Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

TOWARDS A DEFINITION OF QUANTUM INTEGRABILITY

Jesús Clemente-Gallardo, Giuseppe Marmo

Published Jan 1, 2008• 15 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We briefly review the most relevant aspects of complete integrability for classical systems and identify those aspects which should be present in a definition of quantum integrability. We show that a naive extension of classical concepts to the quantum framework would not work because all infinite dimensional Hilbert spaces are unitarily isomorphic and, as a consequence, it would not be easy to define degrees of freedom. We argue that a geometrical formulation of quantum mechanics might provide a way out.

Related papers

TOWARDS A DEFINITION OF QUANTUM INTEGRABILITY

Jesús Clemente-Gallardo, GIUSEPPE MARMO

We briefly review the most relevant aspects of complete integrability for classical systems and identify those aspects which should be present in a definition of quantum integrability. We show that a naive extension of classical concepts to the quantum framework would not work because all infinite dimensional Hilbert spaces are unitarilly isomorphic and, as a consequence, it would not be easy to define degrees of freedom. We argue that a geometrical formulation of quantum mechanics might provide a way out.

arXiv:0808.3819•International Journal of Geometric Methods in Modern Physics•Feb 1, 2009•14 citations

Integrability and nonintegrability of quantum systems: Quantum integrability and dynamical symmetry

Wei-Min Zhang, D.H. Feng, Jian‐Min Yuan +1 more

In this paper we discuss the concepts of quantum integrability and nonintegrability. Based on the concept of a complete set of commuting observables and the Hilbert-space structure of a quantum system, the definitions are given for the quantum-dynamical degrees of freedom and quantum phase space from which the quantum integrability is defined. A criterion for quantum integrability then emerges; the system is integrable if it possesses dynamical symmetry. Breaking of dynamical symmetry is connected with the nonintegrability of systems and thus is the inherent mechanism of chaotic motion. A number of examples are discussed.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1989•61 citations

Classical and Quantum Integrability: A Formulation That Admits Quantum Chaos

Paul Bracken

The concept of integrability of a quantum system is developed and studied. By formulating the concepts of quantum degree of freedom and quantum phase space, a realization of the dynamics is achieved. For a quantum system with a dynamical group G in one of its unitary irreducible representative carrier spaces, the quantum phase space is a finite topological space. It is isomorphic to a coset space G/R by means of the unitary exponential mapping, where R is the maximal stability subgroup of a fixed state in the carrier space. This approach has the distinct advantage of exhibiting consistency between classical and quantum integrability. The formalism will be illustrated by studying several quantum systems in detail after this development.

IntechOpen eBooks•Nov 25, 2020•1 citation

Geometric aspects of quantization and relationship to integrability

Paul Bracken

Abstract It is the case that quantum mechanics has a deep geometric structure and can be presented accordingly. Quantum mechanics is to a certain degree foreshadowed by the geometry inherent in the geometric structure of classical mechanics. The purpose here is to present some new results and proofs which impact the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics. The relationship between integrability and quantum physics is investigated in terms of geometric ideas and structures. Two physical examples are drawn from these mathematical ideas which directly relate to physics. An introduction as to how these ideas can be extended to infinite degrees of freedom is also described.

Physica Scripta•Nov 1, 2023•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics. Algebraic Structure and States

Franco Strocchi

We briefly review the basic structure of quantum mechanics (QM) with the aim of covering both the case of systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom (ordinary QM) as well as the case of systems with an infinite number of degrees of freedom (briefly infinite systems ).

Theoretical and mathematical physics•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Quantum integrability and nonintegrability of Hamiltonian systems with two degrees of freedom

Vyacheslav V. Stepanov

The subject of the four manuscripts which make up this dissertation is the concept of integrability in quantum mechanical systems with two degrees of freedom, including the relation between quantum integrability and classical integrability in such systems. In the first manuscript, I consider a two-spin model both classically and quantum mechanically. In the six-dimensional parameter space of this model, classical integrability is satisfied on a five-dimensional hypersurface, and level crossings occur on four-dimensional manifolds that are completely embedded in the integrability hypersurface except for some lower-dimensional sub-manifolds. Under mild assumptions, the classical integrability condition can be reconstructed from a purely quantum mechanical study of level degeneracies in finite-dimensional invariant blocks of the Hamiltonian matrix. In the second manuscript, I analyze the functional dependence [special characters omitted] of the Hamiltonian operator on the action operators for an integrable quantum system, and I compare it with the corresponding functional relationship H (p1, q1; p2, q 2) = HC(J1, J2) in the classical limit of that system. It is demonstrated that the functional dependence is not the same quantum mechanically and (semi-)classically. The former is shown to converge toward the latter in some asymptotic regime associated with the classical limit, but the convergence may be non-uniform. This analysis is carried out for an integrable one- parameter two-spin model. Additional results presented for the (integrable) circular billiard model exhibit similar quantum corrections to the predictions of semiclassical quantization. In the third and the fourth manuscripts, I investigate the relations between symmetry, integrability, and the assignment of quantum numbers to eigenstates for two-spin and spin-boson models. I calculate quantum invariants in the form of expectation values for selected operators and monitor their dependence on the Hamiltonian parameters along loops within, without, and across the integrability region in parameter space. I find clear-cut signatures of integrability and nonintegrability in the observed traces of quantum invariants evaluated in invariant Hilbert subspaces. The results support the notion that quantum integrability depends on the existence of action operators as constituent elements of the Hamiltonian.

Journal of Media Literacy Education•Jan 1, 1999•0 citations
We briefly review the most relevant aspects of complete integrability for classical systems and identify those aspects which should be present in a definition of quantum integrability. We show that a naive extension of classical concepts to the quantum framework would not work because all infinite dimensional Hilbert spaces are unitarily isomorphic and, as a consequence, it would not be easy to define degrees of freedom. We argue that a geometrical formulation of quantum mechanics might provide a way out.
We briefly review the most relevant aspects of complete integrability for classical systems and identify those aspects which should be present in a definition of quantum integrability. We show that a naive extension of classical concepts to the quantum framework would not work because all infinite dimensional Hilbert spaces are unitarilly isomorphic and, as a consequence, it would not be easy to define degrees of freedom. We argue that a geometrical formulation of quantum mechanics might provide a way out.
In this paper we discuss the concepts of quantum integrability and nonintegrability. Based on the concept of a complete set of commuting observables and the Hilbert-space structure of a quantum system, the definitions are given for the quantum-dynamical degrees of freedom and quantum phase space from which the quantum integrability is defined. A criterion for quantum integrability then emerges; the system is integrable if it possesses dynamical symmetry. Breaking of dynamical symmetry is connected with the nonintegrability of systems and thus is the inherent mechanism of chaotic motion. A number of examples are discussed.
The concept of integrability of a quantum system is developed and studied. By formulating the concepts of quantum degree of freedom and quantum phase space, a realization of the dynamics is achieved. For a quantum system with a dynamical group G in one of its unitary irreducible representative carrier spaces, the quantum phase space is a finite topological space. It is isomorphic to a coset space G/R by means of the unitary exponential mapping, where R is the maximal stability subgroup of a fixed state in the carrier space. This approach has the distinct advantage of exhibiting consistency between classical and quantum integrability. The formalism will be illustrated by studying several quantum systems in detail after this development.
Abstract It is the case that quantum mechanics has a deep geometric structure and can be presented accordingly. Quantum mechanics is to a certain degree foreshadowed by the geometry inherent in the geometric structure of classical mechanics. The purpose here is to present some new results and proofs which impact the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics. The relationship between integrability and quantum physics is investigated in terms of geometric ideas and structures. Two physical examples are drawn from these mathematical ideas which directly relate to physics. An introduction as to how these ideas can be extended to infinite degrees of freedom is also described.
The subject of the four manuscripts which make up this dissertation is the concept of integrability in quantum mechanical systems with two degrees of freedom, including the relation between quantum integrability and classical integrability in such systems. In the first manuscript, I consider a two-spin model both classically and quantum mechanically. In the six-dimensional parameter space of this model, classical integrability is satisfied on a five-dimensional hypersurface, and level crossings occur on four-dimensional manifolds that are completely embedded in the integrability hypersurface except for some lower-dimensional sub-manifolds. Under mild assumptions, the classical integrability condition can be reconstructed from a purely quantum mechanical study of level degeneracies in finite-dimensional invariant blocks of the Hamiltonian matrix. In the second manuscript, I analyze the functional dependence [special characters omitted] of the Hamiltonian operator on the action operators for an integrable quantum system, and I compare it with the corresponding functional relationship H (p1, q1; p2, q 2) = HC(J1, J2) in the classical limit of that system. It is demonstrated that the functional dependence is not the same quantum mechanically and (semi-)classically. The former is shown to converge toward the latter in some asymptotic regime associated with the classical limit, but the convergence may be non-uniform. This analysis is carried out for an integrable one- parameter two-spin model. Additional results presented for the (integrable) circular billiard model exhibit similar quantum corrections to the predictions of semiclassical quantization. In the third and the fourth manuscripts, I investigate the relations between symmetry, integrability, and the assignment of quantum numbers to eigenstates for two-spin and spin-boson models. I calculate quantum invariants in the form of expectation values for selected operators and monitor their dependence on the Hamiltonian parameters along loops within, without, and across the integrability region in parameter space. I find clear-cut signatures of integrability and nonintegrability in the observed traces of quantum invariants evaluated in invariant Hilbert subspaces. The results support the notion that quantum integrability depends on the existence of action operators as constituent elements of the Hamiltonian.