Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Experimental benchmarking of quantum control in zero-field nuclear magnetic resonance

Min Jiang, Teng Wu, John W. Blanchard, Feng, Guanru, Xinhua Peng, Dmitry Budker

Published Jan 1, 2018• 28 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Zero-field nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) provides complementary analysis modalities to those of high-field NMR and allows for ultra-high-resolution spectroscopy and measurement of untruncated spin-spin interactions. Unlike for the high-field case, however, universal quantum control -- the ability to perform arbitrary unitary operations -- has not been experimentally demonstrated in zero-field NMR. This is because the Larmor frequency for all spins is identically zero at zero field, making it challenging to individually address different spin species. We realize a composite-pulse technique for arbitrary independent rotations of $^1$H and $^{13}$C spins in a two-spin system. Quantum-information-inspired randomized benchmarking and state tomography are used to evaluate the quality of the control. We experimentally demonstrate single-spin control for $^{13}$C with an average gate fidelity of $0.9960(2)$ and two-spin control via a controlled-not (CNOT) gate with an estimated fidelity of $0.99$. The combination of arbitrary single-spin gates and a CNOT gate is sufficient for universal quantum control of the nuclear spin system. The realization of complete spin control in zero-field NMR is an essential step towards applications to quantum simulation, entangled-state-assisted quantum metrology, and zero-field NMR spectroscopy.

Related papers

Experimental benchmarking of quantum control in zero-field nuclear magnetic resonance

Min Jiang, Teng Wu, John W. Blanchard +3 more

C with an average fidelity of 0.9960(2) and two-spin control via a CNOT gate with a fidelity of 0.9877(2). Our method can also be extended to more general multispin heteronuclear systems at zero field. The realization of universal quantum control in zero-field NMR is important for quantum state/coherence preparation, pulse sequence design, and is an essential step toward applications to materials science, chemical analysis, and fundamental physics.

arXiv:1708.06324•Science Advances•Jun 1, 2018•61 citations

Universal quantum control in zero-field nuclear magnetic resonance

Ji Bian, Min Jiang, Jiangyu Cui +7 more

This paper describes a general method for the manipulation of nuclear spins in zero magnetic field. In the absence of magnetic fields, the spins lose the individual information on chemical shifts and inequivalent spins can only be distinguished by nuclear gyromagnetic ratios and spin-spin couplings. For spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ nuclei with different gyromagnetic ratios (i.e., different species) in zero magnetic field, we describe the scheme to realize a set of universal quantum logic gates, e.g., arbitrary single-qubit gates and a two-qubit controlled-not gate. This method allows for universal quantum control in systems which might provide promising applications in materials science, chemistry, biology, quantum information processing, and fundamental physics.

arXiv:1705.02064•Physical Review A•May 23, 2017•23 citations

Numerical optimal control of spin systems at zero magnetic field

Min Jiang, Ji Bian, Xiaomei Liu +5 more

Zero-field nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) has been recently developed as a complementary tool for nondestructive structural investigations of matter. However, precise and efficient control in such systems is still at the beginning. Based on the controllability of spin systems, we theoretically study the issue of quantum control in zero-field NMR by using a numerical optimization method based on the gradient ascent pulse engineering (GRAPE) algorithm. A set of quantum gates, including single-qubit and two-qubit gates, are achieved as examples. In particular, we show that homonuclear spins can be individually manipulated in zero-field NMR by the GRAPE method, which extends the ability to manipulate spin systems at zero magnetic field. Quantum control realized by the numerical GRAPE method features the properties of high fidelity, robustness, and hardware-friendly characteristics. High-fidelity quantum control in zero-field NMR systems might provide promising applications in material science, chemical analysis, quantum information processing, and fundamental physics.

Physical Review A•Jun 18, 2018•16 citations

Entanglement Assisted Metrology

Paola Cappellaro, Joseph Emerson, Nicolas Boulant +3 more

We propose a new approach to the measurement of a single spin state, based on nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques and inspired by the coherent control over many-body systems envisaged by quantum information processing. A single target spin is coupled via the magnetic dipolar interaction to a large ensemble of spins. Applying radio frequency pulses, we can control the evolution so that the spin ensemble reaches one of two orthogonal states whose collective properties differ depending on the state of the target spin and are easily measured. We first describe this measurement process using quantum gates; then we show how equivalent schemes can be defined in terms of the Hamiltonian and thus implemented under conditions of real control, using well established NMR techniques. We demonstrate this method with a proof of principle experiment in ensemble liquid state NMR and simulations for small spin systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0411128•Physical Review Letters•Jan 19, 2005•98 citations

Quantum control of nuclear magnetic resonance spin systems

Jun Li, Jiangyu Cui, Xiaodong Yang +6 more

With the development of quantum information science, the active manipulation of quantum systems is becoming an important research frontier. To build realistic quantum information processors, one of the challenges is to implement arbitrary desired operations with high precision on quantum systems. A large number of quantum control methods and relevant numerical techniques have been put forward in recent years, such as quantum optimal control and quantum feedback control. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spin systems offer an excellent testbed to develop benchmark tools and techniques for controlling quantum systems. In this review paper, we briefly introduce some of the basic control ideas developed for NMR systems in recent years. We first explain, for the liquid spin systems, the physics of various couplings and the causes of relaxation effects. These mechanisms govern the system dynamics, and thus are crucial for constructing rigorous and efficient control models. We also identify three types of available control means: 1) raido-frequency fields as coherent controls; 2) phase cycling, gradient fields and relaxation effects as non-unitary controls; 3) radiation damping effect as feedback control mechanism. Then, we elucidate some important control tasks, which may arise from the conventional NMR spectroscopy (e.g., pulse design and polarization transfer) or from quantum information science (e.g., algorithmic cooling and pseudo-pure state preparation). In the last part, we review some of the most important control methods that are applicable to NMR control tasks. For systems with a relatively small number of spins, it is possible to use analytic optimal control theory to realize the target unitary operations. However, for larger systems, numerical methods are necessary. The gradient ascent pulse engineering algorithm and pulse compiler techniques are the most successful techniques for implementing complicated quantum networks currently. There are some interesting topics of utilizing radiation damping and relaxation effects to achieve more powerful controls. Finally, we give an outline of the possible future work.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 2015•4 citations

Quantum Control of Nuclear Spins

J. S. Hodges, Paola Cappellaro, Timothy F. Havel +1 more

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has proven to be a facile means of achieving small-scale demonstrations of quantum information processing. This was in large part made possible by the sophisticated methods of quantum control that have been developed by the NMR community over a span of more than 50 years. The traditional control methods, already perhaps the most complex examples of open-loop control available, were nevertheless designed primarily to assist in identifying the physical parameters of the underlying spin system, rather than to control the system with high precision. We have therefore extended the traditional methods in a variety of ways so as to achieve precise control, by taking advantage of prior knowledge of the physical parameters as determined by traditional methods. Due to the experimental challenges of real-time control, these developments relied upon our ability to simulate the evolution of the system under the action of radio-frequency control fields with essentially arbitrary precision, subject only to the available computing power. This talk presents an overview of our work in quantum control together with some of the on-going challenges still facing us

IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC)•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations
Zero-field nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) provides complementary analysis modalities to those of high-field NMR and allows for ultra-high-resolution spectroscopy and measurement of untruncated spin-spin interactions. Unlike for the high-field case, however, universal quantum control -- the ability to perform arbitrary unitary operations -- has not been experimentally demonstrated in zero-field NMR. This is because the Larmor frequency for all spins is identically zero at zero field, making it challenging to individually address different spin species. We realize a composite-pulse technique for arbitrary independent rotations of 1^11H and 13^{13}13C spins in a two-spin system. Quantum-information-inspired randomized benchmarking and state tomography are used to evaluate the quality of the control. We experimentally demonstrate single-spin control for 13^{13}13C with an average gate fidelity of 0.9960(2)0.9960(2)0.9960(2) and two-spin control via a controlled-not (CNOT) gate with an estimated fidelity of 0.990.990.99. The combination of arbitrary single-spin gates and a CNOT gate is sufficient for universal quantum control of the nuclear spin system. The realization of complete spin control in zero-field NMR is an essential step towards applications to quantum simulation, entangled-state-assisted quantum metrology, and zero-field NMR spectroscopy.
This paper describes a general method for the manipulation of nuclear spins in zero magnetic field. In the absence of magnetic fields, the spins lose the individual information on chemical shifts and inequivalent spins can only be distinguished by nuclear gyromagnetic ratios and spin-spin couplings. For spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ nuclei with different gyromagnetic ratios (i.e., different species) in zero magnetic field, we describe the scheme to realize a set of universal quantum logic gates, e.g., arbitrary single-qubit gates and a two-qubit controlled-not gate. This method allows for universal quantum control in systems which might provide promising applications in materials science, chemistry, biology, quantum information processing, and fundamental physics.
Zero-field nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) has been recently developed as a complementary tool for nondestructive structural investigations of matter. However, precise and efficient control in such systems is still at the beginning. Based on the controllability of spin systems, we theoretically study the issue of quantum control in zero-field NMR by using a numerical optimization method based on the gradient ascent pulse engineering (GRAPE) algorithm. A set of quantum gates, including single-qubit and two-qubit gates, are achieved as examples. In particular, we show that homonuclear spins can be individually manipulated in zero-field NMR by the GRAPE method, which extends the ability to manipulate spin systems at zero magnetic field. Quantum control realized by the numerical GRAPE method features the properties of high fidelity, robustness, and hardware-friendly characteristics. High-fidelity quantum control in zero-field NMR systems might provide promising applications in material science, chemical analysis, quantum information processing, and fundamental physics.
We propose a new approach to the measurement of a single spin state, based on nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques and inspired by the coherent control over many-body systems envisaged by quantum information processing. A single target spin is coupled via the magnetic dipolar interaction to a large ensemble of spins. Applying radio frequency pulses, we can control the evolution so that the spin ensemble reaches one of two orthogonal states whose collective properties differ depending on the state of the target spin and are easily measured. We first describe this measurement process using quantum gates; then we show how equivalent schemes can be defined in terms of the Hamiltonian and thus implemented under conditions of real control, using well established NMR techniques. We demonstrate this method with a proof of principle experiment in ensemble liquid state NMR and simulations for small spin systems.
With the development of quantum information science, the active manipulation of quantum systems is becoming an important research frontier. To build realistic quantum information processors, one of the challenges is to implement arbitrary desired operations with high precision on quantum systems. A large number of quantum control methods and relevant numerical techniques have been put forward in recent years, such as quantum optimal control and quantum feedback control. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spin systems offer an excellent testbed to develop benchmark tools and techniques for controlling quantum systems. In this review paper, we briefly introduce some of the basic control ideas developed for NMR systems in recent years. We first explain, for the liquid spin systems, the physics of various couplings and the causes of relaxation effects. These mechanisms govern the system dynamics, and thus are crucial for constructing rigorous and efficient control models. We also identify three types of available control means: 1) raido-frequency fields as coherent controls; 2) phase cycling, gradient fields and relaxation effects as non-unitary controls; 3) radiation damping effect as feedback control mechanism. Then, we elucidate some important control tasks, which may arise from the conventional NMR spectroscopy (e.g., pulse design and polarization transfer) or from quantum information science (e.g., algorithmic cooling and pseudo-pure state preparation). In the last part, we review some of the most important control methods that are applicable to NMR control tasks. For systems with a relatively small number of spins, it is possible to use analytic optimal control theory to realize the target unitary operations. However, for larger systems, numerical methods are necessary. The gradient ascent pulse engineering algorithm and pulse compiler techniques are the most successful techniques for implementing complicated quantum networks currently. There are some interesting topics of utilizing radiation damping and relaxation effects to achieve more powerful controls. Finally, we give an outline of the possible future work.
Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has proven to be a facile means of achieving small-scale demonstrations of quantum information processing. This was in large part made possible by the sophisticated methods of quantum control that have been developed by the NMR community over a span of more than 50 years. The traditional control methods, already perhaps the most complex examples of open-loop control available, were nevertheless designed primarily to assist in identifying the physical parameters of the underlying spin system, rather than to control the system with high precision. We have therefore extended the traditional methods in a variety of ways so as to achieve precise control, by taking advantage of prior knowledge of the physical parameters as determined by traditional methods. Due to the experimental challenges of real-time control, these developments relied upon our ability to simulate the evolution of the system under the action of radio-frequency control fields with essentially arbitrary precision, subject only to the available computing power. This talk presents an overview of our work in quantum control together with some of the on-going challenges still facing us