Spatial correlations in driven-dissipative photonic lattices

We study the nonequilibrium steady-state of interacting photons in cavity arrays as described by the driven-dissipative Bose–Hubbard and spin-1/2 XY model. For this purpose, we develop a self-consistent expansion in the inverse coordination number of the array ( ) to solve the Lindblad master equation of these systems beyond the mean-field approximation. Our formalism is compared and benchmarked with exact numerical methods for small systems based on an exact diagonalization of the Liouvillian and a recently developed corner-space renormalization technique. We then apply this method to obtain insights beyond mean-field in two particular settings: (i) we show that the gas–liquid transition in the driven-dissipative Bose–Hubbard model is characterized by large density fluctuations and bunched photon statistics. (ii) We study the antibunching–bunching transition of the nearest-neighbor correlator in the driven-dissipative spin-1/2 XY model and provide a simple explanation of this phenomenon.We study the nonequilibrium steady-state of interacting photons in cavity arrays as described by the driven-dissipative Bose–Hubbard and spin-1/2 XY model. For this purpose, we develop a self-consistent expansion in the inverse coordination number of the array ( ) to solve the Lindblad master equation of these systems beyond the mean-field approximation. Our formalism is compared and benchmarked with exact numerical methods for small systems based on an exact diagonalization of the Liouvillian and a recently developed corner-space renormalization technique. We then apply this method to obtain insights beyond mean-field in two particular settings: (i) we show that the gas–liquid transition in the driven-dissipative Bose–Hubbard model is characterized by large density fluctuations and bunched photon statistics. (ii) We study the antibunching–bunching transition of the nearest-neighbor correlator in the driven-dissipative spin-1/2 XY model and provide a simple explanation of this phenomenon.

arXiv:1709.03762New Journal of PhysicsNov 10, 201713 citations

Quantum stabilization of photonic spatial correlations

Matteo Biondi, Saskia Lienhard, G. Blatter +1 more

Abstract The driven, dissipative Bose–Hubbard model (BHM) provides a generic description of collective phases of interacting photons in cavity arrays. In the limit of strong optical nonlinearities (hard-core limit), the BHM maps on the dissipative, transverse-field XY model (XYM). The steady-state of the XYM can be analyzed using mean-field theory, which reveals a plethora of interesting dynamical phenomena. For example, strong hopping combined with a blue-detuned drive, leads to an instability of the homogeneous steady-state with respect to antiferromagnetic fluctuations. In this paper, we address the question whether such an antiferromagnetic instability survives in the presence of quantum correlations beyond the mean-field approximation. For that purpose, we employ a self-consistent 1/ z expansion for the density matrix, where z is the lattice coordination number, i.e. the number of nearest neighbors for each site. We show that quantum fluctuations stabilize a new homogeneous steady-state with antiferromagnetic correlations in agreement with exact numerical simulations for finite lattices. The latter manifests itself as short-ranged oscillations of the first and second-order spatial coherence functions of the photons emitted by the array.Abstract The driven, dissipative Bose–Hubbard model (BHM) provides a generic description of collective phases of interacting photons in cavity arrays. In the limit of strong optical nonlinearities (hard-core limit), the BHM maps on the dissipative, transverse-field XY model (XYM). The steady-state of the XYM can be analyzed using mean-field theory, which reveals a plethora of interesting dynamical phenomena. For example, strong hopping combined with a blue-detuned drive, leads to an instability of the homogeneous steady-state with respect to antiferromagnetic fluctuations. In this paper, we address the question whether such an antiferromagnetic instability survives in the presence of quantum correlations beyond the mean-field approximation. For that purpose, we employ a self-consistent 1/ z expansion for the density matrix, where z is the lattice coordination number, i.e. the number of nearest neighbors for each site. We show that quantum fluctuations stabilize a new homogeneous steady-state with antiferromagnetic correlations in agreement with exact numerical simulations for finite lattices. The latter manifests itself as short-ranged oscillations of the first and second-order spatial coherence functions of the photons emitted by the array.

arXiv:1806.11067Physica ScriptaNov 15, 20182 citations

Nonequilibrium gas-liquid transition in the driven-dissipative photonic lattice

Matteo Biondi, G. Blatter, Hakan E. Türeci +1 more

We study the nonequilibrium steady state of the driven-dissipative Bose-Hubbard model with Kerr nonlinearity. Employing a mean-field decoupling for the intercavity hopping $J$ , we find that the steep crossover between low and high photon-density states inherited from the single cavity transforms into a gas--liquid bistability at large cavity-coupling $J$ . We formulate a van der Waals--like gas--liquid phenomenology for this nonequilibrium setting and determine the relevant phase diagrams, including a new type of diagram where a lobe-shaped boundary separates smooth crossovers from sharp, hysteretic transitions. Calculating quantum trajectories for a one-dimensional system, we provide insights into the microscopic origin of the bistability.We study the nonequilibrium steady state of the driven-dissipative Bose-Hubbard model with Kerr nonlinearity. Employing a mean-field decoupling for the intercavity hopping $J$, we find that the steep crossover between low and high photon-density states inherited from the single cavity transforms into a gas--liquid bistability at large cavity-coupling $J$. We formulate a van der Waals--like gas--liquid phenomenology for this nonequilibrium setting and determine the relevant phase diagrams, including a new type of diagram where a lobe-shaped boundary separates smooth crossovers from sharp, hysteretic transitions. Calculating quantum trajectories for a one-dimensional system, we provide insights into the microscopic origin of the bistability.

arXiv:1611.00697Physical Review AOct 5, 201774 citations

Strongly correlated photons in arrays of nonlinear cavities

Alexandre Le Boité

In recent years, the control of photon-photon interactions in optical nonlinear media has led to the realization of quantum fluids of light. One of the current challenges is to increase the strength of these interactions and enter the so-called strongly correlated regime. To achieve this goal, arrays of nonlinear cavities are a very promising candidate. In this thesis, theoretical results on arrays of nonlinear cavities described by a driven-dissipative Bose-Hubbard model are presented. In particular, a general method to compute the mean-field phase diagram of this model is described. Due to the finite life time of photons, the system is intrinsically dissipative: cavity losses must be compensated by an external driving field. This nonequilibrium nature gives rise to interesting features, such as a transition between monostable and bistable phases induced by tunneling. In the limit of weak dissipation and weak driving, analytical results describing generalized Mott insulating phases are derived. These states survive up to a critical tunneling strength, above which a crossover to a classical coherent state takes place. Finally, the issue of how to go beyond the mean-field approximation is addressed by performing exact numerical simulations. Large arrays of cavities were simulated by implementing a new method specifically tailored for driven-dissipative systems.In recent years, the control of photon-photon interactions in optical nonlinear media has led to the realization of quantum fluids of light. One of the current challenges is to increase the strength of these interactions and enter the so-called strongly correlated regime. To achieve this goal, arrays of nonlinear cavities are a very promising candidate. In this thesis, theoretical results on arrays of nonlinear cavities described by a driven-dissipative Bose-Hubbard model are presented. In particular, a general method to compute the mean-field phase diagram of this model is described. Due to the finite life time of photons, the system is intrinsically dissipative: cavity losses must be compensated by an external driving field. This nonequilibrium nature gives rise to interesting features, such as a transition between monostable and bistable phases induced by tunneling. In the limit of weak dissipation and weak driving, analytical results describing generalized Mott insulating phases are derived. These states survive up to a critical tunneling strength, above which a crossover to a classical coherent state takes place. Finally, the issue of how to go beyond the mean-field approximation is addressed by performing exact numerical simulations. Large arrays of cavities were simulated by implementing a new method specifically tailored for driven-dissipative systems.

May 6, 20151 citation

Beyond mean-field bistability in driven-dissipative lattices: Bunching-antibunching transition and quantum simulation

Juan José Mendoza-Arenas, Stephen R. L. Clark, Simone Felicetti +4 more

In the present work we investigate the existence of multiple nonequilibrium steady states in a coherently driven $XY$ lattice of dissipative two-level systems. A commonly used mean-field ansatz, in which spatial correlations are neglected, predicts a bistable behavior with a sharp shift between low- and high-density states. In contrast one-dimensional matrix product methods reveal these effects to be artifacts of the mean-field approach, with both disappearing once correlations are taken fully into account. Instead, a bunching-antibunching transition emerges. This indicates that alternative approaches should be considered for higher spatial dimensions, where classical simulations are currently infeasible. Thus we propose a circuit QED quantum simulator implementable with current technology to enable an experimental investigation of the model considered.In the present work we investigate the existence of multiple nonequilibrium steady states in a coherently driven $XY$ lattice of dissipative two-level systems. A commonly used mean-field ansatz, in which spatial correlations are neglected, predicts a bistable behavior with a sharp shift between low- and high-density states. In contrast one-dimensional matrix product methods reveal these effects to be artifacts of the mean-field approach, with both disappearing once correlations are taken fully into account. Instead, a bunching-antibunching transition emerges. This indicates that alternative approaches should be considered for higher spatial dimensions, where classical simulations are currently infeasible. Thus we propose a circuit QED quantum simulator implementable with current technology to enable an experimental investigation of the model considered.

arXiv:1510.06651Physical Review AFeb 16, 201689 citations

Correlation-induced steady states and limit cycles in driven dissipative quantum systems

Haggai Landa, Marco Schirò, Grégoire Misguich

We study a driven-dissipative model of spins one-half (qubits) on a lattice with nearest-neighbor interactions. Focusing on the role of spatially extended spin-spin correlations in determining the phases of the system, we characterize the spatial structure of the correlations in the steady state, as well as their temporal dynamics. In dimension one we use essentially exact matrix-product-operator simulations on large systems, and pushing these calculations to dimension two, we obtain accurate results on small cylinders. We also employ an approximation scheme based on solving the dynamics of the mean field dressed by the feedback of quantum fluctuations at leading order. This approach allows us to study the effect of correlations in large lattices with over one hundred thousand spins, as the spatial dimension is increased up to five. In dimension two and higher we find two new states that are stabilized by quantum correlations and do not exist in the mean-field limit of the model. One of these is a steady state with mean magnetization values that lie between the two bistable mean-field values and whose correlation functions have properties reminiscent of both. The correlation length of the new phase diverges at a critical point, beyond which we find emerging a new limit cycle state with the magnetization and correlators oscillating periodically in time.We study a driven-dissipative model of spins one-half (qubits) on a lattice with nearest-neighbor interactions. Focusing on the role of spatially extended spin-spin correlations in determining the phases of the system, we characterize the spatial structure of the correlations in the steady state, as well as their temporal dynamics. In dimension one we use essentially exact matrix-product-operator simulations on large systems, and pushing these calculations to dimension two, we obtain accurate results on small cylinders. We also employ an approximation scheme based on solving the dynamics of the mean field dressed by the feedback of quantum fluctuations at leading order. This approach allows us to study the effect of correlations in large lattices with over one hundred thousand spins, as the spatial dimension is increased up to five. In dimension two and higher we find two new states that are stabilized by quantum correlations and do not exist in the mean-field limit of the model. One of these is a steady state with mean magnetization values that lie between the two bistable mean-field values and whose correlation functions have properties reminiscent of both. The correlation length of the new phase diverges at a critical point, beyond which we find emerging a new limit cycle state with the magnetization and correlators oscillating periodically in time.

arXiv:2001.05474Physical review. B./Physical review. BAug 3, 202016 citations

We study the nonequilibrium steady state of the driven-dissipative Bose-Hubbard model with Kerr nonlinearity. Employing a mean-field decoupling for the intercavity hopping

J

, we find that the steep crossover between low and high photon-density states inherited from the single cavity transforms into a gas--liquid bistability at large cavity-coupling

J

. We formulate a van der Waals--like gas--liquid phenomenology for this nonequilibrium setting and determine the relevant phase diagrams, including a new type of diagram where a lobe-shaped boundary separates smooth crossovers from sharp, hysteretic transitions. Calculating quantum trajectories for a one-dimensional system, we provide insights into the microscopic origin of the bistability.

In the present work we investigate the existence of multiple nonequilibrium steady states in a coherently driven

XY

lattice of dissipative two-level systems. A commonly used mean-field ansatz, in which spatial correlations are neglected, predicts a bistable behavior with a sharp shift between low- and high-density states. In contrast one-dimensional matrix product methods reveal these effects to be artifacts of the mean-field approach, with both disappearing once correlations are taken fully into account. Instead, a bunching-antibunching transition emerges. This indicates that alternative approaches should be considered for higher spatial dimensions, where classical simulations are currently infeasible. Thus we propose a circuit QED quantum simulator implementable with current technology to enable an experimental investigation of the model considered.