takes a canonical form at the Hawking temperature, regardless of the initial entropy carried by the infalling object. Applying this entropy formula to an incoming mode paired by time reversal with an outgoing Hawking radiation mode, we show that their partition-function contributions cancel in the coherent-information balance associated with the horizon area. The resulting area response is then determined only by the energy flux, in agreement with the black-hole first law.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2605.25315May 26, 2026

Symmetry hinders quantum information recovery

Hiroyasu Tajima, Keiji Saito

Quantum information is scrambled via a chaotic time evolution in many-body systems. Clarifying how and to what extent we can recover the quantum information from the scrambled state is a central issue of today's physics, since it commonly appears as an essential factor in various topics including irreversibility of quantum chaotic dynamics, fault-tolerant quantum computation, and black hole information paradox. In realistic settings, symmetry can ubiquitously exist in scrambling dynamics. Here we establish fundamental limitations on the information recovery arising from the Lie group symmetries in the scrambling dynamics. The results are applicable to many situations, including the Hayden-Preskill black hole model with symmetry where the success rate of the information recovery qualitatively changes from the original no-symmetry case. Our findings show a close relationship between information recovery, symmetry, and quantum coherence, and that symmetry hinders the quantum information recovery.

Mar 2, 20214 citations