Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Orientation matters for NIMreps

N. Sousa, A.N. Schellekens

Published Oct 2, 2002• 14 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The problem of finding boundary states in CFT, often rephrased in terms of "NIMreps" of the fusion algebra, has a natural extension to CFT on non-orientable surfaces. This provides extra information that turns out to be quite useful to give the proper interpretation to a NIMrep. We illustrate this with several examples. This includes a rather detailed discussion of the interesting case of the simple current extension of A_2 level 9, which is already known to have a rich structure. This structure can be disentangled completely using orientation information. In particular we find here and in other cases examples of diagonal modular invariants that do not admit a NIMrep, suggesting that there does not exist a corresponding CFT. We obtain the complete set of NIMreps (plus Moebius and Klein bottle coefficients) for many exceptional modular invariants of WZW models, and find an explanation for the occurrence of more than one NIMrep in certain cases. We also (re)consider the underlying formalism, emphasizing the distinction between oriented and unoriented string annulus amplitudes, and the origin of orientation-dependent degeneracy matrices in the latter.

Related papers

Universal dynamics in non-orientable CFT2

Ioannis Tsiares

A bstract Two-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) defined on non-orientable Riemann surfaces obey consistency Cardy conditions analogous to those in the orientable case. We revisit those conditions for irrational theories with central charge c > 1 in the context of two-point functions of primaries on the Real Projective plane $$ {\mathbbm{RP}}^2 $$ RP 2 and the partition function on the Klein bottle $$ {\mathbbm{K}}^2 $$ K 2 . Using the irrational versions of the Virasoro fusion and modular kernels we derive universal expressions for the non-orientable CFT data at large conformal dimension, assuming a gap in the spectrum of scalar primaries. In particular, we derive asymptotic formulas at finite central charge for the averaged Light-Light-Heavy product C LLH × Γ H of OPE coefficients with the $$ {\mathbbm{RP}}^2 $$ RP 2 one-point function normalizations, as well as for the parity-weighted density of heavy scalar primaries (or equivalently the density of heavy $$ {\Gamma}_H^2 $$ Γ H 2 ). We discuss the gravitational interpretation of the results.

arXiv:2011.09250•Journal of High Energy Physics•Sep 11, 2025•7 citations

Open Descendants in Conformal Field Theory

Augusto Sagnotti, Yassen S. Stanev

Open descendants extend Conformal Field Theory to unoriented surfaces with boundaries. The construction rests on two types of generalizations of the fusion algebra. The first is needed even in the relatively simple case of diagonal models. It leads to a new tensor that satisfies the fusion algebra, but whose entries are signed integers. The second is needed when dealing with non-diagonal models, where Cardy's ansatz does not apply. It leads to a new tensor with positive integer entries, that satisfies a set of polynomial equations and encodes the classification of the allowed boundary operators.

Fortschritte der Physik/Progress of Physics•Jan 1, 1996•45 citations

Boundary Conditions in Conformal Field Theory

John Cardy

<!-- *** Custom HTML *** --> We consider conformal field theories on manifolds with a boundary, and the constraints placed by modular invariance on their partition functions. In particular, the partition functions on an annulus with particular boundary conditions are given by the fusion rules. This leads to a simple derivation of the Verlinde formula. We note the remarkable fact that, for some integrable models, these partition functions have the same form away from criticality, with the modular parameter $q$ of the annulus replaced by a temperature-like variable, and give a partial explanation of this in the case of the Ising model.

Advanced studies in pure mathematics•Jun 17, 2018•17 citations

CONFORMAL FIELD THEORY ON SURFACES WITH BOUNDARIES AND NONDIAGONAL MODULAR INVARIANTS

Zvi Bern A, David C. Dunbar

We show that the operator content of a conformal field theory defined on surfaces with boundaries and crosscaps is more restricted when the periodic sector is described by nondiagonal modular invariants than in the case of diagonal modular invariants. By tensoring, the restrictions can be alleviated, leading to a rich structure. Such constructions are useful, for example, in lower-dimensional open superstring models.

International Journal of Modern Physics A•Dec 20, 1990•2 citations

Perturbations of boundary conformal field theories

A. Recknagel, Volker Schomerus

We have gathered quite a large amount of technology to construct conformal boundary conditions and study their properties. So far, most of the tools relied on detailed knowledge of the underlying algebraic structure of conformal field theories (CFTs), such as representations of symmetry algebras and modular transformations. In almost all cases, this route will lead to a restricted class of boundary conditions only, favouring those that preserve a lot of symmetry. In “real life applications” of boundary CFT, arising in string theory, in condensed matter physics, or in the study of integrable models, we are often faced with situations where we start from a simple given boundary condition and then “deform” by “turning on perturbations”. In this chapter, we will discuss methods aimed at making this procedure well defined and at determining the perturbed boundary theory. Most of the time, we will restrict ourselves to pure boundary perturbations, which leave the bulk CFT untouched. We will sometimes be led to new boundary conditions that would have been difficult to find directly. The total space of boundary CFTs takes the form of a fibration over the moduli space of bulk theories, with the fibre over each point made up from all boundary conditions (branes) that exist for that bulk theory. Marginal boundary deformations, if they exist, will generate, starting from a single boundary condition, whole continuous families within this boundary moduli space.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 5, 2013•0 citations

Twisted (co)homology of non-orientable Weyl semimetals

Thijs Douwes, Marcus Stålhammar

The quasi-particle excitations in Weyl semimetals, known as Weyl fermions, are usually forced to emerge in charge-conjugate pairs by the Nielsen--Ninomiya theorem. When the Brillouin zone is non-orientable, this constraint is replaced by a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ charge cancellation, as a result of the chirality becoming ill-defined on such manifolds; this results in configurations with seemingly non-zero total chirality. Here, we set out to explain this behaviour from a purely topological perspective, and provide a classification of non-orientable Weyl semimetal topology in terms of exact sequences of twisted (co)homology groups. This leads to several discoveries of direct physical importance: in particular, we recover the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ charge cancellation in a coordinate-independent way, allowing meaningful limits to be set on its physical interpretation. A detailed discussion is provided on a specific Klein bottle-like topology induced by a momentum-space glide symmetry, including a full review of the insulating and semimetallic invariants of the system and a classification of the surface states on the non-orientable boundary. Beyond this, we provide a complete survey of all possible non-orientable Brillouin zones and their associated invariants, and extend our formalism into the realm of non-Hermitian topological physics and inversion-symmetric Weyl semimetals. Our work exemplifies the vast potential of fundamental mathematical descriptions to not only aid the corresponding physical intuition, but also predict novel and hitherto overlooked phenomena of great relevance throughout the physics research forefront.

cond-mat.mes-hallCross-listedarXiv:2511.22303•Nov 28, 2025
The problem of finding boundary states in CFT, often rephrased in terms of "NIMreps" of the fusion algebra, has a natural extension to CFT on non-orientable surfaces. This provides extra information that turns out to be quite useful to give the proper interpretation to a NIMrep. We illustrate this with several examples. This includes a rather detailed discussion of the interesting case of the simple current extension of A_2 level 9, which is already known to have a rich structure. This structure can be disentangled completely using orientation information. In particular we find here and in other cases examples of diagonal modular invariants that do not admit a NIMrep, suggesting that there does not exist a corresponding CFT. We obtain the complete set of NIMreps (plus Moebius and Klein bottle coefficients) for many exceptional modular invariants of WZW models, and find an explanation for the occurrence of more than one NIMrep in certain cases. We also (re)consider the underlying formalism, emphasizing the distinction between oriented and unoriented string annulus amplitudes, and the origin of orientation-dependent degeneracy matrices in the latter.
A bstract Two-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) defined on non-orientable Riemann surfaces obey consistency Cardy conditions analogous to those in the orientable case. We revisit those conditions for irrational theories with central charge c > 1 in the context of two-point functions of primaries on the Real Projective plane $$ {\mathbbm{RP}}^2 $$ RP 2 and the partition function on the Klein bottle $$ {\mathbbm{K}}^2 $$ K 2 . Using the irrational versions of the Virasoro fusion and modular kernels we derive universal expressions for the non-orientable CFT data at large conformal dimension, assuming a gap in the spectrum of scalar primaries. In particular, we derive asymptotic formulas at finite central charge for the averaged Light-Light-Heavy product C LLH × Γ H of OPE coefficients with the $$ {\mathbbm{RP}}^2 $$ RP 2 one-point function normalizations, as well as for the parity-weighted density of heavy scalar primaries (or equivalently the density of heavy ΓH2 {\Gamma}_H^2 ΓH2​ Γ H 2 ). We discuss the gravitational interpretation of the results.
Open descendants extend Conformal Field Theory to unoriented surfaces with boundaries. The construction rests on two types of generalizations of the fusion algebra. The first is needed even in the relatively simple case of diagonal models. It leads to a new tensor that satisfies the fusion algebra, but whose entries are signed integers. The second is needed when dealing with non-diagonal models, where Cardy's ansatz does not apply. It leads to a new tensor with positive integer entries, that satisfies a set of polynomial equations and encodes the classification of the allowed boundary operators.
<!-- *** Custom HTML *** --> We consider conformal field theories on manifolds with a boundary, and the constraints placed by modular invariance on their partition functions. In particular, the partition functions on an annulus with particular boundary conditions are given by the fusion rules. This leads to a simple derivation of the Verlinde formula. We note the remarkable fact that, for some integrable models, these partition functions have the same form away from criticality, with the modular parameter qqq of the annulus replaced by a temperature-like variable, and give a partial explanation of this in the case of the Ising model.
We have gathered quite a large amount of technology to construct conformal boundary conditions and study their properties. So far, most of the tools relied on detailed knowledge of the underlying algebraic structure of conformal field theories (CFTs), such as representations of symmetry algebras and modular transformations. In almost all cases, this route will lead to a restricted class of boundary conditions only, favouring those that preserve a lot of symmetry. In “real life applications” of boundary CFT, arising in string theory, in condensed matter physics, or in the study of integrable models, we are often faced with situations where we start from a simple given boundary condition and then “deform” by “turning on perturbations”. In this chapter, we will discuss methods aimed at making this procedure well defined and at determining the perturbed boundary theory. Most of the time, we will restrict ourselves to pure boundary perturbations, which leave the bulk CFT untouched. We will sometimes be led to new boundary conditions that would have been difficult to find directly. The total space of boundary CFTs takes the form of a fibration over the moduli space of bulk theories, with the fibre over each point made up from all boundary conditions (branes) that exist for that bulk theory. Marginal boundary deformations, if they exist, will generate, starting from a single boundary condition, whole continuous families within this boundary moduli space.
The quasi-particle excitations in Weyl semimetals, known as Weyl fermions, are usually forced to emerge in charge-conjugate pairs by the Nielsen--Ninomiya theorem. When the Brillouin zone is non-orientable, this constraint is replaced by a Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ charge cancellation, as a result of the chirality becoming ill-defined on such manifolds; this results in configurations with seemingly non-zero total chirality. Here, we set out to explain this behaviour from a purely topological perspective, and provide a classification of non-orientable Weyl semimetal topology in terms of exact sequences of twisted (co)homology groups. This leads to several discoveries of direct physical importance: in particular, we recover the Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ charge cancellation in a coordinate-independent way, allowing meaningful limits to be set on its physical interpretation. A detailed discussion is provided on a specific Klein bottle-like topology induced by a momentum-space glide symmetry, including a full review of the insulating and semimetallic invariants of the system and a classification of the surface states on the non-orientable boundary. Beyond this, we provide a complete survey of all possible non-orientable Brillouin zones and their associated invariants, and extend our formalism into the realm of non-Hermitian topological physics and inversion-symmetric Weyl semimetals. Our work exemplifies the vast potential of fundamental mathematical descriptions to not only aid the corresponding physical intuition, but also predict novel and hitherto overlooked phenomena of great relevance throughout the physics research forefront.