Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Suppressing amplitude inhomogeneity enhances computational performance of Ising machines: why the choice of nonlinearity matters.

Fabian Böhm, Thomas Van Vaerenbergh, Guy Verschaffelt, Guy Van der Sande

Published Dec 18, 2020• 2 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Ising machines based on nonlinear analog systems are a promising method to accelerate computation of NP-hard optimization problems. Yet, their analog nature is also causing amplitude inhomogeneity which can deteriorate the ability to find optimal solutions. Here, we investigate if the shape of the system's nonlinear transfer function can mitigate amplitude inhomogeneity and improve computational performance. By simulating Ising machines with polynomial, periodic, sigmoid and clipped transfer functions and benchmarking them with MaxCut optimization problems, we find the choice of transfer function to have a significant influence on the calculation time and solution quality. For periodic, sigmoid and clipped transfer functions, we report order-ofmagnitude improvements in the time-to-solution compared to conventional polynomial models, which we link to the suppression of amplitude inhomogeneity induced by saturation of the transfer function. This provides insights into the suitability of systems for building Ising machines and presents an efficient way for overcoming performance limitations.

Related papers

Order-of-magnitude differences in computational performance of analog Ising machines induced by the choice of nonlinearity

Fabian Böhm, Thomas Van Vaerenbergh, Guy Verschaffelt +1 more

Abstract Ising machines based on nonlinear analog systems are a promising method to accelerate computation of NP-hard optimization problems. Yet, their analog nature is also causing amplitude inhomogeneity which can deteriorate the ability to find optimal solutions. Here, we investigate how the system’s nonlinear transfer function can mitigate amplitude inhomogeneity and improve computational performance. By simulating Ising machines with polynomial, periodic, sigmoid and clipped transfer functions and benchmarking them with MaxCut optimization problems, we find the choice of transfer function to have a significant influence on the calculation time and solution quality. For periodic, sigmoid and clipped transfer functions, we report order-of-magnitude improvements in the time-to-solution compared to conventional polynomial models, which we link to the suppression of amplitude inhomogeneity induced by saturation of the transfer function. This provides insights into the suitability of nonlinear systems for building Ising machines and presents an efficient way for overcoming performance limitations.

arXiv:2012.10430•Communications Physics•Jul 1, 2021•63 citations

Not all Ising machines are created equal: choice of nonlinearity induces order-of-magnitude differences in computational performance

Fabian Böhm, Thomas Van Vaerenbergh, Guy Verschaffelt +1 more

Various nonlinear systems have been proposed for Ising machines, yet little insight exists into their suitability. We find the choice of nonlinearity to induce order-of-magnitude improvements in time-to-solution for saturable nonlinearities.

Photonics in Switching and Computing (PSC)•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Enhancing the performance of coherent Ising machines in the large-noise regime with a fifth-order nonlinearity

Ruqi Shi, Fabian Böhm, Thomas Van Vaerenbergh +1 more

Coherent Ising machines (CIMs), leveraging the bistable physical properties of coherent light to emulate Ising spins, exhibit great potential as hardware accelerators for tackling complex combinatorial optimization problems. Recent advances have demonstrated that the performance of CIMs can be enhanced either by incorporating large random noise or higher-order nonlinearities, yet their combined effects on CIM performance remain mainly unexplored. In this work, we develop a numerical CIM model that utilizes a tunable fifth-order polynomial nonlinear dynamic function under large noise levels, which has the potential to be implemented in all-optical platforms. We propose a normal form of a CIM model that allows for both supercritical and subcritical pitchfork bifurcation operational regimes, with fifth-order nonlinearity and tunable hyperparameters to control the Ising spin dynamics. In the benchmark studies, we simulate various sets of MaxCut problems using our fifth-order polynomial CIM model. The results show a significant performance improvement, achieving an average of 59.5% improvement in median time-to-solution (TTS) and an average of 6 times improvement in median success rate (SR) for dense Maxcut problems in the BiqMac library, compared to the commonly used third-order polynomial CIM model with low noise. The fifth-order polynomial CIM model in the large-noise regime also shows better performance trends as the problem size scales up. These findings reveal the enhancements on the computational performance of Ising machines in the large-nose regime from fifth-order nonlinearity, showing important implications for both simulation and hardware perspectives.

Optics Express•May 1, 2024•11 citations

A Comparative Study of Coherent Ising Machine Architectures Through a Unified Simulation Model

Vidisha Singhal, Peter A. Bermel

Coherent Ising Machines (CIMs) have emerged as promising hardware solvers for NP-hard combinatorial optimization problems, potentially offering energy-efficiency, accuracy, speed, and scalability. These problems span applications including scheduling, routing, resource allocation, and machine learning. Spin amplitude inhomogeneity (an artifact of its analog nature) can hinder CIM convergence to the ground state. Several CIM modifications have been proposed to address this issue. However, no prior work has systematically compared the performance of these concepts. This paper presents the first side-by-side evaluation of six promising CIM architectures using a unified simulation model. We develop stochastic differential equations, find optimal hyperparameters via Bayesian optimization per problem-architecture pair, and assess the performance on multiple metrics using MaxCut instances from the Gset and BiqMac datasets. CIM-SNN outperforms the rest on most metrics, with a 54.21% average success probability (SP) improvement and 1.36× less time-to-solution (TTS) at 96% GS energy compared to the Standard CIM on BiqMac graphs. Other CIMs show some advantages on certain Gset graphs. CIM-QA is usually the worst-performing, with an 18.55% average SP loss and a 1.30× higher TTS at 96% GS compared to the Standard CIM on BiqMac graphs. CIM-SNN demonstrates the greatest noise robustness and promise for further tuning via a linear pump schedule. CIM-QA benefits from high noise levels. This study makes two key contributions: (1) identifying promising CIM architectures to guide targeted research and accelerate practical adoption, and (2) providing a unified framework for evaluating future architectural modifications against existing ones.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Discretized spin interactions enhance higher-order analog Ising machines

Robbe De Prins, Guy Van der Sande, Peter Bienstman +1 more

Ising machines are specialized devices designed to efficiently solve combinatorial optimization problems. Among such problems, Boolean Satisfiability (SAT) is particularly relevant in industrial applications. To solve SAT problems using Ising machines, it is crucial to incorporate higher-order interactions. However, in analog Ising machines, interactions of different orders scale unevenly with the continuous spin amplitudes, introducing imbalances that can significantly degrade performance. Here we present a numerical comparison of methods to mitigate these imbalances, evaluating time-to-solution and success rate on uniform random 3-SAT and 4-SAT instances. Our results show that the most effective approach employs spin interactions that are proportional to the signs of spins, rather than their continuous amplitudes. We further demonstrate that smooth approximations of this method make it compatible with analog hardware. These findings underscore the central role of spin-sign-based interactions in enabling robust and scalable analog Ising machine dynamics. Ising machines (IMs) offer promising solutions for combinatorial optimization problems yet face challenges with imbalances in higher-order interactions when applied to Boolean Satisfiability (SAT) tasks. Here, the authors demonstrate that employing spin-sign-based interactions effectively mitigates these imbalances, enhancing performance and compatibility with analog hardware, thus advancing robust and scalable IM dynamics.

Communications Physics•Aug 5, 2026•0 citations

How to Boost Ising Machines' Ability to Find Optimum Solutions: a Bifurcation Analysis

Jacob Lamers, Guy Verschaffelt, Guy Van der Sande

Photonic Ising machines are a recent and promising non-von Neuman architecture to efficiently solve large NP-hard optimization problems. This is done by letting spins evolve to the ground state of the Ising system. However, the Ising machine does not always relax to this ground state and can get trapped in local minima, resulting in suboptimal solutions. Here, we show that Ising-encoded optimization problems implemented on analog Ising machines can be divided in three difficulty classes and we propose an annealing scheme to efficiently solve two of them. Furthermore, we show that changing the physical implementation of the Ising machine can cause a problem to change difficulty class, rendering it potentially a lot more easy to solve.

OptoElectronics and Communications Conference and International Conference on Photonics in Switching and Computing (OECC/PSC)•Sep 26, 2023•0 citations
Ising machines based on nonlinear analog systems are a promising method to accelerate computation of NP-hard optimization problems. Yet, their analog nature is also causing amplitude inhomogeneity which can deteriorate the ability to find optimal solutions. Here, we investigate if the shape of the system's nonlinear transfer function can mitigate amplitude inhomogeneity and improve computational performance. By simulating Ising machines with polynomial, periodic, sigmoid and clipped transfer functions and benchmarking them with MaxCut optimization problems, we find the choice of transfer function to have a significant influence on the calculation time and solution quality. For periodic, sigmoid and clipped transfer functions, we report order-ofmagnitude improvements in the time-to-solution compared to conventional polynomial models, which we link to the suppression of amplitude inhomogeneity induced by saturation of the transfer function. This provides insights into the suitability of systems for building Ising machines and presents an efficient way for overcoming performance limitations.
Abstract Ising machines based on nonlinear analog systems are a promising method to accelerate computation of NP-hard optimization problems. Yet, their analog nature is also causing amplitude inhomogeneity which can deteriorate the ability to find optimal solutions. Here, we investigate how the system’s nonlinear transfer function can mitigate amplitude inhomogeneity and improve computational performance. By simulating Ising machines with polynomial, periodic, sigmoid and clipped transfer functions and benchmarking them with MaxCut optimization problems, we find the choice of transfer function to have a significant influence on the calculation time and solution quality. For periodic, sigmoid and clipped transfer functions, we report order-of-magnitude improvements in the time-to-solution compared to conventional polynomial models, which we link to the suppression of amplitude inhomogeneity induced by saturation of the transfer function. This provides insights into the suitability of nonlinear systems for building Ising machines and presents an efficient way for overcoming performance limitations.
Coherent Ising machines (CIMs), leveraging the bistable physical properties of coherent light to emulate Ising spins, exhibit great potential as hardware accelerators for tackling complex combinatorial optimization problems. Recent advances have demonstrated that the performance of CIMs can be enhanced either by incorporating large random noise or higher-order nonlinearities, yet their combined effects on CIM performance remain mainly unexplored. In this work, we develop a numerical CIM model that utilizes a tunable fifth-order polynomial nonlinear dynamic function under large noise levels, which has the potential to be implemented in all-optical platforms. We propose a normal form of a CIM model that allows for both supercritical and subcritical pitchfork bifurcation operational regimes, with fifth-order nonlinearity and tunable hyperparameters to control the Ising spin dynamics. In the benchmark studies, we simulate various sets of MaxCut problems using our fifth-order polynomial CIM model. The results show a significant performance improvement, achieving an average of 59.5% improvement in median time-to-solution (TTS) and an average of 6 times improvement in median success rate (SR) for dense Maxcut problems in the BiqMac library, compared to the commonly used third-order polynomial CIM model with low noise. The fifth-order polynomial CIM model in the large-noise regime also shows better performance trends as the problem size scales up. These findings reveal the enhancements on the computational performance of Ising machines in the large-nose regime from fifth-order nonlinearity, showing important implications for both simulation and hardware perspectives.
Coherent Ising Machines (CIMs) have emerged as promising hardware solvers for NP-hard combinatorial optimization problems, potentially offering energy-efficiency, accuracy, speed, and scalability. These problems span applications including scheduling, routing, resource allocation, and machine learning. Spin amplitude inhomogeneity (an artifact of its analog nature) can hinder CIM convergence to the ground state. Several CIM modifications have been proposed to address this issue. However, no prior work has systematically compared the performance of these concepts. This paper presents the first side-by-side evaluation of six promising CIM architectures using a unified simulation model. We develop stochastic differential equations, find optimal hyperparameters via Bayesian optimization per problem-architecture pair, and assess the performance on multiple metrics using MaxCut instances from the Gset and BiqMac datasets. CIM-SNN outperforms the rest on most metrics, with a 54.21% average success probability (SP) improvement and 1.36× less time-to-solution (TTS) at 96% GS energy compared to the Standard CIM on BiqMac graphs. Other CIMs show some advantages on certain Gset graphs. CIM-QA is usually the worst-performing, with an 18.55% average SP loss and a 1.30× higher TTS at 96% GS compared to the Standard CIM on BiqMac graphs. CIM-SNN demonstrates the greatest noise robustness and promise for further tuning via a linear pump schedule. CIM-QA benefits from high noise levels. This study makes two key contributions: (1) identifying promising CIM architectures to guide targeted research and accelerate practical adoption, and (2) providing a unified framework for evaluating future architectural modifications against existing ones.
Ising machines are specialized devices designed to efficiently solve combinatorial optimization problems. Among such problems, Boolean Satisfiability (SAT) is particularly relevant in industrial applications. To solve SAT problems using Ising machines, it is crucial to incorporate higher-order interactions. However, in analog Ising machines, interactions of different orders scale unevenly with the continuous spin amplitudes, introducing imbalances that can significantly degrade performance. Here we present a numerical comparison of methods to mitigate these imbalances, evaluating time-to-solution and success rate on uniform random 3-SAT and 4-SAT instances. Our results show that the most effective approach employs spin interactions that are proportional to the signs of spins, rather than their continuous amplitudes. We further demonstrate that smooth approximations of this method make it compatible with analog hardware. These findings underscore the central role of spin-sign-based interactions in enabling robust and scalable analog Ising machine dynamics. Ising machines (IMs) offer promising solutions for combinatorial optimization problems yet face challenges with imbalances in higher-order interactions when applied to Boolean Satisfiability (SAT) tasks. Here, the authors demonstrate that employing spin-sign-based interactions effectively mitigates these imbalances, enhancing performance and compatibility with analog hardware, thus advancing robust and scalable IM dynamics.
Photonic Ising machines are a recent and promising non-von Neuman architecture to efficiently solve large NP-hard optimization problems. This is done by letting spins evolve to the ground state of the Ising system. However, the Ising machine does not always relax to this ground state and can get trapped in local minima, resulting in suboptimal solutions. Here, we show that Ising-encoded optimization problems implemented on analog Ising machines can be divided in three difficulty classes and we propose an annealing scheme to efficiently solve two of them. Furthermore, we show that changing the physical implementation of the Ising machine can cause a problem to change difficulty class, rendering it potentially a lot more easy to solve.