Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The self-measurement of the Universe and the concept of time in quantum cosmology

Michael B. Mensky

Published Jan 1, 1991• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The dynamics of the quantum universe under self-measurement is investigated in the framework of the path-integral approach to quantum theory of continuous measurements. The corresponding amplitude (propagator) is evaluated explicitly for a simple superspace model. It is shown that the picture of time evolution of the quantum universe naturally emerges as a result of its self-measurement. The Wheeler-DeWitt dynamics holds for small times when the effect of measurement can be neglected and time dependence disappears.

Related papers

The self-measurement of the universe and the concept of time in quantum cosmology

Michael B. Mensky

The dynamics of the quantum universe under self-measurement is investigated in the framework of the path-integral approach to quantum theory of continuous measurements. The corresponding amplitude (propagator) is evaluated explicitly for a simple superspace model. It is shown that the picture of time evolution of the quantum universe naturally emerges as a result of its self-measurement. The Wheeler-DeWitt dynamics holds for small times when the effect of measurement can be neglected and time dependence disappears.

Classical and Quantum Gravity•Dec 1, 1990•5 citations

Time emergence by self-measurement in a quantum anisotropic universe

Abel Camacho, A. Camacho-Galván

We begin this work calculating Halliwell's propagator in the case of a Mixmaster universe with small anisotropy. Afterwards in the context of the Decoherence Model we introduce in our system terms that comprise the self-measurement of the universe of this model by higher multipoles of matter. Analyzing self-measurement with the Restricted Path Integral Formalism we obtain Halliwell's modified propagator and find that a gauge invariant physical time emerges as consequence of this process. The conditions leading to Wheeler-DeWitt dynamics are also obtained. The comparison of our results with those of the isotropic case will enable us to conclude that the number of conditions to be satisfied in order to have Halliwell's regime is in the anisotropic situation bigger than in an isotropic universe. We obtain also in terms of the parameters of the measurement process an expression for the threshold in time beyond which the scale factors of this model are meaningless.

arXiv:gr-qc/9908011•Il Nuovo Cimento B•Aug 3, 1999•1 citation

Time in Quantum Cosmology

Michael B. Mensky

This chapter applies the path-integral approach to the quantum theory of continuous measurements to investigate the quantum Universe, taking into account its self-measurement. It describes the way to apply the path-integral theory of continuous measurements in quantum cosmology in a general form and develops a minisuperspace model. The path-integral approach can be applied to describe the measurement of a quantum field. The measurement of curvature in the framework of quantum gravity has been considered in such a way by Mensky using a functional integral over configurations of the gravitational field. The chapter considers the possible influence of self-measurement on the dynamics of the quantum Universe. The influence could be caused by reduction of the wavefunction of the Universe in the process of continuous measurement. Therefore the time evolution of the quantum Universe makes sense in quantum cosmology provided its self-measurement is correctly taken into account.

CRC Press eBooks•Oct 19, 2017•0 citations

Relational Quantum Cosmology

Francesca Vidotto

Conceptual Problems in Quantum Cosmology The application of quantum theory to cosmology raises a number of conceptual questions, such as the role of the quantum-mechanical notion of “observer” or the absence of a time variable in the Wheeler–DeWitt equation. I point out that a relational formulation of quantum mechanics, and more in general the observation that evolution is always relational, provides a coherent solution to this tangle of problems. A number of confusing issues appear when we try to apply quantum mechanics to cosmology. Quantum mechanics, for instance, is generally formulated in terms of an observer making measurements on a system. In a laboratory experiment, it is easy to identify the system and the observer: but what is the observer in quantum cosmology? Is it part of the same universe described by the cosmological theory, or should we think of it as external to the universe? Furthermore, the basic quantum dynamical equation describing a system including gravity is not the Schrödinger equation, but rather the Wheeler–DeWitt equation, which has no time parameter: is this related to the absence of an observer external to the universe? How do we describe the quantum dynamics of the universe without a time variable in the dynamical equation and without an observer external to the universe? I suggest that clarity on these issues can be obtained by simply recognizing the relational nature of quantum mechanics and more in general the relational nature of physical evolution. In the context of quantum theory, this nature is emphasized by the so-called relational interpretation of quantum mechanics (Rovelli, 1996). The relational nature of evolution, on the other hand, has been pointed out by the partial-observable formulation of general covariant dynamics (Rovelli, 2002). A central observation is that there is a common confusion between two different meanings of the expression “cosmology”. This is discussed below, in Section 15.1.1. A considerable amount of the difficulties mentioned above stems, I argue, from this confusion. The discussion clarifies on the role of the quantum mechanical observer in cosmology, which is considered in Section 15.1.2. In Section 15.2, I briefly describe the relational interpretation of quantum mechanics and some related aspects of quantum theory.

arXiv:1508.05543•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 1, 2017•14 citations

Time, Bohm's Theory, and Quantum Cosmology

Craig Callender, Robert Weingard

One of the problems of quantum cosmology follows from the fact that the Hamiltonian H of classical general relativity equals zero. Quantizing canonically in the Schrodinger picture, the Schrodinger equation for the wave function Ψ of the universe is therefore the so-called Wheeler-DeWitt equation (where Ĥ is the operator version of H) and we have no quantum dynamics. In particular, it follows directly that, if Ȓ is the operator representing the radius of the universe, where <Ȓ>ψ = Ψ<|Ȓ|>Ψ, for every Ψ. The universe described by (1) does not expand. But worse still is the fact that there is no time development, contrary to our experience. Like a particle in an eigenstate of zero energy, the state of the universe does not change. The still universe resulting from (1) is a manifestation of the more general “problem of time” afflicting canonical quantum gravity. Despite rare claims to the contrary, most consider it to be a serious difficulty for quantum cosmology.

Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 1996•8 citations

Quantum cosmology from the de Broglie–Bohm perspective

Nelson Pinto-Neto, J. C. Fabris

We review the main results that have been obtained in quantum cosmology from the perspective of the de Broglie-Bohm quantum theory. As it is a dynamical theory of assumed objectively real trajectories in the configuration space of the physical system under investigation, this quantum theory is not essentially probabilistic and dispenses the collapse postulate, turning it suitable to be applied to cosmology. In the framework of minisuperspace models, we show how quantum cosmological effects in the de-Broglie-Bohm's approach can avoid the initial singularity, and isotropize the Universe. We then extend minisuperspace in order to include linear cosmological perturbations. We present the main equations which govern the dynamics of quantum cosmological perturbations evolving in non-singular quantum cosmological backgrounds, and calculate some of their observational consequences. These results are not known how to be obtained in other approaches to quantum theory. In the general case of full superspace, we enumerate the possible structures of quantum space and time that emerge from the de Broglie-Bohm picture. Finally, we compare some of the results coming from the de Broglie-Bohm theory with other approaches, and discuss the physical reasons for some discrepancies that occur.

arXiv:1306.0820•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Jun 12, 2013•126 citations
The dynamics of the quantum universe under self-measurement is investigated in the framework of the path-integral approach to quantum theory of continuous measurements. The corresponding amplitude (propagator) is evaluated explicitly for a simple superspace model. It is shown that the picture of time evolution of the quantum universe naturally emerges as a result of its self-measurement. The Wheeler-DeWitt dynamics holds for small times when the effect of measurement can be neglected and time dependence disappears.
The dynamics of the quantum universe under self-measurement is investigated in the framework of the path-integral approach to quantum theory of continuous measurements. The corresponding amplitude (propagator) is evaluated explicitly for a simple superspace model. It is shown that the picture of time evolution of the quantum universe naturally emerges as a result of its self-measurement. The Wheeler-DeWitt dynamics holds for small times when the effect of measurement can be neglected and time dependence disappears.
We begin this work calculating Halliwell's propagator in the case of a Mixmaster universe with small anisotropy. Afterwards in the context of the Decoherence Model we introduce in our system terms that comprise the self-measurement of the universe of this model by higher multipoles of matter. Analyzing self-measurement with the Restricted Path Integral Formalism we obtain Halliwell's modified propagator and find that a gauge invariant physical time emerges as consequence of this process. The conditions leading to Wheeler-DeWitt dynamics are also obtained. The comparison of our results with those of the isotropic case will enable us to conclude that the number of conditions to be satisfied in order to have Halliwell's regime is in the anisotropic situation bigger than in an isotropic universe. We obtain also in terms of the parameters of the measurement process an expression for the threshold in time beyond which the scale factors of this model are meaningless.
This chapter applies the path-integral approach to the quantum theory of continuous measurements to investigate the quantum Universe, taking into account its self-measurement. It describes the way to apply the path-integral theory of continuous measurements in quantum cosmology in a general form and develops a minisuperspace model. The path-integral approach can be applied to describe the measurement of a quantum field. The measurement of curvature in the framework of quantum gravity has been considered in such a way by Mensky using a functional integral over configurations of the gravitational field. The chapter considers the possible influence of self-measurement on the dynamics of the quantum Universe. The influence could be caused by reduction of the wavefunction of the Universe in the process of continuous measurement. Therefore the time evolution of the quantum Universe makes sense in quantum cosmology provided its self-measurement is correctly taken into account.
Conceptual Problems in Quantum Cosmology The application of quantum theory to cosmology raises a number of conceptual questions, such as the role of the quantum-mechanical notion of “observer” or the absence of a time variable in the Wheeler–DeWitt equation. I point out that a relational formulation of quantum mechanics, and more in general the observation that evolution is always relational, provides a coherent solution to this tangle of problems. A number of confusing issues appear when we try to apply quantum mechanics to cosmology. Quantum mechanics, for instance, is generally formulated in terms of an observer making measurements on a system. In a laboratory experiment, it is easy to identify the system and the observer: but what is the observer in quantum cosmology? Is it part of the same universe described by the cosmological theory, or should we think of it as external to the universe? Furthermore, the basic quantum dynamical equation describing a system including gravity is not the Schrödinger equation, but rather the Wheeler–DeWitt equation, which has no time parameter: is this related to the absence of an observer external to the universe? How do we describe the quantum dynamics of the universe without a time variable in the dynamical equation and without an observer external to the universe? I suggest that clarity on these issues can be obtained by simply recognizing the relational nature of quantum mechanics and more in general the relational nature of physical evolution. In the context of quantum theory, this nature is emphasized by the so-called relational interpretation of quantum mechanics (Rovelli, 1996). The relational nature of evolution, on the other hand, has been pointed out by the partial-observable formulation of general covariant dynamics (Rovelli, 2002). A central observation is that there is a common confusion between two different meanings of the expression “cosmology”. This is discussed below, in Section 15.1.1. A considerable amount of the difficulties mentioned above stems, I argue, from this confusion. The discussion clarifies on the role of the quantum mechanical observer in cosmology, which is considered in Section 15.1.2. In Section 15.2, I briefly describe the relational interpretation of quantum mechanics and some related aspects of quantum theory.
One of the problems of quantum cosmology follows from the fact that the Hamiltonian H of classical general relativity equals zero. Quantizing canonically in the Schrodinger picture, the Schrodinger equation for the wave function Ψ of the universe is therefore the so-called Wheeler-DeWitt equation (where Ĥ is the operator version of H) and we have no quantum dynamics. In particular, it follows directly that, if Ȓ is the operator representing the radius of the universe, where <Ȓ>ψ = Ψ<|Ȓ|>Ψ, for every Ψ. The universe described by (1) does not expand. But worse still is the fact that there is no time development, contrary to our experience. Like a particle in an eigenstate of zero energy, the state of the universe does not change. The still universe resulting from (1) is a manifestation of the more general “problem of time” afflicting canonical quantum gravity. Despite rare claims to the contrary, most consider it to be a serious difficulty for quantum cosmology.
We review the main results that have been obtained in quantum cosmology from the perspective of the de Broglie-Bohm quantum theory. As it is a dynamical theory of assumed objectively real trajectories in the configuration space of the physical system under investigation, this quantum theory is not essentially probabilistic and dispenses the collapse postulate, turning it suitable to be applied to cosmology. In the framework of minisuperspace models, we show how quantum cosmological effects in the de-Broglie-Bohm's approach can avoid the initial singularity, and isotropize the Universe. We then extend minisuperspace in order to include linear cosmological perturbations. We present the main equations which govern the dynamics of quantum cosmological perturbations evolving in non-singular quantum cosmological backgrounds, and calculate some of their observational consequences. These results are not known how to be obtained in other approaches to quantum theory. In the general case of full superspace, we enumerate the possible structures of quantum space and time that emerge from the de Broglie-Bohm picture. Finally, we compare some of the results coming from the de Broglie-Bohm theory with other approaches, and discuss the physical reasons for some discrepancies that occur.