Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Entropy

Matrix Product State Simulations of Non-Equilibrium Steady States and Transient Heat Flows in the Two-Bath Spin-Boson Model at Finite Temperatures

Angus Dunnett, Alex W. Chin

Published Jan 6, 2021• 16 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Simulating the non-perturbative and non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems is a very challenging many body problem, due to the need to evolve both the system and its environments on an equal footing. Tensor network and matrix product states (MPS) have emerged as powerful tools for open system models, but the numerical resources required to treat finite-temperature environments grow extremely rapidly and limit their applications. In this study we use time-dependent variational evolution of MPS to explore the striking theory of Tamascelli et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett. 2019, 123, 090402.) that shows how finite-temperature open dynamics can be obtained from zero temperature, i.e., pure wave function, simulations. Using this approach, we produce a benchmark dataset for the dynamics of the Ohmic spin-boson model across a wide range of coupling strengths and temperatures, and also present a detailed analysis of the numerical costs of simulating non-equilibrium steady states, such as those emerging from the non-perturbative coupling of a qubit to baths at different temperatures. Despite ever-growing resource requirements, we find that converged non-perturbative results can be obtained, and we discuss a number of recent ideas and numerical techniques that should allow wide application of MPS to complex open quantum systems.

DOI
10.3390/e23010077

Related papers

Tensor network simulations of open quantum systems

Dainius Kilda

The nonequilibrium effects of dissipation and drive play a key role in an immense variety of nanoscale and mesoscale quantum systems. To understand the behaviour of open quantum systems, we need accurate methods that capture the influence of the environment on the system, while managing the exponentially large Hilbert space required to describe the system. Tensor network algorithms offer an efficient way to approach this challenge. In this thesis, we develop and apply tensor network techniques to study the dynamics and steady states of various open quantum systems. The first part of the thesis focuses on the driven dissipative many body physics in coupled cavity arrays described by Born-Markov master equations. We extend transfer matrix product operator methods to Liouvillian dynamics, and utilize them to compute dynamical correlation functions and fluorescence spectrum of an infinite coupled cavity array in 1D. We also investigate thermalization, and observe the emergence of a quasi-thermal steady state with a negative effective temperature. In another study, we use infinite projected entangled pair state (iPEPS) methods to compute steady states of coupled cavity lattices in 2D. We find that a straightforward adaptation of iPEPS to Liouvillian dynamics is unstable, contradicting a recent publication in the field. The second part investigates more general systems involving strong couplings and structured environments that induce non-Markovian dynamics. We develop a powerful time-evolving matrix product operator (TEMPO) algorithm that builds on Feynman-Vernon influence functional formalism, and uses matrix product states (MPS) to represent the temporal non-Markovian correlations efficiently. We apply TEMPO to study the localization phase transition of the spin-boson model and the dynamics of two spatially separated two-level systems coupled to a common environment. Finally, we propose the Toblerone TEMPO algorithm, which extends TEMPO to many-body systems interacting with general bosonic environments.

•Mar 3, 2020•0 citations

A bound on approximating non-Markovian dynamics by tensor networks in the time domain

Ilya Vilkoviskiy, Dmitry A. Abanin

Spin-boson (SB) model plays a central role in studies of dissipative quantum dynamics, both due its conceptual importance and relevance to a number of physical systems. Here we provide rigorous bounds of the computational complexity of the SB model for the physically relevant case of a zero temperature Ohmic bath. We start with the description of the bosonic bath via its Feynman-Vernon influence functional (IF), which is a tensor on the space of spin's trajectories. By expanding the kernel of the IF functional via a sum of decaying exponentials, we obtain an analytical approximation of the continuous bath by a finite number of damped bosonic modes. We bound the error induced by restricting bosonic Hilbert spaces to a finite-dimensional subspace with small boson numbers, which yields an analytical form of a matrix-product state (MPS) representation of the IF. We show that the MPS bond dimension $D$ scales polynomially in the error on physical observables $ε$, as well as in the evolution time $T$, $D\propto T^4/ε^2$. This bound indicates that the spin-boson model can be efficiently simulated using polynomial in time computational resources.

arXiv:2307.15592•Jul 28, 2023•0 citations

MPSDynamics.jl: Tensor network simulations for finite-temperature (non-Markovian) open quantum system dynamics

Thibaut Lacroix, Brieuc Le Dé, Angela Riva +2 more

The MPSDynamics.jl package provides an easy-to-use interface for performing open quantum systems simulations at zero and finite temperatures. The package has been developed with the aim of studying non-Markovian open system dynamics using the state-of-the-art numerically exact Thermalized-Time Evolving Density operator with Orthonormal Polynomials Algorithm based on environment chain mapping. The simulations rely on a tensor network representation of the quantum states as matrix product states (MPS) and tree tensor network states. Written in the Julia programming language, MPSDynamics.jl is a versatile open-source package providing a choice of several variants of the Time-Dependent Variational Principle method for time evolution (including novel bond-adaptive one-site algorithms). The package also provides strong support for the measurement of single and multi-site observables, as well as the storing and logging of data, which makes it a useful tool for the study of many-body physics. It currently handles long-range interactions, time-dependent Hamiltonians, multiple environments, bosonic and fermionic environments, and joint system-environment observables.

arXiv:2406.07052•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Aug 28, 2024•23 citations

Simulating non-equilibrium dynamics and finite temperature physics: efficient representations for matrix product states

Lucas Kohn

Experimental advances have made it possible to realize and control quantum many-body systems, allowing the experimental study of non-equilibrium phenomena. Due to the Hilbert space growing exponentially with the number of particles, advanced numerical techniques are usually required to understand many-body effects at the theoretical level. In this thesis, we address the question of how to efficiently simulate the non-equilibrium dynamics of many-body systems using matrix product states (MPS). In particular, we consider quantum systems in interaction with macroscopic environments, as they appear in Anderson impurity problems, quantum thermodynamics, or open quantum systems. We develop a low-entanglement representation of the environment with only short-range interactions, perfectly suitable for simulations with MPS. We further show that an interleaved ordering of tight-binding chains can significantly reduce the creation of entanglement, as opposed to an intuitive implementation of the Hamiltonian's geometry. Our approach allows long-time simulations and an analysis of the environmental dynamics, in which, after a sudden quench, we find clear signatures of many-body effects. We employ our techniques to compute spectral functions of impurity models, with possible applications to dynamical mean-field theory impurity solvers, and to calculate dissipation in the non-equilibrium Anderson model with explicit time-dependence, as relevant for ongoing experiments with oscillating tip atomic force microscopes.

•Sep 29, 2021•0 citations

Simulating Quantum Vibronic Dynamics at Finite Temperatures With Many Body Wave Functions at 0 K

Angus Dunnett, Alex W. Chin

For complex molecules, nuclear degrees of freedom can act as an environment for the electronic "system" variables, allowing the theory and concepts of open quantum systems to be applied. However, when molecular system-environment interactions are non-perturbative and non-Markovian, numerical simulations of the complete system-environment wave function become necessary. These many body dynamics can be very expensive to simulate, and extracting finite-temperature results-which require running and averaging over many such simulations-becomes especially challenging. Here, we present numerical simulations that exploit a recent theoretical result that allows dissipative environmental effects at finite temperature to be extracted efficiently from a single, zero-temperature wave function simulation. Using numerically exact time-dependent variational matrix product states, we verify that this approach can be applied to vibronic tunneling systems and provide insight into the practical problems lurking behind the elegance of the theory, such as the rapidly growing numerical demands that can appear for high temperatures over the length of computations.

arXiv:2101.01098•Frontiers in Chemistry•Jan 7, 2021•24 citations

A Heuristic for Matrix Product State Simulation of Out-of-Equilibrium Dynamics of Two-Dimensional Quantum Spin Systems

Salvatore Mandrà, Brayden Ware, Nikita Astrakhantsev +4 more

Out-of-equilibrium dynamics of non-integrable Hamiltonian many-body quantum systems are characterized by highly entangled wave functions. Near-maximal entanglement arises in systems exhibiting thermalization or pre-thermalization, where the system converges to a steady state with a fixed energy density. Classical simulation of the time dependence of such wave functions requires exponential resources. However, typical computations aim to estimate expectation values of local operators and correlation functions to some expected precision. For thermalizing systems at sufficiently high energy densities, such computations can be done without storing the full wave function by instead simulating the evolution of the local operator, which requires significantly fewer resources. Nonetheless, constructing such resource-efficient classical algorithms remains a challenge for intermediate energy densities, where simulating both the wave function and operator evolution is costly. In this paper, we propose a heuristic approach to accelerate the convergence of Matrix Product State (MPS) simulations of expectation values, applicable across a broad range of energy densities. We estimate the desired observables by rescaling the MPS results at low bond dimensions with a factor that depends on the fidelity of the MPS wave function. Using this technique, we simulated the dynamics of the two-dimensional Transverse-Field Ising Model (TFIM) on a $7\times8$ grid with periodic boundary conditions, using a maximum bond dimension of $χ= 4096$ on a single A100 GPU, as well as the dynamics of the two-dimensional XY model on grids of size up to $9\times9$. We compare our TFIM results to similar simulations on a digital quantum processor [R. Haghshenas et al., Nature 653, 56 (2026)], demonstrating excellent agreement and confirming the predictive power of our method.

quant-pharXiv:2511.23438•PRX Quantum•Dec 1, 2025•0 citations
Simulating the non-perturbative and non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems is a very challenging many body problem, due to the need to evolve both the system and its environments on an equal footing. Tensor network and matrix product states (MPS) have emerged as powerful tools for open system models, but the numerical resources required to treat finite-temperature environments grow extremely rapidly and limit their applications. In this study we use time-dependent variational evolution of MPS to explore the striking theory of Tamascelli et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett. 2019, 123, 090402.) that shows how finite-temperature open dynamics can be obtained from zero temperature, i.e., pure wave function, simulations. Using this approach, we produce a benchmark dataset for the dynamics of the Ohmic spin-boson model across a wide range of coupling strengths and temperatures, and also present a detailed analysis of the numerical costs of simulating non-equilibrium steady states, such as those emerging from the non-perturbative coupling of a qubit to baths at different temperatures. Despite ever-growing resource requirements, we find that converged non-perturbative results can be obtained, and we discuss a number of recent ideas and numerical techniques that should allow wide application of MPS to complex open quantum systems.
The nonequilibrium effects of dissipation and drive play a key role in an immense variety of nanoscale and mesoscale quantum systems. To understand the behaviour of open quantum systems, we need accurate methods that capture the influence of the environment on the system, while managing the exponentially large Hilbert space required to describe the system. Tensor network algorithms offer an efficient way to approach this challenge. In this thesis, we develop and apply tensor network techniques to study the dynamics and steady states of various open quantum systems. The first part of the thesis focuses on the driven dissipative many body physics in coupled cavity arrays described by Born-Markov master equations. We extend transfer matrix product operator methods to Liouvillian dynamics, and utilize them to compute dynamical correlation functions and fluorescence spectrum of an infinite coupled cavity array in 1D. We also investigate thermalization, and observe the emergence of a quasi-thermal steady state with a negative effective temperature. In another study, we use infinite projected entangled pair state (iPEPS) methods to compute steady states of coupled cavity lattices in 2D. We find that a straightforward adaptation of iPEPS to Liouvillian dynamics is unstable, contradicting a recent publication in the field. The second part investigates more general systems involving strong couplings and structured environments that induce non-Markovian dynamics. We develop a powerful time-evolving matrix product operator (TEMPO) algorithm that builds on Feynman-Vernon influence functional formalism, and uses matrix product states (MPS) to represent the temporal non-Markovian correlations efficiently. We apply TEMPO to study the localization phase transition of the spin-boson model and the dynamics of two spatially separated two-level systems coupled to a common environment. Finally, we propose the Toblerone TEMPO algorithm, which extends TEMPO to many-body systems interacting with general bosonic environments.
Spin-boson (SB) model plays a central role in studies of dissipative quantum dynamics, both due its conceptual importance and relevance to a number of physical systems. Here we provide rigorous bounds of the computational complexity of the SB model for the physically relevant case of a zero temperature Ohmic bath. We start with the description of the bosonic bath via its Feynman-Vernon influence functional (IF), which is a tensor on the space of spin's trajectories. By expanding the kernel of the IF functional via a sum of decaying exponentials, we obtain an analytical approximation of the continuous bath by a finite number of damped bosonic modes. We bound the error induced by restricting bosonic Hilbert spaces to a finite-dimensional subspace with small boson numbers, which yields an analytical form of a matrix-product state (MPS) representation of the IF. We show that the MPS bond dimension DDD scales polynomially in the error on physical observables εεε, as well as in the evolution time TTT, D∝T4/ε2D\propto T^4/ε^2D∝T4/ε2. This bound indicates that the spin-boson model can be efficiently simulated using polynomial in time computational resources.
The MPSDynamics.jl package provides an easy-to-use interface for performing open quantum systems simulations at zero and finite temperatures. The package has been developed with the aim of studying non-Markovian open system dynamics using the state-of-the-art numerically exact Thermalized-Time Evolving Density operator with Orthonormal Polynomials Algorithm based on environment chain mapping. The simulations rely on a tensor network representation of the quantum states as matrix product states (MPS) and tree tensor network states. Written in the Julia programming language, MPSDynamics.jl is a versatile open-source package providing a choice of several variants of the Time-Dependent Variational Principle method for time evolution (including novel bond-adaptive one-site algorithms). The package also provides strong support for the measurement of single and multi-site observables, as well as the storing and logging of data, which makes it a useful tool for the study of many-body physics. It currently handles long-range interactions, time-dependent Hamiltonians, multiple environments, bosonic and fermionic environments, and joint system-environment observables.
Experimental advances have made it possible to realize and control quantum many-body systems, allowing the experimental study of non-equilibrium phenomena. Due to the Hilbert space growing exponentially with the number of particles, advanced numerical techniques are usually required to understand many-body effects at the theoretical level. In this thesis, we address the question of how to efficiently simulate the non-equilibrium dynamics of many-body systems using matrix product states (MPS). In particular, we consider quantum systems in interaction with macroscopic environments, as they appear in Anderson impurity problems, quantum thermodynamics, or open quantum systems. We develop a low-entanglement representation of the environment with only short-range interactions, perfectly suitable for simulations with MPS. We further show that an interleaved ordering of tight-binding chains can significantly reduce the creation of entanglement, as opposed to an intuitive implementation of the Hamiltonian's geometry. Our approach allows long-time simulations and an analysis of the environmental dynamics, in which, after a sudden quench, we find clear signatures of many-body effects. We employ our techniques to compute spectral functions of impurity models, with possible applications to dynamical mean-field theory impurity solvers, and to calculate dissipation in the non-equilibrium Anderson model with explicit time-dependence, as relevant for ongoing experiments with oscillating tip atomic force microscopes.
For complex molecules, nuclear degrees of freedom can act as an environment for the electronic "system" variables, allowing the theory and concepts of open quantum systems to be applied. However, when molecular system-environment interactions are non-perturbative and non-Markovian, numerical simulations of the complete system-environment wave function become necessary. These many body dynamics can be very expensive to simulate, and extracting finite-temperature results-which require running and averaging over many such simulations-becomes especially challenging. Here, we present numerical simulations that exploit a recent theoretical result that allows dissipative environmental effects at finite temperature to be extracted efficiently from a single, zero-temperature wave function simulation. Using numerically exact time-dependent variational matrix product states, we verify that this approach can be applied to vibronic tunneling systems and provide insight into the practical problems lurking behind the elegance of the theory, such as the rapidly growing numerical demands that can appear for high temperatures over the length of computations.
Out-of-equilibrium dynamics of non-integrable Hamiltonian many-body quantum systems are characterized by highly entangled wave functions. Near-maximal entanglement arises in systems exhibiting thermalization or pre-thermalization, where the system converges to a steady state with a fixed energy density. Classical simulation of the time dependence of such wave functions requires exponential resources. However, typical computations aim to estimate expectation values of local operators and correlation functions to some expected precision. For thermalizing systems at sufficiently high energy densities, such computations can be done without storing the full wave function by instead simulating the evolution of the local operator, which requires significantly fewer resources. Nonetheless, constructing such resource-efficient classical algorithms remains a challenge for intermediate energy densities, where simulating both the wave function and operator evolution is costly. In this paper, we propose a heuristic approach to accelerate the convergence of Matrix Product State (MPS) simulations of expectation values, applicable across a broad range of energy densities. We estimate the desired observables by rescaling the MPS results at low bond dimensions with a factor that depends on the fidelity of the MPS wave function. Using this technique, we simulated the dynamics of the two-dimensional Transverse-Field Ising Model (TFIM) on a 7×87\times87×8 grid with periodic boundary conditions, using a maximum bond dimension of χ=4096χ= 4096χ=4096 on a single A100 GPU, as well as the dynamics of the two-dimensional XY model on grids of size up to 9×99\times99×9. We compare our TFIM results to similar simulations on a digital quantum processor [R. Haghshenas et al., Nature 653, 56 (2026)], demonstrating excellent agreement and confirming the predictive power of our method.