The Two-fold Role of Observables in Classical and Quantum Kinematics

Federico Zalamea

Published Nov 19, 2017• 4 citations

Abstract

Observables have a dual nature in both classical and quantum kinematics: they are at the same time quantities, allowing to separate states by means of their numerical values, and generators of transformations, establishing relations between different states. In this work, we show how this two-fold role of observables constitutes a key feature in the conceptual analysis of classical and quantum kinematics, shedding a new light on the distinguishing feature of the quantum at the kinematical level. We first take a look at the algebraic description of both classical and quantum observables in terms of Jordan-Lie algebras and show how the two algebraic structures are the precise mathematical manifestation of the two-fold role of observables. Then, we turn to the geometric reformulation of quantum kinematics in terms of Kähler manifolds. A key achievement of this reformulation is to show that the two-fold role of observables is the constitutive ingredient defining what an observable is. Moreover, it points to the fact that, from the restricted point of view of the transformational role of observables, classical and quantum kinematics behave in exactly the same way. Finally, we present Landsman's general framework of Poisson spaces with transition probability, which highlights with unmatched clarity that the crucial difference between the two kinematics lies in the way the two roles of observables are related to each other.

Related papers

Duality of observables and generators in classical and quantum mechnics

Emile Grgin, Aage Petersen

In classical and in quantum mechanics physical variables play a dual role as observables and as generators of infinitesimal transformations in the invariance groups. We show that if the Lie algebra of generators is central simple, the observable-generator duality restricts the structure of the algebra of observables to two cases: a commutative, associative algebra as in classical mechanics, or a central simple special Jordan algebra as in quantum mechanics.

Journal of Mathematical PhysicsJun 1, 197429 citations

Observables and States, Reduction, Quantumness and Classicality.

Leonardo Ferro

The main objective of this dissertation is the study of the theory of Lie-Jordan Banach algebras, their role in the framework of classical and quantum mechanics, and their applications to different aspects of quantum systems. One of the main results of this thesis is the novel proof of a theorem which characterizes the Jordan (-Banach) algebras that are in a unique correspondence with C*-algebras. The novelty lies in the introduction of a Lie structure on the algebra, which is required to be compatible with the Jordan one. The physical interpretation of this connection with the Lie structure reflects the dual role played by the observables: they are measurable quantities but also the generators of motions of the state space. Whenever constraints are imposed on a quantum system or symmetries are present, both dynamical or gauge, some reduction on the state space must be considered either because not all states are physical and/or because families of states are equivalent. We address this problem in algebraic terms and obtain a reduction procedure which is free from the problems of gauge anomalies which is often encountered in a heuristic approach to the quantization of constraints. Then we study the composition of physical systems and we prove, from algebraic considerations only, the uniqueness of the Planck's constant. This is a strong result, since he existence of multiple Planck's constants would lead to violations of basic space-time conservation laws, which are not observed experimentally. Finally we address the problem of characterizing classical and quantum states, which has become particularly relevant for the field of quantum information and quantum computation, since a number of tasks in computation and communication can be performed only if quantum resources are available. By using the Jordan product we are able to provide a general definition of classical states and the associated quantumness witness which is suitable to infinite-dimensional systems. Then we propose a measure of nonclassicality based on the incompatibility of states relative to each other, rather than on correlations. Surprisingly, this new measure turns out to be experimentally suitable to a direct estimation by using a quantun circuit based on an interference experiment. We finally describe this experiment which is realizable with current technology.

Mar 30, 20140 citations

Observables and Dynamics Quantum to Classical from a Relativity Symmetry and Noncommutative-Geometric Perspective

Chuan Sheng Chew, Otto C. W. Kong, Jason Payne

With approaching quantum/noncommutative models for the deep microscopic spacetime in mind, and inspired by our recent picture of the (projective) Hilbert space as the model of physical space behind basic quantum mechanics, we reformulate here the WWGM formalism starting from the canonical coherent states and taking wavefunctions as expansion coefficients in terms of this basis. This provides us with a transparent and coherent story of simple quantum dynamics where both the wavefunctions for the pure states and operators acting on them arise from the single space/algebra, which exactly includes the WWGM observable algebra. Altogether, putting the emphasis on building our theory out of the underlying relativity symmetry -- the centrally extended Galilean symmetry in the case at hand -- allows one to naturally derive both a kinematical and a dynamical description of a quantum particle, which moreover recovers the corresponding classical picture (understood in terms of the Koopman-von Neumann formalism) in the appropriate (relativity symmetry contraction) limit. Our formulation here is the most natural framework directly connecting all of the relevant mathematical notions and we hope it may help a general physicist better visualize and appreciate the noncommutative-geometric perspective behind quantum physics. It also helps to inspire and illustrate our perspective on looking at quantum mechanics and quantum physics in general in direct connection to the notion of quantum (deformed) relativity symmetries and the corresponding quantum/noncommutative models of spacetime as various levels of approximations all the way down to the Newtonian.

arXiv:1703.04128Journal of High Energy Physics Gravitation and CosmologyJan 1, 201912 citations

Observables and Dynamics, Quantum to Classical, from a Relativity Symmetry Perspective

Chuan Sheng Chew, Otto C. W. Kong, Jason Payne

Motivated by a recent investigation into the notion of a quantum space underlying ordinary quantum mechanics, we reformulate here the WWGM formalism with canonical coherent states and wavefunctions as expansion coefficients in terms of this basis as the starting point. It turns out that this provides us with a transparent and coherent story of simple quantum dynamics where both states (pure and mixed, making use of the Tomita representation), as wavefunctions in Hilbert spaces, and observables arise from \textit{a single space/algebra}. Altogether, putting the emphasis on building our theory out of the underlying relativity symmetry -- the centrally extended Galilean symmetry in the case at hand -- allows one to naturally derive both a kinematical and a dynamical description of a (free) quantum particle, which moreover recovers the corresponding classical picture (understood in terms of the Koopman-von Neumann formalism) in the appropriate (relativity symmetry contraction) limit. Our formulation here is the most natural framework directly connecting all of the relevant mathematical notions and we hope it may help a general physicist better visualize and appreciate the noncommutative-geometric perspective behind quantum physics.

Mar 12, 20173 citations

Schwinger's picture of quantum mechanics II : Algebras and observables

Florio M. Ciaglia, Alberto Ibort, Giuseppe Marmo

The kinematical foundations of Schwinger's algebra of selective measurements were discussed in a previous paper (arXiv:1905.12274) and, as a consequence of this, a new picture of quantum mechanics based on groupoids was proposed. In this paper, the dynamical aspects of the theory are analysed. For that, the algebra generated by the observables, as well as the notion of state, are dicussed, and the structure of the transition functions, that plays an instrumental role in Schwinger's picture, is elucidated. A Hamiltonian picture of dynamical evolution emerges naturally, and the formalism offers a simple way to discuss the quantum-to-classical transition. Some basic examples, the qubit and the harmonic oscillator, are examined, and the relation with the standard Dirac-Schr\"odinger and Born-Jordan-Heisenberg pictures is discussed.

Jan 1, 201919 citations

Symmetries in covariant quantum mechanics

Dirk Saller

The thesis is divided in two parts. In the first part of the thesis, I present an updated version of the theory of covariant quantum mechanics and of the associated classical background. This theory has originally been proposed by Jadczyk and Modugno and further developed in cooperation with other people. It provides a geometric model for quantum mechanics of a scalar and spin particle in a curved spacetime with absolute time equipped with a given classical gravitational and electromagnetic field. Starting from minimal axioms, this model yields in a covariant way the Schrödinger equation by means of a global Lagrangian formalism and the quantum operators associated with classical quantisable functions by means of classification of distinguished quantum vector fields. In the second part of the thesis, I investigate systematically the infinitesimal symmetries of the classical and quantum geometric structures. This part deals with the main original contributions of the thesis. Some results fit well-known facts of other mathematical models of quantum mechanics, but are derived by innovative procedures. Other results are completely new. The most important original contributions can be summarized by the following two statements: The quantum symmetries constitute Lie algebras, which are naturally isomorphic to subalgebras of the new classical Lie algebra of quantisable functions. Let me stress that this algebra is not a Poisson subalgebra. On the other hand, by means of the quantum Lagrangian formalism, we can associate a conserved quantum current with any element of a distinguished classical subalgebra. These results might be the prequantum source of the probabilistic interpretation of quantum mechanics.

Jan 1, 20013 citations